Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service
Donnie
Review left Jan 15 2025
Review
Overall the whole process of sending cards for sale is amazing! I had these old MTG cards i have moved from place to place. This time when moving i decided to see if i could sell them! Info on how to ship back cards was great! And it turns out i had $1400 worth of cards laying around! THANK YOU!!
Overall the whole process of sending cards for sale is amazing! I had these old MTG cards i have moved from place to place. This time when moving i decided to see if i could sell them! Info on how to ship back cards was great! And it turns out i had $1400 worth of cards laying around! THANK YOU!!
Deryk Frank
Review left Jan 15 2025
Review
The fact that I could sell my entire collection (apart from my decks) all in one go by shipping them to a single address and got a quick payout via Zelle is insane. Card Conduit is the GOAT fr.
The fact that I could sell my entire collection (apart from my decks) all in one go by shipping them to a single address and got a quick payout via Zelle is insane. Card Conduit is the GOAT fr.
Clay
Review left Jan 14 2025
Review
I can't recommend this service highly enough. I found the collection estimate to be fairly accurate for my shipment and the response and payment time as quick as estimated. The updates and customer service were excellent and gave me a lot of confidence in the process. I'm going to use this again in the future and recommend to friends.
I can't recommend this service highly enough. I found the collection estimate to be fairly accurate for my shipment and the response and payment time as quick as estimated. The updates and customer service were excellent and gave me a lot of confidence in the process. I'm going to use this again in the future and recommend to friends.
Alex
Review left Jan 14 2025
Review
I was very skeptical at first but the process was super easy. They were fair on the conditions of the cards and they amount they offered was right in line with what I thought I should get. Minimal effort on my end and it didn't take long at all to receive payment. I will be using them in the future to get rid of my higher end bulk.
I was very skeptical at first but the process was super easy. They were fair on the conditions of the cards and they amount they offered was right in line with what I thought I should get. Minimal effort on my end and it didn't take long at all to receive payment. I will be using them in the future to get rid of my higher end bulk.
Zach Boxley
Review left Jan 14 2025
Review
I use card kingdom to sell cards, since tcgplayer stopped accepting trade ins. They're pretty slow, so I thought I'd try card conduit. The cards I sent started being verified right away, not a few days later. From the time they got the order of 119 cards until my direct deposit hit, I was only a wee
...
Read more
I use card kingdom to sell cards, since tcgplayer stopped accepting trade ins. They're pretty slow, so I thought I'd try card conduit. The cards I sent started being verified right away, not a few days later. From the time they got the order of 119 cards until my direct deposit hit, I was only a week start to finish. Very happy overall. Thank you, Card Conduit. I'll definitely use you again.
Harrison Howard
Review left Jan 14 2025
Review
The whole process was smooth and simple, less than 2 weeks in total! I will definitely be using this service in the future for all my selling needs!
The whole process was smooth and simple, less than 2 weeks in total! I will definitely be using this service in the future for all my selling needs!
Daniel Cotto
Review left Jan 13 2025
Shipment processed Jan 03 2025
Review
Being able to get rid of some cards that may not necessarily be worth anything on other sites is a nice way to not just throw away old cards.
Being able to get rid of some cards that may not necessarily be worth anything on other sites is a nice way to not just throw away old cards.
Drew
Review left Jan 13 2025
Shipment processed Dec 20 2024
Review
What makes this service useful is how smooth it is. The prices are nothing amazing, but that's what you pay for having to do a small fraction of the work.
I did a sorted shipment, but in the future I might not bother and just do an unsorted shipment because selecting and sorting cards was a lot ... Read more
I did a sorted shipment, but in the future I might not bother and just do an unsorted shipment because selecting and sorting cards was a lot ... Read more
What makes this service useful is how smooth it is. The prices are nothing amazing, but that's what you pay for having to do a small fraction of the work.
I did a sorted shipment, but in the future I might not bother and just do an unsorted shipment because selecting and sorting cards was a lot of work. If you do a sorted shipment, make sure you sort the cards from the card list _before_ you finalize the contents. Once you confirm the card list you can't change it, so any mistakes can be a pain to fix.
I did a sorted shipment, but in the future I might not bother and just do an unsorted shipment because selecting and sorting cards was a lot of work. If you do a sorted shipment, make sure you sort the cards from the card list _before_ you finalize the contents. Once you confirm the card list you can't change it, so any mistakes can be a pain to fix.
Jaynell
Review left Jan 13 2025
Review
I'd definitely start recommending it to my friends.
I'd definitely start recommending it to my friends.
Benjamin Steiger
Review left Jan 12 2025
Review
Selling with Card Conduit was the best selling experience I've had. Everything from the excellent communication, to the transparency and quick digital payment were much appreciated. They are as harsh on grading as any large store, so be prepared for that, but no other selling service comes close on their rates and service.
Selling with Card Conduit was the best selling experience I've had. Everything from the excellent communication, to the transparency and quick digital payment were much appreciated. They are as harsh on grading as any large store, so be prepared for that, but no other selling service comes close on their rates and service.
