Chat with us

Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service

(2583)
Trent Broeckel
Review left Feb 27 2024
Shipment processed Jan 18 2024
$237.90 payout, $4.36 fees

Review

Overall, CC makes selling cards pretty darn easy and at a great value. There was great communication at every step with clear instructions . Once my cards had been received at CC they were checked very quickly and payment arrived quick as well. 10/10 would use again :)
Overall, CC makes selling cards pretty darn easy and at a great value. There was great communication at every step with clear instructions . Once my cards had been received at CC they were checked very quickly and payment arrived quick as well. 10/10 would use again :)
Mark
Review left Feb 26 2024
Shipment processed Feb 16 2024
$903.04 payout, $18.43 fees

Review

I was nervous shipping off my collection to try and sell some valuable cards. I had a great experience. Card Conduit communicated early and often and made me confident in my choice to work with them. I'd certainly recommend them to others.
I was nervous shipping off my collection to try and sell some valuable cards. I had a great experience. Card Conduit communicated early and often and made me confident in my choice to work with them. I'd certainly recommend them to others.
Eric
Review left Feb 26 2024
Shipment processed Feb 13 2024
$554.49 payout, $10.16 fees

Review

Another great experience, easy to deal with and great payouts. I wish my LGS was able to match prices but CC was able to give me almost $200 more than they offered.
Another great experience, easy to deal with and great payouts. I wish my LGS was able to match prices but CC was able to give me almost $200 more than they offered.
Reilynn
Review left Feb 26 2024
Shipment processed Feb 16 2024
$649.39 payout, $11.91 fees

Review

I would recommend them, they reached out to me when they didn’t need to the process was easy the price for the cards was more than fair, i would definitely use them again!
I would recommend them, they reached out to me when they didn’t need to the process was easy the price for the cards was more than fair, i would definitely use them again!
Alan Larsen
Review left Feb 26 2024
Shipment processed Feb 17 2024
$250.25 payout, $11.79 fees

Review

I sent in a bunch of Planechase planes with my last batch of cards, apparently they don't process them. that's on me for sending them in blind no questions asked. Still love the service it is the only way I sell cards for a few years now. TYVM!
I sent in a bunch of Planechase planes with my last batch of cards, apparently they don't process them. that's on me for sending them in blind no questions asked. Still love the service it is the only way I sell cards for a few years now. TYVM!
Casey T.
Review left Feb 26 2024
Shipment processed Feb 13 2024
$2,894.47 payout, $59.07 fees

Review

The whole process was easy to get through. The price check tool was extremely helpful and the steps are laid out in a manageable way. Nick checked in with me directly; it was nice to know an actual person was overseeing your shipment. I plan on using card conduit again in the future!
The whole process was easy to get through. The price check tool was extremely helpful and the steps are laid out in a manageable way. Nick checked in with me directly; it was nice to know an actual person was overseeing your shipment. I plan on using card conduit again in the future!
Gage Boquet
Review left Feb 26 2024
Shipment processed Jan 20 2024
$1,724.91 payout, $35.20 fees

Review

The process went as described. The people were transparent about the process. Overall I am satisfied with the service and recommend to anyone who may want to sell some magic cards without the hassle of listing cards and waiting for sellers.
The process went as described. The people were transparent about the process. Overall I am satisfied with the service and recommend to anyone who may want to sell some magic cards without the hassle of listing cards and waiting for sellers.
Ethan poppleton
Review left Feb 26 2024
Shipment processed Feb 15 2024
$15.64 payout, No fees
*Fees were waived during a special promotion.

Review

I marked the wrong thing and they fixed it immediately and emailed me about what to do in the future
I marked the wrong thing and they fixed it immediately and emailed me about what to do in the future
Andrew Beane
Review left Feb 25 2024
Shipment processed Jan 20 2024
$734.56 payout, $13.46 fees

Review

Such a smooth and easy process to send in my old magic cards and get a good percentage of their value. I don't have the time or want to make the effort sell them individually and deal with random people and their complaints and returns - let Card Conduit deal with all of that! I have already recom ... Read more
Such a smooth and easy process to send in my old magic cards and get a good percentage of their value. I don't have the time or want to make the effort sell them individually and deal with random people and their complaints and returns - let Card Conduit deal with all of that! I have already recommended Card Conduit to family members and friends that I played magic with 20 years ago and after seeing the $$$ I received they are going through their cards now!
Nicola Bruno
Review left Feb 25 2024
Shipment processed Feb 15 2024

