Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service
(6073)
Andrew Bower
Review left May 13 2026
Review
Process painless from start to finish, some things got jumbled up on my end and they were more than accommodating.
Process painless from start to finish, some things got jumbled up on my end and they were more than accommodating.
Cheeselueez
Review left May 13 2026
Review
They were a day early! Can’t beat that by any standards! The fact that they’re willing to take over 40,000 cards and great them within two weeks is kind of magnificent!
Shout out to y’all! Keep being great business entrepreneurs. This is what makes America a great place.
Shout out to y’all! Keep being great business entrepreneurs. This is what makes America a great place.
They were a day early! Can’t beat that by any standards! The fact that they’re willing to take over 40,000 cards and great them within two weeks is kind of magnificent!
Shout out to y’all! Keep being great business entrepreneurs. This is what makes America a great place.
Shout out to y’all! Keep being great business entrepreneurs. This is what makes America a great place.
Joe Young
Review left May 12 2026
Review
This is my 3rd time selling through card conduit. They are very fair with their condition assessment, give a better buy list price than practically any local game store ever would, and pay out quickly. The fees are also fair - the more work you put in as a seller to organize and sort your cards prio
...
Read more
This is my 3rd time selling through card conduit. They are very fair with their condition assessment, give a better buy list price than practically any local game store ever would, and pay out quickly. The fees are also fair - the more work you put in as a seller to organize and sort your cards prior to shipping, the more money you get to keep. Can’t recommend this service enough!
Wiley
Review left May 12 2026
Review
better than card kingdom, very honest about what theyre giving you in relation to other options
better than card kingdom, very honest about what theyre giving you in relation to other options
Nickolas Vicente
Review left May 12 2026
Review
The system and methods Card Conduit uses for MTG buylists is the best it gets, easy step by step process and no need to reach out for updates. They even caught a fake card I had been ignorantly using for years, that the LGS I bought it from didn't catch.
The system and methods Card Conduit uses for MTG buylists is the best it gets, easy step by step process and no need to reach out for updates. They even caught a fake card I had been ignorantly using for years, that the LGS I bought it from didn't catch.
Ciran Miller
Review left May 11 2026
Review
Very quick processing. Cards were graded fairly. Payment was issued in a timely manner.
Very quick processing. Cards were graded fairly. Payment was issued in a timely manner.
Edward Stuart
Review left May 11 2026
Shipment processed Apr 29 2026
Review
After extensively reading the prep for bulk sell it took me about a week for de-sleeving and sorting my cards. Then the question of how am I going to send 4k+ cards without spending an arm and a leg and still keeping the integrity of the cards. But after talking to different shipping companies and b
...
Read more
After extensively reading the prep for bulk sell it took me about a week for de-sleeving and sorting my cards. Then the question of how am I going to send 4k+ cards without spending an arm and a leg and still keeping the integrity of the cards. But after talking to different shipping companies and buying specific card boxes to fit the cards it was done and it was just sit back and wait for the team to sort and give me my results. It was almost 3 weeks before I got my order results and it was simply accept or deny. Very easy, payment came in a few days following and I am 4k cards lighter in my collection! Thank You.
Austin Hopkins
Review left May 11 2026
Shipment processed Apr 30 2026
Review
Everything was streamlined. CSV upload made it very easy. I exported my collections out of Manabox, then submitted the CSV to the Collection Estimate tool. Then from there started a sorted service. Recommend for anyone like me who has thousands of low value cards and not enough time to sell them off
...
Read more
Everything was streamlined. CSV upload made it very easy. I exported my collections out of Manabox, then submitted the CSV to the Collection Estimate tool. Then from there started a sorted service. Recommend for anyone like me who has thousands of low value cards and not enough time to sell them off individually. Will be continuing using the service as much as I can. Funds I received were fair based on the variables provided. At the end of the day, it was money for cards sitting around collecting dust not being played.
Alan O
Review left May 11 2026
Shipment processed May 01 2026
Review
The process was very easy. Their search feature for finding buylist cards is easier to use than any other site. Being able to send in so many cards at once was great, and their communication is fantastic. They are VERY tight graders on the cards, but I get that they need to make sure their grading i
...
