Chat with us

Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service

(217)
Sean W.
Review left Aug 17 2021
Shipment processed Aug 06 2021
$297.04 payout, $41.67 fees

Very Easy and Honest Process

Review

I feel this was the most honest and transparent process possible for getting some value for rares I didn't need and for getting rid of bulk I didn't want lying around anymore. Very good communication at all steps, very helpful info for getting started, and very fair return of money for what I sent i ... Read more
I feel this was the most honest and transparent process possible for getting some value for rares I didn't need and for getting rid of bulk I didn't want lying around anymore. Very good communication at all steps, very helpful info for getting started, and very fair return of money for what I sent in.
Joshua H.
Review left Aug 15 2021
Shipment processed Jul 10 2021
$2,682.40 payout, $333.04 fees

Simple, pretty fast, transaction

Review

I heard about them through a Youtuber a few times and since I mostly play Magic on mobile I decided to sell my cards. The service was great and the communication through email informative. I made much more than I would have trying to sell them individually.
Well done, good service!
I heard about them through a Youtuber a few times and since I mostly play Magic on mobile I decided to sell my cards. The service was great and the communication through email informative. I made much more than I would have trying to sell them individually.
Well done, good service!
Stephen M.
Review left Aug 15 2021
Shipment processed Jul 10 2021
$797.98 payout, $120.71 fees

Well handled.

Review

Easy processing and shipping. Things moved smoothly and payout was expected fair pricing amd good communication.
Easy processing and shipping. Things moved smoothly and payout was expected fair pricing amd good communication.
Eric P.
Review left Aug 14 2021
Shipment processed Jul 14 2021
$448.54 payout, $23.61 fees

Always a pleasure

Review

Fair pricing and quick payment. Makes it easy to sell cards when you just don’t have the time to grind them out. Love me some card conduit
Fair pricing and quick payment. Makes it easy to sell cards when you just don’t have the time to grind them out. Love me some card conduit
David E.
Review left Aug 11 2021
Shipment processed Aug 01 2021

Great Communication & Fair Prices

Review

I found this service great for selling off my magic collection. Their communication was top notch and their assessments of value quite fair. I'd certainly recommend using them.
I found this service great for selling off my magic collection. Their communication was top notch and their assessments of value quite fair. I'd certainly recommend using them.
David E.
Review left Aug 11 2021
Shipment processed Aug 01 2021

Great Communication & Fair Prices

Review

I found this service great for selling off my magic collection. Their communication was top notch and their assessments of value quite fair. I'd certainly recommend using them.
I found this service great for selling off my magic collection. Their communication was top notch and their assessments of value quite fair. I'd certainly recommend using them.
David E.
Review left Aug 11 2021
Shipment processed Aug 01 2021

Great Communication and Fair Prices

Review

I found this service great for selling off my magic collection. Their communication was top notch and their assessments of value quite fair. I'd certainly recommend using them.
I found this service great for selling off my magic collection. Their communication was top notch and their assessments of value quite fair. I'd certainly recommend using them.
Garrett
Review left Aug 11 2021
Shipment processed Jul 17 2021
$420.82 payout, $261.19 fees

Money for a crate full of cards

Review

The process was really easy. I sorted a crate full of mostly bulk, got rid of most of the commons, but sent everything else and got some good money back. Will use again.
The process was really easy. I sorted a crate full of mostly bulk, got rid of most of the commons, but sent everything else and got some good money back. Will use again.
Sam N.
Review left Aug 10 2021
Shipment processed Jul 30 2021
$170.40 payout, $91.90 fees

Exact Service I Was Seeking

Review

I needed to downsize my collection a bit to gear up for the DnD set, I would have gone to my LGS but I didn't want to haggle or pick through the value of each card. This service is easy and carefree and will come back and use it too.
I needed to downsize my collection a bit to gear up for the DnD set, I would have gone to my LGS but I didn't want to haggle or pick through the value of each card. This service is easy and carefree and will come back and use it too.
Steven M.
Review left Aug 10 2021
Shipment processed Jun 11 2021
$15,845.23 payout, $833.96 fees

Completely satisfied and pleasantly surprised.

Review

If you have Magic cards lying around collecting dust, I highly recommend Nick and the folks at Card Conduit to take care of you. They were professional, informative, and kept in constant communication with me at all times. I plan on doing business with them again in the future.
Keep up the great ... Read more
If you have Magic cards lying around collecting dust, I highly recommend Nick and the folks at Card Conduit to take care of you. They were professional, informative, and kept in constant communication with me at all times. I plan on doing business with them again in the future.
Keep up the great work guys!
Summer W
Review left Aug 10 2021
Shipment processed Jun 13 2021

Simple and easy

Review

Every shipment has been so easy to not have to fret about selling every card or how much should I sell for. I can just send them in and have them processed and be done. No worries not stress.
Every shipment has been so easy to not have to fret about selling every card or how much should I sell for. I can just send them in and have them processed and be done. No worries not stress.
Chris M.
Review left Aug 08 2021
Shipment processed Jul 27 2021
$441.92 payout, $20.83 fees

