Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service
(4057)
Ryan Newman
Review left Jan 30 2025
Review
Harsh on the grading compared to elsewhere, but overall a good experience and reliable service for selling collections.
Harsh on the grading compared to elsewhere, but overall a good experience and reliable service for selling collections.
Braden Carlson
Review left Jan 29 2025
Review
This was my fourth or fifth shipment. It's always pretty easy just takes time to sort everything. My last two shipments haven't received as much as I expected based on condition but definitely better than all the effort to offload my stuff that's not high in demand.
This was my fourth or fifth shipment. It's always pretty easy just takes time to sort everything. My last two shipments haven't received as much as I expected based on condition but definitely better than all the effort to offload my stuff that's not high in demand.
Peter
Review left Jan 25 2025
Review
The service was quick, payed out good, and fair. However having to import a collection via CSB is terrible. For many of us casual players who are likely the ones looking to sell all the crap we don’t use we do t have entire collections logged under anything but tcg player, and if you used the mobi
...
Read more
The service was quick, payed out good, and fair. However having to import a collection via CSB is terrible. For many of us casual players who are likely the ones looking to sell all the crap we don’t use we do t have entire collections logged under anything but tcg player, and if you used the mobile iOS app then there is no way to export it as csv. I got payed so I’m happy, but be prepared to take several days figuring out your csv stuff if it’s a big collection
Jordan
Review left Jan 23 2025
Shipment processed Jan 10 2025
Review
Process was easy and took about a week to get cards sorted and paid. Thought payment was a bit low cause some cards were marked lightly played when they were never played. 90% of them were from booster pack pulls.
Process was easy and took about a week to get cards sorted and paid. Thought payment was a bit low cause some cards were marked lightly played when they were never played. 90% of them were from booster pack pulls.
Brandon
Review left Jan 21 2025
Review
They gave me a detailed summary of how my shipment was in relatively good time. Everything was accurate to how I sent it. Not the most money for everything, but there were no issues or returns.
They gave me a detailed summary of how my shipment was in relatively good time. Everything was accurate to how I sent it. Not the most money for everything, but there were no issues or returns.
JB
Review left Jan 10 2025
Shipment processed Dec 29 2024
Review
Condition grading felt very conservative. I feel like it’s help to post a video or images to align with customers on how you grade. I felt you could buy LP from TCGplayer and should expect MP from CardConduit. Regardless of whether they do or it is intentional, the incentives are setup for CC to w
...
Read more
Condition grading felt very conservative. I feel like it’s help to post a video or images to align with customers on how you grade. I felt you could buy LP from TCGplayer and should expect MP from CardConduit. Regardless of whether they do or it is intentional, the incentives are setup for CC to want not grade fairly (e.g. covers them in case buy list grades differently).
That said, I wasn’t going to sell all my singles myself, so I appreciated that the service exists even if I’m not sold on the grading. The team was fairly transparent and communicated well. Payment was prompt.
That said, I wasn’t going to sell all my singles myself, so I appreciated that the service exists even if I’m not sold on the grading. The team was fairly transparent and communicated well. Payment was prompt.
Andy
Review left Jan 09 2025
Review
The grading has become more inconsistent. Even pack fresh cards that I have double checked before submitting are receiving MP grades, significantly lowering the payout. This is particularly true for foils. Still, this is a smooth and easy process if you have more difficult to move cards.
The grading has become more inconsistent. Even pack fresh cards that I have double checked before submitting are receiving MP grades, significantly lowering the payout. This is particularly true for foils. Still, this is a smooth and easy process if you have more difficult to move cards.
Julian
Review left Jan 07 2025
Review
Easy process, decent value. Would use the service again.
Easy process, decent value. Would use the service again.
Blake
Review left Dec 21 2024
Shipment processed Dec 13 2024
Review
The process was very easy. The most disappointing aspect is not being able to really contest any of the grading. For offloading cards very quickly and with minimal effort and decent returns, I can recommend the service.
The process was very easy. The most disappointing aspect is not being able to really contest any of the grading. For offloading cards very quickly and with minimal effort and decent returns, I can recommend the service.
Christian
Review left Dec 18 2024
Review
Service was excellent I kept a record of my cards prior to submittal no oddities identified. The evaluation is slightly more aggressive on NM/SP/Etc than anticipated but expected. Overall due to ease of submittal they're the best service on the market.
