Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service
(4363)
Zach Boxley
Review left Apr 22 2025
Review
The best part about card conduit is they don't hammer you like a local lgs would on prices, you get a usually above fair offer. There was one card condition in my most recent shipment that I disagreed with, called a card damaged when it wasn't, but oh well. Overall they're great and I recommend them.
The best part about card conduit is they don't hammer you like a local lgs would on prices, you get a usually above fair offer. There was one card condition in my most recent shipment that I disagreed with, called a card damaged when it wasn't, but oh well. Overall they're great and I recommend them.
Cromat55
Review left Apr 21 2025
Review
I've used their service twice and each time I am impressed with how quick and efficient they are. Really appreciate how communicative they are throughout each part of the process.
I've used their service twice and each time I am impressed with how quick and efficient they are. Really appreciate how communicative they are throughout each part of the process.
Drew
Review left Apr 17 2025
Review
I did the unsorted shipment this time, which I think was worth it. It saved me easily 30 minutes of managing and sorting my cards and the fee was not particularly higher.
I still think it's a great deal for how little work I have to do.
I still think it's a great deal for how little work I have to do.
I did the unsorted shipment this time, which I think was worth it. It saved me easily 30 minutes of managing and sorting my cards and the fee was not particularly higher.
I still think it's a great deal for how little work I have to do.
I still think it's a great deal for how little work I have to do.
Zach
Review left Apr 12 2025
Review
Always an easy process. I know people who own card stores and I continue to think card conduit is a little harsh on grading but over all a great experience.
Always an easy process. I know people who own card stores and I continue to think card conduit is a little harsh on grading but over all a great experience.
James Ellis
Review left Apr 09 2025
Review
The streamlining of the information for putting in the cards and shipping is better than any other place I've used for selling cards, but the hold before the cards are processed took a bit to get used to.
Took a bit longer than I expected for processing to finish, but that is relatively nothing ... Read more
Took a bit longer than I expected for processing to finish, but that is relatively nothing ... Read more
The streamlining of the information for putting in the cards and shipping is better than any other place I've used for selling cards, but the hold before the cards are processed took a bit to get used to.
Took a bit longer than I expected for processing to finish, but that is relatively nothing overall.
Given the amount I was able to receive from most cards submitted and the transparency, I will recommend, and have already recommended to friends, using Card Conduit.
Took a bit longer than I expected for processing to finish, but that is relatively nothing overall.
Given the amount I was able to receive from most cards submitted and the transparency, I will recommend, and have already recommended to friends, using Card Conduit.
Dustyn Pruitt
Review left Apr 04 2025
Shipment processed Apr 04 2025
Review
I disagree with some quality ratings but everything went well.
I disagree with some quality ratings but everything went well.
Tyler Redding
Review left Apr 04 2025
Review
The process was fairly simple and fast. Stayed in contact throughout each step of the process.
I was a bit bummed at the card value total. I scanned the collection beforehand to get an idea of what it was worth and it came out quite a bit lower than I anticipated.
Overall, I'd recommend Card Conduit to anyone looking to sell in a timely manner.
I was a bit bummed at the card value total. I scanned the collection beforehand to get an idea of what it was worth and it came out quite a bit lower than I anticipated.
Overall, I'd recommend Card Conduit to anyone looking to sell in a timely manner.
The process was fairly simple and fast. Stayed in contact throughout each step of the process.
I was a bit bummed at the card value total. I scanned the collection beforehand to get an idea of what it was worth and it came out quite a bit lower than I anticipated.
Overall, I'd recommend Card Conduit to anyone looking to sell in a timely manner.
I was a bit bummed at the card value total. I scanned the collection beforehand to get an idea of what it was worth and it came out quite a bit lower than I anticipated.
Overall, I'd recommend Card Conduit to anyone looking to sell in a timely manner.
Cardboard Odysseys
Review left Apr 02 2025
Review
I highly recommend using their tool to look up each individual card because some cards buy prices are extremely low and some are quite good. I would highly advise against just sending in your cards without curating a list. Do the extra work. I got about 73% of what i would have gotten if i were to s
...
Read more
I highly recommend using their tool to look up each individual card because some cards buy prices are extremely low and some are quite good. I would highly advise against just sending in your cards without curating a list. Do the extra work. I got about 73% of what i would have gotten if i were to sell on TCG for the low price at NM value. Of my 361 cards i sent in, they marked 53 LP, 38 MP, 6 HP. I recorded the grades id give each card and they doubled the LP i had recorded quadrupled the number of MP cards. The number of HP cards were accurate but the cards they said were HP were not the ones i had. At the end of the day im overall happy with the service. After seller fees and mailing everything individually and all the time/postage it takes to ship 361 cards this is a killer deal even at lower grading.
Devin
Review left Mar 31 2025
Review
The process of selling magic cards with card conduit was seamless from sorting and shipping the cards to receiving payment. If selling and haggling over cards seems daunting, card conduit is the route to take. Curb your expectations on the payout though!
The process of selling magic cards with card conduit was seamless from sorting and shipping the cards to receiving payment. If selling and haggling over cards seems daunting, card conduit is the route to take. Curb your expectations on the payout though!
Kevin Litner
Review left Mar 29 2025
Review
Smooth transaction, I think they grade foils a little roughly, but no real complaints
Smooth transaction, I think they grade foils a little roughly, but no real complaints
John Brett Linton
Review left Mar 27 2025
Review
Overall I was pleased. Just couldn't understand that every card that was actually worth something, the grading was either LP OR MP. CARDS that just came out of the pack. I know in shipment they could be damaged. I generally look at front , back and sides of cards. Actually took some pictur
...
