Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service
(6840)
Jaime
Review left Oct 24 2026
Review
Recently sold a portion of my collection through card conduit. They are fast and professional, but I do urge you to not over estimate your collection. They are in the market to make money as well. I would equate it to trading in at GameStop, you'll never get market value, but they are convenient, qu
...
Read more
Recently sold a portion of my collection through card conduit. They are fast and professional, but I do urge you to not over estimate your collection. They are in the market to make money as well. I would equate it to trading in at GameStop, you'll never get market value, but they are convenient, quick, and will pay for your collection. That convenience was worth it for me and the whole process took about 7 business days from start to payment hitting my bank. Would recommend!
Brently
Review left Oct 24 2026
Review
Card Conduit made everything really easy. They offer multiple options for how to send your cards in. I went with curated, which involved me using their card value tool to determine what they would pay for each card. But you don't have to put any energy at all into the situation. You can just send al
...
Read more
Card Conduit made everything really easy. They offer multiple options for how to send your cards in. I went with curated, which involved me using their card value tool to determine what they would pay for each card. But you don't have to put any energy at all into the situation. You can just send all the cards you want in and let them figure it out, but you'll pay them a bit more for doing so. I think their card condition evaluation is stricter than most. That can be a bad thing for your overall payout. But as a positive, I buy cards from them a lot already, and they actually do send near mint cards when the condition is supposed to near mint. Most large sellers like this tend to send lightly played cards instead or worse. And sticking to stricter grading is a reason I continue to buy from them.
Carlos Quintero
Review left Oct 24 2026
Shipment processed Oct 10 2026
Review
Easy process and was kept informed of every step of the way. I would use the service again in the future.
Easy process and was kept informed of every step of the way. I would use the service again in the future.
Tyler Wilson
Review left Oct 24 2026
Review
Process was relatively easy. Wish there was more transparency on what the payment for cards would be. Like an estimate before shipping. I may have missed that feature though. All and all a good experience
Process was relatively easy. Wish there was more transparency on what the payment for cards would be. Like an estimate before shipping. I may have missed that feature though. All and all a good experience
Michael
Review left Oct 23 2026
Shipment processed Oct 14 2026
Review
Everything was very quick and painless. Payout was more-or-less what I was expecting. If I need to sell cards again I’ll likely use this service.
Everything was very quick and painless. Payout was more-or-less what I was expecting. If I need to sell cards again I’ll likely use this service.
Ryan Keating
Review left Oct 23 2026
Shipment processed Oct 14 2026
Review
Highly recommend using card conduit for selling cards
Highly recommend using card conduit for selling cards
Patrick Nol
Review left Oct 23 2026
Review
The team quickly cataloged my cards, graded them, and got me the list and prices. They responded promptly to my only question. I will continue to use their services!!
The team quickly cataloged my cards, graded them, and got me the list and prices. They responded promptly to my only question. I will continue to use their services!!
Paul B
Review left Oct 23 2026
Shipment processed Oct 14 2026
Review
The process was fairly quick and easy. Sort foils out and separate. Take sleeves off. My only gripe is that communication was a bit slow. When dealing with high value deals you want good support. I would recommend the service for someone who has an untracked collection.
The process was fairly quick and easy. Sort foils out and separate. Take sleeves off. My only gripe is that communication was a bit slow. When dealing with high value deals you want good support. I would recommend the service for someone who has an untracked collection.
Jeremy Cooper
Review left Oct 23 2026
Review
Card Conduit offers the best value for selling a collection. Their process and instructions are straight forward. They offer many ways to maximize your earnings through one's own work to sort and/or catalog the collection before sending it. Or they will let you just ship them bulk and let them figur
...
Read more
Card Conduit offers the best value for selling a collection. Their process and instructions are straight forward. They offer many ways to maximize your earnings through one's own work to sort and/or catalog the collection before sending it. Or they will let you just ship them bulk and let them figure it out. I have used Card Conduit before, and I keep coming back for the one stop shop of it all. One logistical issue, is that they do require shipping and processing time, so it is not instant. Be prepared to wait up to a few weeks depending on what you are doing. If you want something fast, your best bet is your local LGS. But if you want top dollar, and a single smooth process, Card Conduit can't be beat!
