Customer Reviews

of our Magic collection selling service

The whole process was easy, secure, and accessible. Could not have asked for a better service and would highly recommend to any person looking for an easy way to sell their cards.

The whole process was easy, secure, and accessible. Could not have asked for a better service and would highly recommend to any person looking for an easy way to sell their cards.

this is like the 3rd or 4th time i've worked with card conduit and the process is always super easy. looking forward to working with you again!

this is like the 3rd or 4th time i've worked with card conduit and the process is always super easy. looking forward to working with you again!

As always, Card Conduit has been the best way for me to sell my cards for cash. I will always appreciate their efforts.

As always, Card Conduit has been the best way for me to sell my cards for cash. I will always appreciate their efforts.

The whole thing was easy; the value was worth it; the processing was quick. Much faster than doing it all yourself.

The whole thing was easy; the value was worth it; the processing was quick. Much faster than doing it all yourself.

I messed up in a couple places in the order but the CC team was super helpful and understanding, great service thanks again

I messed up in a couple places in the order but the CC team was super helpful and understanding, great service thanks again

About a year ago I was bored so I catalogued all my 6000 magic cards into a phone app called Mana Box. Using that app, I was able to generate card data for my collection and upload it into Card Conduit's system (they walk you through this) and this let me see what the most valuable cards were at the ... Read more

About a year ago I was bored so I catalogued all my 6000 magic cards into a phone app called Mana Box. Using that app, I was able to generate card data for my collection and upload it into Card Conduit's system (they walk you through this) and this let me see what the most valuable cards were at the time. Card Conduit's system flags the cards that are worth at least 50 cents for you (because it's not worthwhile to sell them the others). If you've also got your cards physically sorted, this process becomes pretty easy to choose those cards you wish to sell and send them in. I sent in a test batch of 54 cards and got a little over $80 for them. I made the choice to mail this first batch in a small priority mail box because there was one pretty valuable card in there and I didn't want any chance of the cards being sent through an automated envelope sorter. Most cards were played, but some were straight out of the package and into storage, but I don't think any cards got graded as NM, I guess because the newest of them were opened five years ago and aged in the box and lose that new card smell? Overall, I found the process to be pretty painless for me (a tech savvy former game store owner who "gets" the collector mentality). Just make sure you follow all of the directions, including putting your cards in the correct order when you package them up. The easier you make it on their staff, the more you get for your cards. I'll be doing this again. It's way easier than taking cards in person to a shop or trying to sell them on Ebay.

Easy to use and great service. They answer any questions and move quickly.

Easy to use and great service. They answer any questions and move quickly.

Thanks for finding my cards good homes, and giving me money for more cards.

Thanks for finding my cards good homes, and giving me money for more cards.

Great as always. Love using card conduit. They make the whole process very easy!!! Thank you for everything!!!

Great as always. Love using card conduit. They make the whole process very easy!!! Thank you for everything!!!

Great customer service, easy process, I don't think their pricing is correct but I'm not unhappy with the service. Just sent them another 3 boxes. TCG price on what I sent was around $21,000. Lets see how this goes.

Great customer service, easy process, I don't think their pricing is correct but I'm not unhappy with the service. Just sent them another 3 boxes. TCG price on what I sent was around $21,000. Lets see how this goes.

I had a bunch of cards sitting in closet that I had accumulated from opening packs/boxes. Most of the higher value cards I had already sold. After months of them just sitting in the closet, I decided to send them off to be auto-sifted. I sent nearly 3k cards. All I had to do was put them facing the ... Read more

I had a bunch of cards sitting in closet that I had accumulated from opening packs/boxes. Most of the higher value cards I had already sold. After months of them just sitting in the closet, I decided to send them off to be auto-sifted. I sent nearly 3k cards. All I had to do was put them facing the same way and separate foils from regular cards. I received a report of the cards and was surprised how many I had of value even though the cards were of no use/value to me. I would definitely recommend the auto-sifted service if you have a bunch of leftover cards sitting in booster boxes that you are not using. I felt the grading and prices were very fair and the fee was minimal compared to the time I’d have taken looking them all up on my own.

I've been using Card Conduit for a while. every experience is perfect from start to finish. This time I got to use a promo code from one of my favorite content creators Joel Are Magic which was awesome!

I've been using Card Conduit for a while. every experience is perfect from start to finish. This time I got to use a promo code from one of my favorite content creators Joel Are Magic which was awesome!

Fair pricing, easy shipment process and no hassles. Thank you!

Fair pricing, easy shipment process and no hassles. Thank you!

I have sold many Magic cards throughout my life. From different shops/LGS, online retailers (Star City Games, Channel Fireball, etc), and even individuals, Card Conduit is currently the best experience I have had selling cards. From the beginning they project a time window of when you will receive ... Read more

I have sold many Magic cards throughout my life. From different shops/LGS, online retailers (Star City Games, Channel Fireball, etc), and even individuals, Card Conduit is currently the best experience I have had selling cards. From the beginning they project a time window of when you will receive your payout, and it is very accurate. I have had nightmares with other companies where they sent payment to an incorrect PayPal account, or told me the condition of a card was way worse than it was when I mailed it.
Card Conduit was fair throughout the entire process. The online buy-list and shipping instructions were easy to navigate and tracking the process was easy. When they sent the final report and payment, I had a few questions to review on condition, and they kindly sent photos of some of the wear on corners of a card and surface scratches that kept the card from being NM. They were professional and the process is the most fair I have dealt with recently. Sure you can find individual buyers that may pay a little more but the security isn't there. You may be able to get more store credit from Star City Games, but they don't always have the card you need in stock. If you are looking to buy into another format, or are looking to pick up a few higher end cards, this has got to be the best way to go.

I would recommend them for sure. Got 400 out of stuff I had laying around. 75 less than I thought. But I just had to ship off the cards and get paid. Little effort on my part. I missed a 125 dollar card on their state sheet they gave me. I would have kept that one.

I would recommend them for sure. Got 400 out of stuff I had laying around. 75 less than I thought. But I just had to ship off the cards and get paid. Little effort on my part. I missed a 125 dollar card on their state sheet they gave me. I would have kept that one.

An outstanding company dedicated to the service of Magic The Gathering fans everywhere. They are the absolute cornerstone of everything MACIC!

An outstanding company dedicated to the service of Magic The Gathering fans everywhere. They are the absolute cornerstone of everything MACIC!

Easy to use, fair grading and prices. Will continue to use.

Easy to use, fair grading and prices. Will continue to use.

great company for selling cards!!! have used them multiple times

great company for selling cards!!! have used them multiple times

I've done a few shipments through card conduit and it's always everything I want in a service like this. They pay good value for the cards, charge a reasonable fee, and it's very quick and easy.

I've done a few shipments through card conduit and it's always everything I want in a service like this. They pay good value for the cards, charge a reasonable fee, and it's very quick and easy.

Sent a curated group of cards. The communication was great I knew what was happening every step they provide great detail of values and condition. Fair prices and easy to submit. I would recommend.

Sent a curated group of cards. The communication was great I knew what was happening every step they provide great detail of values and condition. Fair prices and easy to submit. I would recommend.