Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service

Kainan Jarrette
Review left Jan 20 2026
Shipment processed Jan 10 2026
$386.10 payout, $7.88 fees

Review

Process was very easy and straightforward, communication was great, and final price was absolutely fair. Would absolutely do business with again.
Process was very easy and straightforward, communication was great, and final price was absolutely fair. Would absolutely do business with again.
Tamija Tillis
Review left Jan 20 2026
Shipment processed Jan 09 2026
$412.16 payout, $7.55 fees

Review

The process is easy and not complicated. Support got back to me quickly with help and the payouts are very fair
The process is easy and not complicated. Support got back to me quickly with help and the payouts are very fair
Jacob Arford
Review left Jan 20 2026
Shipment processed Jan 10 2026
$1,777.12 payout, $36.27 fees

Review

Boy oh boy where do I even begin. Lebron... honey, my pookie bear. I have loved you ever since I first laid eyes on you. The way you drive into the paint and strike fear into your enemies eyes. Your silky smooth touch around the rim, and that gorgeous jumpshot. I would do anything for you. I wish it ... Read more
Boy oh boy where do I even begin. Lebron... honey, my pookie bear. I have loved you ever since I first laid eyes on you. The way you drive into the paint and strike fear into your enemies eyes. Your silky smooth touch around the rim, and that gorgeous jumpshot. I would do anything for you. I wish it were possible to freeze time so I would never have to watch you retire. You had a rough childhood, but you never gave up hope. You are even amazing off the court, you're a great husband and father, sometimes I even call you dad. I forever dread and weep, thinking of the day you will one day retire. I would sacrifice my own life it were the only thing that could put a smile on your beautiful face. You have given me so much joy, and heartbreak over the years. I remember when you first left clevenland and its like my heart got broken into a million pieces. But a tear still fell from my right eye when I watched you win your first ring in miami, because deep down, my glorious king deserved it. I just wanted you to return home. Then allas, you did, my sweet baby boy came home and I rejoiced. 2015 was a hard year for us baby, but in 2016 you made history happen. You came back from 3-1 and I couldn't believe it. I was crying, bawling even, and I heard my glorious king exclaim these words, "CLEVELAND, THIS IS FOR YOU!" Not only have you changed the game of basketball and the world forever, but you've eternally changed my world. And now you're getting older, but still the goat, my goat. I love you pookie bear, my glorious king, Lebron James.
Alan J.
Review left Jan 19 2026
Shipment processed Jan 15 2026
$5,374.06 payout, $109.67 fees

Review

After my first trial experience selling to them, Card Conduit has earned my business in selling off my collection. The second shipment processed faster then I expected and I was paid very close to the assessed value of my submission. Will be using them again for quick and painless large quantity sales.
After my first trial experience selling to them, Card Conduit has earned my business in selling off my collection. The second shipment processed faster then I expected and I was paid very close to the assessed value of my submission. Will be using them again for quick and painless large quantity sales.
Quick and Easy
Review left Jan 19 2026
Shipment processed Jan 09 2026
$895.43 payout, $16.42 fees

Review

This was quick and I would recommend it to others.
This was quick and I would recommend it to others.
Dan
Review left Jan 19 2026
Shipment processed Jan 10 2026
$245.56 payout, $4.50 fees

Review

Great service. Fair value. Happy with the communication and ease of use. Definitely the place I’ll be sending in cards to again.
Great service. Fair value. Happy with the communication and ease of use. Definitely the place I’ll be sending in cards to again.
Richard
Review left Jan 19 2026
Shipment processed Jan 17 2026
$221.88 payout, $10.46 fees

Review

Used moxfield to get an estimate and card conduit gave me a list of cards to send in. Super easy to figure it out, with clear explanations of the process. Quick turnaround and payment.
Used moxfield to get an estimate and card conduit gave me a list of cards to send in. Super easy to figure it out, with clear explanations of the process. Quick turnaround and payment.
Ian
Review left Jan 18 2026
Shipment processed Jan 16 2026
$577.04 payout, $11.78 fees

Review

The process was incredibly easy, even doing a large-ish sorted shipment. Shipping was easy, the steps updated quickly, and I even got a personalized message with some notes on my shipment when it was all over. The grading also lined up, broadly, with my expectations for cards. I would recommend this service to my friends in a heartbeat.
The process was incredibly easy, even doing a large-ish sorted shipment. Shipping was easy, the steps updated quickly, and I even got a personalized message with some notes on my shipment when it was all over. The grading also lined up, broadly, with my expectations for cards. I would recommend this service to my friends in a heartbeat.
Aaron K.
Review left Jan 18 2026
Shipment processed Dec 17 2025
$920.87 payout, $16.87 fees

Review

Having dealt with Card Conduit before, I knew what to expect. The process remained simple, easy, communication was prompt, and the pricing was incredibly fair. I've shared them and intend to bring more of my own business back
Having dealt with Card Conduit before, I knew what to expect. The process remained simple, easy, communication was prompt, and the pricing was incredibly fair. I've shared them and intend to bring more of my own business back
Alan Johnson
Review left Jan 18 2026
Shipment processed Jan 09 2026
$2,904.44 payout, $59.27 fees

