Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service
(6841)
Pat
Review left Nov 06 2026
Review
I just completed my first order with Card Conduit. I was a small order, less than 100 cards. Once my cards were delivered I received my offer within the estimated window and payment posted the day I accepted the offer. I will definitely be using Card Conduit again and highly recommend it!
I just completed my first order with Card Conduit. I was a small order, less than 100 cards. Once my cards were delivered I received my offer within the estimated window and payment posted the day I accepted the offer. I will definitely be using Card Conduit again and highly recommend it!
Derek Applegarth
Review left Nov 06 2026
Review
I have sold cards here multiple times and have always had a good experience.
I have sold cards here multiple times and have always had a good experience.
John S
Review left Nov 06 2026
Review
This is the third time sending cards to CC. They have been great every time. They are always fast, fair, and transparent throughout the process.
This is the third time sending cards to CC. They have been great every time. They are always fast, fair, and transparent throughout the process.
Ian
Review left Nov 06 2026
Shipment processed Oct 23 2026
Review
This was my first time working with Card Conduit. I was pleasantly surprised by how easy it was to catalogue my cards for sale and have them processed. The turnaround time was also very impressive. Overall, a 5-star experience.
Some feedback from a user perspective: costs of processing aside, it ... Read more
Some feedback from a user perspective: costs of processing aside, it ... Read more
This was my first time working with Card Conduit. I was pleasantly surprised by how easy it was to catalogue my cards for sale and have them processed. The turnaround time was also very impressive. Overall, a 5-star experience.
Some feedback from a user perspective: costs of processing aside, it would be very helpful to have transparency around grading processes (i.e. photographic evidence, documentation of individual card condition) available after processing and before accepting payment. Nearly 100% of the cards that I included for sale were freshly pulled from packs before being stored safely ahead of shipment. It did come as a mild surprise that so many of them (125 cards out of the 500 shipped) were graded at 'Lightly Played'. I understand that some of the packs were from older sets which could account for a slight decrease in condition, but the harshness of grading definitely stood out to me. I have another 500-card shipment out with Card Conduit right now and would be interested to see how those cards grade as well before I decide whether I'll be committing more cards in the future.
Some feedback from a user perspective: costs of processing aside, it would be very helpful to have transparency around grading processes (i.e. photographic evidence, documentation of individual card condition) available after processing and before accepting payment. Nearly 100% of the cards that I included for sale were freshly pulled from packs before being stored safely ahead of shipment. It did come as a mild surprise that so many of them (125 cards out of the 500 shipped) were graded at 'Lightly Played'. I understand that some of the packs were from older sets which could account for a slight decrease in condition, but the harshness of grading definitely stood out to me. I have another 500-card shipment out with Card Conduit right now and would be interested to see how those cards grade as well before I decide whether I'll be committing more cards in the future.
Gene
Review left Nov 04 2026
Shipment processed Nov 04 2026
Review
My friend told me about this site and his experience with it. As someone who has difficulties trusting sources (online or in person) to assess value in cards fairly, I am very pleased to see how well and easy it was. Card Conduit took the time to judge each card and the generated report made me glad
...
Read more
My friend told me about this site and his experience with it. As someone who has difficulties trusting sources (online or in person) to assess value in cards fairly, I am very pleased to see how well and easy it was. Card Conduit took the time to judge each card and the generated report made me glad to know every card was judged accurately. I will be submitting more orders in the future to these guys! Thanks and keep up the great work.
Joshua Richardson
Review left Nov 04 2026
Review
The process was simpe, straightforward, and paid out quickly. I will definitely use the service again in the future.
The process was simpe, straightforward, and paid out quickly. I will definitely use the service again in the future.
Loren Carlos
Review left Nov 04 2026
Review
This is the second time I’ve sent a shipment in! Took 2 weeks from the day I shipped to payout. I love being able to see the process and eventually the payout list and highlights. If you are wanting to sell your ungraded cards, this is how.
This is the second time I’ve sent a shipment in! Took 2 weeks from the day I shipped to payout. I love being able to see the process and eventually the payout list and highlights. If you are wanting to sell your ungraded cards, this is how.
G Cole
Review left Nov 04 2026
Review
I've done quite a few shipments with Card Conduit, never had any problems and they've always been great.
I've done quite a few shipments with Card Conduit, never had any problems and they've always been great.
Joshua Smith
Review left Nov 04 2026
Review
Card Conduit did a fantastic job organizing and buying out the cards I sent them. When I ran into shipping trouble their customer service did a great job getting back to me so that we could coordinate and make sure my cards got to them in one piece. The Stats page and payout pages were very intuitiv
...
