Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service
(5856)
Luis Buitrago
Review left Mar 01 2026
Shipment processed Feb 21 2026
Review
The process to upload a CSV file and proceed from there was so smooth, I wish this would have been the platform I used before. My only concern is that there were multiple cards in my shipment that were quite literally straight from the pack (or secret lair pack) into a sleeve and then sent into the
...
Read more
The process to upload a CSV file and proceed from there was so smooth, I wish this would have been the platform I used before. My only concern is that there were multiple cards in my shipment that were quite literally straight from the pack (or secret lair pack) into a sleeve and then sent into the order (no sleeve) and were marked as light play. Perhaps that is the one thing I noticed, multiple cards got dinged that way but otherwise, I highly recommend this platform.
Ian
Review left Mar 01 2026
Shipment processed Jan 27 2026
Review
Card conduit was very proactive, transparent, and professional. Would recommend!
Card conduit was very proactive, transparent, and professional. Would recommend!
walter bunts
Review left Feb 28 2026
Review
was a little worried sending my cards off to strangers but there was no need to worry.
very helpful staff and the grading was what i expected.
will send more cardss again
very helpful staff and the grading was what i expected.
will send more cardss again
was a little worried sending my cards off to strangers but there was no need to worry.
very helpful staff and the grading was what i expected.
will send more cardss again
very helpful staff and the grading was what i expected.
will send more cardss again
Anthony Acampora
Review left Feb 28 2026
Review
I can’t say enough great things about Nick Anderson at Card Conduit. He made the entire process of selling my sealed Magic: The Gathering product incredibly fast, simple, and completely stress-free. From start to finish, everything was handled with professionalism, transparency, and efficiency.
... Read more
... Read more
I can’t say enough great things about Nick Anderson at Card Conduit. He made the entire process of selling my sealed Magic: The Gathering product incredibly fast, simple, and completely stress-free. From start to finish, everything was handled with professionalism, transparency, and efficiency.
Nick was super responsive, explained every step clearly, and made sure I felt confident throughout the process. What could have been a complicated, time-consuming experience turned into something smooth and effortless. I never once felt unsure about what was happening, and the communication was top-tier the entire time.
If you’re looking to sell Magic cards or sealed product and want a trustworthy, easy, and professional experience, Nick is the guy to work with. Truly a 5-star experience — I would absolutely use Card Conduit again and highly recommend Nick to anyone in the hobby.
Nick was super responsive, explained every step clearly, and made sure I felt confident throughout the process. What could have been a complicated, time-consuming experience turned into something smooth and effortless. I never once felt unsure about what was happening, and the communication was top-tier the entire time.
If you’re looking to sell Magic cards or sealed product and want a trustworthy, easy, and professional experience, Nick is the guy to work with. Truly a 5-star experience — I would absolutely use Card Conduit again and highly recommend Nick to anyone in the hobby.
Aiden Davenport
Review left Feb 28 2026
Review
I've sold cards to Card Kingdom. Working with Card Conduit was as professional and expedient as my experiences with other companies.
I've sold cards to Card Kingdom. Working with Card Conduit was as professional and expedient as my experiences with other companies.
Alberto Alvarez
Review left Feb 28 2026
Review
This was my first time using card conduit, the process was incredibly easy and got a decent payout. More than expected from my Local game store. Shipment was straightforward following guides provided by team.
This was my first time using card conduit, the process was incredibly easy and got a decent payout. More than expected from my Local game store. Shipment was straightforward following guides provided by team.
Kevin Levi Glenn
Review left Feb 28 2026
Review
I honestly wasn't sure what to expect when I submitted my cards to sell but overall I was very pleased with the experience. They processed my shipment very quickly and most of my cards were in NM/LP condition and they were graded as such.
I honestly wasn't sure what to expect when I submitted my cards to sell but overall I was very pleased with the experience. They processed my shipment very quickly and most of my cards were in NM/LP condition and they were graded as such.
Alex
Review left Feb 28 2026
Review
Just sorted my value cards from my bulk and ordered as best I could to the provided list. Got a great price that I don't think I could of managed without spending months trying to sell one by one.
Just sorted my value cards from my bulk and ordered as best I could to the provided list. Got a great price that I don't think I could of managed without spending months trying to sell one by one.
Evan b
Review left Feb 27 2026
Review
I love card conduit. They make everything so easy and always come thru. I started proxying all my cards and i only play cube so i have no need for my collection anymore. After i play limited for a while ill use my real cards to sell to card conduit
I love card conduit. They make everything so easy and always come thru. I started proxying all my cards and i only play cube so i have no need for my collection anymore. After i play limited for a while ill use my real cards to sell to card conduit
Susana
Review left Feb 27 2026
Review
Service was great. They delivered in the time they said and overall very good first time experience. Definitely recommend and will do again!