Read more
The process was very easy. Their search feature for finding buylist cards is easier to use than any other site. Being able to send in so many cards at once was great, and their communication is fantastic. They are VERY tight graders on the cards, but I get that they need to make sure their grading is at least as strict as whoever they are selling them to. But I was surprised at how many cards they graded as MP in the order. Still, a very good experience, and I would use them again without hesitation.
amazing
Review left May 11 2026
Review
great prices, great communication, will always sell too
great prices, great communication, will always sell too
Greg M.
Review left May 10 2026
Review
The instructions throughout the process were easy to follow to ensure safe arrival and grading of the shipment. Support from CardConduit was consistent and supportive from the start. My only reason for not giving a 5 would be the value returned for my shipment... There were an exorbitant amount of c
...
Read more
The instructions throughout the process were easy to follow to ensure safe arrival and grading of the shipment. Support from CardConduit was consistent and supportive from the start. My only reason for not giving a 5 would be the value returned for my shipment... There were an exorbitant amount of cards graded below what I considered their true condition - a convenient and uncontestable way to pay less to the customer (eyebrow raise...). Otherwise, I have no complaints, and thank CardConduit for their business.
Dereke Lawson
Review left May 10 2026
Review
The entire process was well guided, relatively fast, and I'm happy with the grading and offered prices for my cards.
The entire process was well guided, relatively fast, and I'm happy with the grading and offered prices for my cards.
Zac A.
Review left May 10 2026
Review
Howdy y'all, wanted to chip in my 2 cents. I'd been looking for somewhere to get rid of my lil 8-9k card collection I'd been building since like, 2018? Been enjoying magic, but I'm switching over to proxies and a small group of friends to play personally with, so I didn't really need my physical car
...
Read more
Howdy y'all, wanted to chip in my 2 cents. I'd been looking for somewhere to get rid of my lil 8-9k card collection I'd been building since like, 2018? Been enjoying magic, but I'm switching over to proxies and a small group of friends to play personally with, so I didn't really need my physical cards anymore. Went through some of my more expensive ones for this first order and they were fair with grading, quick about getting them processed once they arrived, and got me paid out the day after I confirmed I read their report. Total between this finished order and a pending auto-sift order, I've had like 4 different people reach out to me so they seem like a very cohesive team. Overall great experience
Gregory Bastidas
Review left May 10 2026
Review
The whole process with Card Conduit was extremely smooth. Everything was laid out properly from start to finish. Everything was thoroughly checked and the timeline they had was spot on. They had notified everything about my shipment from the moment it arrived to the moment that they priced everythin
...
Read more
The whole process with Card Conduit was extremely smooth. Everything was laid out properly from start to finish. Everything was thoroughly checked and the timeline they had was spot on. They had notified everything about my shipment from the moment it arrived to the moment that they priced everything out. After they completely the shipment, they also gave a summary of the overall condition of the cards. It felt like a very personalized experience. I was recommended this website and I would like to recommend it to whoever else wants to sell their bulk since I rather make some actual money from it instead of having it rot in my closet.
Johnny C
Review left May 10 2026
Review
Card conduit’s easy to understand online process made selecting the cards I was trying to sell a breeze! Fair pricing for the condition my cards were in made sure I received the value that my cards were worth, and helped me pay the bills without the hassle of trying to locate local card shops. All
...
Read more
Card conduit’s easy to understand online process made selecting the cards I was trying to sell a breeze! Fair pricing for the condition my cards were in made sure I received the value that my cards were worth, and helped me pay the bills without the hassle of trying to locate local card shops. All in all a pleasant experience, and I would recommend to anybody with plenty of extra Magic cards lying around!
Nicholas Ely
Review left May 10 2026
Review
Little low on the high end foil
Assessment. It was my choice to take the payout and I did so. That being said, the process is quick , the staff communicates very well! Pay outs are super fast.