Review

First time trying out. Saved me time looking for the best pay out. Compared the price of the card to other website that direct buy and they were either a match or comparable.
First time trying out. Saved me time looking for the best pay out. Compared the price of the card to other website that direct buy and they were either a match or comparable.
Christopher C.
Review left Feb 25 2024
Shipment processed Feb 15 2024
$6,679.78 payout, $351.57 fees

Review

Not only was the process itself completely painless and transparent, but even simple emails regarding concerns I had were answered quick and courteously before I even sent the shipment!
Not only was the process itself completely painless and transparent, but even simple emails regarding concerns I had were answered quick and courteously before I even sent the shipment!
Don Roth
Review left Feb 25 2024
Shipment processed Feb 22 2024

Review

I am pleased with how easy the whole process was. Fair grading and and fast payment. I plan to use again.
I am pleased with how easy the whole process was. Fair grading and and fast payment. I plan to use again.
James Shaw
Review left Feb 24 2024
Shipment processed Feb 13 2024
$602.36 payout, $12.29 fees

Review

The process was very easy and much less stressful than selling directly to customers. I will definitely use this site again
The process was very easy and much less stressful than selling directly to customers. I will definitely use this site again
Andrew D
Review left Feb 24 2024
Shipment processed Feb 13 2024
$339.11 payout, $6.92 fees

Review

This is my 5th or 6th time sending cards in. Always a great transaction. Saves a TON of time trying to sell off cards. Could I make more per card if I worked harder on my own? Yes, probably… but it’s definitely a trade off for the time saved by just sending everything to Card Conduit. Definitely recommend!
This is my 5th or 6th time sending cards in. Always a great transaction. Saves a TON of time trying to sell off cards. Could I make more per card if I worked harder on my own? Yes, probably… but it’s definitely a trade off for the time saved by just sending everything to Card Conduit. Definitely recommend!
Joshua
Review left Feb 24 2024
Shipment processed Feb 17 2024
$74.42 payout, $24.77 fees

Review

Well unfortunately I wouldn't recommend them to anybody they have a grading scale that is everything you think is mint is lp and they buy list expensive lands they literally buylist 15$ urza's powerplants and tower as buylist I sent over 1500 cards 76 if which I had almost sent to another buylist co ... Read more
Well unfortunately I wouldn't recommend them to anybody they have a grading scale that is everything you think is mint is lp and they buy list expensive lands they literally buylist 15$ urza's powerplants and tower as buylist I sent over 1500 cards 76 if which I had almost sent to another buylist company for 150$ which was huge mistake I didn't because these people literally didn't even give me 100$ for over 1600 cards I highly recommend going anywhere else what's worse is once they process your order they own it you have no chance to back out you just have to accept it one of the worst experiences ive ever had I recommend sending your cards anywhere but here
Card Conduit Team

Replied Feb 24 2024

We understand it can be frustrating when your expectations are not met using our service. In this case, the customer mistakenly identified their Foreign Chronicles cards for Antiquities cards – which is certainly easy to do since Foreign Chronicles cards have a black border and look much closer to the Antiquities versions than English Chronicles (which have a white border) – but this misidentification has resulted in the customer having incorrect value expectations coming into the process. Furthermore, the vast majority of the cards sent in this shipment were bulk; we waived half of our fees since it was clear there was misunderstanding of how bulk affects payouts, but even with half the fees waived, the fees to process the shipment were nearly $25.

We understand that grading cards may not be everyone's forte. We are always happy to provide additional information regarding grading to help get on the same page for that shipment and any future shipments. You do agree that the ... Read more
We understand it can be frustrating when your expectations are not met using our service. In this case, the customer mistakenly identified their Foreign Chronicles cards for Antiquities cards – which is certainly easy to do since Foreign Chronicles cards have a black border and look much closer to the Antiquities versions than English Chronicles (which have a white border) – but this misidentification has resulted in the customer having incorrect value expectations coming into the process. Furthermore, the vast majority of the cards sent in this shipment were bulk; we waived half of our fees since it was clear there was misunderstanding of how bulk affects payouts, but even with half the fees waived, the fees to process the shipment were nearly $25.

