Chat with us

Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service

(544)
Devin Ryan
Review left May 27 2022
Shipment processed Apr 23 2022
$617.19 payout, $99.38 fees

Review

The process was super easy and straight forward. I sent my cards in a box unsleeved and they counted them and sent me a check. I was unsure how true to their word they would be with buying according to the market prices as well as counting all the cards for me, but they were honest and did a great ... Read more
The process was super easy and straight forward. I sent my cards in a box unsleeved and they counted them and sent me a check. I was unsure how true to their word they would be with buying according to the market prices as well as counting all the cards for me, but they were honest and did a great job. I would highly recommend this to anyone selling their cards!! Great service and experience!
Matt
Review left May 27 2022
Shipment processed May 14 2022
$3,772.27 payout, $198.54 fees

Review

The process went very close to how it is described on the site. I was not as strict in card grading as Card Conduit, but I am happy with the result.
The process went very close to how it is described on the site. I was not as strict in card grading as Card Conduit, but I am happy with the result.
Greg
Review left May 25 2022
Shipment processed May 14 2022
$5,156.07 payout, $242.95 fees

Review

Simple, clear, fair, and thorough. I had information about every step. Never felt in the dark, felt like there was real time put into my order specifically. I could never have made the money I made on my own, given that stamps, envelopes, and top loaders don’t just appear in my house.
Simple, clear, fair, and thorough. I had information about every step. Never felt in the dark, felt like there was real time put into my order specifically. I could never have made the money I made on my own, given that stamps, envelopes, and top loaders don’t just appear in my house.
Hunter
Review left May 25 2022
Shipment processed May 14 2022
$2,975.27 payout, $156.59 fees

Review

They make it clear how best to get your money from your collection—excellent stuff.
They make it clear how best to get your money from your collection—excellent stuff.
Joe
Review left May 25 2022
Shipment processed May 21 2022
$5,432.66 payout, $255.99 fees

Review

Fast payment and value exceeded my expectations!!!

For the curated service I used, the value was great as an alternative to buylisting. It took about 10 days from the day they received until I got payment. I can’t speak to non-curated services. If you are looking for a quick sale at a decent pr ... Read more
Fast payment and value exceeded my expectations!!!

For the curated service I used, the value was great as an alternative to buylisting. It took about 10 days from the day they received until I got payment. I can’t speak to non-curated services. If you are looking for a quick sale at a decent price, give them a try. The total I got was ~200% of my conservative estimate. As they say all over their ads and website, if you want top dollar, consider another option.
Brian
Review left May 25 2022
Shipment processed Apr 01 2022
$349.51 payout, $16.47 fees

Review

Very easy process, and thorough communication from the team. Thanks!
Very easy process, and thorough communication from the team. Thanks!
Sean W.
Review left May 24 2022
Shipment processed May 13 2022
$317.30 payout, $14.95 fees

Review

This was the third shipment I've had in the last couple years and they always grade quickly and fairly. Sending in through the curated shipment is a great way to maximize value on cards I wouldn't want to have to worry about selling/shipping/paying fees for on other site. Thanks again!
This was the third shipment I've had in the last couple years and they always grade quickly and fairly. Sending in through the curated shipment is a great way to maximize value on cards I wouldn't want to have to worry about selling/shipping/paying fees for on other site. Thanks again!
Daniel O'Donnell
Review left May 24 2022
Shipment processed Apr 21 2022
$2,340.92 payout, $110.30 fees

Review

I attempted to use a competitor's card submission service, but their website interface kept dropping cards and forgetting information. After spending more than ten hours being frustrated on their site. I gave up, and found Card Conduit as an alternative, from their Reddit posts. I hoped it was worth ... Read more
I attempted to use a competitor's card submission service, but their website interface kept dropping cards and forgetting information. After spending more than ten hours being frustrated on their site. I gave up, and found Card Conduit as an alternative, from their Reddit posts. I hoped it was worth the cost to have their team do the grunt work.

I was absolutely correct. The price they charged for handling and processing was more than fair. I have since submitted two more collections to them, and I will happily use Card Conduit again for all future card sales.
David
Review left May 23 2022
Shipment processed Apr 19 2022
$1,302.52 payout, $61.37 fees

Review

1st time using card conduit, overall good and easy to use. From TCGplayer app said the value was 2200 and I received 1300 which is not bad. The issue I had is with the grading of the cards. Some of my cars I have never played with or handle a lot and the were graded lightly played or worse.
1st time using card conduit, overall good and easy to use. From TCGplayer app said the value was 2200 and I received 1300 which is not bad. The issue I had is with the grading of the cards. Some of my cars I have never played with or handle a lot and the were graded lightly played or worse.
Rocky Clapp II
Review left May 23 2022
Shipment processed Apr 19 2022