Review

Process was easy and well-defined. A little time consuming for the sorted service, but that comes with the territory if you are trying to maximize your return. The detailed report was comprehensive and the processing speed was as advertised. Will use again. In fact currently have 3 more submissions ... Read more
Process was easy and well-defined. A little time consuming for the sorted service, but that comes with the territory if you are trying to maximize your return. The detailed report was comprehensive and the processing speed was as advertised. Will use again. In fact currently have 3 more submissions active of 400 cards. If you don't have time or energy to sell each card on it's own, this is the solution.
Kory Ortity
Review left Jan 17 2026
Shipment processed Jan 09 2026
$909.21 payout, $16.67 fees

Review

I have worked with Card Conduit multiple times. They provide the best prices for your cards with a fair grading process. Using them I've turned a huge pile of bulk cards into some reserve list investments. Will use again.
I have worked with Card Conduit multiple times. They provide the best prices for your cards with a fair grading process. Using them I've turned a huge pile of bulk cards into some reserve list investments. Will use again.
Sean R
Review left Jan 17 2026
Shipment processed Dec 30 2025
$6,891.61 payout, $249.96 fees

Review

There's a bit of a curve to the process, it's a little daunting if you're shipping a big supply. The team seemed very happy to assist with the process however. I sent in a very sizeable order and received as much as expected. I could have received more if I went with a higher processing part of my o ... Read more
There's a bit of a curve to the process, it's a little daunting if you're shipping a big supply. The team seemed very happy to assist with the process however. I sent in a very sizeable order and received as much as expected. I could have received more if I went with a higher processing part of my own, but the convenience and to get back a sizeable chunk was very appreciated. They even bumped my order from the lowest tier (which I selected for convenience sake) to the mid tier due to the quality of my cards.

Overall, extremely impressed with the customer service and overall process.

However, I will strongly caution to take them at their word about rejected cards. Card Conduit does not seem to send them back automatically. I sent some high value non-english cards which were not included in the shipment write up. They were returned to me, but it was not automatic, it was done after I inquired about them. I appreciate that the rejected cards were returned, but take their terms seriously when they indicate no foreign language cards.

Once again, great service, I'm happy it exists, and I will likely use again.
Chris B
Review left Jan 17 2026
Shipment processed Jan 07 2026
$3,230.58 payout, $65.93 fees

Review

Easy, and speedy. I've done over 10k worth of cards over several shipments. Pretty fast turn around, once cards are inventoried... payment is super fast. I'll be back.
Easy, and speedy. I've done over 10k worth of cards over several shipments. Pretty fast turn around, once cards are inventoried... payment is super fast. I'll be back.
Justin
Review left Jan 17 2026
Shipment processed Jan 09 2026
$1,087.64 payout, $19.93 fees

Review

Use a sorted shipment, trust me. The little extra work to order the cards is worth the 60+% discount on fees compared to the other shipment options
Use a sorted shipment, trust me. The little extra work to order the cards is worth the 60+% discount on fees compared to the other shipment options
Ian W
Review left Jan 17 2026
Shipment processed Jan 03 2026
$61.43 payout, $68.22 fees

Review

Quick, simple, great way to offload bulk. Fair grading system, and all in all just an absolutely fantastic experience. Will use again.
Quick, simple, great way to offload bulk. Fair grading system, and all in all just an absolutely fantastic experience. Will use again.
Paul Chapin
Review left Jan 17 2026
Shipment processed Dec 19 2025
$93.83 payout, $1.91 fees

Review

Girlfriend shipped without tracking...I emailed right away and let Nick or Nathaniel know...they told me they would jeep an eye out for it. After a month thought it was a lost cause, then I get an email stating my shipment had arrived. I was so relieved...I NEVER ship without tracking and insuran ... Read more
Girlfriend shipped without tracking...I emailed right away and let Nick or Nathaniel know...they told me they would jeep an eye out for it. After a month thought it was a lost cause, then I get an email stating my shipment had arrived. I was so relieved...I NEVER ship without tracking and insurance...and never sending girlfriend to do something I should have done myself (don't blame her at all!!!! 100% my bad).
John Boyer
Review left Jan 16 2026
Shipment processed Jan 15 2026
$896.71 payout, $16.43 fees

Review

This is my 3rd shipmentthrough CC and once again, another 10/10 experience. Can't recommend Card Conduit enough.
This is my 3rd shipmentthrough CC and once again, another 10/10 experience. Can't recommend Card Conduit enough.
Kevin Fish
Review left Jan 16 2026
Shipment processed Jan 14 2026
$693.12 payout, $32.66 fees

Review

Overall a simple and convenient way to liquidate my unwanted cards.
Overall a simple and convenient way to liquidate my unwanted cards.
Juan Ceballo
Review left Jan 15 2026
Shipment processed Jan 06 2026
$407.60 payout, $5.79 fees

Review

the process was pretty easy, they provide quite clear instructions on the website and made things smooth for sending out my cards. I felt it was priced fairly and kept me updated during the process, including informing me about the delay due to the holiday. overall easy and good experience would definitely plan on using again on next selling order
the process was pretty easy, they provide quite clear instructions on the website and made things smooth for sending out my cards. I felt it was priced fairly and kept me updated during the process, including informing me about the delay due to the holiday. overall easy and good experience would definitely plan on using again on next selling order
Brian H
Review left Jan 15 2026
Shipment processed Dec 19 2025
$1,269.22 payout, $46.03 fees

Review

I would 100% recommend this service to anyone thinking of cleaning out old unused cards. Couldn't be easier, just package up everything and ship!
I would 100% recommend this service to anyone thinking of cleaning out old unused cards. Couldn't be easier, just package up everything and ship!
1 2 ... 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 ... 281 282
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every previous customer to leave a review. Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page. We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).