Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service
(6840)
Dino Hall
Review left Sep 25 2026
Review
I reviewed all the cards before sending out and the number they marked down from NM this time seemed extremely excessive compared to prior times using the service. Dropped payout by $100 and just did not seem right.
I reviewed all the cards before sending out and the number they marked down from NM this time seemed extremely excessive compared to prior times using the service. Dropped payout by $100 and just did not seem right.
Quinn Dunphrey
Review left Sep 25 2026
Review
All of it was very simple and easy to use. Will use again
All of it was very simple and easy to use. Will use again
Joel
Review left Sep 25 2026
Review
I sent a bunch of cards that had never been in a deck to Card Conduit. Their graders are extremely hard on cards. I sent 2 shipments to another site, and got much better grades on cards that were not as nice as the ones I sent o CardConduit.
I sent a bunch of cards that had never been in a deck to Card Conduit. Their graders are extremely hard on cards. I sent 2 shipments to another site, and got much better grades on cards that were not as nice as the ones I sent o CardConduit.
Jason
Review left Sep 24 2026
Review
Easy service, cost me 50$ on 6000 . 50 cent cards equalling 1000$ or so will keep using this has revolutionized me buying bulk. Would have taken days manually adding to card kingdom
Easy service, cost me 50$ on 6000 . 50 cent cards equalling 1000$ or so will keep using this has revolutionized me buying bulk. Would have taken days manually adding to card kingdom
Jasons
Review left Sep 24 2026
Review
Easy service, cost me 50$ on 6000 . 50 cent cards equalling 1000$ or so will keep using this has revolutionized me buying bulk. Would have taken days manually adding to card kingdom
Easy service, cost me 50$ on 6000 . 50 cent cards equalling 1000$ or so will keep using this has revolutionized me buying bulk. Would have taken days manually adding to card kingdom
Jason
Review left Sep 24 2026
Review
Easy service, cost me 50$ on 6000 . 50 cent cards equalling 1000$ or so will keep using this has revolutionized me buying bulk. Would have taken days manually adding to card kingdom
Easy service, cost me 50$ on 6000 . 50 cent cards equalling 1000$ or so will keep using this has revolutionized me buying bulk. Would have taken days manually adding to card kingdom
Alex Haluska
Review left Sep 24 2026
Review
Was easy to send in the cards, great pricing and solid feedback. 10/10
Was easy to send in the cards, great pricing and solid feedback. 10/10
Carter
Review left Sep 24 2026
Shipment processed Sep 15 2026
Review
This is the easiest way to sell your cards. They will grade them fairly aggressively but it's fair considering they need to resell them.
This is the easiest way to sell your cards. They will grade them fairly aggressively but it's fair considering they need to resell them.
Alex Bennett
Review left Sep 23 2026
Review
Very consistent and fair with card conditions and easy to ship out.
Very consistent and fair with card conditions and easy to ship out.
Jeff
Review left Sep 23 2026
Shipment processed Sep 04 2026
Review
They processed fast. Overall great experience but they continue to under value cards and say the are lightly played on higer valed cards and under paid for these cards.
They processed fast. Overall great experience but they continue to under value cards and say the are lightly played on higer valed cards and under paid for these cards.
Dan
Review left Sep 23 2026
Review
Super easy to trade in some cards, love sending them to Card Conduit!
Super easy to trade in some cards, love sending them to Card Conduit!
Darren Lindemann
Review left Sep 23 2026
Review
Easy fast great awesome i need 30 more characters to submit
Easy fast great awesome i need 30 more characters to submit
Danny
Review left Sep 23 2026
Review
I’ve completed multiple shipments now with Card Conduit, and it has been stellar every single time. Communication throughout the entire process is right on point. I love working with this company and always have excellent experiences.
I’ve completed multiple shipments now with Card Conduit, and it has been stellar every single time. Communication throughout the entire process is right on point. I love working with this company and always have excellent experiences.
Andrew
Review left Sep 23 2026
Shipment processed Sep 21 2026
Review
The entire process from start to finish was fantastic. Turnaround time was faster than expected and the prices I got for the cards I submitted was fair and reasonable. An excellent way to slim down a collection without trying to sell to multiple different buy lists.
The entire process from start to finish was fantastic. Turnaround time was faster than expected and the prices I got for the cards I submitted was fair and reasonable. An excellent way to slim down a collection without trying to sell to multiple different buy lists.
nicholaus williams
Review left Sep 23 2026
Review
I appreciate the clear communication, the ease of working together, the fair evaluation, and the good payout.
I appreciate the clear communication, the ease of working together, the fair evaluation, and the good payout.
Matthew
Review left Sep 22 2026
Review
This was my first time sending cards to Card Conduit, and it couldn't have gone smoother. I sent 1000 cards using Curated service. I did notice a few errors in their report (a missing card, and cards flagged as bulk that weren't bulk), and they did not hesitate to correct them. I would definitely use their services again.
This was my first time sending cards to Card Conduit, and it couldn't have gone smoother. I sent 1000 cards using Curated service. I did notice a few errors in their report (a missing card, and cards flagged as bulk that weren't bulk), and they did not hesitate to correct them. I would definitely use their services again.
Nathan Bundy
Review left Sep 22 2026
Review
Between quotes ahead of time, clear communication all along the way, and great buylist rates, Card Conduit continues to be my go-to way to trade in my collection, bulk, sorted, or curated. Great company and excellent service.
Between quotes ahead of time, clear communication all along the way, and great buylist rates, Card Conduit continues to be my go-to way to trade in my collection, bulk, sorted, or curated. Great company and excellent service.
Sean McVannel
Review left Sep 22 2026
Review
Other places force you make dozens of smaller packages to send. Just sort the foils out!? Card conduit will always be my ideal place to send!
Other places force you make dozens of smaller packages to send. Just sort the foils out!? Card conduit will always be my ideal place to send!
Michael A
Review left Sep 21 2026
Review
Easy process like usual! I still really enjoy using this service when I have cards just sitting around that have value.
Easy process like usual! I still really enjoy using this service when I have cards just sitting around that have value.
Chandler Gatlin
Review left Sep 21 2026
Review
Very simple and streamlined! Actually took me longer to choose which cards I wanted to send out of my collection than the actual process of setting up the shipment, but after that it was very reliving to not have to worry about handling things much further. And the value I got back from the cards th
...
Read more
Very simple and streamlined! Actually took me longer to choose which cards I wanted to send out of my collection than the actual process of setting up the shipment, but after that it was very reliving to not have to worry about handling things much further. And the value I got back from the cards themselves seemed to be fair, so overall I’d definitely recommend!
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every
previous customer to leave a review.
Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page.
We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a
review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).