Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service
(5855)
David
Review left Apr 02 2026
Review
Process was easy, I think the comp was fair. Some of the grades seemed harsh relative to some of the more expensive cards. Before shipping I would have thought 90% at near mint as that is how I've been selling myself on tcgplayer per their guidelines, which card conduit follows. But some cards came
...
Read more
Process was easy, I think the comp was fair. Some of the grades seemed harsh relative to some of the more expensive cards. Before shipping I would have thought 90% at near mint as that is how I've been selling myself on tcgplayer per their guidelines, which card conduit follows. But some cards came back as MP or LP but not specific evidence to support. I understand too that logistically that could be a challenge but it would be great to have that detail (like how TAG does their card grading) to invoke a greater sense of transparency and drive up confidence
Brett Manifold-Wheeler
Review left Mar 31 2026
Review
I think the process was quick and easy, and overall, I got about what I expected for my cards. Interestingly, there were card grades that I think were completely bogus, and other grades that I think were likely better than I expected. It did even out in the end.
My general commentary on the gradi ... Read more
My general commentary on the gradi ... Read more
I think the process was quick and easy, and overall, I got about what I expected for my cards. Interestingly, there were card grades that I think were completely bogus, and other grades that I think were likely better than I expected. It did even out in the end.
My general commentary on the grading is that items which had low value, that there were a lot of (10+), tended to be lower graded as a lumped grade, and things that had higher value ($50+ tended to be more harshly graded, which is partially expected, but in some cases felt questionable. By no stretch do I think my shipment was all NM or even LP; however, some items were pack to sleeve that got graded as damaged (most notably a Secret Lair Phyrexian Tower) when it was IMO, clearly NM or at worst LP. Again, none of this is a big deal, and I believe it is the cost of doing business.
I want to emphasize at the end here that my experience was overall very positive, but I want to give an honest assessment of the areas I found were good as well as bad. The speed at which everything was completed and that money was sent was phenomenal, and even with my issues with grading on certain items, my expected payout was right about where I expected it to be, so everything came out as a wash for any issues I had with grading.
My general commentary on the grading is that items which had low value, that there were a lot of (10+), tended to be lower graded as a lumped grade, and things that had higher value ($50+ tended to be more harshly graded, which is partially expected, but in some cases felt questionable. By no stretch do I think my shipment was all NM or even LP; however, some items were pack to sleeve that got graded as damaged (most notably a Secret Lair Phyrexian Tower) when it was IMO, clearly NM or at worst LP. Again, none of this is a big deal, and I believe it is the cost of doing business.
I want to emphasize at the end here that my experience was overall very positive, but I want to give an honest assessment of the areas I found were good as well as bad. The speed at which everything was completed and that money was sent was phenomenal, and even with my issues with grading on certain items, my expected payout was right about where I expected it to be, so everything came out as a wash for any issues I had with grading.
Justin Brady
Review left Mar 28 2026
Review
I sent them a package of rares I was not playing and was chided for how small the shipment was, but I got about $140.
Then I sent a 7 lb package of cards of all rarities to get about $20. That covers shipping and a pack of gum.
Basically dont bother sending your bulk, they just want the good stuff, which you probably want to keep anyhow.
Then I sent a 7 lb package of cards of all rarities to get about $20. That covers shipping and a pack of gum.
Basically dont bother sending your bulk, they just want the good stuff, which you probably want to keep anyhow.
I sent them a package of rares I was not playing and was chided for how small the shipment was, but I got about $140.
Then I sent a 7 lb package of cards of all rarities to get about $20. That covers shipping and a pack of gum.
Basically dont bother sending your bulk, they just want the good stuff, which you probably want to keep anyhow.
Then I sent a 7 lb package of cards of all rarities to get about $20. That covers shipping and a pack of gum.
Basically dont bother sending your bulk, they just want the good stuff, which you probably want to keep anyhow.
Thomas Fischl
Review left Mar 26 2026
Review
Amount was towards the lower end of value scale and I found that a bit disappointing. I wasn't expecting the full amount based on the condition of the cards but it felt a bit low. Overall, good experience though.
Amount was towards the lower end of value scale and I found that a bit disappointing. I wasn't expecting the full amount based on the condition of the cards but it felt a bit low. Overall, good experience though.
Sean
Review left Mar 25 2026
Review
Process was super easy, wouldn’t say there was much value as I lost money shipping the cards safely. Have to assume that’s on me for not having very many high value cards but having sent just over 1800 cards I was expecting to get more than the cost of a handful booster packs. I do think if you
...
