Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service
(4237)
Michael
Review left Mar 14 2025
Review
Overall the process was very fast and easy! Definitely would recommend card conduit to anyone trying to sell some cards.
Overall the process was very fast and easy! Definitely would recommend card conduit to anyone trying to sell some cards.
John Pacey
Review left Mar 13 2025
Review
Sent my cards in, they graded them and paid me, the entire process was incredibly easy.
Sent my cards in, they graded them and paid me, the entire process was incredibly easy.
Lindsey Melville Burrell
Review left Mar 13 2025
Review
A simple streamlined process for selling unwanted portions of your collection. Highly recommended!
A simple streamlined process for selling unwanted portions of your collection. Highly recommended!
Dick Powis
Review left Mar 13 2025
Review
The first time is a little confusing, but CC makes it pretty easy to just follow the instructions. I sent it in, they provided a readout of what I sent, and then cut me a check. Doesn't get easier.
The first time is a little confusing, but CC makes it pretty easy to just follow the instructions. I sent it in, they provided a readout of what I sent, and then cut me a check. Doesn't get easier.
Elizabeth Phipps
Review left Mar 13 2025
Review
This process is so easy and the payouts are so fair - I tell all my MTG friends about Card Conduit. This is legit & worth the time it saves me!
This process is so easy and the payouts are so fair - I tell all my MTG friends about Card Conduit. This is legit & worth the time it saves me!
Jared Slate
Review left Mar 13 2025
Review
This service is always an easy solution to selling bulk with minimum effort. I like being able to fill a box and ship it out and know I will get a fair value for my cards.
This service is always an easy solution to selling bulk with minimum effort. I like being able to fill a box and ship it out and know I will get a fair value for my cards.
Matt
Review left Mar 12 2025
Review
I was skeptical at first after reading some reviews of the process. But I figured I’d sort what I had and sent it in and take what they offered. I knew most of my cards were in NM condition and was happy too see CardConduit reciprocated my observations. Process took a little over a week and they w
...
Read more
I was skeptical at first after reading some reviews of the process. But I figured I’d sort what I had and sent it in and take what they offered. I knew most of my cards were in NM condition and was happy too see CardConduit reciprocated my observations. Process took a little over a week and they were communicative the whole time. Would recommend this to anyone who has a collection sitting about and needs a couple coins.
Patrick Holley
Review left Mar 12 2025
Review
Not my first time using this service, probably not my last either. Card Conduit makes it super easy, barely an inconvenience!
Not my first time using this service, probably not my last either. Card Conduit makes it super easy, barely an inconvenience!
Hagen Goldwin
Review left Mar 12 2025
Review
The process was timely and efficient, I am likely to use it again in the future and recommend it to others.
The process was timely and efficient, I am likely to use it again in the future and recommend it to others.
Wes Heymann
Review left Mar 11 2025
Review
The process was quick and easy. Communication was exceptional throughout the process. Highly recommend Cardconduit!
The process was quick and easy. Communication was exceptional throughout the process. Highly recommend Cardconduit!
Jeremy
Review left Mar 11 2025
Review
The process was easy if you follow their instructions; I did have to pay for a special box to ship, and shipping costs are high right now, so that ate into the profit a little bit. They do tend to undergrade cards in my opinion, and don't always give what you may think of as the best price out there
...
Read more
The process was easy if you follow their instructions; I did have to pay for a special box to ship, and shipping costs are high right now, so that ate into the profit a little bit. They do tend to undergrade cards in my opinion, and don't always give what you may think of as the best price out there, but overall it was fine if you don't want to bring them into an LGS. I would say it was a little better than what I would get from an LGS, but far less than if I had used ebay. However, for convenience and my time, it easily beats ebay or selling individually. I think curated is the way to go. your mileage will certainly vary. If I could sum it up in a few words: Not the best prices, but hard to beat on convenience.
Joe
Review left Mar 11 2025
Shipment processed Feb 27 2025
Review
Excellent communication and customer service, have used several times and would use again!
Excellent communication and customer service, have used several times and would use again!
Marc M.
Review left Mar 11 2025
Review
Process was hassle free and they were transparent about the process and results.
I have already started another shipment and will continue to do so.
Thanks!
I have already started another shipment and will continue to do so.
Thanks!
Process was hassle free and they were transparent about the process and results.
I have already started another shipment and will continue to do so.
Thanks!
I have already started another shipment and will continue to do so.
Thanks!
Peter Nguyen
Review left Mar 11 2025
Review
Card Conduit is incredible. I was nervous about releasing such a valuable collection with them but the amount of detail they provided on the process gave me a lot of confidence and ease. Thank you so much for the great experience.
Card Conduit is incredible. I was nervous about releasing such a valuable collection with them but the amount of detail they provided on the process gave me a lot of confidence and ease. Thank you so much for the great experience.
Kelly
Review left Mar 10 2025
Review
Super easy process. They gobble up cards quick and pay better than a card shop would. The grading is interesting though. Some cards that were direct from pack were given MP grades where cards that definitely were MP got LP or NM. It seems this is an area where they are getting a lot of feedback they
...
Read more
Super easy process. They gobble up cards quick and pay better than a card shop would. The grading is interesting though. Some cards that were direct from pack were given MP grades where cards that definitely were MP got LP or NM. It seems this is an area where they are getting a lot of feedback they may want to pay more attention to. I got almost exactly what I was expecting so can't complain too much.
Ceasar649
Review left Mar 09 2025
Review
Great process overall, very easy to use and supper communicative throughout the process. Will definitely use again if I need to sell more cards.
Great process overall, very easy to use and supper communicative throughout the process. Will definitely use again if I need to sell more cards.
David Ding
Review left Mar 09 2025
Review
Process was done smoothly and I received my payouts in a timely manner.
Process was done smoothly and I received my payouts in a timely manner.
Stéphane Fournier
Review left Mar 09 2025
Review
What a simple and effective way to offload my cards. Loved the service and quick turnaround. Highly recommended!
What a simple and effective way to offload my cards. Loved the service and quick turnaround. Highly recommended!
Sean
Review left Mar 09 2025
Review
Was 100% worried about sending cards off but process is really transparent and quick. Pricing was fair, I had no complaints and you get a list of reasons on any conditions. I had some issues with payment but it was taken care of immediately and directly with a person. Ill be doing a few more shipments with them soon.
Was 100% worried about sending cards off but process is really transparent and quick. Pricing was fair, I had no complaints and you get a list of reasons on any conditions. I had some issues with payment but it was taken care of immediately and directly with a person. Ill be doing a few more shipments with them soon.
Erik Fendenheim
Review left Mar 08 2025
Review
This has been an excellent experience. I have sent two shipments so far and the whole process is quick. The itemized report they send is impressive. My favorite feature is the highlights report they send. It shows you your most valuable cards and what they offered for them. This service is exactly what I was looking for to help manage my collection.
This has been an excellent experience. I have sent two shipments so far and the whole process is quick. The itemized report they send is impressive. My favorite feature is the highlights report they send. It shows you your most valuable cards and what they offered for them. This service is exactly what I was looking for to help manage my collection.
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every
previous customer to leave a review.
Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page.
We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a
review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).