Customer Reviews

of our Magic collection selling service

I was able to look through my bulk cards and identify prices very easily with tools from their website. The whole process from searching to shipping only took a few hours, and payment was quick and fair. They also sent regular updates about shipping, sorting, and payment. I’ll definitely use this service again to sell my extra cards.

I was able to look through my bulk cards and identify prices very easily with tools from their website. The whole process from searching to shipping only took a few hours, and payment was quick and fair. They also sent regular updates about shipping, sorting, and payment. I’ll definitely use this service again to sell my extra cards.

Yes it was very easy I bet most people get it on their first go around. It was a very simple straight forward process. Unsleeve cards, pack them up safely and neatly. Write your order number on the box. Ship it, watch your tracking number through the locations. Wait and receive payment. Will u ... Read more

Yes it was very easy I bet most people get it on their first go around. It was a very simple straight forward process. Unsleeve cards, pack them up safely and neatly. Write your order number on the box. Ship it, watch your tracking number through the locations. Wait and receive payment. Will use this again very soon. They are working on another order from me. Thank you Card Conduit.

I have sold with card conduit before and I have never been disappointed. Communication was open, prices were fair and I got paid quickly. This time was no different.
However, it has been over a year since I sold with them and in that time I believe that they have become more fastidious and scrutini ... Read more

I have sold with card conduit before and I have never been disappointed. Communication was open, prices were fair and I got paid quickly. This time was no different.
However, it has been over a year since I sold with them and in that time I believe that they have become more fastidious and scrutinizing in their grading. They rated a number of cards that were very clearly near mint as lightly played and respectfully, I believe they were wrong. This is absolutely their prerogative, and I can certainly be wrong, but there seem to be more discrepancies with condition this time than the last time I sold. Just something I noticed.

Super easy process, great communication and quick payout. Best way to sell cards without the hassle!

Super easy process, great communication and quick payout. Best way to sell cards without the hassle!

They make it so easy to get your cards sold and I got more than expected! Best way to sell my large collection when I don't have the time or patience to do it by myself.
Thanks to the whole team for providing great service!

They make it so easy to get your cards sold and I got more than expected! Best way to sell my large collection when I don't have the time or patience to do it by myself.
Thanks to the whole team for providing great service!

I Love Cardconduit, it is an amazing service and I love that it's made by the people who make Cardhoarder loans which is also a great service.

I Love Cardconduit, it is an amazing service and I love that it's made by the people who make Cardhoarder loans which is also a great service.

Sent in a card lot and was surprised that it was fast and accurate and easy, payment was fast and they offer different payment methods

Sent in a card lot and was surprised that it was fast and accurate and easy, payment was fast and they offer different payment methods

Great easy fast service, accurate grading and payment was fast and easy with all the options they give .

Great easy fast service, accurate grading and payment was fast and easy with all the options they give .

Once you get your .csv files sorted out everything is pretty simple. I did the curated shipments and everything went off without an issue. I put a couple shipments in the same USPS flat rate box to save on shipping too. And at the end you get a full breakdown on every card you ship. 10/10!

Once you get your .csv files sorted out everything is pretty simple. I did the curated shipments and everything went off without an issue. I put a couple shipments in the same USPS flat rate box to save on shipping too. And at the end you get a full breakdown on every card you ship. 10/10!

Super easy process, quick turnaround with the card review and fair assessment.

Super easy process, quick turnaround with the card review and fair assessment.

Having done this before I was pleased. Everything went as expected, the instructions were complete and the payout was fair and on time. My one piece of feedback would be that the estimate on cards being sent ought to show some calculated average between near mint price and moderate play, since most ... Read more

Having done this before I was pleased. Everything went as expected, the instructions were complete and the payout was fair and on time. My one piece of feedback would be that the estimate on cards being sent ought to show some calculated average between near mint price and moderate play, since most cards sold won't receive max price. New sellers are prone to overestimate what they'll receive.

I've been using Card Conduit for a couple years now and have always been happy with how quick and easy the process is.

I've been using Card Conduit for a couple years now and have always been happy with how quick and easy the process is.