Review

I used this service once and the next time I'm looking to pair down my collection I will again. I thought the payout was more than fair for such an easy process.
I used this service once and the next time I'm looking to pair down my collection I will again. I thought the payout was more than fair for such an easy process.
DR
Review left May 23 2022
Shipment processed May 07 2022
$4,757.60 payout, $224.18 fees

Review

I am INSANELY impressed with their services. I got a whole lot more than what I initially thought and customer service was both professional and honest. I was super nervous shipping my prized collection across the country for grading but now that I've done it once, I wouldn't hesitate to use Card Conduit again!
I am INSANELY impressed with their services. I got a whole lot more than what I initially thought and customer service was both professional and honest. I was super nervous shipping my prized collection across the country for grading but now that I've done it once, I wouldn't hesitate to use Card Conduit again!
Woohoo
Review left May 23 2022
Shipment processed May 18 2022
$979.86 payout, $139.24 fees

Review

Awesome - SUPER easy. Clicked to add a shipment, sent via USPS priority mail box, they did all the legwork! Took VERY little time and I got more than I expected! HIGHLY recommended.

I just sent out another shipment and am looking forward to see how this goes!
Awesome - SUPER easy. Clicked to add a shipment, sent via USPS priority mail box, they did all the legwork! Took VERY little time and I got more than I expected! HIGHLY recommended.

I just sent out another shipment and am looking forward to see how this goes!
Andrew H
Review left May 22 2022
Shipment processed May 10 2022
$1,163.65 payout, $54.83 fees

Review

Simple, effective, I could not be happier.
If you are like me you have way too many cards but not enough time to buylist them all. Card Conduit makes it easy. I sent in a pile of cards, quickly got a credit and now I can buy a new deck or too without putting up more cash.
Simple, effective, I could not be happier.
If you are like me you have way too many cards but not enough time to buylist them all. Card Conduit makes it easy. I sent in a pile of cards, quickly got a credit and now I can buy a new deck or too without putting up more cash.
Brock Newman
Review left May 21 2022
Shipment processed May 07 2022
$73.24 payout, $17.72 fees

Review

Easy, fast, fair pricing. I would recommend them to my friends and would use again.
Easy, fast, fair pricing. I would recommend them to my friends and would use again.
Arri Maskell
Review left May 21 2022
Shipment processed May 07 2022
$2,021.74 payout, $95.26 fees

Review

Was very easy and convenient way to sell my cards. Would definitely use the service again.
Was very easy and convenient way to sell my cards. Would definitely use the service again.
Simon
Review left May 21 2022
Shipment processed May 10 2022
$292.85 payout, $15.41 fees

Review

The process was incredibly smooth and I even received a discount on my processing fees because I sent very little bulk. The employees were also incredibly responsive and transparent with the procesa. If you have a lot of cards to sell, definitely use this service!
The process was incredibly smooth and I even received a discount on my processing fees because I sent very little bulk. The employees were also incredibly responsive and transparent with the procesa. If you have a lot of cards to sell, definitely use this service!
Galen
Review left May 21 2022
Shipment processed May 10 2022
$145.40 payout, $100.93 fees

Review

They were super helpful and had great customer service. 10/10 will do it again
They were super helpful and had great customer service. 10/10 will do it again
Matt
Review left May 21 2022
Shipment processed May 11 2022
$333.83 payout, $35.50 fees

Review

Process was easy and I always get more than I expect!
Process was easy and I always get more than I expect!
Tessa M.
Review left May 20 2022
Shipment processed Apr 27 2022
$3,000.14 payout, $141.36 fees

Review

I saw an ad for the server on Reddit and had grown tired of lugging around all of my magic cards for the past 8 years and 5 moves. I decided to roughly go over all of my cards and personally sorted out the ones I remembered being worth something and was surprised at how much I got paid for them. I h ... Read more
I saw an ad for the server on Reddit and had grown tired of lugging around all of my magic cards for the past 8 years and 5 moves. I decided to roughly go over all of my cards and personally sorted out the ones I remembered being worth something and was surprised at how much I got paid for them. I had emailed a couple of questions before and during the process and got quick responses to them and they not only answered my questions but gave me piece of mind about my shipment.
Steve S
Review left May 19 2022
Shipment processed Apr 15 2022
$269.26 payout, $12.69 fees

Review

I had a pile of cards I didn't want to keep that I knew had a value of at least ~$2.
I believe the value of traded cards was fair, exceeding what I have previously received as a percent of the market value compared to selling with Card Kingdom.
It took a little while, like 2 weeks to get sorted a ... Read more
I had a pile of cards I didn't want to keep that I knew had a value of at least ~$2.
I believe the value of traded cards was fair, exceeding what I have previously received as a percent of the market value compared to selling with Card Kingdom.
It took a little while, like 2 weeks to get sorted and another 1-2 weeks to get paid via check.
I would be a likely repeat client with them.
« 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 ... 27 28
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every previous customer to leave a review. Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page. We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).