Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service
(6103)
Bryan
Review left May 28 2026
Shipment processed May 15 2026
Review
Process was quick, easy, and payment was quick as always! Thank you!
Process was quick, easy, and payment was quick as always! Thank you!
Carl
Review left May 28 2026
Review
I've sold a few lots to CC and each time it was straightforward to list, get an offer along with recommended sort order, ship to, and receive a payment from them and the fees they charge seem fair to me!
I've sold a few lots to CC and each time it was straightforward to list, get an offer along with recommended sort order, ship to, and receive a payment from them and the fees they charge seem fair to me!
Mike Smith
Review left May 28 2026
Review
Used Card Conduit multiple times over the years. Appreciate the ease of the entire process and experience every time
Used Card Conduit multiple times over the years. Appreciate the ease of the entire process and experience every time
Caleb Pardon
Review left May 28 2026
Review
This is my 3rd time using this service. The entire process was laid out simply and the timelines were very accurate. There were no problems and they let me know exactly how my cards were. The price was also fair, and came without delay. If you need to sell bulk, I highly recommend these guys
This is my 3rd time using this service. The entire process was laid out simply and the timelines were very accurate. There were no problems and they let me know exactly how my cards were. The price was also fair, and came without delay. If you need to sell bulk, I highly recommend these guys
AP
Review left May 28 2026
Shipment processed May 27 2026
Review
Always the easiest way to buylist cards! Great experience.
Always the easiest way to buylist cards! Great experience.
AP
Review left May 28 2026
Shipment processed May 27 2026
Review
Always an easy and positive experience. Thank you!
Always an easy and positive experience. Thank you!
Nicola Bruno
Review left May 27 2026
Review
Always love that I can send in a box of my bulk instead of trying to sell singles. Makes life easy.
Always love that I can send in a box of my bulk instead of trying to sell singles. Makes life easy.
Drew
Review left May 27 2026
Review
Very straight forward setup, I appreciate the end summary results the most. I would love if there was an option for a printout of every card and what it was valued at instead of just the top ten.
I do wish the service was a little faster.
I do wish the service was a little faster.
Very straight forward setup, I appreciate the end summary results the most. I would love if there was an option for a printout of every card and what it was valued at instead of just the top ten.
I do wish the service was a little faster.
I do wish the service was a little faster.
Chris
Review left May 27 2026
Review
Very easy process, especially if you use the sorted option feels like the best bang for your buck. Will be using again.
Very easy process, especially if you use the sorted option feels like the best bang for your buck. Will be using again.
Daniel
Review left May 27 2026
Shipment processed Apr 24 2026
Review
Easy review process. Quick resolution of a card quality discrepancy.
Easy review process. Quick resolution of a card quality discrepancy.
J-Rob
Review left May 27 2026
Review
Got paid the exact amount I anticipated to receive, so thats great! This is my 4th time using the service and i will return and do recommend it.
Got paid the exact amount I anticipated to receive, so thats great! This is my 4th time using the service and i will return and do recommend it.
Brandon Krause
Review left May 27 2026
Review
I had used MTG as a bonding thing with my kids years ago, and I thought the thousands I spent were gone. My collection turned out to be worth almost a thousand dollars, and Card Conduit was happy to pay me for them. I have had this collection since 1994 when I first started playing, and haven't pl
...
Read more
I had used MTG as a bonding thing with my kids years ago, and I thought the thousands I spent were gone. My collection turned out to be worth almost a thousand dollars, and Card Conduit was happy to pay me for them. I have had this collection since 1994 when I first started playing, and haven't played in years. I thought trading off my dual lands meant I had nothing of value, but Card Conduit payed me well for the remainder, and I was able to recoup a good portion of what I put in. Thanks Cart Conduit.
Jesse Valles
Review left May 27 2026
Review
Cards rated better than expected. Saw plenty of reviews about CC rating cards lower than expected and a few were, but all in all not bad.
Cards rated better than expected. Saw plenty of reviews about CC rating cards lower than expected and a few were, but all in all not bad.
Isaac boles
Review left May 26 2026
Review
It was quick and easy. It really helped me I’m moving so I needed to sell my cards. I was done playing and they were the quickest and best payment options. They gave me. It was awesome thank y’all so much!!!
It was quick and easy. It really helped me I’m moving so I needed to sell my cards. I was done playing and they were the quickest and best payment options. They gave me. It was awesome thank y’all so much!!!
John
Review left May 26 2026
Shipment processed May 15 2026
$129.47
payout, $6.81
fees
Review
Overall pretty easy - just shipped my cards off to them, and they were super communicative throughout the whole process. Would use them again.
Overall pretty easy - just shipped my cards off to them, and they were super communicative throughout the whole process. Would use them again.
Avery
Review left May 26 2026
Review
Card conduit came thru with the grading I expected this time.
Card conduit came thru with the grading I expected this time.
Garrett L
Review left May 26 2026
Review
I did the auto-sifted shipment and sent in around 5000 cards. The process was simple. I separated out the cards based if they were foil or not, put them in the 400 count card boxes and then shipped them out. The process took about 2 weeks total and the dashboard for my shipment was updated along the
...
Read more
I did the auto-sifted shipment and sent in around 5000 cards. The process was simple. I separated out the cards based if they were foil or not, put them in the 400 count card boxes and then shipped them out. The process took about 2 weeks total and the dashboard for my shipment was updated along the way. The condition of the cards I sent it were in good to great condition and CardConduit rated them that way too. Excellent experience!
Cha Vang
Review left May 25 2026
Review
It was fine as long the cards were processed and sorted. I am glad that got the cards sold at least
It was fine as long the cards were processed and sorted. I am glad that got the cards sold at least
Shawn R.
Review left May 25 2026
Review
Thank you for the expedited processing, even during the holidays. I appreciate the service.
Thank you for the expedited processing, even during the holidays. I appreciate the service.
Harvey Whiting
Review left May 23 2026
Review
The process was very easy, and prompt. I was however a little disappointed with the value I got back. I use manna box and frequently check tcg player. I was told that some of my higher value foils were “clouded” and I was dinged for card quality a bit more than I thought was fair. I only rec
...
Read more
The process was very easy, and prompt. I was however a little disappointed with the value I got back. I use manna box and frequently check tcg player. I was told that some of my higher value foils were “clouded” and I was dinged for card quality a bit more than I thought was fair. I only recieved a little more than $8.00 for a foil super shredder. I feel like having to take the cards out of sleeves caused this issue. I tried to pack them as tightly as I could, but shipping carriers don’t treat things with the best of care at times. The market value I assessed on my cards was about $800. I was hoping to get about 60% of that, $450-$480. I recieved $367 dollars. I feel that was a bit low.
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every
previous customer to leave a review.
Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page.
We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a
review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).