Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service
(6304)
Avery
Review left Jun 02 2026
Shipment processed May 29 2026
$203.82
payout, $4.16
fees
Review
Sad there was a counterfeit but otherwise smooth and easy process
Sad there was a counterfeit but otherwise smooth and easy process
Good Job
Review left Jun 02 2026
Review
don't necesarily agree with the grading on some of the cards as they are freshly opened from packs but they get the job done.
don't necesarily agree with the grading on some of the cards as they are freshly opened from packs but they get the job done.
Jon
Review left Jun 01 2026
Review
Extremely easy and use friendly. The checklist prior to sending out my cards guided me with ease. Questions I had regarding specific cards of concern were addressed quickly. Incredible exeperience.
Extremely easy and use friendly. The checklist prior to sending out my cards guided me with ease. Questions I had regarding specific cards of concern were addressed quickly. Incredible exeperience.
Marco
Review left Jun 01 2026
Review
used them a lot. quick communication. top notch
used them a lot. quick communication. top notch
Marco
Review left Jun 01 2026
Review
used them a lot. quick communication. top notch
used them a lot. quick communication. top notch
Marco
Review left Jun 01 2026
Review
used them a lot. quick communication. top notch
used them a lot. quick communication. top notch
Marco
Review left Jun 01 2026
Review
used them a lot. quick communication. top notch
used them a lot. quick communication. top notch
John W Scarbeck
Review left Jun 01 2026
Review
There is no easier way to sell your magic cards than this company. Quick efficient and hassle free. I cannot give enough praise for their service and efficiency.
There is no easier way to sell your magic cards than this company. Quick efficient and hassle free. I cannot give enough praise for their service and efficiency.
Paul B
Review left Jun 01 2026
Review
Easiest way to sell my collection by far! The customer service was stellar, it’s clear the staff is responsive and very personable. In a time when I’m constantly frustrated with companies cutting corners with chat bots and AI, it was so nice to exchange emails with real, kind humans!
Easiest way to sell my collection by far! The customer service was stellar, it’s clear the staff is responsive and very personable. In a time when I’m constantly frustrated with companies cutting corners with chat bots and AI, it was so nice to exchange emails with real, kind humans!
Ethan
Review left May 31 2026
Review
Very easy process to complete, and some of the best prices to sell cards. Would definitely use again!
Very easy process to complete, and some of the best prices to sell cards. Would definitely use again!
avery
Review left May 31 2026
Shipment processed May 28 2026
Review
USPS had a mailing issue but everything ended up fine!
USPS had a mailing issue but everything ended up fine!
Jesse Valles
Review left May 31 2026
Review
Great experience, even with my less expensive cards! Would recommend.
Great experience, even with my less expensive cards! Would recommend.
Kevin Francisco + Princess Jaco (Cat)
Review left May 31 2026
Review
I looked through all the major MTD resellers and Card Conduit was the easiest to navigate, most compatible with CSV upload, and had the best and only unique UI out of all of them. It seems like all the top card sites just copy and pasted ONE template from 2010, but going through Card Conduit felt li
...
Read more
I looked through all the major MTD resellers and Card Conduit was the easiest to navigate, most compatible with CSV upload, and had the best and only unique UI out of all of them. It seems like all the top card sites just copy and pasted ONE template from 2010, but going through Card Conduit felt like... the internet in 2026.
Honestly a great business model that really helped me out in a financial pinch. Pure laser focus of buying your cards, will go back again (or invent a magic card sorting machine) A+++ recommend.
Special thanks to Nathaniel Buckley-Wright from Card Conduit team for looking out for me and my cat, Princess Jaco during our processing time. You're the real intrepid hero.
Honestly a great business model that really helped me out in a financial pinch. Pure laser focus of buying your cards, will go back again (or invent a magic card sorting machine) A+++ recommend.
Special thanks to Nathaniel Buckley-Wright from Card Conduit team for looking out for me and my cat, Princess Jaco during our processing time. You're the real intrepid hero.
Andy C
Review left May 30 2026
Shipment processed May 20 2026
Review
Easy process, decent pricing, worth not dealing with the hassle for FB marketplace or ebay.
Easy process, decent pricing, worth not dealing with the hassle for FB marketplace or ebay.
Kevin T.
Review left May 30 2026
Review
I've always wanted to get rid of my bulk and the fee is negligible.
I've always wanted to get rid of my bulk and the fee is negligible.
Evan Bisel
Review left May 30 2026
Review
I really liked working with CC, they made the whole process easy for selling and payout and were very transparent every step of the way.
I really liked working with CC, they made the whole process easy for selling and payout and were very transparent every step of the way.
Big Dog JD
Review left May 30 2026
Review
Easy process, quick turnaround, fast payment. I was initially hesitant, but I just finished my first shipment, and I am starting my next one.
Easy process, quick turnaround, fast payment. I was initially hesitant, but I just finished my first shipment, and I am starting my next one.
Daniel C
Review left May 30 2026
Review
Easy to ship and you get notifications every step of the way. Love using CardConduit! 🙂
Easy to ship and you get notifications every step of the way. Love using CardConduit! 🙂
Ryland Q
Review left May 30 2026
Review
Shipped with curated service, turnaround time was exactly the expected date, and results were almost exactly as expected. Every card I had questions on, I got a quick response, picture, and explanation from support regarding grade.
Was able to clear out ~600 cards of my collection easily, and wit ... Read more
Was able to clear out ~600 cards of my collection easily, and wit ... Read more
Shipped with curated service, turnaround time was exactly the expected date, and results were almost exactly as expected. Every card I had questions on, I got a quick response, picture, and explanation from support regarding grade.
Was able to clear out ~600 cards of my collection easily, and with a great return compared to how long it would’ve taken to sell locally/via online.
Was able to clear out ~600 cards of my collection easily, and with a great return compared to how long it would’ve taken to sell locally/via online.
Adam
Review left May 29 2026
Shipment processed May 27 2026
Review
This was a quick and easy process. Their fee is ridiculously small for the work they put in. Thank you!
This was a quick and easy process. Their fee is ridiculously small for the work they put in. Thank you!
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every
previous customer to leave a review.
Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page.
We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a
review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).