Service was easy, prompt and worked well

Review

Card Conduit did a good job of presenting the timelines that are involved, and then communicating what the result of the cards I sent in was, and why some of them were graded the way that they were. I appreciated the high level of communication. I would use the platform again in the future if the ... Read more
Card Conduit did a good job of presenting the timelines that are involved, and then communicating what the result of the cards I sent in was, and why some of them were graded the way that they were. I appreciated the high level of communication. I would use the platform again in the future if the situation comes up.
Katherine S.
Review left Aug 04 2021
Shipment processed Jul 31 2021
$11.71 payout, $10.53 fees

Met My Needs / Exceeded My Expectations

Review

Card Conduit does what they say they are going to do.
Card Conduit does what they say they are going to do.
Tyler Fife
Review left Aug 02 2021
Shipment processed Jun 28 2021
$564.63 payout, $105.63 fees

Simple and easy way to sell cards

Review

The process was easy and got a better amount than I would trying to sell cards individually by myself.
The process was easy and got a better amount than I would trying to sell cards individually by myself.
Katherine S.
Review left Aug 01 2021
Shipment processed Jul 28 2021
$14.25 payout, $2.73 fees

Met My Needs / Exceeded My Expectations

Review

Card Conduit does what they say they are going to do.
Card Conduit does what they say they are going to do.
Steven
Review left Jul 30 2021
Shipment processed Jul 22 2021
$312.32 payout, $14.71 fees

Great Experience. First time user. Very Happy

Review

I didn't do anything besides send them the cards. I got the money directly into my account via zelle. The ease of use is the real selling point here.
My one critic would be that cards over 20 $ were tough on the grading and percentage of price they were sold for. Without doing any of the work ... Read more
I didn't do anything besides send them the cards. I got the money directly into my account via zelle. The ease of use is the real selling point here.
My one critic would be that cards over 20 $ were tough on the grading and percentage of price they were sold for. Without doing any of the work selling, its difficult to complain. Next time I use Conduit I am going to double check the prices with the price check interface.
Andrew J
Review left Jul 29 2021
Shipment processed Jun 13 2021
$140.96 payout, $29.83 fees

Really Good Service and Continues to Get Better

Review

This service continues to improve in its speed and turn around times. I play draft style tournaments with a small group of friends. Card Conduit in combination with these draft game nights is an amazing combination. We often find enough cards to make a significant dent in the cost of buying an entir ... Read more
This service continues to improve in its speed and turn around times. I play draft style tournaments with a small group of friends. Card Conduit in combination with these draft game nights is an amazing combination. We often find enough cards to make a significant dent in the cost of buying an entire booster box. I am giving them a 5 out of 5 this time around because they seem to continue to improve. Based on the pricing structure, it's a little difficult to sort out whether it makes sense to exclude uncommons or to include them.

A tiny suggestion would be that if a customer opts to pay for processing for uncommons, it would be amazing (above and beyond really) to include the theoretical price if we chose to exclude those cards. I think I can sort it from the CSV, but I'm not sure I know what all the column labels mean. Of course I wouldn't expect a comparison price if I opted not to pay to process my uncommons. Still, keep up the good work and I will keep send cards.
Alan Seabaugh
Review left Jul 29 2021
Shipment processed May 27 2021
$346.35 payout, $57.16 fees

Professional and reasonable

Review

This is a great service for people who like the idea of getting their unused cards back into circulation. The cards were evaluated within about 2 weeks and the return from Card Conduit was good. Card lists were provided and it was fun to see the value of each card sold.
This is a great service for people who like the idea of getting their unused cards back into circulation. The cards were evaluated within about 2 weeks and the return from Card Conduit was good. Card lists were provided and it was fun to see the value of each card sold.
William Ferola
Review left Jul 28 2021
Shipment processed Jun 24 2021
$95.52 payout, $10.39 fees

Quick painless and surprised by outcome amount

Review

Super simple to do, the turnaround time from shipping my cards til I got the check was shorter than expected and got more back than I anticipated.
Super simple to do, the turnaround time from shipping my cards til I got the check was shorter than expected and got more back than I anticipated.
Twoshotsnokills
Review left Jul 27 2021
Shipment processed Jul 14 2021
$584.22 payout, $30.75 fees

Exactly as described!

Review

I was a bit of a skeptic with it being my first time selling cards like this but turns out sorting my cards out was the hardest part. Once they were in the mail CC kept me updated and got my payout in less than two weeks. It took like 9 days for a curated shipment but mainly due to me shipping it on ... Read more
I was a bit of a skeptic with it being my first time selling cards like this but turns out sorting my cards out was the hardest part. Once they were in the mail CC kept me updated and got my payout in less than two weeks. It took like 9 days for a curated shipment but mainly due to me shipping it on a Thursday and then receiving it on a Saturday. I am satisfied and already working on my next shipment ^_^
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every previous customer to leave a review. Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page. We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).