Customer Reviews

of our Magic collection selling service

Incredibly easy, I used the auto sorted service and couldn’t be happier with the results! Fast, easy, and money deposited directly to my bank!

Incredibly easy, I used the auto sorted service and couldn’t be happier with the results! Fast, easy, and money deposited directly to my bank!

Good communication. Process was all completed in a reasonable time frame. Fair pricing.

Good communication. Process was all completed in a reasonable time frame. Fair pricing.

Good place to sell bulk or if you're lazy just send everything. You don't get top dollar but my time is very valuable and I rather just let them handle all the selling. I highly recommend this service if you are lazy and just want to get some cash for your cards at a reasonable rate.

Good place to sell bulk or if you're lazy just send everything. You don't get top dollar but my time is very valuable and I rather just let them handle all the selling. I highly recommend this service if you are lazy and just want to get some cash for your cards at a reasonable rate.

this is my 4th or so shipment and its been consistently pleasant. customer service has responded when i had questions and the process is very straight forward. if you are waffeling on weather or not to do this... do it. its worth it vs having a stack of cards from the last set that will never get sorted or put away or into a deck.

this is my 4th or so shipment and its been consistently pleasant. customer service has responded when i had questions and the process is very straight forward. if you are waffeling on weather or not to do this... do it. its worth it vs having a stack of cards from the last set that will never get sorted or put away or into a deck.

Have sold multiple shipments, and this one was just as easy, just as worthwhile as every other time.

Have sold multiple shipments, and this one was just as easy, just as worthwhile as every other time.

Very quick turnaround time and very fair with the values. Will definitely be using the service again.

Very quick turnaround time and very fair with the values. Will definitely be using the service again.

This review comes after my 3rd shipment with CC. I continue to appreciate their professionalism, ease-of-use platform, and swift communication. I look forward to my 4th shipment!

This review comes after my 3rd shipment with CC. I continue to appreciate their professionalism, ease-of-use platform, and swift communication. I look forward to my 4th shipment!

The process was smooth and simple, the time frames given were accurate and payment was prompt.

The process was smooth and simple, the time frames given were accurate and payment was prompt.

Extremely easy and streamlined process. Quick payment that followed the guidelines they set. I’d recommend taking pictures of all cards you send before submitting because several of my more valuable cards were magically lightly played despite being sleeved straight from pack. If I wasn’t so hard ... Read more

Extremely easy and streamlined process. Quick payment that followed the guidelines they set. I’d recommend taking pictures of all cards you send before submitting because several of my more valuable cards were magically lightly played despite being sleeved straight from pack. If I wasn’t so hard pressed for the money I would’ve fought harder, but here we are. Still the best way to sell bulk cards or higher value lots.

Second time using their service and it has yet to let me down. Excellent turnaround time on processing and always notifies in a timely manner with progress updates.

Second time using their service and it has yet to let me down. Excellent turnaround time on processing and always notifies in a timely manner with progress updates.

Thanks for the quick turn around. I appreciate it. Professional team.

Thanks for the quick turn around. I appreciate it. Professional team.

I shipped card conduit around 500 cards that were never played and pack fresh. Of those 500 cards around 200 were found to be LP and an additional 30 were MP. A lot of these interpretations are very subjective and I wish they used a machine with consistent parameters for grading decisions. At least ... Read more

I shipped card conduit around 500 cards that were never played and pack fresh. Of those 500 cards around 200 were found to be LP and an additional 30 were MP. A lot of these interpretations are very subjective and I wish they used a machine with consistent parameters for grading decisions. At least they were up front about it. I just find I hard to believe that pack fresh cards never played have a 1/2 rate of degradation. In general I find CC to be very tough when grading cards and I wish you were more consistent about it.

Other than that, customer service and speed were good. I had like 10-15 extra cards not properly sorted that they included in the final tally.

Thank you for that.


They were able to pay out and sort all cards same week of receipt which was a great turn around and I appreciate that aspect very much.