Read more
Card Conduit did a fantastic job organizing and buying out the cards I sent them. When I ran into shipping trouble their customer service did a great job getting back to me so that we could coordinate and make sure my cards got to them in one piece. The Stats page and payout pages were very intuitive and easy to follow so I felt like I got a great deal for the amount of cards I sent in. Overall, I would definitely recommend Card Conduit for people selling cards, and I would especially recommend them if you are sending large shipments of cards to be Auto-sifted. Thanks guys!
David Kilpatrick
Review left Nov 04 2026
Review
The process was as easy as I could hope for. I put some extra work in because I didn't know them from Adam, but once I was able to meet the team face to face since I'm local to them I felt so much better about the whole transaction. I personally found their estimate tool to be very accurate to what
...
Read more
The process was as easy as I could hope for. I put some extra work in because I didn't know them from Adam, but once I was able to meet the team face to face since I'm local to them I felt so much better about the whole transaction. I personally found their estimate tool to be very accurate to what I eventually received. I would definitely recommend Card Conduit to anybody wanting to sell their Magic.
Barry Patterson
Review left Nov 04 2026
Review
The other company has sent back so many of my card sets for every reason available. They obviously have become ungrateful and think they can't be taken down. I have never had a single issue with C.C. and the things I send are the exact same. I know I can't be the only one that struggles with Kingdom. I am apprciative of Card Conduit.
The other company has sent back so many of my card sets for every reason available. They obviously have become ungrateful and think they can't be taken down. I have never had a single issue with C.C. and the things I send are the exact same. I know I can't be the only one that struggles with Kingdom. I am apprciative of Card Conduit.
Ahmed Alahmady
Review left Nov 04 2026
Review
Easy, fast, and saved me a bunch of time with the auto-sift feature.
Easy, fast, and saved me a bunch of time with the auto-sift feature.
John C
Review left Nov 03 2026
Review
Thank You!!
So simple and easy! I had an overflow of cards that I needed to find a place for as was cleaning things out. Honestly, extra commons, lands, rates and very few mythic. Received a check for over $700.00.
So simple and easy! I had an overflow of cards that I needed to find a place for as was cleaning things out. Honestly, extra commons, lands, rates and very few mythic. Received a check for over $700.00.
Thank You!!
So simple and easy! I had an overflow of cards that I needed to find a place for as was cleaning things out. Honestly, extra commons, lands, rates and very few mythic. Received a check for over $700.00.
So simple and easy! I had an overflow of cards that I needed to find a place for as was cleaning things out. Honestly, extra commons, lands, rates and very few mythic. Received a check for over $700.00.
Isaac Moore
Review left Nov 03 2026
Review
Shipping and everything great. Timely. Biggest problem was I didn't love the grading without explanation. Like what was wrong/ pics of problems
Shipping and everything great. Timely. Biggest problem was I didn't love the grading without explanation. Like what was wrong/ pics of problems
Miguel Becerril
Review left Nov 03 2026
Review
It is not very sure to send my value cards here, and after much thought, I sent them, and the process was fast and accurate, I will send another package of cards and I will leave my review of the work you did thank you
It is not very sure to send my value cards here, and after much thought, I sent them, and the process was fast and accurate, I will send another package of cards and I will leave my review of the work you did thank you
Roberto
Review left Nov 02 2026
Review
Was quick and fast and the conditions and final total aligned with what I thought it would be, will use you again of course!
Was quick and fast and the conditions and final total aligned with what I thought it would be, will use you again of course!
William Jr.
Review left Nov 02 2026
Shipment processed Oct 30 2026
Review
Another great job. Always guiding you throughout the entire process! Thanks again!
Another great job. Always guiding you throughout the entire process! Thanks again!
Jake Giovati
Review left Nov 02 2026
Review
Typically this company is reliable and responsive, however they lost over 1000 dollars worth of product from this order. The concerned cards included a Raised Foil Bellow the Bard and SLD Kaalia. They assured me they reviewed their process and that I must have misplaced them. After nearly 3 months o
...
Read more
Typically this company is reliable and responsive, however they lost over 1000 dollars worth of product from this order. The concerned cards included a Raised Foil Bellow the Bard and SLD Kaalia. They assured me they reviewed their process and that I must have misplaced them. After nearly 3 months of scouring for them I can assure you this is not the case. I'm sure they will reply with an explanation, just know it's in their best interest to dissuade you from taking this warning seriously.
Ana Lopez
Review left Nov 01 2026
Shipment processed Oct 23 2026
Review
Always in contact letting me know how the process is going without asking.
Always in contact letting me know how the process is going without asking.
Dustin Conway
Review left Oct 31 2026
Shipment processed Oct 22 2026
Review
Everything was rather simple! I felt the payout was reasonable. Im sad my box opened in transit but that was my fault.
Everything was rather simple! I felt the payout was reasonable. Im sad my box opened in transit but that was my fault.
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every
previous customer to leave a review.
Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page.
We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a
review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).