Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service
Judith
Review left Sep 12 2024
Shipment processed Aug 31 2024
Review
Overall, the experience was very positive. They were helpful, professional and friendly. I would recommend using them if you have the need.
Overall, the experience was very positive. They were helpful, professional and friendly. I would recommend using them if you have the need.
Noel Hernandez
Review left Sep 11 2024
Review
Good value for cards with a quick time turn around
Good value for cards with a quick time turn around
Benjamin S
Review left Sep 11 2024
Review
The overall process was great, between easy steps online to prepare and getting everything shipped with their own tips and info they provide. It was also nice to see updates as the cards went through the process.
As for the payout, the money came quickly once the reports were done. And out of my ... Read more
As for the payout, the money came quickly once the reports were done. And out of my ... Read more
The overall process was great, between easy steps online to prepare and getting everything shipped with their own tips and info they provide. It was also nice to see updates as the cards went through the process.
As for the payout, the money came quickly once the reports were done. And out of my roughly 200 cards between 2 shipments I made, there were only 2 cards that I feel were not graded correctly. 99% perfect? I’ll take it! The ease and convenience, to get the same money in the end (after fees and shipping) as you would get selling individually on a site like eBay, was great!
As for the payout, the money came quickly once the reports were done. And out of my roughly 200 cards between 2 shipments I made, there were only 2 cards that I feel were not graded correctly. 99% perfect? I’ll take it! The ease and convenience, to get the same money in the end (after fees and shipping) as you would get selling individually on a site like eBay, was great!
B Wendel
Review left Sep 11 2024
Shipment processed Aug 31 2024
Review
Incredibly painless process. Clear shipping instructions and communication each step along the processing cycle. Will definitely use again.
Incredibly painless process. Clear shipping instructions and communication each step along the processing cycle. Will definitely use again.
Morgan Von Druitt
Review left Sep 11 2024
Review
The process was incredibly easy and straight forward. The payout made sense and I absolutely love the reports about what artist I had the most of, what sets I had the most of and so forth. Card conduit will be my go to for selling cards hassle free to unlocking value within my stacks of cards that h
...
Read more
The process was incredibly easy and straight forward. The payout made sense and I absolutely love the reports about what artist I had the most of, what sets I had the most of and so forth. Card conduit will be my go to for selling cards hassle free to unlocking value within my stacks of cards that haven't made the cut into my main decks. The team is responsive and helpful as well!
I am only removing one star because at times payment processing took longer than expected and I wasn't able to switch from check to ACH. Also, in a very small handful of cases I felt like a card was significantly undervalued - example: an Edgar Markov I expected to be around $100 going for $27.
BUT I trust their system and grading and assume there was damage I didn't notice.
Great service overall, 9/10 recommend
I am only removing one star because at times payment processing took longer than expected and I wasn't able to switch from check to ACH. Also, in a very small handful of cases I felt like a card was significantly undervalued - example: an Edgar Markov I expected to be around $100 going for $27.
BUT I trust their system and grading and assume there was damage I didn't notice.
Great service overall, 9/10 recommend
John Herrin
Review left Sep 11 2024
Review
The process was easy and service was great Nick was really nice and got back to me quick. Payment was very easy to set up as well.
The process was easy and service was great Nick was really nice and got back to me quick. Payment was very easy to set up as well.
MARCO
Review left Sep 11 2024
Review
I'm very skeptical at first and did a lot reading reviews before I finally decided to send a batch of cards in. I did the sorted route and after I arranged the cards the way they wanted it, I shipped it and did my prayers. Once they said they received my cards I prayed more, then after a couple of
...
Read more
I'm very skeptical at first and did a lot reading reviews before I finally decided to send a batch of cards in. I did the sorted route and after I arranged the cards the way they wanted it, I shipped it and did my prayers. Once they said they received my cards I prayed more, then after a couple of weeks I received payment! woohoo it's a legit company and their pricing is great! I am already preparing my next batch to send in!
Mark T
Review left Sep 11 2024
Review
It was a straightforward process, had no issues with my shipment. They were very courteous after they received my shipment.
Would use this site again!
Would use this site again!
It was a straightforward process, had no issues with my shipment. They were very courteous after they received my shipment.
Would use this site again!
Would use this site again!
Reginald Eckert
Review left Sep 10 2024
Review
It took a lot longer than I was anticipating but that's probably due to the covid situation however the end result was fine
It took a lot longer than I was anticipating but that's probably due to the covid situation however the end result was fine
Erik F
Review left Sep 10 2024
Shipment processed Aug 24 2024
Review
Card conduit it made it fast and easy to trade in mtg cards. I highly recommend them to anyone who plays Magic looking to trade in.
Card conduit it made it fast and easy to trade in mtg cards. I highly recommend them to anyone who plays Magic looking to trade in.
dnltype
Review left Sep 10 2024
Review
The sell order was processed, there was a detailed explanation of the condition of the cards, and a electronic deposit was issued shortly thereafter. It couldn't have been simpler
The sell order was processed, there was a detailed explanation of the condition of the cards, and a electronic deposit was issued shortly thereafter. It couldn't have been simpler
Alejandro
Review left Sep 09 2024
Review
Great job everyone. Group hugs in the showers tonight!
Great job everyone. Group hugs in the showers tonight!
Alejandro
Review left Sep 09 2024
Review
Even though an outbreak hit right as they got my shipment, their communication and helpfulness kept me well informed and comfortable. Excellent job and excellent service! Thanks Nick!
