Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service
(6498)
Michael Cardona
Review left Aug 17 2026
Review
The instructions were simple to follow. The overall price was very reasonable and I had no problem excepting the offer.
The instructions were simple to follow. The overall price was very reasonable and I had no problem excepting the offer.
Josh M.
Review left Aug 17 2026
Review
The process was pretty simple: I sent thousands of bulk cards in (from opening packs, cast-offs from deckbuilding, draft chaff) and got back some cash, along with some space in my dining room.
The process was pretty simple: I sent thousands of bulk cards in (from opening packs, cast-offs from deckbuilding, draft chaff) and got back some cash, along with some space in my dining room.
Josh
Review left Aug 17 2026
Shipment processed Jul 14 2026
Review
Process was quick and easy. Check was a little late, but not too bad and the amount back was amazing
Process was quick and easy. Check was a little late, but not too bad and the amount back was amazing
Fletcher
Review left Aug 17 2026
Review
Thanks! Always the best! Quick turn around for what I sent in
Thanks! Always the best! Quick turn around for what I sent in
Amos
Review left Aug 17 2026
Review
I was honestly expecting to get lowballed or have the card conditions graded pretty harshly, but when I received the report, I was shocked by how fair everything was. I’ll definitely be using Card Conduit to unload my bulk in the future.
I’ve looked at other services, and their offers tend to ... Read more
I’ve looked at other services, and their offers tend to ... Read more
I was honestly expecting to get lowballed or have the card conditions graded pretty harshly, but when I received the report, I was shocked by how fair everything was. I’ll definitely be using Card Conduit to unload my bulk in the future.
I’ve looked at other services, and their offers tend to be much lower. Selling cards one at a time is also so time-consuming that it basically becomes a second job. When you factor in the time, hassle, and postage costs Card Conduit saves, it just makes the most sense for me.
I’m already prepping my next submission.
I’ve looked at other services, and their offers tend to be much lower. Selling cards one at a time is also so time-consuming that it basically becomes a second job. When you factor in the time, hassle, and postage costs Card Conduit saves, it just makes the most sense for me.
I’m already prepping my next submission.
Quincy Hernan
Review left Aug 17 2026
Shipment processed Jul 30 2026
Review
Process was super easy as always. Card Conduit is the best in the business!
Process was super easy as always. Card Conduit is the best in the business!
Josh H
Review left Aug 17 2026
Review
The process was very straightforward- Card Conduit gives very clear instructions and leaves no questions unanswered. I was satisfied with the overall value. I was a bit surprised at how many of my cards were considered "LP" and not "NM", but after some reflection, I think most people (myself include
...
Read more
The process was very straightforward- Card Conduit gives very clear instructions and leaves no questions unanswered. I was satisfied with the overall value. I was a bit surprised at how many of my cards were considered "LP" and not "NM", but after some reflection, I think most people (myself included) probably view their cards as though they're in better condition than they actually are.
David B
Review left Aug 17 2026
Shipment processed Jul 22 2026
Review
From letting go of decks to breaking down collections and hoards of bulk. Cardconduit has made the process safe and convenient. After moving past the fear of mailing your valuable card board, this team helps every step of the way.
From letting go of decks to breaking down collections and hoards of bulk. Cardconduit has made the process safe and convenient. After moving past the fear of mailing your valuable card board, this team helps every step of the way.
Matt Arnott
Review left Aug 16 2026
Review
The team handled my shipment with care and were quick to provide examples of card damage. I was able to use their testimony and the clear and defined pictures of my cards to process an insurance claim. The shipment was also placed on hold while this was being processed for around a month with no com
...
Read more
The team handled my shipment with care and were quick to provide examples of card damage. I was able to use their testimony and the clear and defined pictures of my cards to process an insurance claim. The shipment was also placed on hold while this was being processed for around a month with no complaints. The support team checked in during the process and even reached out to confirm I was ready to move forward when I set my shipment as ready for processing. Overall they assisted in dealing with damage to a serialized card and still purchased the damaged cards after a settlement was reached with shipping insurance.
Joe
Review left Aug 16 2026
Review
This is an amazing service that I am super grateful for! A very transparent process and fair assessments! Will definitely do again!
This is an amazing service that I am super grateful for! A very transparent process and fair assessments! Will definitely do again!