Read more
Overall I was pleased. Just couldn't understand that every card that was actually worth something, the grading was either LP OR MP. CARDS that just came out of the pack. I know in shipment they could be damaged. I generally look at front , back and sides of cards. Actually took some pictures. It's all water under the bridge now. Thank you for your time. Have a great day.
Neil T Merrick
Review left Mar 26 2025
Review
I find the experience overall good, I think the grading is extremely harsh but whatever. The communication was excellent and payment was quick.
I find the experience overall good, I think the grading is extremely harsh but whatever. The communication was excellent and payment was quick.
JM
Review left Mar 25 2025
Review
The process was fairly straightforward. My main complaint if you could call it that, was the inability to transfer my card list from the TCG app over to CC. I ended up going with the 5% fee rather than the 2% because of that issue, but it could have been user error. I got a little less than I was ex
...
Read more
The process was fairly straightforward. My main complaint if you could call it that, was the inability to transfer my card list from the TCG app over to CC. I ended up going with the 5% fee rather than the 2% because of that issue, but it could have been user error. I got a little less than I was expecting but I didn’t take into account the surface scratches on many cards from regular play. Over all it was a good experience. If I had more cards worth sending I would use the service again.
Erik
Review left Mar 22 2025
Shipment processed Feb 20 2025
Review
Cards didn't come back graded at the quality expected, but the customer service representative I communicated with was very helpful in the overall experience. Would definitely recommend using this service based on the customer service alone. These people do care more than most local gamestore owners I've met.
Cards didn't come back graded at the quality expected, but the customer service representative I communicated with was very helpful in the overall experience. Would definitely recommend using this service based on the customer service alone. These people do care more than most local gamestore owners I've met.
D. Huma
Review left Mar 15 2025
Review
Thank you for your consideration in adjusting the service type. Your system is convenient, that's for sure. But to be honest, I'm a little discouraged by these wear ratings since these cards were never played. The money seems OK but I'm only a lay user so it's hard for me to judge.
Thank you for your consideration in adjusting the service type. Your system is convenient, that's for sure. But to be honest, I'm a little discouraged by these wear ratings since these cards were never played. The money seems OK but I'm only a lay user so it's hard for me to judge.
Jeremy
Review left Mar 11 2025
Review
The process was easy if you follow their instructions; I did have to pay for a special box to ship, and shipping costs are high right now, so that ate into the profit a little bit. They do tend to undergrade cards in my opinion, and don't always give what you may think of as the best price out there
...
Read more
The process was easy if you follow their instructions; I did have to pay for a special box to ship, and shipping costs are high right now, so that ate into the profit a little bit. They do tend to undergrade cards in my opinion, and don't always give what you may think of as the best price out there, but overall it was fine if you don't want to bring them into an LGS. I would say it was a little better than what I would get from an LGS, but far less than if I had used ebay. However, for convenience and my time, it easily beats ebay or selling individually. I think curated is the way to go. your mileage will certainly vary. If I could sum it up in a few words: Not the best prices, but hard to beat on convenience.
Kelly
Review left Mar 10 2025
Review
Super easy process. They gobble up cards quick and pay better than a card shop would. The grading is interesting though. Some cards that were direct from pack were given MP grades where cards that definitely were MP got LP or NM. It seems this is an area where they are getting a lot of feedback they
...
Read more
Super easy process. They gobble up cards quick and pay better than a card shop would. The grading is interesting though. Some cards that were direct from pack were given MP grades where cards that definitely were MP got LP or NM. It seems this is an area where they are getting a lot of feedback they may want to pay more attention to. I got almost exactly what I was expecting so can't complain too much.
Will
Review left Mar 06 2025
Review
Love the customer support, communication, efficiency. My one caveat is that the system automatically uses the lowest available price on TCGPlayer, which is sometimes a clearly fake listing (user has 0 sales, 1 dollar for a 100 dollar card, you know what it looks like). Please address this. This bene
...
Read more
Love the customer support, communication, efficiency. My one caveat is that the system automatically uses the lowest available price on TCGPlayer, which is sometimes a clearly fake listing (user has 0 sales, 1 dollar for a 100 dollar card, you know what it looks like). Please address this. This benefits y'all in the short term but it's a huge feel bad on our end, and clearly not fair pricing. I had to wait for a week or so for the system to ignore a 60 cent pricing on Radiant Lotus!
Tyler
Review left Feb 24 2025
Review
Easy and fast only bad taste left in my mouth was the grading of the cards. I sent in some high priced cards and I feel like my order some of the cards were bumped down in grade which made me get about 20% less than what my order originally was quoted. Cards were nm when I acquired them then double
...
Read more
Easy and fast only bad taste left in my mouth was the grading of the cards. I sent in some high priced cards and I feel like my order some of the cards were bumped down in grade which made me get about 20% less than what my order originally was quoted. Cards were nm when I acquired them then double sleeved in a binder in a fire box barely moved and almost every one of them were down graded. But I got a better payout than my local card shops.
Darrelle K
Review left Feb 21 2025
Review
Process was incredibly easy. Customer service is always quick to answer and questions. I don't agree with some of the list prices on certain cards but I understand the process of reselling. I have used card conduit 3 separate times and have had a satisfactory experience everytime.
Process was incredibly easy. Customer service is always quick to answer and questions. I don't agree with some of the list prices on certain cards but I understand the process of reselling. I have used card conduit 3 separate times and have had a satisfactory experience everytime.
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every
previous customer to leave a review.
Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page.
We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a
review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).