Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service
(6305)
Jay Gray
Review left Jul 08 2026
Shipment processed Jun 29 2026
Review
This is my 3rd or 4th order with Card Conduit. I use the sorted fee option, I don’t mind taking the time to sort cards. I haven’t processed bulk, just singles. Their buy prices seem to be higher than other sites, and they accept more cards than other sites. If you’re trying to get rid of 200 o
...
Read more
This is my 3rd or 4th order with Card Conduit. I use the sorted fee option, I don’t mind taking the time to sort cards. I haven’t processed bulk, just singles. Their buy prices seem to be higher than other sites, and they accept more cards than other sites. If you’re trying to get rid of 200 or so cards, even with most of them being less than $5, I would recommend Card Conduit
Johnny D
Review left Jul 08 2026
Review
I’ve done a few shipments with Card Conduit and they’ve been fantastic each time. I’ve done bulk shipments as well as the curated one where you ship the cards in order and the processing time & payout amounts exceeded my expectations each time!
I’ve done a few shipments with Card Conduit and they’ve been fantastic each time. I’ve done bulk shipments as well as the curated one where you ship the cards in order and the processing time & payout amounts exceeded my expectations each time!
Owen Januska
Review left Jul 08 2026
Review
Card Conduct is a great company when it comes to giving over cards and being able to process them. They are also really good at explaining how they justify the cost of how they came to the price of the sale. Sadly, the payout for the cards that I have had have personally not panned out to what I wan
...
Read more
Card Conduct is a great company when it comes to giving over cards and being able to process them. They are also really good at explaining how they justify the cost of how they came to the price of the sale. Sadly, the payout for the cards that I have had have personally not panned out to what I want them to be due to the value of the card based on the market. I understand the extent of how the prints determine the price and if it’s damaged or how bad it is. Price wise, I haven’t gotten the best payout with it. I still recommend Card Conduct regardless for cards.
David Kantro
Review left Jul 08 2026
Review
Process was easy and professional, but only 1 out of 500 cards was marked as near mint and the most expensive cards happened to be the ones that were graded as heavily played or damaged, so my interest in sending you my tens of thousands in good cards is now at 0%, but I will probably send another round of junk cards.
Process was easy and professional, but only 1 out of 500 cards was marked as near mint and the most expensive cards happened to be the ones that were graded as heavily played or damaged, so my interest in sending you my tens of thousands in good cards is now at 0%, but I will probably send another round of junk cards.
Michael
Review left Jul 08 2026
Review
I keep coming back to this service for ease of use. Easy process again, thank you!
I keep coming back to this service for ease of use. Easy process again, thank you!
Matt C
Review left Jul 08 2026
Shipment processed Jun 26 2026
Review
The process is fast and easy. Overall a fair process that allowed me to liquidate some cards that I no longer needed. Thanks Card Conduit
The process is fast and easy. Overall a fair process that allowed me to liquidate some cards that I no longer needed. Thanks Card Conduit
Brady Nash
Review left Jul 08 2026
Review
Process is very easy and fast, received about 3/4th of the value I shipped in. I know not every card is NM but I was hoping to get around 80% instead of 75%. The speed of conversion might be worth it though.
Process is very easy and fast, received about 3/4th of the value I shipped in. I know not every card is NM but I was hoping to get around 80% instead of 75%. The speed of conversion might be worth it though.
Brian Burkhart
Review left Jul 07 2026
Review
Process was very easy, importing cards was easy and looking at which ones they would pay for was clear and easy. The near mint prices were very competitive to what I would get if I sold each on eBay, with much less work. Grading is always going to be subjective but had a very enjoyable experience. I will be using this service again!
Process was very easy, importing cards was easy and looking at which ones they would pay for was clear and easy. The near mint prices were very competitive to what I would get if I sold each on eBay, with much less work. Grading is always going to be subjective but had a very enjoyable experience. I will be using this service again!