Service was excellent I kept a record of my cards prior to submittal no oddities identified. The evaluation is slightly more aggressive on NM/SP/Etc than anticipated but expected. Overall due to ease of submittal they're the best service on the market.
James
Review left Dec 16 2024
Shipment processed Dec 06 2024
Review
Very smooth process. Was a little disappointed in car condition rating but seeing as it is a re seller, they need them in perfect mint, while most of the cards sent were in mint-near mint condition, they were rated at in a good condition with very very small wear of scuff( assumed from going through
...
Read more
Very smooth process. Was a little disappointed in car condition rating but seeing as it is a re seller, they need them in perfect mint, while most of the cards sent were in mint-near mint condition, they were rated at in a good condition with very very small wear of scuff( assumed from going through bulk and cards sliding against each other) so very fair and was able to remove a chunk of bulk that otherwise would have just sat around
Will Young
Review left Dec 16 2024
Review
Very easy process, straightforward, good communication. Expect your cards to be graded down from your expectations. Overall a good experience
Very easy process, straightforward, good communication. Expect your cards to be graded down from your expectations. Overall a good experience
Christian Ralles
Review left Dec 13 2024
Review
Process is fast and very fair pricing for my collection, but I wish that with the report it would show photos of the cards as I thought one of my more valuable cards was in better condition than what it was appraised as.
Process is fast and very fair pricing for my collection, but I wish that with the report it would show photos of the cards as I thought one of my more valuable cards was in better condition than what it was appraised as.
Brian
Review left Dec 08 2024
Review
Heard about the site from Jake & Joel Are Magic and decided to give it a try. I'm not a huge seller of MtG cards, but I've sent at least 30 larger packages out to other reputable sites such as Card Kingdom and TCG Player, so I decided to give Card Conduit a try. After digging through the site a bit,
...
Read more
Heard about the site from Jake & Joel Are Magic and decided to give it a try. I'm not a huge seller of MtG cards, but I've sent at least 30 larger packages out to other reputable sites such as Card Kingdom and TCG Player, so I decided to give Card Conduit a try. After digging through the site a bit, a found the user interface to be very friendly for selling cards. Below are pros & cons comparative to the other sites;
Pros
-Great UI with clear pictures and easy search function, especially when trying to categorize between the 1000 different variants MtG now has
-Low fees if you're willing to sort the cards yourself; even having the option of not sorting is a huge + where other companies don't allow that
-Higher estimated NM pricing compared to some other sites
-Clear step by step on where they are in processing your cards
-Selection of cards they'll take; CC seems to have a larger buylist than most others
Cons
-Grading seems a little strict; took a 20% cut in NM pricing from estimated. I usually only see about 5% from TCG or CK
Overall a great experience. I would recommend CC to my friends, especially ones who have a lot of bulk to get rid of. The things I look for most in a buylist company like this are ease of use and value for amount of effort spent. I don't have time to list everything on eBay so bulk shipment is preferred. CC is easy to work with and makes the process very efficient. My biggest gripe would just be value from estimated pricing.
Pros
-Great UI with clear pictures and easy search function, especially when trying to categorize between the 1000 different variants MtG now has
-Low fees if you're willing to sort the cards yourself; even having the option of not sorting is a huge + where other companies don't allow that
-Higher estimated NM pricing compared to some other sites
-Clear step by step on where they are in processing your cards
-Selection of cards they'll take; CC seems to have a larger buylist than most others
Cons
-Grading seems a little strict; took a 20% cut in NM pricing from estimated. I usually only see about 5% from TCG or CK
Overall a great experience. I would recommend CC to my friends, especially ones who have a lot of bulk to get rid of. The things I look for most in a buylist company like this are ease of use and value for amount of effort spent. I don't have time to list everything on eBay so bulk shipment is preferred. CC is easy to work with and makes the process very efficient. My biggest gripe would just be value from estimated pricing.
Matt
Review left Nov 28 2024
Review
Process way simple and easy. I felt a few cards were graded at a lower quality than I expected.
Process way simple and easy. I felt a few cards were graded at a lower quality than I expected.
Wesley
Review left Nov 22 2024
Shipment processed Nov 12 2024
Review
The process was really easy and stress-free and the payout is pretty fast. They update you along with the way so you know exactly where you are in the process. My only feedback is that like all collection buying vendors, the grading can be a bit strict at times, a few of my pack fresh cards were graded as LP or even MP which does affect the value a bit.