Jarreth W.
Review left Aug 16 2026
Review
The process to submit a collection to Card Conduit was intuitive and easy to use. The interface was clear and communicated all of the necessary information for each step; additionally, my collection was processed in a timely manner and I received the expected valuation for my collection. I would highly recommend Card Conduit to anyone!
The process to submit a collection to Card Conduit was intuitive and easy to use. The interface was clear and communicated all of the necessary information for each step; additionally, my collection was processed in a timely manner and I received the expected valuation for my collection. I would highly recommend Card Conduit to anyone!
Jared Bailey
Review left Aug 15 2026
Review
I got way more for the cards I sent than I would have taking them to a store. The buylist checks really shine vs a store trying to pay bulk.
I got way more for the cards I sent than I would have taking them to a store. The buylist checks really shine vs a store trying to pay bulk.
Brian West
Review left Aug 15 2026
Review
Sending my old cards that have some value to Card Conduit is always fast and easy. No supplies or shipping, no mess and time spent packaging orders. Send one package, get paid quickly, I love it!
Sending my old cards that have some value to Card Conduit is always fast and easy. No supplies or shipping, no mess and time spent packaging orders. Send one package, get paid quickly, I love it!
Mike
Review left Aug 15 2026
Review
The process couldn’t be easier. Of course I look at all the old cards I played with in the 90’s and say they are lightly played and they probably aren’t. Don’t be shocked if the grading comes back lower than you think. Outside of that hope/expectation the process is perfect. Definitely the b
...
Read more
The process couldn’t be easier. Of course I look at all the old cards I played with in the 90’s and say they are lightly played and they probably aren’t. Don’t be shocked if the grading comes back lower than you think. Outside of that hope/expectation the process is perfect. Definitely the best way for me to sell the 250 cards in my collection in the $10-$200 range.
Brian Ashton
Review left Aug 15 2026
Review
The process was extremely easy, fast, and the overall order and payment was processed quickly.
The process was extremely easy, fast, and the overall order and payment was processed quickly.
Bryan Barton
Review left Aug 15 2026
Shipment processed Aug 05 2026
Review
Really transparent service and great communication! It was really quick and I was able to get questions answered as soon as possible.
Really transparent service and great communication! It was really quick and I was able to get questions answered as soon as possible.
KJN
Review left Aug 14 2026
Review
Five stars. I appreciated the expectation management from other reviewers and CC themselves. READ THE FAQS AND DO YOUR RESEARCH.
Five stars. I appreciated the expectation management from other reviewers and CC themselves. READ THE FAQS AND DO YOUR RESEARCH.
Alexander Wellems
Review left Aug 14 2026
Review
The process was very easy. I uploaded my card list and determined the cards I wanted to sell based on the values provided. After selecting the type of service, I packed my shipment and sent it out. Once received, I could review the status online and the assessment list was sent to me for my review.
...
Read more
The process was very easy. I uploaded my card list and determined the cards I wanted to sell based on the values provided. After selecting the type of service, I packed my shipment and sent it out. Once received, I could review the status online and the assessment list was sent to me for my review. The card values after evaluation were in-line with my expectations. After my approval, the check was issued in a timely manner. Great experience and I will used Card Conduit in the future.
Alexander Wellems
Review left Aug 14 2026
Review
The process was very easy to upload my card list from manabox. The prices were transparent and easy to review. The options for sorting and shipping were great as I could choose the one that fit my needs. After Card Conduit received the shipment, the processing was very quick and the assessed value w
...
Read more
The process was very easy to upload my card list from manabox. The prices were transparent and easy to review. The options for sorting and shipping were great as I could choose the one that fit my needs. After Card Conduit received the shipment, the processing was very quick and the assessed value was in-line with the initial provided online. I was allowed to review the assessment list prior to completing the transaction and the payment was issued in a timely manner. Overall, a great experience and I will continue to use Card Conduit to sell my card singles.
Graham Vetta
Review left Aug 14 2026
Review
Process was easy the payment was fast and the value was OK. I wish I could have gotten more money out of the cards but doesn’t everybody.
Process was easy the payment was fast and the value was OK. I wish I could have gotten more money out of the cards but doesn’t everybody.
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every
previous customer to leave a review.
Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page.
We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a
review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).