Nicholas Leyda
Review left Jul 07 2026
Shipment processed Jun 25 2026
Review
super easy process and great options depending on your limit of time
super easy process and great options depending on your limit of time
Ben Barty
Review left Jul 07 2026
Shipment processed Jun 23 2026
Review
I was really pleased with my experience with Card Conduit. Thanks Nick for being fast and thorough.
I was really pleased with my experience with Card Conduit. Thanks Nick for being fast and thorough.
Gregory Gallegos
Review left Jul 07 2026
Review
Packed up a bunch of my old $1-$4 cards and sent them out. About a week later got my payout. Pretty decent rate, better than if I sold them off TCG personally.
Packed up a bunch of my old $1-$4 cards and sent them out. About a week later got my payout. Pretty decent rate, better than if I sold them off TCG personally.
Patrick Joyce
Review left Jul 07 2026
Review
This is my second time using Card Conduit, and I'm extremely satisfied. They were more timely than they promised, and I had zero issues selling my collection. Their fees were reasonable, and they provided fair, honest assessments of my cards. I couldn't recommend them more!
This is my second time using Card Conduit, and I'm extremely satisfied. They were more timely than they promised, and I had zero issues selling my collection. Their fees were reasonable, and they provided fair, honest assessments of my cards. I couldn't recommend them more!
Eric L
Review left Jul 06 2026
Shipment processed May 15 2026
Review
Easy shipping and organizing process, lower fees than any other buylist and usually the highest prices I can find.
Easy shipping and organizing process, lower fees than any other buylist and usually the highest prices I can find.
BIG D
Review left Jul 06 2026
Review
Quick and easy! 10/10 recommend. wish they did other tcgs too
Quick and easy! 10/10 recommend. wish they did other tcgs too
Jake Giovati
Review left Jul 05 2026
Review
Excellent customer service communication and explanations.
Excellent customer service communication and explanations.
Tyler Richardson
Review left Jul 05 2026
Review
Everything felt easy and smooth. Shipping instructions were simple as well. Communications were precise and clear. Money appeared quickly and the whole process was very professional. I am definitely considering another shipment.
Everything felt easy and smooth. Shipping instructions were simple as well. Communications were precise and clear. Money appeared quickly and the whole process was very professional. I am definitely considering another shipment.
Christopher Sampson
Review left Jul 04 2026
Review
I would recommend using Card Conduit, so simple and easy and they were there to answer any questions I had and gave me a very fair assessment of my cards. Thank you!!!
I would recommend using Card Conduit, so simple and easy and they were there to answer any questions I had and gave me a very fair assessment of my cards. Thank you!!!
Nick S
Review left Jul 04 2026
Review
The hardest part is sorting the cards according to the CSV they provide! Quick and easy. Got my money about a week after shipping the cards off.
My only “con” is that they are very strict on card condition. I was expecting around $2900 but got around $2550.
My only “con” is that they are very strict on card condition. I was expecting around $2900 but got around $2550.
The hardest part is sorting the cards according to the CSV they provide! Quick and easy. Got my money about a week after shipping the cards off.
My only “con” is that they are very strict on card condition. I was expecting around $2900 but got around $2550.
My only “con” is that they are very strict on card condition. I was expecting around $2900 but got around $2550.
Zezhong Huang
Review left Jul 04 2026
Review
This was my first and last time selling cards, in a good way. It was very easy for a beginner like me to leave my entire collection in your hands.
This was my first and last time selling cards, in a good way. It was very easy for a beginner like me to leave my entire collection in your hands.
Daren Carmola
Review left Jul 04 2026
Shipment processed Jun 24 2026
Review
It was good seeing the step by step process of my shipment. Upon completing the order, you get a breakdown of the items that was sent in. That's was a great addition to the service.
It was good seeing the step by step process of my shipment. Upon completing the order, you get a breakdown of the items that was sent in. That's was a great addition to the service.
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every
previous customer to leave a review.
Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page.
We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a
review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).