Service was great. They delivered in the time they said and overall very good first time experience. Definitely recommend and will do again!
Brad McArtor
Review left Feb 27 2026
Shipment processed Feb 18 2026
$55.55
payout, $17.11
fees
Review
I operate a Hobby store, and I often find myself purchasing collections with a middle ground of card that are not quite worth listing, and not quite worth bulking out. Card Conduit sits in a nice spot in the (value derived / time spent) calculation that leaves me making shipments for them regularly, a few times a year.
I operate a Hobby store, and I often find myself purchasing collections with a middle ground of card that are not quite worth listing, and not quite worth bulking out. Card Conduit sits in a nice spot in the (value derived / time spent) calculation that leaves me making shipments for them regularly, a few times a year.
Marco
Review left Feb 27 2026
Review
great communication, things processed in a timely fashion
great communication, things processed in a timely fashion
Ryan
Review left Feb 26 2026
Review
The process was very simple- no issues with tracking the delivery and the WebUI contains enough information to have an idea where I was during the process. Prices were fair and transparent. Looking forward to using the service again!
The process was very simple- no issues with tracking the delivery and the WebUI contains enough information to have an idea where I was during the process. Prices were fair and transparent. Looking forward to using the service again!
Justin Gonzales
Review left Feb 26 2026
Review
Nick Anderson was extremely helpful and thorough with his review and assessment of my shipment. This process was smooth and convenient, I will definitely be recommending your services to others.
Nick Anderson was extremely helpful and thorough with his review and assessment of my shipment. This process was smooth and convenient, I will definitely be recommending your services to others.
Jorge
Review left Feb 26 2026
Shipment processed Feb 18 2026
Review
Very clear instructions and transparent in process.
Very clear instructions and transparent in process.
Chris Cornell
Review left Feb 26 2026
Review
Process was extremely simple after importing the card list. Good communication throughout the process and grading felt very fair.
Process was extremely simple after importing the card list. Good communication throughout the process and grading felt very fair.
Jacob Dominguez
Review left Feb 26 2026
Review
I was nervous for sure going into selling cards(first time, hasn't been in the MTG scene for long), so I wasn't sure if I'd get even a minutia of the value of the cards. I was more than pleasantly surprised, the trade-off for the fractional fees in exchange for the convenience and piece of mind Card
...
Read more
I was nervous for sure going into selling cards(first time, hasn't been in the MTG scene for long), so I wasn't sure if I'd get even a minutia of the value of the cards. I was more than pleasantly surprised, the trade-off for the fractional fees in exchange for the convenience and piece of mind Card Conduit provides was more than enough for me personally. If I ever want to sell cards again, I'll know where to go.
Chris
Review left Feb 26 2026
Shipment processed Feb 17 2026
Review
This was too easy. I found a bunch of cards I no longer needed, boxed them up, creeted a shipment, and sent them on their way. Once received they kept me apprised of everything and then sent me a report. Too easy. Highly recommend
This was too easy. I found a bunch of cards I no longer needed, boxed them up, creeted a shipment, and sent them on their way. Once received they kept me apprised of everything and then sent me a report. Too easy. Highly recommend
Jorge Martinez Jr.
Review left Feb 26 2026
Shipment processed Feb 18 2026
Review
Great self service tools and honestly the best way to sell cards your lgs may not buy from you at all or buy at a price well below fair price.
Highly recommend Card Conduit for anyone looking to thin out a collection.
Highly recommend Card Conduit for anyone looking to thin out a collection.
Great self service tools and honestly the best way to sell cards your lgs may not buy from you at all or buy at a price well below fair price.
Highly recommend Card Conduit for anyone looking to thin out a collection.
Highly recommend Card Conduit for anyone looking to thin out a collection.
Kyler
Review left Feb 26 2026
Shipment processed Feb 18 2026
Review
Ive used Card Conduit quite a bit, and plan to continue using them, but will be much more selective with what I ship due to how harsh the grading on cards is. Currently the ease of use is outweighing the downside of the harsh grading.
Ive used Card Conduit quite a bit, and plan to continue using them, but will be much more selective with what I ship due to how harsh the grading on cards is. Currently the ease of use is outweighing the downside of the harsh grading.
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every
previous customer to leave a review.
Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page.
We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a
review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).