ONLY downside is turn around from shipping to money being in your account is about 3 weeks. Payout and ease of use is so much higher then anybody else

ONLY downside is turn around from shipping to money being in your account is about 3 weeks. Payout and ease of use is so much higher then anybody else

Was fast and easy, and the payout was reasonable for the value of the cards.

Was fast and easy, and the payout was reasonable for the value of the cards.

I sent in cards that looked to be paying out at around $900 if all were NM. However, by the time the cards arrived, the max payout was a good deal lower - around $850. They were upfront about card prices not locking in until they receive the cards, and though it did not work in my favor this time, I ... Read more

I sent in cards that looked to be paying out at around $900 if all were NM. However, by the time the cards arrived, the max payout was a good deal lower - around $850. They were upfront about card prices not locking in until they receive the cards, and though it did not work in my favor this time, I am sure it actually benefits sellers at times.

My cards were mostly pack fresh or very nearly pack fresh. However, I received a spread of about 55% NM, 25% LP, and 20% HP. I was understandably concerned and put my sale on hold and asked for clarification. Though the automated outreach did not work, I eventually connected with support and received a full image breakdown of all cards I flagged.

After reviewing their photos I actually agree with most of their grade assessments. Honestly, they often erred on the side of caution and gave me a better grade than the card warranted. We discussed two cards and I negotiated a slightly better payout. One card I wanted returned because their offer price was too low for me. They returned that free of charge, and I am certain they would have done the same with the entire shipment if I had requested it.

Card Conduit is a business and they likely sell the cards they receive to other buyers and vendors. They will have built up trust with these clients that a NM card is always 100% NM. That is almost certainly why they are so strict on conditions. Would I have liked to receive $900 for my cards. Heck yea. Am I happy with $700? Eh, not really. But at the end of the day, it was my choice alone to take the deal.

They paid me out at around 70% of market value in cash (even when factoring in their processing fee and my shipping costs). You will not find anywhere else willing to do this while simultaneously providing such good customer service. If you find someone doing it better, then use them. But when you don't, no worries. You can always come back and use Card Conduit with full confidence.

Seth from MTG goldfish is right. Card Conduit really is the easiest way to sell magic cards. They are also the most reliable and quickest way too. I’ve sold with them about 5-6 times in the past two years. Always get a fair evaluation and quick payout. Their options for sorting and getting paid is ... Read more

Seth from MTG goldfish is right. Card Conduit really is the easiest way to sell magic cards. They are also the most reliable and quickest way too. I’ve sold with them about 5-6 times in the past two years. Always get a fair evaluation and quick payout. Their options for sorting and getting paid is very generous. I also appreciate they offer promo codes. Will be selling again more soon.

It was indeed easy and the fee was minimal. There was a follow up email from an actual human rather than a bot and they made sure I was happy with everything. Some of the cards were old and partially damaged and I felt that I still got a fair price on them.

It was indeed easy and the fee was minimal. There was a follow up email from an actual human rather than a bot and they made sure I was happy with everything. Some of the cards were old and partially damaged and I felt that I still got a fair price on them.

The process saved me a lot of time and I get a good money for my stuff, thanks a lot!

The process saved me a lot of time and I get a good money for my stuff, thanks a lot!

Large card order was processed by Auto-sift and I was given a good payout. Would use Card Conduit again.

Large card order was processed by Auto-sift and I was given a good payout. Would use Card Conduit again.

My brother passed away in December and I needed an easy way to sell off some of his vintage collection. I found Card Conduit through Google and Reddit searches. The process was painless and I was paid pretty quickly. The card condition was fair given how they were maintained (many were MP or HP) so ... Read more

My brother passed away in December and I needed an easy way to sell off some of his vintage collection. I found Card Conduit through Google and Reddit searches. The process was painless and I was paid pretty quickly. The card condition was fair given how they were maintained (many were MP or HP) so I have no complaints there. My only request would be for a submission to allow me to select the condition rather than default to NM as I knew these cards were not in that condition. Otherwise, would absolutely use again!