The process was really easy and stress-free and the payout is pretty fast. They update you along with the way so you know exactly where you are in the process. My only feedback is that like all collection buying vendors, the grading can be a bit strict at times, a few of my pack fresh cards were graded as LP or even MP which does affect the value a bit.
Diego Kolesnikovas Castro
Review left Nov 21 2024
Review
This is the third time I have used their services and there were some issues, unlike the previous ones.
I'm aware that they're very strict on grading and I'm fine with that, but this time, they treated some cards as bulk when they certainly weren't (Kozilek's Return M3C *foil* as $0.13), even if ... Read more
I'm aware that they're very strict on grading and I'm fine with that, but this time, they treated some cards as bulk when they certainly weren't (Kozilek's Return M3C *foil* as $0.13), even if ... Read more
This is the third time I have used their services and there were some issues, unlike the previous ones.
I'm aware that they're very strict on grading and I'm fine with that, but this time, they treated some cards as bulk when they certainly weren't (Kozilek's Return M3C *foil* as $0.13), even if it's not in mint condition.
It appears they often send to Card Kingdom, then if the card isn't on their buylist, it is treated as bulk, so it is not always the best optimized buylist price as Card Conduit claim to be.
Additionally, there was some delay to take my package from the mailbox and bring to the facility, not a big deal, but hasn't happened previously.
That aside, their customer support is very efficient and I still think it's a solid service worth trying, just not flawless.
I hope to see some improvement and continue using your services.
I'm aware that they're very strict on grading and I'm fine with that, but this time, they treated some cards as bulk when they certainly weren't (Kozilek's Return M3C *foil* as $0.13), even if it's not in mint condition.
It appears they often send to Card Kingdom, then if the card isn't on their buylist, it is treated as bulk, so it is not always the best optimized buylist price as Card Conduit claim to be.
Additionally, there was some delay to take my package from the mailbox and bring to the facility, not a big deal, but hasn't happened previously.
That aside, their customer support is very efficient and I still think it's a solid service worth trying, just not flawless.
I hope to see some improvement and continue using your services.
Matthew Roberts
Review left Nov 18 2024
Review
Transferring my list to get a price was the more difficult of it all. Even that is easy to fix but everything else was easy. Send in your cards and wait. Iv sold on other platforms and I would say this is the best break down iv ever gotten of my cards. The wait for payment as for all others is alwa
...
Read more
Transferring my list to get a price was the more difficult of it all. Even that is easy to fix but everything else was easy. Send in your cards and wait. Iv sold on other platforms and I would say this is the best break down iv ever gotten of my cards. The wait for payment as for all others is always nail biting though. However I would recommend to friends and will soon be sending them more of my collection. I appreciate your services and wished Yugioh and Pokémon had someone doing it as well.
Adam
Review left Nov 06 2024
Review
The process was painless, just box up your cards and ship it off. Only issue I had was with grading. Nearly all the Secret Lair foils and most other foils were graded lower than NM, which is not the case when I buylist separately to vendors. I believe they need to fix this process in the future.
The process was painless, just box up your cards and ship it off. Only issue I had was with grading. Nearly all the Secret Lair foils and most other foils were graded lower than NM, which is not the case when I buylist separately to vendors. I believe they need to fix this process in the future.
Terry G.
Review left Oct 31 2024
Review
+: The communication and service is great. Staff are responsive and willing to work through issues and queries.
-: As many others have noted, the grading is very strict. I have had about half of pack-fresh cards from recent sets graded as MP. I cannot comment whether the same cards would be grade ... Read more
-: As many others have noted, the grading is very strict. I have had about half of pack-fresh cards from recent sets graded as MP. I cannot comment whether the same cards would be grade ... Read more
+: The communication and service is great. Staff are responsive and willing to work through issues and queries.
-: As many others have noted, the grading is very strict. I have had about half of pack-fresh cards from recent sets graded as MP. I cannot comment whether the same cards would be graded better if sent directly to a vendor, but this is quite surprising and also somewhat disappointing. I would recommend the hold for review option for any shipment containing high value cards.
-: As many others have noted, the grading is very strict. I have had about half of pack-fresh cards from recent sets graded as MP. I cannot comment whether the same cards would be graded better if sent directly to a vendor, but this is quite surprising and also somewhat disappointing. I would recommend the hold for review option for any shipment containing high value cards.
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every
previous customer to leave a review.
Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page.
We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a
review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).