Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service
(6073)
Josh S
Review left Apr 12 2026
Review
The process was simple. I sorted all my cards beforehand because I only had ~150 cards to offload. I wasn’t too concerned with the conditions since I had a range of conditions so when I reviewed the conditions of the cards and the prices I was pleasantly surprised. Overall, great experience, simpl
...
Read more
The process was simple. I sorted all my cards beforehand because I only had ~150 cards to offload. I wasn’t too concerned with the conditions since I had a range of conditions so when I reviewed the conditions of the cards and the prices I was pleasantly surprised. Overall, great experience, simple to use, and friendly customer service. Great customer service truly. I will definitely use Card Conduit again.
Colin N.
Review left Apr 12 2026
Review
Process was clear and easy from beginning to end. As promised, payment was fast and efficient once the order was processed in the expected amount of time.
I have no complaints other than the card quality evaluation was a little bit more stringent than I was expecting. Long story short, they were ... Read more
I have no complaints other than the card quality evaluation was a little bit more stringent than I was expecting. Long story short, they were ... Read more
Process was clear and easy from beginning to end. As promised, payment was fast and efficient once the order was processed in the expected amount of time.
I have no complaints other than the card quality evaluation was a little bit more stringent than I was expecting. Long story short, they were all Rhystic Studies from original Prophecy that just sat in a bulk box for many years. Didn't get played much (if at all), but were subject to the typical bumps and scrapes from being in a bin and not in a binder.
I was expecting Moderately Played as a rating (I've been shipped cards myself from other resellers in much the same condition, with this same rating), but they all got Heavily Played instead. That's fine, and now I know what to expect.
Would use the service again and would recommend to others with this caveat.
I have no complaints other than the card quality evaluation was a little bit more stringent than I was expecting. Long story short, they were all Rhystic Studies from original Prophecy that just sat in a bulk box for many years. Didn't get played much (if at all), but were subject to the typical bumps and scrapes from being in a bin and not in a binder.
I was expecting Moderately Played as a rating (I've been shipped cards myself from other resellers in much the same condition, with this same rating), but they all got Heavily Played instead. That's fine, and now I know what to expect.
Would use the service again and would recommend to others with this caveat.
Lucas Colburn
Review left Apr 11 2026
Review
I was either lucky or this service is just that good! I think on the total value of my cards I sent in (~4500), I lost like 50 bucks, which I could've saved by waiting for months to sell my high value cards on TCG player (yeah, right!). This is clearly the best option for selling your entire collect
...
Read more
I was either lucky or this service is just that good! I think on the total value of my cards I sent in (~4500), I lost like 50 bucks, which I could've saved by waiting for months to sell my high value cards on TCG player (yeah, right!). This is clearly the best option for selling your entire collection. The whole process was quick; it took only a couple weeks from googling 'what to do about my magic collection' to receiving a check for a cool grand. Maybe someday there will be one of these for Pokemon cards. A boy can dream. But anyway, I'm very pleased.
Michael Mazzola
Review left Apr 11 2026
Review
Never had a bad experience with this service. Easiest way to sell your collection
Never had a bad experience with this service. Easiest way to sell your collection
J Cros
Review left Apr 11 2026
Review
Simple to use, good pricing and grading was very fair with about 90% of my cards rated near mint.
Was paid within about a week and half after shipping out my cards.
Will use their service again and recommend to others.
Was paid within about a week and half after shipping out my cards.
Will use their service again and recommend to others.
Simple to use, good pricing and grading was very fair with about 90% of my cards rated near mint.
Was paid within about a week and half after shipping out my cards.
Will use their service again and recommend to others.
Was paid within about a week and half after shipping out my cards.
Will use their service again and recommend to others.
Marco Garcia
Review left Apr 10 2026
Review
love the processing time and always good prices. thank u
love the processing time and always good prices. thank u
Frederick Balsley
Review left Apr 10 2026
Review
3 shipments now, zero issues and super easy. I am building a business around them as we speak because I hate the hassle of selling to anyone else!
3 shipments now, zero issues and super easy. I am building a business around them as we speak because I hate the hassle of selling to anyone else!
Eric
Review left Apr 10 2026
Review
I'm moving soon and needed to downsize my collection quickly, and Card Conduit's new sorter tier made it so easy for me in terms of my effort, while maximizing my value.
I'm moving soon and needed to downsize my collection quickly, and Card Conduit's new sorter tier made it so easy for me in terms of my effort, while maximizing my value.
Eric Barrera-Palacios
Review left Apr 10 2026
Shipment processed Mar 31 2026
Review
Due to my large collection, I did have to scan and organize my cards in order for card conduit to get a better value. However this process personally let me know the value of my collection and what to expect on payment. Highly recommended this website to sell complete collection or looking a way to sell cards you no longer need.
Due to my large collection, I did have to scan and organize my cards in order for card conduit to get a better value. However this process personally let me know the value of my collection and what to expect on payment. Highly recommended this website to sell complete collection or looking a way to sell cards you no longer need.
