Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service
(5627)
Avery
Review left Feb 10 2026
Review
Easy process and payout ax always. Great service for mtg playerz
Easy process and payout ax always. Great service for mtg playerz
Fimafeng
Review left Feb 10 2026
Review
I was expecting to have to request cards be shipped back, but was happy to see that even the worst among them (Ulamog--what happened to you!?) was able to get a fair price.
I was expecting to have to request cards be shipped back, but was happy to see that even the worst among them (Ulamog--what happened to you!?) was able to get a fair price.
Joseph Wang
Review left Feb 09 2026
Review
Professional service with fair prices and fast turnaround. Communication was clear, payment was prompt, and the whole process was hassle-free. Exactly what I was looking for. Highly recommend for anyone looking to sell their collection efficiently.
Professional service with fair prices and fast turnaround. Communication was clear, payment was prompt, and the whole process was hassle-free. Exactly what I was looking for. Highly recommend for anyone looking to sell their collection efficiently.
Sean
Review left Feb 09 2026
Review
Rather than deal with the secondary market directly for many of my most valuable MTG cards, I chose to sell through Card Conduit again. Yes, there is the singular obvious drawback of likely not getting 'full' market value for your card. However, not needing to compete with other sellers, wait for an
...
Read more
Rather than deal with the secondary market directly for many of my most valuable MTG cards, I chose to sell through Card Conduit again. Yes, there is the singular obvious drawback of likely not getting 'full' market value for your card. However, not needing to compete with other sellers, wait for an expensive card to maybe get sold, and knowing that Card Conduit is doing everything they can to ensure I get as much as I can while they can still operate their business is worth the lost cost. I had 100 cards that were market valued NM at around 2000, and I got 1750 from Card Conduit. I didn't need to wait for buyers to be interested, I didn't need to ship cards individually, I didn't need to deal with 'lost in mail' or other buyer complaints or issues. I got a good deal without any of the hassle. What's not to like.
T. Schmidt
Review left Feb 09 2026
Review
My brother and I use Card Conduit for our cards. Even though im was leary of sending cards to a company without a guarantee of the amount I would get for them. Ive only sent in fresh pulls that were sleeved and hard cased . Nick and his team have judged each accurately. And I was able to get a solid
...
Read more
My brother and I use Card Conduit for our cards. Even though im was leary of sending cards to a company without a guarantee of the amount I would get for them. Ive only sent in fresh pulls that were sleeved and hard cased . Nick and his team have judged each accurately. And I was able to get a solid price for my cards that offer a higher % rate for my cards than any competitors company such as fb ebay etc I have agreed to share my info so everyone knows that im a real person and not a company marketing director or a AI computer system. Also my grammar cant be faked haha. Thanks again Nick . ☆☆☆☆☆
Sebastian
Review left Feb 09 2026
Review
The process is extremely easy. They are always fair.
The process is extremely easy. They are always fair.
Ryan C
Review left Feb 08 2026
Shipment processed Jan 06 2026
Review
with the customer service, and the price point as well as the quote on how much i am gettting back, i would have to say that i will be selling only to card conduit moving forward.
with the customer service, and the price point as well as the quote on how much i am gettting back, i would have to say that i will be selling only to card conduit moving forward.
Jon
Review left Feb 08 2026
Shipment processed Jan 06 2026
Review
Super easy and good value, fair pricing and the entire process was made super smooth with the ability to follow your cards theough each step of the process. Would definitely use again
Super easy and good value, fair pricing and the entire process was made super smooth with the ability to follow your cards theough each step of the process. Would definitely use again
Phoenix Wachob
Review left Feb 08 2026
Review
It is a nice and easy process that makes selling cards easy. Feels good!
It is a nice and easy process that makes selling cards easy. Feels good!
Brandon Budenz
Review left Feb 08 2026
Review
I sent a shipment in and at least two-thirds of the cards were near mint. I was given the 'lightly played' rate for the whole batch of cards that had never been played.
I sent a shipment in and at least two-thirds of the cards were near mint. I was given the 'lightly played' rate for the whole batch of cards that had never been played.
Jordan
Review left Feb 08 2026
Review
Was also pleasantly surprised to receive communication from the Card Conduit team themselves when they appraised my cards. Their appraisals were accurate and very detailed. Will definitely be using their services again!
Was also pleasantly surprised to receive communication from the Card Conduit team themselves when they appraised my cards. Their appraisals were accurate and very detailed. Will definitely be using their services again!