Sal
Review left Oct 23 2026
Review
Great service for getting money back for cards you're not using or trading. Get 4 400 count boxes, put them in a flat rate medium USPS box and see your payout in a few weeks.
Great service for getting money back for cards you're not using or trading. Get 4 400 count boxes, put them in a flat rate medium USPS box and see your payout in a few weeks.
Michael Witting
Review left Oct 22 2026
Review
I have my cards in set boxes. The review page was simple enough to find the cards over $.5 and find the bulk rates in my sideboard for commander decks to add to the list
I have my cards in set boxes. The review page was simple enough to find the cards over $.5 and find the bulk rates in my sideboard for commander decks to add to the list
Tim
Review left Oct 22 2026
Review
I’ve used Card Conduit on multiple occasions, amounting to many thousands of dollars. It’s always been stress free, accurate, and and easy process. I highly recommend this service and the modularity they provide on how to sell your collection.
I’ve used Card Conduit on multiple occasions, amounting to many thousands of dollars. It’s always been stress free, accurate, and and easy process. I highly recommend this service and the modularity they provide on how to sell your collection.
David G
Review left Oct 22 2026
Review
The process is very straightforward and easy. The shipment was me getting rid of bulk rares and foils that I was tired of storing, along with random bulk to fill the box. I received more money that I was expecting and I feel that grading was fair
The process is very straightforward and easy. The shipment was me getting rid of bulk rares and foils that I was tired of storing, along with random bulk to fill the box. I received more money that I was expecting and I feel that grading was fair
Michael Cardona
Review left Oct 22 2026
Review
Used this method of selling multiple times, no issues, always a quick and easy process.
Used this method of selling multiple times, no issues, always a quick and easy process.
Michael Cardona
Review left Oct 22 2026
Review
Great value with fast payments. Beats selling individually on others sites for sure.
Great value with fast payments. Beats selling individually on others sites for sure.
Loren Carlos
Review left Oct 21 2026
Review
Sent in my cards back in APR of 2026 and got word back fairly quickly. Although not packaged correctly, CC responded quickly about the process and what options I have. I saw the shipment and how things were rated. I was happy with how fairly my cards were paid out for. Will be sending another box TODAY!
Sent in my cards back in APR of 2026 and got word back fairly quickly. Although not packaged correctly, CC responded quickly about the process and what options I have. I saw the shipment and how things were rated. I was happy with how fairly my cards were paid out for. Will be sending another box TODAY!
Ryan Mallory
Review left Oct 21 2026
Review
I had a great experience with the team and they responded in a very timely manner and were very pleasant through the whole process and it was pretty fast
I had a great experience with the team and they responded in a very timely manner and were very pleasant through the whole process and it was pretty fast
Great service and amazing communication
Review left Oct 21 2026
Review
Very easy process with a great result. I had heard about Card Conduit from MTG Goldfish but never tried it until now. The process was very easy to start, with great guides to get you going. Once the cards were shipped, there was clear communication about where the cards were and how they were graded
...
Read more
Very easy process with a great result. I had heard about Card Conduit from MTG Goldfish but never tried it until now. The process was very easy to start, with great guides to get you going. Once the cards were shipped, there was clear communication about where the cards were and how they were graded. I felt informed throughout the whole process and I would be happy to use this service again!
Regan Buonadonna
Review left Oct 20 2026
Review
USPS totally screwed up my shipment and all of the cards flew out of the box. I was contacted immediately and asked whether I wanted to proceed (with a slightly extra fee) or have them return the cards. We chose to proceed, and it took a little longer than it was originally supposed to, because of t
...
Read more
USPS totally screwed up my shipment and all of the cards flew out of the box. I was contacted immediately and asked whether I wanted to proceed (with a slightly extra fee) or have them return the cards. We chose to proceed, and it took a little longer than it was originally supposed to, because of the cards that were all messed up, but they were really good at communicating that from the start. Payout was a little lower than my husband expected, but right about where I thought it would be. Either way, we believe that it was a fair amount and we would definitely go with Card Conduit again.
Paul Menze
Review left Oct 20 2026
Review
First time selling cards, smooth as silk. I'd recommend this to everyone trying to get rid of individual cards worth $2-$30.
First time selling cards, smooth as silk. I'd recommend this to everyone trying to get rid of individual cards worth $2-$30.
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every
previous customer to leave a review.
Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page.
We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a
review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).