I’ve noticed a change like some others have who’ve been using CC for several years now. I’ve submitted roughly 10 orders to CC. I began noticing a change in their standard for grading in a previous submission. However, now it’s more than clear the changes. Now, I’m submitting cards pulled ... Read more

I’ve noticed a change like some others have who’ve been using CC for several years now. I’ve submitted roughly 10 orders to CC. I began noticing a change in their standard for grading in a previous submission. However, now it’s more than clear the changes. Now, I’m submitting cards pulled directly from packs that are not foil and receiving immediate LP conditioning and not NM as often.

Clearly, we should all be aware that card conditions are not Mint out of a pack. However, to say that they are not Near Mint out of a package the majority of the time is very laughable. This submission had many cards that came direct from packs only a few days before shipping to CC.

I just opened two more boxes of MaKM and as usual pulled a ton of Surveil Lands and other good cards. Why should I send them to CC only to be instantly be hit with LP conditioning on cards and losing out Selling individual cards myself while also only sending cards to CC that are clearly in the HP to LP condition already, because you’ll be automatically downgraded to a lower rating if NM and the price difference between LP and NM is a wide enough gap to try and sneak one past your customers?

After submitting my complaint, the person (maybe a human) replied back with what you’d expect to hear. However, I do love that they mentioned it wouldn’t he in CC’s interest to down grade cards, because they don’t sell them to vendors at a different grade. But, you’ll notice something, there’s no proof to say they don’t just mark the card’s condition higher when selling to vendors.

Ultimately, rating I give is purely based on how they grade the cards. Everything else is smooth as usual and easy to do. However, at this point, CC isn’t a new company and now they can get away with not being as generous and fair with their grading since it’s obvious their name is now out there. I’ll maybe come back in a year to two and see if things have changed, but we shall see.

The process was extremely easy and the provided timeline was met. Payout was quick and the whole process was hurdle-free.

The process was extremely easy and the provided timeline was met. Payout was quick and the whole process was hurdle-free.

I worked on selling my collection for months; taking pictures, creating ebay listings, driving to the post office every other day. It was exhausting and awful. Also, the ebay cut is steep. As I move on from collecting I know I've gotten the best price for my collection while also putting in low effo ... Read more

I worked on selling my collection for months; taking pictures, creating ebay listings, driving to the post office every other day. It was exhausting and awful. Also, the ebay cut is steep. As I move on from collecting I know I've gotten the best price for my collection while also putting in low effort. I was able to meet a few of the folks when dropping off my cards and they are so helpful and kind from the start (shout out Hailey).

Thank you everybody!

Fast processing, best offer on my cards for the easiest process and quick instant payout as always!!

Fast processing, best offer on my cards for the easiest process and quick instant payout as always!!

The process was super easy, just pack your cards very well and safe and there should be no problems, there is a bunch of links explaining what to do and not to do, i send them my cards and withing a week or two i already got an value that they were willingly to Pay and it was reasonably within my expectations, would definitely recomend

The process was super easy, just pack your cards very well and safe and there should be no problems, there is a bunch of links explaining what to do and not to do, i send them my cards and withing a week or two i already got an value that they were willingly to Pay and it was reasonably within my expectations, would definitely recomend

Super easy process, very easy processing. Very easy to communicate with the team from preprocessing to the end.

Super easy process, very easy processing. Very easy to communicate with the team from preprocessing to the end.

These guys are awesome. They have a very fair price model, and I'll be using them again in the future. Thank you so much for doing all the hard work

These guys are awesome. They have a very fair price model, and I'll be using them again in the future. Thank you so much for doing all the hard work

The cards’ ulimate value depends on the condition as determined by the Card Conduit grader and it will generally be 1-4 grades lower than expected. It is fine to only pay DMG price on big foil cards, but that should be disclosed. Their grading is done to fit in the price they are willing to pay/ ... Read more

The cards’ ulimate value depends on the condition as determined by the Card Conduit grader and it will generally be 1-4 grades lower than expected. It is fine to only pay DMG price on big foil cards, but that should be disclosed. Their grading is done to fit in the price they are willing to pay/what their buyer is willing to pay. The estimated value of my shipment was way too high and caused me to over-insure the shipment and not check around with other vendors. Easy way to get rid of cards, I just wish the grading accurately reflected the actual condition of the cards and Card Conduit could adjust their payout and payout estimates accordingly.