Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service
(5856)
Susan Ponds
Review left Mar 26 2026
Review
I put off doing anything with my son’s old magic cards for years because of the amount of time and effort I felt it would require. I saw card conduit online and decided to give them a shot. I initially sent about 2000 cards. I was BLOWN AWAY by how easy it was, how informative card conduit was
...
Read more
I put off doing anything with my son’s old magic cards for years because of the amount of time and effort I felt it would require. I saw card conduit online and decided to give them a shot. I initially sent about 2000 cards. I was BLOWN AWAY by how easy it was, how informative card conduit was in every step of the process, how fair they were in determining the value of my cards and how quickly they paid for the cards!
I chose the auto-sort method and could not be happier. I promptly boxed up the rest of the cards which are en-route to card conduit as we speak.
Obviously I have no hesitation about using them again!
Great experience! Great communication every step of the way! Just all around great company!
Thanks!!
I chose the auto-sort method and could not be happier. I promptly boxed up the rest of the cards which are en-route to card conduit as we speak.
Obviously I have no hesitation about using them again!
Great experience! Great communication every step of the way! Just all around great company!
Thanks!!
Jonathan Jenkins
Review left Mar 26 2026
Review
Everything went great working with Card Conduit. I followed their instructions and was able to sell my cards without a hitch. Will definitely recommend to friends and use again.
Everything went great working with Card Conduit. I followed their instructions and was able to sell my cards without a hitch. Will definitely recommend to friends and use again.
Knewt C .
Review left Mar 26 2026
Shipment processed Feb 24 2026
Review
Highly recommend because of the ease of use, the value given.
Highly recommend because of the ease of use, the value given.
Paul Chapin
Review left Mar 25 2026
Review
I have dealt with Card Conduit several times so far...I love their service. Reasonable pricing, fast turnaround, great communication....tried a few other places but had horribly mixed results...came back to Card Conduit because it is so much easier. I MAY have gotten a few bucks more somewhere els
...
Read more
I have dealt with Card Conduit several times so far...I love their service. Reasonable pricing, fast turnaround, great communication....tried a few other places but had horribly mixed results...came back to Card Conduit because it is so much easier. I MAY have gotten a few bucks more somewhere else but it would have created MANY HOURS more work to put together...not at all worth it. I won't deal with anyone but Card Conduit now.
Trist
Review left Mar 25 2026
Review
Shipped a “large” list in and cards were processed and paid in about a week.
Shipped a “large” list in and cards were processed and paid in about a week.
Sean
Review left Mar 25 2026
Review
Process was super easy, wouldn’t say there was much value as I lost money shipping the cards safely. Have to assume that’s on me for not having very many high value cards but having sent just over 1800 cards I was expecting to get more than the cost of a handful booster packs. I do think if you
...
Read more
Process was super easy, wouldn’t say there was much value as I lost money shipping the cards safely. Have to assume that’s on me for not having very many high value cards but having sent just over 1800 cards I was expecting to get more than the cost of a handful booster packs. I do think if you have the volume and high value cards this would be a great service but if you’re just looking to clear bulk of negligible value I’d recommend maybe looking for someone who offers trade credit instead.
Tim
Review left Mar 24 2026
Review
Thanks for processing my order - good service and value
Thanks for processing my order - good service and value
Tim
Review left Mar 24 2026
Review
Thank you for processing my order. Would recommend
Thank you for processing my order. Would recommend
Tim
Review left Mar 24 2026
Review
Thanks for another transaction, I like the auto sift service
Thanks for another transaction, I like the auto sift service
Corey G
Review left Mar 23 2026
Shipment processed Mar 17 2026
Review
Amazing! Effortless. This service will be recommended to everyone I know who plays.
Amazing! Effortless. This service will be recommended to everyone I know who plays.
Matt
Review left Mar 23 2026
Shipment processed Feb 28 2026
Review
Fast, easy, and great communication. Nice job! I'll definitely use the service again.
Fast, easy, and great communication. Nice job! I'll definitely use the service again.
Matt
Review left Mar 23 2026
Review
Extremely easy, fast processing, fast payout. This company is dream.
Extremely easy, fast processing, fast payout. This company is dream.
Greg
Review left Mar 22 2026
Review
The process was well outlined and guidelines were clear. The timelines for processing were reasonable and the shareable report was a hoot. As a player for 30 years the service was handy for selling the remainder inventory from a large collection rather than the opportunity cost of time consuming in
...