Assessment. It was my choice to take the payout and I did so. That being said, the process is quick , the staff communicates very well! Pay outs are super fast.
Little low on the high end foil
Assessment. It was my choice to take the payout and I did so. That being said, the process is quick , the staff communicates very well! Pay outs are super fast.
Assessment. It was my choice to take the payout and I did so. That being said, the process is quick , the staff communicates very well! Pay outs are super fast.
Duoc
Review left May 10 2026
Review
The process was easy. Separating cards based on value was a bit tricky when doing bulk but wasn't too bad to get better returns.
The process was easy. Separating cards based on value was a bit tricky when doing bulk but wasn't too bad to get better returns.
Josh Wade
Review left May 09 2026
Review
(note: this review is copied from my review of AF27-BJ. This shipment was sent in a bundle with it, along with AF27-5L)
I had gotten a lot of recommendations for Card Conduit from many different places, and CC did not disappoint. It was about 2 weeks between sending my shipment and receiving paymen ... Read more
I had gotten a lot of recommendations for Card Conduit from many different places, and CC did not disappoint. It was about 2 weeks between sending my shipment and receiving paymen ... Read more
(note: this review is copied from my review of AF27-BJ. This shipment was sent in a bundle with it, along with AF27-5L)
I had gotten a lot of recommendations for Card Conduit from many different places, and CC did not disappoint. It was about 2 weeks between sending my shipment and receiving payment, and I got full transparency throughout the process. At the end of the process, I got a thorough analysis of the cards I had sent with comprehensive breakdowns on the prices, conditions, and overall statistics. I'm happy with the value that I got - though if I weren't, the shipment was under a 48 hour hold and ready to be returned. Looking forward to using this service again the next time I need to cash in some cardboard.
I had gotten a lot of recommendations for Card Conduit from many different places, and CC did not disappoint. It was about 2 weeks between sending my shipment and receiving payment, and I got full transparency throughout the process. At the end of the process, I got a thorough analysis of the cards I had sent with comprehensive breakdowns on the prices, conditions, and overall statistics. I'm happy with the value that I got - though if I weren't, the shipment was under a 48 hour hold and ready to be returned. Looking forward to using this service again the next time I need to cash in some cardboard.
Josh Wade
Review left May 09 2026
Review
(note: this review is copied from my review of AF27-BJ. This shipment was sent in a bundle with it, along with AF27-EZ)
I had gotten a lot of recommendations for Card Conduit from many different places, and CC did not disappoint. It was about 2 weeks between sending my shipment and receiving paymen ... Read more
I had gotten a lot of recommendations for Card Conduit from many different places, and CC did not disappoint. It was about 2 weeks between sending my shipment and receiving paymen ... Read more
(note: this review is copied from my review of AF27-BJ. This shipment was sent in a bundle with it, along with AF27-EZ)
I had gotten a lot of recommendations for Card Conduit from many different places, and CC did not disappoint. It was about 2 weeks between sending my shipment and receiving payment, and I got full transparency throughout the process. At the end of the process, I got a thorough analysis of the cards I had sent with comprehensive breakdowns on the prices, conditions, and overall statistics. I'm happy with the value that I got - though if I weren't, the shipment was under a 48 hour hold and ready to be returned. Looking forward to using this service again the next time I need to cash in some cardboard.
I had gotten a lot of recommendations for Card Conduit from many different places, and CC did not disappoint. It was about 2 weeks between sending my shipment and receiving payment, and I got full transparency throughout the process. At the end of the process, I got a thorough analysis of the cards I had sent with comprehensive breakdowns on the prices, conditions, and overall statistics. I'm happy with the value that I got - though if I weren't, the shipment was under a 48 hour hold and ready to be returned. Looking forward to using this service again the next time I need to cash in some cardboard.
Enrique Iniguez
Review left May 09 2026
Review
Shipment and processing went super quick as well as processing the shipment and payment distribution once it was received. Would highly recommend
Shipment and processing went super quick as well as processing the shipment and payment distribution once it was received. Would highly recommend
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every
previous customer to leave a review.
Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page.
We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a
review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).