Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service
(5627)
Levi
Review left Jan 24 2026
Shipment processed Jan 10 2026
Review
I've sent a few orders to Card Conduit, and each time the service is easy, quick, and I get a solid return. Highly recommend!
I've sent a few orders to Card Conduit, and each time the service is easy, quick, and I get a solid return. Highly recommend!
Matt
Review left Jan 24 2026
Review
I used the pre-sorted option, packed & sent my cards. Got paid after the order was processed. Way easier than me having to post hundreds of individual card auctions. I'd sell more here if I had any left to sell lol
I used the pre-sorted option, packed & sent my cards. Got paid after the order was processed. Way easier than me having to post hundreds of individual card auctions. I'd sell more here if I had any left to sell lol
Mike
Review left Jan 24 2026
Shipment processed Jan 15 2026
Review
I have come across Card Conduit a few times and finally decided to give it a try. I was more than impressed with how everything turned out. Sent in a bunch of cards, and in about a week had the money in my account. The breakdown and prices were extremely accurate and better than anything I could get
...
Read more
I have come across Card Conduit a few times and finally decided to give it a try. I was more than impressed with how everything turned out. Sent in a bunch of cards, and in about a week had the money in my account. The breakdown and prices were extremely accurate and better than anything I could get locally. Highly recommend and this will definitely be my go-to service for selling cards!
Bencion Mishiyev
Review left Jan 24 2026
Review
Card conduit was a super easy process, i was able to send all my cards in and made way more than i would have trying to sell it in a store. Nick Anderson was super helpful all the way through. I highly recommend it to anyone trying to sell their cards.
Card conduit was a super easy process, i was able to send all my cards in and made way more than i would have trying to sell it in a store. Nick Anderson was super helpful all the way through. I highly recommend it to anyone trying to sell their cards.
Blake
Review left Jan 24 2026
Review
Great company, good communication and what i considered very fair. Would hesitate recommending these guys if you are gonna sell your cards
Great company, good communication and what i considered very fair. Would hesitate recommending these guys if you are gonna sell your cards
Aadi Kaul
Review left Jan 24 2026
Shipment processed Jan 15 2026
Review
Process was incredibly easy, I've already recommended Card Conduit to several friends!
Process was incredibly easy, I've already recommended Card Conduit to several friends!
Matt
Review left Jan 24 2026
Shipment processed Jun 21 2025
$269.86
payout, $76.92
fees
Review
Using a discount code and sorting out some high value cards made this service very useful and simple to clear some excess cards. This was my 3rd shipment using their basic service and I haven't been disappointed with value. Some cards come in lower than expected some higher but overall I have a sign
...
Read more
Using a discount code and sorting out some high value cards made this service very useful and simple to clear some excess cards. This was my 3rd shipment using their basic service and I haven't been disappointed with value. Some cards come in lower than expected some higher but overall I have a significantly better return than taking the cards to a local shop with less headaches than if I tried to sell the lower value cards myself.
Jack Kelley
Review left Jan 23 2026
Review
The process was very straightforward. I opted for the pre-sorted option to pay a smaller fee and the process of uploading my list of cards and retrieving the list for sorting was easy to understand. It was also the best value option I could find (outside of listing and shipping all of my cards separ
...
Read more
The process was very straightforward. I opted for the pre-sorted option to pay a smaller fee and the process of uploading my list of cards and retrieving the list for sorting was easy to understand. It was also the best value option I could find (outside of listing and shipping all of my cards separately). I'm overall very happy with the process and would use this service again in the future.
Mathew Schick
Review left Jan 23 2026
Review
I was amazed at how professional, diligent and easy the process was to sell my cards. The directions were clear, their methods transparent, and I was completely satisfied by the results.
I was amazed at how professional, diligent and easy the process was to sell my cards. The directions were clear, their methods transparent, and I was completely satisfied by the results.
Terry C
Review left Jan 22 2026
Shipment processed Jan 10 2026
Review
I’ve used card conduit quite a few times and it’s always been a pleasure. It’s been smooth, the payouts have been fair and the communication is always great.
I would highly suggest this service to anyone looking to sell a bunch of cards at once.
I would highly suggest this service to anyone looking to sell a bunch of cards at once.
I’ve used card conduit quite a few times and it’s always been a pleasure. It’s been smooth, the payouts have been fair and the communication is always great.
I would highly suggest this service to anyone looking to sell a bunch of cards at once.
I would highly suggest this service to anyone looking to sell a bunch of cards at once.
Ryan S.