Read more
Process was super easy, wouldn’t say there was much value as I lost money shipping the cards safely. Have to assume that’s on me for not having very many high value cards but having sent just over 1800 cards I was expecting to get more than the cost of a handful booster packs. I do think if you have the volume and high value cards this would be a great service but if you’re just looking to clear bulk of negligible value I’d recommend maybe looking for someone who offers trade credit instead.
Fillmore
Review left Mar 22 2026
Review
Overall I was pleasantly surprised at how easy it was to ship a large MTG collection of rares and foils to CC. The process and website were simple and easy to understand. Pricing was decent and the report back was super easy to understand. My only issue was the time between my shipment to payment
...
Read more
Overall I was pleasantly surprised at how easy it was to ship a large MTG collection of rares and foils to CC. The process and website were simple and easy to understand. Pricing was decent and the report back was super easy to understand. My only issue was the time between my shipment to payment. It took longer than I expected, but knowing that I'll just be more prepared for next time. Really good experience over all, would use you all again!
Jaime Najera
Review left Mar 16 2026
Review
I had no issues. I would definitely use it again to sell bulk or to quickly get rid low-mid emd cards for a quick profit. Unless you have high chase cards that sell for a premium , it's otherwise the best option to get bang for you're buck after shipping your cards carefully to this service. My only
...
Read more
I had no issues. I would definitely use it again to sell bulk or to quickly get rid low-mid emd cards for a quick profit. Unless you have high chase cards that sell for a premium , it's otherwise the best option to get bang for you're buck after shipping your cards carefully to this service. My only gripe would be how you can't sell you're cards at full price. But for convenience/quick turnaround it's a fair deal.
Matthew Wright
Review left Mar 09 2026
Shipment processed Feb 26 2026
Review
I have sold with card conduit before and I have never been disappointed. Communication was open, prices were fair and I got paid quickly. This time was no different.
However, it has been over a year since I sold with them and in that time I believe that they have become more fastidious and scrutini ... Read more
However, it has been over a year since I sold with them and in that time I believe that they have become more fastidious and scrutini ... Read more
I have sold with card conduit before and I have never been disappointed. Communication was open, prices were fair and I got paid quickly. This time was no different.
However, it has been over a year since I sold with them and in that time I believe that they have become more fastidious and scrutinizing in their grading. They rated a number of cards that were very clearly near mint as lightly played and respectfully, I believe they were wrong. This is absolutely their prerogative, and I can certainly be wrong, but there seem to be more discrepancies with condition this time than the last time I sold. Just something I noticed.
However, it has been over a year since I sold with them and in that time I believe that they have become more fastidious and scrutinizing in their grading. They rated a number of cards that were very clearly near mint as lightly played and respectfully, I believe they were wrong. This is absolutely their prerogative, and I can certainly be wrong, but there seem to be more discrepancies with condition this time than the last time I sold. Just something I noticed.
Luis Buitrago
Review left Mar 01 2026
Shipment processed Feb 21 2026
Review
The process to upload a CSV file and proceed from there was so smooth, I wish this would have been the platform I used before. My only concern is that there were multiple cards in my shipment that were quite literally straight from the pack (or secret lair pack) into a sleeve and then sent into the
...
Read more
The process to upload a CSV file and proceed from there was so smooth, I wish this would have been the platform I used before. My only concern is that there were multiple cards in my shipment that were quite literally straight from the pack (or secret lair pack) into a sleeve and then sent into the order (no sleeve) and were marked as light play. Perhaps that is the one thing I noticed, multiple cards got dinged that way but otherwise, I highly recommend this platform.
Susana
Review left Feb 27 2026
Review
Service was great. They delivered in the time they said and overall very good first time experience. Definitely recommend and will do again!
Service was great. They delivered in the time they said and overall very good first time experience. Definitely recommend and will do again!
Kyler
Review left Feb 26 2026
Shipment processed Feb 18 2026
Review
Ive used Card Conduit quite a bit, and plan to continue using them, but will be much more selective with what I ship due to how harsh the grading on cards is. Currently the ease of use is outweighing the downside of the harsh grading.
Ive used Card Conduit quite a bit, and plan to continue using them, but will be much more selective with what I ship due to how harsh the grading on cards is. Currently the ease of use is outweighing the downside of the harsh grading.
Shane Hall
Review left Feb 24 2026
Review
Many of the cards I sent in were never played, yet they valued a lot of them at light to moderate play. It depleted the value of the collection by one fifth, and even more when going off of TCG low on a curated list. The turnaround took longer then I anticipated to. I may or may not use them again.
