Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service
(6840)
Travis
Review left Sep 20 2026
Review
The communication was great. The process was super easy. I catalogued everything myself to save some money and it easy to do on my end. Had a great experience and I will be using this service again.
The communication was great. The process was super easy. I catalogued everything myself to save some money and it easy to do on my end. Had a great experience and I will be using this service again.
Timothy W
Review left Sep 19 2026
Review
After many years playing magic it was time to get out of the hobby. card conduit made it easy to send everything to one place and have my collection sold to one place. I didn't have to haggle across many game stores or find a convention who would purchase everything.
After many years playing magic it was time to get out of the hobby. card conduit made it easy to send everything to one place and have my collection sold to one place. I didn't have to haggle across many game stores or find a convention who would purchase everything.
Nicholas A.
Review left Sep 19 2026
Shipment processed Sep 04 2026
Review
Was not expecting this process to be as smooth and easy as it was. The turnaround was quick and the constant updates were a plus. I'm going to be using this service again and would recommend to anyone.
Was not expecting this process to be as smooth and easy as it was. The turnaround was quick and the constant updates were a plus. I'm going to be using this service again and would recommend to anyone.
Carlton Maddox
Review left Sep 19 2026
Shipment processed Sep 11 2026
Review
This is the only place I will ever unload cards. Always fast, efficient and fair! Love it!
This is the only place I will ever unload cards. Always fast, efficient and fair! Love it!
Tainymar Santiago-Cruz
Review left Sep 19 2026
Review
This site helped my partner and I learn about card value, card quality, and helped us find some fun cards along the way.
This site helped my partner and I learn about card value, card quality, and helped us find some fun cards along the way.
Oscar Simoza
Review left Sep 19 2026
Review
I was a little hesitant by sending the amount of cards I sent BUT this was super easy and a really good experience, seriously cannot wait to gather a bunch of cards I don’t use again and turn them into $!
I was a little hesitant by sending the amount of cards I sent BUT this was super easy and a really good experience, seriously cannot wait to gather a bunch of cards I don’t use again and turn them into $!
Woody Butler
Review left Sep 19 2026
Review
10/10 experience. They've got a helpful price checker that works really well. I sifted through my ~6k bulk cards for everything over 30 cents and shipped it out to them. TBH it was fund and satisfying. Also the people you talk to in the process are genuinely nice. After submitting everything they gi
...
Read more
10/10 experience. They've got a helpful price checker that works really well. I sifted through my ~6k bulk cards for everything over 30 cents and shipped it out to them. TBH it was fund and satisfying. Also the people you talk to in the process are genuinely nice. After submitting everything they give a breakdown on every card, and even provide some fun little reports of top 5 cards in each a couple different categories, in addition to providing a full CSV with every card submitted, their assesment of condition, value. The data-nerds will love this.
My workflow:
1. Search scryfall for commons/uncommons of certain sets, with price filter over 38 cents
2. Go through bulk for any of those cards (I would go 1 color at a time)
3. Confirm all those hits on card conduit price-checker - it tells you their value and how much you will get at NM minus their fees
4. Ship everything that will profit!
Overall just an awesome service. No one else handles large buylists / bulk for those lower-value but still sellable cards like this.
My workflow:
1. Search scryfall for commons/uncommons of certain sets, with price filter over 38 cents
2. Go through bulk for any of those cards (I would go 1 color at a time)
3. Confirm all those hits on card conduit price-checker - it tells you their value and how much you will get at NM minus their fees
4. Ship everything that will profit!
Overall just an awesome service. No one else handles large buylists / bulk for those lower-value but still sellable cards like this.
Joshua Bruce
Review left Sep 19 2026
Review
3-4th time going thru Card Conduit. Each time it's been extremely easy, with awesome communication and top-notch customer service. The only choice to go thru in selling your magic cards.
3-4th time going thru Card Conduit. Each time it's been extremely easy, with awesome communication and top-notch customer service. The only choice to go thru in selling your magic cards.