Review left Jan 22 2026
Review
Service was great as always. I have been using Card Conduit for years, and they are still my go-to place for selling my cards. No hassle, easy, and they take care of everything. Thank you again!
Service was great as always. I have been using Card Conduit for years, and they are still my go-to place for selling my cards. No hassle, easy, and they take care of everything. Thank you again!
Lorelei
Review left Jan 21 2026
Review
The website is exceptional; very easy to use. The customer service is excellent too. My shipment was processed within the estimated time frame and I received payment soon thereafter.
The website is exceptional; very easy to use. The customer service is excellent too. My shipment was processed within the estimated time frame and I received payment soon thereafter.
David Britt
Review left Jan 21 2026
Review
I've been Using CC for years now and it's the best card selling experience I've come across. The price is always fair and the report you get back is super helpful as well. There is a reason I keep coming back to their service
I've been Using CC for years now and it's the best card selling experience I've come across. The price is always fair and the report you get back is super helpful as well. There is a reason I keep coming back to their service
Will G
Review left Jan 21 2026
Review
Really provided a good value for my cards, would highly recommend the sorted service
Really provided a good value for my cards, would highly recommend the sorted service
Will G
Review left Jan 21 2026
Review
Would definitely recommend folks use cardconduits service
Would definitely recommend folks use cardconduits service
Ilya Zarembsky
Review left Jan 21 2026
Review
I used the Sorted version of the service and found it to be a great experience that exceeded my expectations (I expected to get fleeced by 20-30% of what I considered fair value, but that did not happen - I got 95%+ of what I felt was fair).
Good website with clear instructions - regular email u ... Read more
Good website with clear instructions - regular email u ... Read more
I used the Sorted version of the service and found it to be a great experience that exceeded my expectations (I expected to get fleeced by 20-30% of what I considered fair value, but that did not happen - I got 95%+ of what I felt was fair).
Good website with clear instructions - regular email updates on progress of processing (as well as in-webapp updates) - grading matched my expectations / my own opinion of the condition of my cards very well - payment in full was issued promptly.
I am happy to recommend this service as a convenient, fair, secure option for anyone looking to sell a large number of (fairly) valuable cards, and will in fact be sending in another shipment myself soon. I hope I will not need to revise this review on the basis of my experience with this upcoming shipment, but I have no reason to think that I'll need to do that (aside from my general/default cynicism/pessimism wrt to all interactions with businesses, especially ones that feel like they've "secured" your continued custom, but that is not Card Conduit specific).
Good website with clear instructions - regular email updates on progress of processing (as well as in-webapp updates) - grading matched my expectations / my own opinion of the condition of my cards very well - payment in full was issued promptly.
I am happy to recommend this service as a convenient, fair, secure option for anyone looking to sell a large number of (fairly) valuable cards, and will in fact be sending in another shipment myself soon. I hope I will not need to revise this review on the basis of my experience with this upcoming shipment, but I have no reason to think that I'll need to do that (aside from my general/default cynicism/pessimism wrt to all interactions with businesses, especially ones that feel like they've "secured" your continued custom, but that is not Card Conduit specific).
Mathew Kita
Review left Jan 21 2026
Review
These guys are easily the best I have found and the most pleasant to work with when it comes to getting money out of your bulk, and the break downs after make it easy to know how to work better with them next time!
These guys are easily the best I have found and the most pleasant to work with when it comes to getting money out of your bulk, and the break downs after make it easy to know how to work better with them next time!
Logan Huskins
Review left Jan 20 2026
Review
The process was very simple and communication was great throughout. The hardest part was deciding which cards to part with!
The process was very simple and communication was great throughout. The hardest part was deciding which cards to part with!
Thomas
Review left Jan 20 2026
Review
I heard a lot about Card Conduit and how easy it is to use, and my experience confirmed that
I heard a lot about Card Conduit and how easy it is to use, and my experience confirmed that
Travis
Review left Jan 20 2026
Review
I've had a small collection of cards that I no longer had a use for sitting around my office for years. I already know what I had and roughly how much it was worth, but I never wanted to go through the effort of listing them one by one and sending them out. Card Conduit maybe got me a bit less money
...
Read more
I've had a small collection of cards that I no longer had a use for sitting around my office for years. I already know what I had and roughly how much it was worth, but I never wanted to go through the effort of listing them one by one and sending them out. Card Conduit maybe got me a bit less money than I could have, but I barely had to do any work, just shoved the cards they wanted in a box and they cut me a check, easy peasy. Highly recommend if you're in my situation.
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every
previous customer to leave a review.
Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page.
We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a
review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).