Xapher
Review left Jan 12 2025
Shipment processed Dec 06 2024
Review
The process was easy if you already had a CSV file. Everything else allowed you to build a "cart" but I couldn't find something like that.
But if I sell cards again I'm going with you. You had cards available for trade in where other dedicated stores weren't accepting.
Thank you.
But if I sell cards again I'm going with you. You had cards available for trade in where other dedicated stores weren't accepting.
Thank you.
The process was easy if you already had a CSV file. Everything else allowed you to build a "cart" but I couldn't find something like that.
But if I sell cards again I'm going with you. You had cards available for trade in where other dedicated stores weren't accepting.
Thank you.
But if I sell cards again I'm going with you. You had cards available for trade in where other dedicated stores weren't accepting.
Thank you.
Matt R
Review left Jan 11 2025
Review
Using Card Conduit was a fantastic experience from start to finish. The process was incredibly easy to navigate, and I was kept in the loop at every stage of the shipment. Their frequent updates made it clear exactly where my shipment was in the process, which gave me great peace of mind.
On top ... Read more
On top ... Read more
Using Card Conduit was a fantastic experience from start to finish. The process was incredibly easy to navigate, and I was kept in the loop at every stage of the shipment. Their frequent updates made it clear exactly where my shipment was in the process, which gave me great peace of mind.
On top of that, I had an issue with a previous payout (completely my mistake, not Card Conduit's), and their team went above and beyond to help me resolve it without any hassle. The level of customer service was outstanding, and they handled everything with efficiency and professionalism.
I would absolutely use them again and recommend the service to others ( and have!).
On top of that, I had an issue with a previous payout (completely my mistake, not Card Conduit's), and their team went above and beyond to help me resolve it without any hassle. The level of customer service was outstanding, and they handled everything with efficiency and professionalism.
I would absolutely use them again and recommend the service to others ( and have!).
Matthew
Review left Jan 09 2025
Review
From start to finish the process was quick, easy and painless. The overall interface made adding the cards with their estimated value a breeze. The list given to sort the cards is concise and easy to read. I had no issues with any estimations or quality choices that the team made. 10/10 will be using again.
From start to finish the process was quick, easy and painless. The overall interface made adding the cards with their estimated value a breeze. The list given to sort the cards is concise and easy to read. I had no issues with any estimations or quality choices that the team made. 10/10 will be using again.
Eric P
Review left Jan 09 2025
Review
Helping me fund a man cave one shipment at a time. Wife can’t complain about found money, that’s what this place offers.
Helping me fund a man cave one shipment at a time. Wife can’t complain about found money, that’s what this place offers.
Michael
Review left Jan 08 2025
Review
The process was very quick, taking just about a week from ship out to pay out during the week of Christmas, which I was very impressed with. I used the sorted tier sending in my trades that my locals at the LGS haven't been interested in. The payout was as expected and I was quite pleased with it.
The process was very quick, taking just about a week from ship out to pay out during the week of Christmas, which I was very impressed with. I used the sorted tier sending in my trades that my locals at the LGS haven't been interested in. The payout was as expected and I was quite pleased with it.
Daniel Tolbert
Review left Jan 08 2025
Review
Typically I buy list my cards to cardkingdom for store credit. However, they've been slower and slower recently and I had a batch of cards worth $0.50+ and sent to CC.
They were quick, paid cash (a bit less than CK credit, but actual dollars), and good communication.
They were quick, paid cash (a bit less than CK credit, but actual dollars), and good communication.
Typically I buy list my cards to cardkingdom for store credit. However, they've been slower and slower recently and I had a batch of cards worth $0.50+ and sent to CC.
They were quick, paid cash (a bit less than CK credit, but actual dollars), and good communication.
They were quick, paid cash (a bit less than CK credit, but actual dollars), and good communication.
James
Review left Jan 08 2025
Review
The entire process from start to finish is easy to navigate. The level of communication and the speed at which my order was processed far outpaced the companies providing similar services. If you're thinking about giving card conduit a chance, do it.
The entire process from start to finish is easy to navigate. The level of communication and the speed at which my order was processed far outpaced the companies providing similar services. If you're thinking about giving card conduit a chance, do it.
Eric
Review left Jan 07 2025
Review
I have used this service multiple times and will continue to in the future. Best way to sell cards for a fair price and no hassle!
I have used this service multiple times and will continue to in the future. Best way to sell cards for a fair price and no hassle!
Dustin Hudson
Review left Jan 07 2025
Review
The process was easy, efficient and at every point felt safe and secure. I highly recommend Card Conduit.
The process was easy, efficient and at every point felt safe and secure. I highly recommend Card Conduit.
Ray
Review left Jan 07 2025
Review
Very easy. Only suggestion: would be nice if able to export list of cards in shipment with both CC price and TCG market/low price (like in the price check tool). That would be nice to quickly see which cards I may want to take out due to low buylist values
Very easy. Only suggestion: would be nice if able to export list of cards in shipment with both CC price and TCG market/low price (like in the price check tool). That would be nice to quickly see which cards I may want to take out due to low buylist values
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every
previous customer to leave a review.
Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page.
We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a
review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).