Robert I
Review left Sep 19 2026
Review
Pack em up and ship em out. Process was incredibly smooth, this was my 2nd time using CC. I will be doing it again shortly.
Pack em up and ship em out. Process was incredibly smooth, this was my 2nd time using CC. I will be doing it again shortly.
Mitchell Lesteberg
Review left Sep 18 2026
Review
Great!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Great!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Chad Mccaffrey
Review left Sep 18 2026
Review
Process was easy and payment was fast and efficient
Process was easy and payment was fast and efficient
Sean Nilapant
Review left Sep 17 2026
Shipment processed Sep 15 2026
Review
First time trying Card Conduit and had a great experience. Cards were graded fair and payment was fast! Thank you!
First time trying Card Conduit and had a great experience. Cards were graded fair and payment was fast! Thank you!
William Bell
Review left Sep 17 2026
Review
Fast and easy! I wish they took more of my cards, but the process was seamless!
Fast and easy! I wish they took more of my cards, but the process was seamless!
Tim Schultz
Review left Sep 17 2026
Review
They helped with all my questions, good communication, and the process was very simple
They helped with all my questions, good communication, and the process was very simple
Adam F.
Review left Sep 17 2026
Review
I had a group of older MTG cards just sitting around, and Card Conduit was great in easily helping get them converted to cash. Due to their age, most weren't in the best shape, but I believe they were fair in evaluating the condition and giving what they were worth.
I had a group of older MTG cards just sitting around, and Card Conduit was great in easily helping get them converted to cash. Due to their age, most weren't in the best shape, but I believe they were fair in evaluating the condition and giving what they were worth.
Jonathon Cameron Weaver
Review left Sep 17 2026
Review
Quick process and they were very honest with their pricing
Quick process and they were very honest with their pricing
NAL
Review left Sep 17 2026
Review
Super easy to create order and ship off. Payout process was easy too!
Super easy to create order and ship off. Payout process was easy too!
Andrea
Review left Sep 17 2026
Shipment processed Aug 04 2026
$45.80
payout, $0.93
fees
Review
It's really easy working with Card Conduit. The platform and the process are simple and the steps are easy to follow. I appreciate the report after the shipment has been received.
It's really easy working with Card Conduit. The platform and the process are simple and the steps are easy to follow. I appreciate the report after the shipment has been received.
Elizabeth
Review left Sep 17 2026
Review
The auto-sifted option was perfect for my collection of over 2,500 cards. I didn't get as much as i would have liked but the process was close to effortless; unsleeved some cards, separated foil and non-foil, and make sure they were all the same direction. I had gotten close to 55% of my estimated m
...
Read more
The auto-sifted option was perfect for my collection of over 2,500 cards. I didn't get as much as i would have liked but the process was close to effortless; unsleeved some cards, separated foil and non-foil, and make sure they were all the same direction. I had gotten close to 55% of my estimated market price, where i was hoping to see closer to 70% like a friend had described to me
Josh
Review left Sep 17 2026
Shipment processed Aug 14 2026
Review
First off - read the shipping tips, you don’t realize how heavy things get once you start getting into the hundreds - let alone THOUSANDS of cards. Take the time to pack your stuff - I did, and had no additional delays or fees. Take the time to prep everything - preparation is key, you don’t wan
...
Read more
First off - read the shipping tips, you don’t realize how heavy things get once you start getting into the hundreds - let alone THOUSANDS of cards. Take the time to pack your stuff - I did, and had no additional delays or fees. Take the time to prep everything - preparation is key, you don’t want to make the lives of the nice Card Conduit people harder! Process was simple, simple to track process, once the processing was complete, everything was listed out and transparent. Payout was quick, I opted for a paper check, took just under a week to arrive. No issues or complaints there. For someone who has grown out of MTG for other (just as consuming and expensive) hobbies - the services were just what I needed to clear out the space needed and get some cash for stuff I haven’t used or played with in close to 8 years. Happy customer here.
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every
previous customer to leave a review.
Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page.
We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a
review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).