Arthur Ambrose
Review left Apr 09 2026
Review
This was by far the most easy, low stress experience I could have asked for. They were efficient, communicated well and gave me really good prices for my items.
This was by far the most easy, low stress experience I could have asked for. They were efficient, communicated well and gave me really good prices for my items.
B. Stager
Review left Apr 09 2026
Shipment processed Mar 31 2026
Review
everything has gone smoothly and about matches their timeline estimates.
prices are fair. lot easier to use their sorting method than buyers that need an itemized list ahead of time.
thanks!
prices are fair. lot easier to use their sorting method than buyers that need an itemized list ahead of time.
thanks!
everything has gone smoothly and about matches their timeline estimates.
prices are fair. lot easier to use their sorting method than buyers that need an itemized list ahead of time.
thanks!
prices are fair. lot easier to use their sorting method than buyers that need an itemized list ahead of time.
thanks!
Zachary Woodman
Review left Apr 09 2026
Review
The process was super easy to set up and get mailed out and even though I made a mistake when shipping the cards out the customer support team was amazing and quick to contact me. We had everything taken care of within the hour the issue was brought to my attention. I highly recommend using this ser
...
Read more
The process was super easy to set up and get mailed out and even though I made a mistake when shipping the cards out the customer support team was amazing and quick to contact me. We had everything taken care of within the hour the issue was brought to my attention. I highly recommend using this service to turn in your bulk magic cards and thank you again to all the staff that helped me out. You guys are awesome :)
Armando Beas
Review left Apr 09 2026
Review
I love these guys, they were very transparent and on time with everything they said. Very good with communication and nice people. 10/10 satisfactorily, I highly recommend these people.
I love these guys, they were very transparent and on time with everything they said. Very good with communication and nice people. 10/10 satisfactorily, I highly recommend these people.
Alex v
Review left Apr 09 2026
Review
I used Card Conduit to finally get rid of the remaining bits of my collection that I hadn’t used or played with for about 10 years. It was incredibly straightforward and worked great! I spent an afternoon sorting through all of my cards with the verification service using a card scanning app and w
...
Read more
I used Card Conduit to finally get rid of the remaining bits of my collection that I hadn’t used or played with for about 10 years. It was incredibly straightforward and worked great! I spent an afternoon sorting through all of my cards with the verification service using a card scanning app and was able to use the curated shipment to reduce fees - I think I could have packed the cards a bit better as I think a bit of friction in the deck boxes I used might have made some of the cards from lightly played to moderately played, but otherwise I sent them via a flat rate box, put the order number on the side, and was processed within 2 weeks ( I sent it on the 17th, it was received on the 23rd, and processed by the 30th of March.). I feel like I got a good value and it was a lot better getting a fair cash split on retail prices for a lot of cards, I had 200 cards in my shipment. I didn’t have any extremely valuable cards, so it would have taken a lot of effort to try to move them on my own. Thank you Card Conduit for a transparent and fair process!
maloof
Review left Apr 08 2026
Shipment processed Apr 07 2026
Review
Thanks for making process quick and easy to understand
Thanks for making process quick and easy to understand
Christopher
Review left Apr 08 2026
Review
Process went great. The support team was incredibly helpful with every question I had. Some cards were priced out differently than I thought, but support showed me actual photos of my cards and as to why they were conditioned that way. They are incredibly transparent with the entire process. Much be
...
Read more
Process went great. The support team was incredibly helpful with every question I had. Some cards were priced out differently than I thought, but support showed me actual photos of my cards and as to why they were conditioned that way. They are incredibly transparent with the entire process. Much better than the hassle of selling them individually yourself or getting a lower amount at the local LGS. Great experience. If you are reluctant to try it for the first time (like I was), give it a try, and you will definitely be happy with the results.
Austin
Review left Apr 08 2026
Review
The process from beginning to end was very easy! I'll definitely be using Card Conduit for shipping my extra cards moving forward.
The process from beginning to end was very easy! I'll definitely be using Card Conduit for shipping my extra cards moving forward.
Robert
Review left Apr 08 2026
Review
Three words… quick, fair, convenient. Website could be a little easier to navigate, could just be user error... Would use them again.
Also, one of my go to shops on tcgplayer. Great value and quick shipping always!
Also, one of my go to shops on tcgplayer. Great value and quick shipping always!
Three words… quick, fair, convenient. Website could be a little easier to navigate, could just be user error... Would use them again.
Also, one of my go to shops on tcgplayer. Great value and quick shipping always!
Also, one of my go to shops on tcgplayer. Great value and quick shipping always!
Tom Fitzsimmons
Review left Apr 08 2026
Review
Very smooth, great customer experience, if need to contact very prompt and accurate, would recommend
Very smooth, great customer experience, if need to contact very prompt and accurate, would recommend
Trey Lasseigne
Review left Apr 08 2026
Review
Super fair with reading and information provision.
Super fair with reading and information provision.
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every
previous customer to leave a review.
Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page.
We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a
review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).