We understand that grading cards may not be everyone's forte. We are always happy to provide additional information regarding grading to help get on the same page for that shipment and any future shipments. You do agree that the cards will not be returned, but ultimately our goal is to find an agreeable solution – but, that cannot happen if you do not reach out to us to discuss the situation. For anyone considering the service that is concerned with the grading and/or their ability to assess the grades of their own cards, we always recommend you request a hold for review, which gives you the opportunity to review and discuss the report with us prior to it being finalized.
Alex
Review left Feb 24 2024
Shipment processed Feb 13 2024
$210.00 payout, No fees
*Fees were waived during a special promotion.

Review

I had some sealed product to offload, and Card Conduit offered the best price. Setting up the sale in the portal was very easy and I received constant updates on the status of my shipment and payment. Would strongly recommend.
I had some sealed product to offload, and Card Conduit offered the best price. Setting up the sale in the portal was very easy and I received constant updates on the status of my shipment and payment. Would strongly recommend.
Fernando Arteaga
Review left Feb 23 2024
Shipment processed Jan 30 2024
$935.30 payout, $44.07 fees

Review

I had a positive experience collaborating with the Card Conduit team. As I was stepping away from the hobby, I decided to sell my collection, which held a moderate value. I shipped it via UPS with insurance coverage. Unfortunately, upon arrival, the cards were in poor condition due to mishandling by ... Read more
I had a positive experience collaborating with the Card Conduit team. As I was stepping away from the hobby, I decided to sell my collection, which held a moderate value. I shipped it via UPS with insurance coverage. Unfortunately, upon arrival, the cards were in poor condition due to mishandling by UPS—they were wet, damaged, and packaged differently from the original. The Card Conduit team promptly informed me of the situation and remained transparent throughout. Despite my efforts to claim insurance from UPS, they ultimately denied any reimbursement after extensive communication with their customer service. My advice is to insure your shipment and meticulously document all details, including taking pictures of the package and saving all registry information, to hold UPS accountable in case of damage. Otherwise, it becomes a matter of your word against theirs. Nonetheless, the Card Conduit team was consistently helpful and responsive. After failing to secure insurance compensation from UPS, I authorized Card Conduit to proceed with assessing and selling my cards. They returned the most damaged ones to me. I would recommend Card Conduit's service, with the caveat to exercise caution when dealing with shipments.
Tyler Harris
Review left Feb 23 2024
Shipment processed Feb 13 2024
$594.59 payout, $10.90 fees

Review

This process was easy and straightforward, and the staff was timely and professional when responding to my questions. This is the best way to sell your cards. No LGS prive gouges or having to list each card individually online.
This process was easy and straightforward, and the staff was timely and professional when responding to my questions. This is the best way to sell your cards. No LGS prive gouges or having to list each card individually online.
Philip Honeycutt
Review left Feb 23 2024
Shipment processed Feb 13 2024
$517.82 payout, $10.57 fees

Review

The process of selling my cards was much less daunting than expected. I had used the Delver Lense app to scan everything I had into a list and uploaded it to Card Conduit's site. The site then automatically pursed the information and told me the values and what they would offer for them. Upon me sor ... Read more
The process of selling my cards was much less daunting than expected. I had used the Delver Lense app to scan everything I had into a list and uploaded it to Card Conduit's site. The site then automatically pursed the information and told me the values and what they would offer for them. Upon me sorting the cards I chose to send them - per their currated service - I sent it off only to receive super fast responses from the team that my order was received. Overall process was fast and I was kept in the loop at every step of the way. This team offers an amazing service at reasonable rates that I have yet to find a better alternative for - nor do I think I ever will. 10/10 recommend

(I also am editing my review as I just saw my stats and there is a section on most cards by an artist which is super cool, and now I feel like I want to start a collection based off of the art, thank you)
SenapiSpidey
Review left Feb 23 2024
Shipment processed Feb 13 2024
$574.31 payout, $10.53 fees

Review

Selling vintage cards is not easy, because you have to find the collectors that want them. It's nice to find a place that will just outright buy them, instead of sitting on them for years. I was a little disappointed about the conditions/versions being lower than originally thought, but that's not r ... Read more
Selling vintage cards is not easy, because you have to find the collectors that want them. It's nice to find a place that will just outright buy them, instead of sitting on them for years. I was a little disappointed about the conditions/versions being lower than originally thought, but that's not really CardConduits fault, more the "whatNot" sellers lying about conditions/versions.

10/10 recommend, especially if you've been sitting on cards that just aren't selling.
1 2 ... 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 ... 129 130
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every previous customer to leave a review. Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page. We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).