Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service
(5856)
Elias Inaty
Review left Mar 05 2026
Review
I was using this service to downsize my collection primarily. I had my list from a trade binder and the 16000 or so bulk I had lying around. My hope was to make a little money back and to at least pay for shipping. My expectations were blown out of the water. I won’t be offloading my Magic cards a
...
Read more
I was using this service to downsize my collection primarily. I had my list from a trade binder and the 16000 or so bulk I had lying around. My hope was to make a little money back and to at least pay for shipping. My expectations were blown out of the water. I won’t be offloading my Magic cards any other way now. I’ve sold to LGS and card shows, but nothing beats how clean the whole experience is for Card Conduit. Shoutout to Joel Are Magic for the recommendation.
David Pujol
Review left Mar 05 2026
Review
The shipping guide contained plenty of information on how to properly package and send out my cards. They were then promptly sorted and evaluated, resulting in a comprehensive report.
The process was very easy from start to finish and I was well informed of everything along the way.
I hope s ... Read more
The process was very easy from start to finish and I was well informed of everything along the way.
I hope s ... Read more
The shipping guide contained plenty of information on how to properly package and send out my cards. They were then promptly sorted and evaluated, resulting in a comprehensive report.
The process was very easy from start to finish and I was well informed of everything along the way.
I hope someone else can enjoy those cards as much as I have over the years.
The process was very easy from start to finish and I was well informed of everything along the way.
I hope someone else can enjoy those cards as much as I have over the years.
Michael Atkinson
Review left Mar 05 2026
Review
I sent it 60-something cards and got a return of about $350. I'm very happy with this service and have used them a few times now.
I sent it 60-something cards and got a return of about $350. I'm very happy with this service and have used them a few times now.
Jon
Review left Mar 05 2026
Review
The process, once studied, becomes Insanely easy. I like to sort my cards myself. The grading wasn’t 100% to my liking, but I understand that’s how they make money. Used “KingdomsTV” code for discounted fees. I’d say 85% positive grading. Would recommend for sure.
The process, once studied, becomes Insanely easy. I like to sort my cards myself. The grading wasn’t 100% to my liking, but I understand that’s how they make money. Used “KingdomsTV” code for discounted fees. I’d say 85% positive grading. Would recommend for sure.
Julius C. Pina
Review left Mar 05 2026
Review
The process was extremely easy and to the point. The payout for the cards perfect it was better than expected. Definitely will recommend the service as well as using it again for myself.
The process was extremely easy and to the point. The payout for the cards perfect it was better than expected. Definitely will recommend the service as well as using it again for myself.
T.Green
Review left Mar 04 2026
Review
Payout was quick on this one, less than 4 days. Service is great!
Payout was quick on this one, less than 4 days. Service is great!
Joshua Fagin
Review left Mar 04 2026
Review
The hardest part was letting go and deciding to sell the cards. The shipment directions are easy, the sortment process was quick, the payout was even quicker. Every card shop in the city would've paid me out at half the value of my cards, but card conduit kept the smallest fee leaving me with the biggest payout ive ever heard of. Use. This. Service!
The hardest part was letting go and deciding to sell the cards. The shipment directions are easy, the sortment process was quick, the payout was even quicker. Every card shop in the city would've paid me out at half the value of my cards, but card conduit kept the smallest fee leaving me with the biggest payout ive ever heard of. Use. This. Service!
Michael
Review left Mar 04 2026
Review
I use Card Conduit for sending about 40-50 cards at a time. It is an easy process. All I do is input the cards I want to sell, sort them according to the order they provide, put them in a plastic box and then in a bubble mailer, mail to them and in a week or 2 I get money for cards that I didn't need anymore.
I use Card Conduit for sending about 40-50 cards at a time. It is an easy process. All I do is input the cards I want to sell, sort them according to the order they provide, put them in a plastic box and then in a bubble mailer, mail to them and in a week or 2 I get money for cards that I didn't need anymore.
Delbert
Review left Mar 04 2026
Review
Fairly priced and very organized. If you're looking for a hassle-free selling experience for magic cards, this is one worth investing into.
