Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service
(6603)
Quinn M.
Review left Aug 06 2026
Review
Card Conduit is exceptional at processing orders and delivering quick payouts. I’ve used the curated service multiple times as it’s an easy method for selling cards out of an organized collection.
Card Conduit is exceptional at processing orders and delivering quick payouts. I’ve used the curated service multiple times as it’s an easy method for selling cards out of an organized collection.
Matthew Michelin
Review left Aug 05 2026
Review
Submitted may cards that have been well-played (i.e. "damaged") in addition to many others in much better condition. Prices were fair and transparent. Process was easy. Thanks!
Submitted may cards that have been well-played (i.e. "damaged") in addition to many others in much better condition. Prices were fair and transparent. Process was easy. Thanks!
Daniel
Review left Aug 05 2026
Review
Process is quick, professionally detailed, and easy. Have used multiple times and never dissatisfied.
Process is quick, professionally detailed, and easy. Have used multiple times and never dissatisfied.
Vina
Review left Aug 05 2026
Review
My son was given over 3,000 magic cards which he stopped playing a while ago. We packed them up and shipped them in and got more than we had expected for them. The process was easy and they pay out a fair price. I recommend using this service if you need to unload a large amount of cards.
My son was given over 3,000 magic cards which he stopped playing a while ago. We packed them up and shipped them in and got more than we had expected for them. The process was easy and they pay out a fair price. I recommend using this service if you need to unload a large amount of cards.
Trevor
Review left Aug 05 2026
Review
Super easy to do and gave great prices. Would recommend to anyone asking where to sell cards
Super easy to do and gave great prices. Would recommend to anyone asking where to sell cards
Will Overton
Review left Aug 05 2026
Review
Very easy and straight forward. I normally do curated lists so glad to see the other processes are simple. It takes longer but it’s expected and disclosed! Will be doing this again as I am consolidating my collection
Very easy and straight forward. I normally do curated lists so glad to see the other processes are simple. It takes longer but it’s expected and disclosed! Will be doing this again as I am consolidating my collection
Logan
Review left Aug 04 2026
Review
The process was easy, and for the cards that weren't as valuable pricing and grading was fair, however for the most valuable card I sent in, a Silver Scroll Vampiric Tutor being graded at Moderately Played was disappointing. Every card shop near me has said the card was lightly played at the worst,
...
Read more
The process was easy, and for the cards that weren't as valuable pricing and grading was fair, however for the most valuable card I sent in, a Silver Scroll Vampiric Tutor being graded at Moderately Played was disappointing. Every card shop near me has said the card was lightly played at the worst, and it's disappointing that Card Conduit would grade it lower based on damage that TCGplayer says is LP.
If you have a lot of cards you're looking to sell, the service is decent and convenient, just make sure you save anything extremely valuable to sell yourself and don't hesitate to have those cards sent back after getting the news that they believe your card is in much worse condition than it actually is.
And as an update to the review several weeks later, I sold the Vampiric Tutor to an LGS, and they fairly and correctly graded the exact same card as Lightly played, giving me a SIGNIFICANT amount more than card conduit offered. Absolutely be cautious sending cards in, know what they're worth, know the condition they're in, and do NOT hesitate getting them sent back if this happens to you too.
If you have a lot of cards you're looking to sell, the service is decent and convenient, just make sure you save anything extremely valuable to sell yourself and don't hesitate to have those cards sent back after getting the news that they believe your card is in much worse condition than it actually is.
And as an update to the review several weeks later, I sold the Vampiric Tutor to an LGS, and they fairly and correctly graded the exact same card as Lightly played, giving me a SIGNIFICANT amount more than card conduit offered. Absolutely be cautious sending cards in, know what they're worth, know the condition they're in, and do NOT hesitate getting them sent back if this happens to you too.
Evan Beam
Review left Aug 04 2026
Review
I was impressed with the speed and accuracy of my order. Even some cards that I would’ve graded lower or were maybe on the fence about were graded fairly and accurately. I thought the process itself was easy and payout was quick. Will use the service again!
I was impressed with the speed and accuracy of my order. Even some cards that I would’ve graded lower or were maybe on the fence about were graded fairly and accurately. I thought the process itself was easy and payout was quick. Will use the service again!
William Chaise Robertson
Review left Aug 04 2026
Review
Easy to deal with, I love the tracking system to show exactly where your shipment is in the process, and the prices are better than anywhere near me. Highly recommend!
Easy to deal with, I love the tracking system to show exactly where your shipment is in the process, and the prices are better than anywhere near me. Highly recommend!
Dillon
Review left Aug 04 2026
Review
Easy process and great customer service when i had questions that needed answering
Easy process and great customer service when i had questions that needed answering
Vince
Review left Aug 03 2026
Review
Everytime I ship the cards are fresh out of the pack and I get 20 or 30 percent less than the actual value amount because you keep marking as LP or MP
Everytime I ship the cards are fresh out of the pack and I get 20 or 30 percent less than the actual value amount because you keep marking as LP or MP
david walser
Review left Aug 03 2026
Review
no i wont reccomnd this to anyone it too costing to ship for small aumot it was my life and some card worth more than it should be coller and shipping cost only profit half of cost i expect alot more it was my collection for longg time
no i wont reccomnd this to anyone it too costing to ship for small aumot it was my life and some card worth more than it should be coller and shipping cost only profit half of cost i expect alot more it was my collection for longg time
Max
Review left Aug 03 2026
Review
80% of the cards I sent in were graded as LP despite the vast majority being pack fresh. I didn't send anything worth more than $20 but I probably wouldn't recommend buylisting anything over $5 for this service. Overall I got slightly above what the LP estimate was but it definitely felt like I was lowballed.
80% of the cards I sent in were graded as LP despite the vast majority being pack fresh. I didn't send anything worth more than $20 but I probably wouldn't recommend buylisting anything over $5 for this service. Overall I got slightly above what the LP estimate was but it definitely felt like I was lowballed.
roland prochaska
Review left Aug 03 2026
Review
only problem I have is that payment is really slow not sure why
only problem I have is that payment is really slow not sure why
Ryan Thomason
Review left Aug 03 2026
Shipment processed Jul 31 2026
Review
The entire process was easy and simple. Not a MTG player, but came into a large collection of cards that was just taking up space in my storage. Glad to be able to offload the cards and hopefully they will make it into the hands of people who will enjoy them. I would highly recommend this service
...
Read more
The entire process was easy and simple. Not a MTG player, but came into a large collection of cards that was just taking up space in my storage. Glad to be able to offload the cards and hopefully they will make it into the hands of people who will enjoy them. I would highly recommend this service if you are looking to sell a large amount of cards and are not concerned about haggling over the price.
Genesis
Review left Aug 02 2026
Review
Process was super fast and easy. Got payment right away. Kept me updated every step of the way.
Process was super fast and easy. Got payment right away. Kept me updated every step of the way.
b. stager
Review left Aug 02 2026
Shipment processed Jul 24 2026
Review
this is the best way ive come accross to sell a lot of cards at once, easily.
this is the best way ive come accross to sell a lot of cards at once, easily.
Marco Garcia
Review left Aug 02 2026
Review
great service like always, thank you so much for your service
great service like always, thank you so much for your service
Marco Garcia
Review left Aug 02 2026
Review
great service like always, thank you so much for your service
great service like always, thank you so much for your service
Marco Garcia
Review left Aug 02 2026
Review
great service like always, thank you so much for your service
great service like always, thank you so much for your service
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every
previous customer to leave a review.
Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page.
We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a
review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).