...
Read more
Many of the cards I sent in were never played, yet they valued a lot of them at light to moderate play. It depleted the value of the collection by one fifth, and even more when going off of TCG low on a curated list. The turnaround took longer then I anticipated to. I may or may not use them again. I do have a bulk order I am waiting on to be sorted and graded yet. We will see how that pans out.
What the Fixation
Review left Feb 19 2026
Review
I love how easy using card conduit is. You can send it and trust that you will get better pricing than any other buyer. That being said, expect to wait. It takes two to three weeks for them to process. Overall fine if you have the time.
I love how easy using card conduit is. You can send it and trust that you will get better pricing than any other buyer. That being said, expect to wait. It takes two to three weeks for them to process. Overall fine if you have the time.
Ian Kirby
Review left Feb 18 2026
Review
When I started trying to assess my collection to sell it, I was using Moxfield to take stock of what I was scanning. I initially used the autoestimate feature there as another metric to get a sense of what I had. I'm normally skeptical of third party associations like that, but everything I read onl
...
Read more
When I started trying to assess my collection to sell it, I was using Moxfield to take stock of what I was scanning. I initially used the autoestimate feature there as another metric to get a sense of what I had. I'm normally skeptical of third party associations like that, but everything I read online seemed decent. I first sold most of the higher end stuff in my collection to an LGS, but their bulk cutoff ended up being quite high so I figured I'd try sending the rest here. The submission process was super easy and my cards were processed within a week. For my collection mostly being 10-20 years old I'm sure the grading was perfectly reasonable. It might be another 10 years, but if I end up with a chunk of cards I'm not using again I wouldn't hesitate to send them here again.
Andy
Review left Feb 17 2026
Review
I have been using card conduit for some time. The process is still smooth and easy but the card grading and the most recent payout % was a lot less than my previous shipments. Foils almost never get NM and this most recent shipment had a bunch marked down to MP when they should not have. It's still
...
Read more
I have been using card conduit for some time. The process is still smooth and easy but the card grading and the most recent payout % was a lot less than my previous shipments. Foils almost never get NM and this most recent shipment had a bunch marked down to MP when they should not have. It's still an easy process to ship to card conduit even with the extremely harsh grading.
Clint M
Review left Feb 11 2026
Review
The process of selling cards was simple. Evaluation of cards at lower quality is odd. I'd expected about $40 more.
This next bit is more on the fault of snail mail. The check delivery took about 8 days.
Overall a positive experience.
This next bit is more on the fault of snail mail. The check delivery took about 8 days.
Overall a positive experience.
The process of selling cards was simple. Evaluation of cards at lower quality is odd. I'd expected about $40 more.
This next bit is more on the fault of snail mail. The check delivery took about 8 days.
Overall a positive experience.
This next bit is more on the fault of snail mail. The check delivery took about 8 days.
Overall a positive experience.
Nick
Review left Feb 07 2026
Review
Overall, I like the ease of the process and overall its very easy and the prices are okay. Obviously you get much less than if you sell the cards yourself but you get the convenience here. Overall Satisfied.
Overall, I like the ease of the process and overall its very easy and the prices are okay. Obviously you get much less than if you sell the cards yourself but you get the convenience here. Overall Satisfied.
Anonymous
Review left Feb 03 2026
Shipment processed Jan 10 2026
Review
Overall experience was great only issue was the payment I received didn’t even cover the shipping cost I had to pay to send the cards to them.
Overall experience was great only issue was the payment I received didn’t even cover the shipping cost I had to pay to send the cards to them.
Colby Schaeffer
Review left Jan 25 2026
Review
The detailed card value report for the curated shipment was nice. I felt some of the gradings were a little aggressive but other than that, I found the service trustworthy and easy to use.
The detailed card value report for the curated shipment was nice. I felt some of the gradings were a little aggressive but other than that, I found the service trustworthy and easy to use.
Ryan
Review left Jan 14 2026
Shipment processed Dec 05 2025
Review
I would recommend Card Conduit to others as an option to a LGS. Process was great overall being quick and easy. I would set the expectation that your payout may change from when you submit as the payout will go off the date the cards are inspected - not sent/received. Either way, still great expe
...
Read more
I would recommend Card Conduit to others as an option to a LGS. Process was great overall being quick and easy. I would set the expectation that your payout may change from when you submit as the payout will go off the date the cards are inspected - not sent/received. Either way, still great experience overall and look forward to working with the team in the future.
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every
previous customer to leave a review.
Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page.
We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a
review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).