Nick
Review left Feb 07 2026
Review
Overall, I like the ease of the process and overall its very easy and the prices are okay. Obviously you get much less than if you sell the cards yourself but you get the convenience here. Overall Satisfied.
Overall, I like the ease of the process and overall its very easy and the prices are okay. Obviously you get much less than if you sell the cards yourself but you get the convenience here. Overall Satisfied.
D
Review left Feb 07 2026
Shipment processed Jan 30 2026
Review
Process was easy and payouts came about as expected
Process was easy and payouts came about as expected
Micheal Taylor
Review left Feb 06 2026
Review
Card Conduit was such a great find! After collecting MTG for many years and realizing I needed more space, I decided to ship some of my collection to them. The process was super easy, and once I received the stats and information from my shipment, I learned a lot about my cards and had zero regrets—not even about one card!
Card Conduit was such a great find! After collecting MTG for many years and realizing I needed more space, I decided to ship some of my collection to them. The process was super easy, and once I received the stats and information from my shipment, I learned a lot about my cards and had zero regrets—not even about one card!
Aaron Y
Review left Feb 06 2026
Shipment processed Jan 28 2026
Review
This shipment was full of old, played cards. I was worried they'd all get graded super harshly but I felt the grades on this shipment were fair. It's one of my most consistent gripes about using Card Conduit - pack fresh cards getting an LP grade from card conduit is a running joke in my playgroup.
...
Read more
This shipment was full of old, played cards. I was worried they'd all get graded super harshly but I felt the grades on this shipment were fair. It's one of my most consistent gripes about using Card Conduit - pack fresh cards getting an LP grade from card conduit is a running joke in my playgroup. This shipment has made me a little more confident about sending in newer cards again.
Thomas Childress
Review left Feb 06 2026
Review
This is my second order and it was just as good as the first one. I love the fast processing and the ease to do business with Card Conduit!!
This is my second order and it was just as good as the first one. I love the fast processing and the ease to do business with Card Conduit!!
Christian R.
Review left Feb 06 2026
Review
This is either my second or third time using Card Conduit, and if I ever need to sell MTG cards again, I will absolutely come back again! Putting together a list was quite quick and easy, especially when compared to the latter of selling individual cards by oneself. I'm very happy with the amount I
...
Read more
This is either my second or third time using Card Conduit, and if I ever need to sell MTG cards again, I will absolutely come back again! Putting together a list was quite quick and easy, especially when compared to the latter of selling individual cards by oneself. I'm very happy with the amount I was able to be paid, overall I do recommend Card Conduit to anyone looking to sell MTG cards and get paid relatively quickly, the whole process took me about two weeks total, and that's with me not knowing exactly what cards I wanted to sell and taking my time to sort through my whole collection.
Peter Trihas
Review left Feb 06 2026
Review
Maybe some slight discrepenscies on grading, but nothing to be weary about, they provide a service unmatched in the industry and takes the burden away from us casual players, collectors, and sellers when needed ! Will continue to support and use their services so that they continue to be an excellent sources for people!
Maybe some slight discrepenscies on grading, but nothing to be weary about, they provide a service unmatched in the industry and takes the burden away from us casual players, collectors, and sellers when needed ! Will continue to support and use their services so that they continue to be an excellent sources for people!
Peter Trihas
Review left Feb 06 2026
Review
Just an overall great experience! There were maybe a few high dollar cards that were advised Mint or Near Mint by local shops/players however overall I want to make sure induslitries like Card Caonduit also make profits so that they continue to provide these services! Overall it was a great experience and I will continue to offset cards to them.
Just an overall great experience! There were maybe a few high dollar cards that were advised Mint or Near Mint by local shops/players however overall I want to make sure induslitries like Card Caonduit also make profits so that they continue to provide these services! Overall it was a great experience and I will continue to offset cards to them.
Peter Trihas
Review left Feb 06 2026
Review
Just an overall great experience! There were maybe a few high dollar cards that were advised Mint or Near Mint by local shops/players however overall I want to make sure induslitries like Card Caonduit also make profits so that they continue to provide these services! Overall it was a great experience and I will continue to offset cards to them.
Just an overall great experience! There were maybe a few high dollar cards that were advised Mint or Near Mint by local shops/players however overall I want to make sure induslitries like Card Caonduit also make profits so that they continue to provide these services! Overall it was a great experience and I will continue to offset cards to them.
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every
previous customer to leave a review.
Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page.
We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a
review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).