Fairly priced and very organized. If you're looking for a hassle-free selling experience for magic cards, this is one worth investing into.
Isiah Stewart
Review left Mar 03 2026
Review
I made about as much as I would have if I sold them myself. The service was easy to use!
I made about as much as I would have if I sold them myself. The service was easy to use!
Ronnie Rickman
Review left Mar 03 2026
Review
Overall the process was very easy and simple. There were clear instructions on what to do along with consistent updates on the process with realistic expectations on the timeline. They were fairly quick and it was a great experience overall!
Overall the process was very easy and simple. There were clear instructions on what to do along with consistent updates on the process with realistic expectations on the timeline. They were fairly quick and it was a great experience overall!
Tommie
Review left Mar 03 2026
Review
Card conduit provides an awesome step-by-step process to selling them your cards. And I compared the money that they were willing to give me to two LGS’s and Card Conduit provided me more money for less cards. I love my local LGS’s but some times they try to give nothing for your collection.
Card conduit provides an awesome step-by-step process to selling them your cards. And I compared the money that they were willing to give me to two LGS’s and Card Conduit provided me more money for less cards. I love my local LGS’s but some times they try to give nothing for your collection.
Toby Conachan
Review left Mar 03 2026
Review
2nd time using this service and it was seamless. I will continue to use Card Conduit for selling my medium to high value cards!
2nd time using this service and it was seamless. I will continue to use Card Conduit for selling my medium to high value cards!
Joseph
Review left Mar 03 2026
Review
Every step was clearly communicated, a deadline was given and the full process, including payment, was completed before the time given. Exactly what I wanted out of a service like this. Definitely recommending this to freinds.
Every step was clearly communicated, a deadline was given and the full process, including payment, was completed before the time given. Exactly what I wanted out of a service like this. Definitely recommending this to freinds.
Justin
Review left Mar 03 2026
Review
I was very pleased with the service provided for selling my cards with card conduit. I selected the curated service and took the time to ensure all of my cards when searched in their database qualified for this service. I put them in a deck box and shipped them off. They stayed in communication thr
...
Read more
I was very pleased with the service provided for selling my cards with card conduit. I selected the curated service and took the time to ensure all of my cards when searched in their database qualified for this service. I put them in a deck box and shipped them off. They stayed in communication throughout the process and updated me on the status of the order. Once approved, payment was very fast. I had quite a few cards and haven't played in a very long time and did not want to go through the bother of selling each card one by one. This was a great service and highly recommended.
Bryan
Review left Mar 02 2026
Review
Process was easy, quick, and I was satisfied with my results!
Process was easy, quick, and I was satisfied with my results!
Brandon
Review left Mar 02 2026
Review
The process is simple and relatively fast. They categorize everything that was sent in and explain any changes that are made.
The process is simple and relatively fast. They categorize everything that was sent in and explain any changes that are made.
Max Luna
Review left Mar 02 2026
Review
I reviewed the reports and agreed with the payout.
I reviewed the reports and agreed with the payout.
Martin Johnson
Review left Mar 02 2026
Review
Due to the size of the shipment, I was impressed by the speed it was processed.
Due to the size of the shipment, I was impressed by the speed it was processed.
Spencer
Review left Mar 01 2026
Shipment processed Feb 21 2026
$522.33
payout, $21.76
fees
Review
I have used Card Kingdom several times, and they have always been really easy to use, fast, and given fair value for the cards. In each case, I sent in my "bulk rares," most of which were under 1 dollar in value and was able to turn that into 500+ dollars each time. New Zelle option is even easier
...
Read more
I have used Card Kingdom several times, and they have always been really easy to use, fast, and given fair value for the cards. In each case, I sent in my "bulk rares," most of which were under 1 dollar in value and was able to turn that into 500+ dollars each time. New Zelle option is even easier to get your funds. Excellent company, and much easier than buylisting your own cards that are not high value.
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every
previous customer to leave a review.
Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page.
We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a
review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).