Read more
The process was well outlined and guidelines were clear. The timelines for processing were reasonable and the shareable report was a hoot. As a player for 30 years the service was handy for selling the remainder inventory from a large collection rather than the opportunity cost of time consuming inventory and listing on other sales channels. The payment was a fair tradeoff of sending rares only and donating the commons and uncommons to charity so that younger players can discover the joy of playing MTG. Highly recommended for older players who have outgrown the hobby like me.
John A
Review left Mar 22 2026
Review
Was my first time selling a lot of cards online after going through a lot of my bulk loose cards. Will be using again soon to sell part of my binder collection.
Was my first time selling a lot of cards online after going through a lot of my bulk loose cards. Will be using again soon to sell part of my binder collection.
Fillmore
Review left Mar 22 2026
Review
Overall I was pleasantly surprised at how easy it was to ship a large MTG collection of rares and foils to CC. The process and website were simple and easy to understand. Pricing was decent and the report back was super easy to understand. My only issue was the time between my shipment to payment
...
Read more
Overall I was pleasantly surprised at how easy it was to ship a large MTG collection of rares and foils to CC. The process and website were simple and easy to understand. Pricing was decent and the report back was super easy to understand. My only issue was the time between my shipment to payment. It took longer than I expected, but knowing that I'll just be more prepared for next time. Really good experience over all, would use you all again!
Joshua
Review left Mar 21 2026
Review
The process was really smooth, communication is great, in less than a week I got my money for the cards. Definitely a great way to sell your old cards.
The process was really smooth, communication is great, in less than a week I got my money for the cards. Definitely a great way to sell your old cards.
Joshua Daniels
Review left Mar 21 2026
Shipment processed Mar 13 2026
$1,257.17
payout, $25.66
fees
Review
This is my second time selling cards through card conduit which show my confidence in their ability to be fair and reliable. I got 80-85% of their near mint estimate, which felt very appropriate given the play the cards had gotten. I had questions about the modifications they made to my listed cards
...
Read more
This is my second time selling cards through card conduit which show my confidence in their ability to be fair and reliable. I got 80-85% of their near mint estimate, which felt very appropriate given the play the cards had gotten. I had questions about the modifications they made to my listed cards, and they responded within a day explaining what happened and reassuring me that the cards I shipped had been accounted for correctly. Thanks for a great experience and sorry about all the "list" reprints I thought were from the original set lol.
Jonine Woods
Review left Mar 21 2026
Review
First time using Card Conduit and I would definitely use them again! The process was easy and the time to evaluate my cards was fair. Once they gave me my offer I accepted and was paid the next day! I hope someone else enjoys them as much as I did!
First time using Card Conduit and I would definitely use them again! The process was easy and the time to evaluate my cards was fair. Once they gave me my offer I accepted and was paid the next day! I hope someone else enjoys them as much as I did!
Mike
Review left Mar 21 2026
Shipment processed Mar 13 2026
$664.73
payout, $13.57
fees
Review
This was my 2nd time using CardConduit but my first time itemizing a list. Their process was super straightforward and instructions we clear and concise. I think it took less than 2 days for them to process my list and I was ecstatic at the payout amount they offered! Highly recommended to anyone and everyone!
This was my 2nd time using CardConduit but my first time itemizing a list. Their process was super straightforward and instructions we clear and concise. I think it took less than 2 days for them to process my list and I was ecstatic at the payout amount they offered! Highly recommended to anyone and everyone!
Jake
Review left Mar 20 2026
Review
Mind shipping bulk cards, otherwise fantastic service!
Shipping row boxes was a bit more complicated than expected as the standard 1600 card boxes are now longer than medium flat rate boxes at USPS. This may have been my error in purchasing the wrong row boxes. Great value since they are fulfilling buy lists for you! Would recommend!
Shipping row boxes was a bit more complicated than expected as the standard 1600 card boxes are now longer than medium flat rate boxes at USPS. This may have been my error in purchasing the wrong row boxes. Great value since they are fulfilling buy lists for you! Would recommend!
Mind shipping bulk cards, otherwise fantastic service!
Shipping row boxes was a bit more complicated than expected as the standard 1600 card boxes are now longer than medium flat rate boxes at USPS. This may have been my error in purchasing the wrong row boxes. Great value since they are fulfilling buy lists for you! Would recommend!
Shipping row boxes was a bit more complicated than expected as the standard 1600 card boxes are now longer than medium flat rate boxes at USPS. This may have been my error in purchasing the wrong row boxes. Great value since they are fulfilling buy lists for you! Would recommend!
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every
previous customer to leave a review.
Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page.
We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a
review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).