Even though an outbreak hit right as they got my shipment, their communication and helpfulness kept me well informed and comfortable. Excellent job and excellent service! Thanks Nick!
Alejandro
Review left Sep 09 2024
Review
Worked out great, they were communicative and did their best even when complications arose. Definitely looking forward to using their services again!
Worked out great, they were communicative and did their best even when complications arose. Definitely looking forward to using their services again!
clayton snyder
Review left Sep 09 2024
Shipment processed Aug 29 2024
Review
Don't actually eat pie over your cards. Regardless, great service!
Don't actually eat pie over your cards. Regardless, great service!
Nate 4tran
Review left Sep 09 2024
Review
They processed my cards quickly and paid very close to market rate for the cards.
They processed my cards quickly and paid very close to market rate for the cards.
Zach G
Review left Sep 09 2024
Review
Card Conduit is amazing. I sent almost 3,000 cards in and they got through them within a decent timespan. When there was a delay they sent me emails explaining what had happened (Covid). Overall very communicative. The fees are very standard and I did not feel like I was being ripped off. Would use this company again to send my bulk cards.
Card Conduit is amazing. I sent almost 3,000 cards in and they got through them within a decent timespan. When there was a delay they sent me emails explaining what had happened (Covid). Overall very communicative. The fees are very standard and I did not feel like I was being ripped off. Would use this company again to send my bulk cards.
Jeffrey
Review left Sep 09 2024
Review
Overall the process took long but I understand, times are tough and staff can be limiting. However I basically lost about $600 in trades and had to wait to get the brutal review of my collection. Which fine whatever, I get it, someone’s gotta make money somehow, it definitely hits as an unfair tra
...
Read more
Overall the process took long but I understand, times are tough and staff can be limiting. However I basically lost about $600 in trades and had to wait to get the brutal review of my collection. Which fine whatever, I get it, someone’s gotta make money somehow, it definitely hits as an unfair trade but as someone trying to get by and feed a growing family and pay bills. I’ll take it, but to anyone else scoping out this website…sell local or find somewhere else unless you don’t care and just wanna off load some old cards.
Card Conduit Team
Replied Sep 09 2024
We understand it can be frustrating when your expectations on value do not align with your payout. We go through great pains to set expectations ahead of time to avoid any unpleasant surprises. In this example, the $600 in trades being cited is the TCGPlayer Low price (retail price), which should never be a baseline expectation for anyone selling cards - even if you yourself sell them on TCGPlayer, as it does not reflect the costs associated with selling (postage, TCGPlayer fees, shipping materials, and time).
We offer a price check tool and a collection estimate tool, and always strongly encourage anyone considering our service to look up prices to ensure they are within the realm of acceptability. Buylist prices - even optimized buylist prices like our service offers - are not the same thing as retail prices, and generally reflect the cost of selling cards, the carrying cost and price risk of holding cards that sell slowly, and a margin so the business can pay for its overhead.
We offer a price check tool and a collection estimate tool, and always strongly encourage anyone considering our service to look up prices to ensure they are within the realm of acceptability. Buylist prices - even optimized buylist prices like our service offers - are not the same thing as retail prices, and generally reflect the cost of selling cards, the carrying cost and price risk of holding cards that sell slowly, and a margin so the business can pay for its overhead.
We understand it can be frustrating when your expectations on value do not align with your payout. We go through great pains to set expectations ahead of time to avoid any unpleasant surprises. In this example, the $600 in trades being cited is the TCGPlayer Low price (retail price), which should never be a baseline expectation for anyone selling cards - even if you yourself sell them on TCGPlayer, as it does not reflect the costs associated with selling (postage, TCGPlayer fees, shipping materials, and time).
We offer a price check tool and a collection estimate tool, and always strongly encourage anyone considering our service to look up prices to ensure they are within the realm of acceptability. Buylist prices - even optimized buylist prices like our service offers - are not the same thing as retail prices, and generally reflect the cost of selling cards, the carrying cost and price risk of holding cards that sell slowly, and a margin so the business can pay for its overhead.
We offer a price check tool and a collection estimate tool, and always strongly encourage anyone considering our service to look up prices to ensure they are within the realm of acceptability. Buylist prices - even optimized buylist prices like our service offers - are not the same thing as retail prices, and generally reflect the cost of selling cards, the carrying cost and price risk of holding cards that sell slowly, and a margin so the business can pay for its overhead.
Kevin Wilson
Review left Sep 09 2024
Review
I am very happy with the overall process of selling MTG cards through Card Conduit. I sent them a curated shipment and the whole process was very straightforward. I also think they were fair in their grading of my cards and what they paid out was about what I expected to receive.
I also love thei ... Read more
I also love thei ... Read more
I am very happy with the overall process of selling MTG cards through Card Conduit. I sent them a curated shipment and the whole process was very straightforward. I also think they were fair in their grading of my cards and what they paid out was about what I expected to receive.
I also love their collection estimator! It's a great tool to get a sense of how much of a decrease you will expect from mint on down to other grades. Thanks for creating such a painless process for selling MTG cards!
I also love their collection estimator! It's a great tool to get a sense of how much of a decrease you will expect from mint on down to other grades. Thanks for creating such a painless process for selling MTG cards!
Spencer
Review left Sep 08 2024
Review
Keep up the good work! Simple and hassle free l!!!
Keep up the good work! Simple and hassle free l!!!
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every
previous customer to leave a review.
Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page.
We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a
review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).