Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service
(6840)
jj
Review left Oct 30 2026
Review
In terms of the advertised service everything went very well. I did the sorted service and used their website to build the list and put everything in order, it was fast and easy. I was very disappointed in the grading particularly of the most valuable cards. My #1 most valuable card which was never
...
Read more
In terms of the advertised service everything went very well. I did the sorted service and used their website to build the list and put everything in order, it was fast and easy. I was very disappointed in the grading particularly of the most valuable cards. My #1 most valuable card which was never played and went straight into a sleeve graded as LP and my 3rd most valuable card did the same thing. This would be less annoying if there was some even distribution of card grades but the LP grade was really biased towards the most valuable cards in my shipment, which I find questionable. I ultimately decided to proceed with the payment since shipping with tracking was ~$30 anyways. If you plan to use this service I would set an expectation level around 80% of the advertised price, even if you consider all cards NM. Otherwise the other features of this service were as advertised. It is a good way to unload bulk but if I were to do it again I would prefer to do the legwork myself for any card over $20.
Zach H
Review left Oct 30 2026
Review
Wanted to sell some cards that I had but didnt have the time to individually sell. Card conduit has been super helpful in offloading these cards without spending exessive amount of time listing,packing, shipping multiple cards on other sites. Thank you
Wanted to sell some cards that I had but didnt have the time to individually sell. Card conduit has been super helpful in offloading these cards without spending exessive amount of time listing,packing, shipping multiple cards on other sites. Thank you
Jacob Stank
Review left Oct 29 2026
Review
Fast percise, only down side was shipping the card was way overpriced for some reason, which is not the fault of them just usps or fedex being greedy!
Fast percise, only down side was shipping the card was way overpriced for some reason, which is not the fault of them just usps or fedex being greedy!
Enricco Gemha
Review left Oct 29 2026
Review
I used the Sorted service to sell my MTG cards, and the process was straightforward. The shipment report made it easy to see the proceeds and fees. I’d use Card Conduit again no doubts. Highly recommend it.
I used the Sorted service to sell my MTG cards, and the process was straightforward. The shipment report made it easy to see the proceeds and fees. I’d use Card Conduit again no doubts. Highly recommend it.
Taylor
Review left Oct 29 2026
Shipment processed Oct 16 2026
Review
Thanks card conduit for always making this as painless as possible!
Thanks card conduit for always making this as painless as possible!
Great
Review left Oct 29 2026
Shipment processed Oct 06 2026
Review
Love this service! Card conduit is the best! Will use again
Love this service! Card conduit is the best! Will use again
Andy Mills
Review left Oct 29 2026
Review
The process was easy, this was the first order I have sent in where the amount was very different than what was initially displayed when I initially shipped my order. Otherwise it’s the easiest company to send cards into.
The process was easy, this was the first order I have sent in where the amount was very different than what was initially displayed when I initially shipped my order. Otherwise it’s the easiest company to send cards into.
Alec Hullinger
Review left Oct 29 2026
Review
I would never recommend card conduit, I believe with tens of thousands of cards I made about $10 total after the shipping fees. Cards were undervalued left and right, they penalize you with an absurd fee if they aren’t sorted before sending them as if that isn’t totally reasonable for such a petty service to do. Would never use again
I would never recommend card conduit, I believe with tens of thousands of cards I made about $10 total after the shipping fees. Cards were undervalued left and right, they penalize you with an absurd fee if they aren’t sorted before sending them as if that isn’t totally reasonable for such a petty service to do. Would never use again
Vinnie
Review left Oct 29 2026
Review
Easy process. They worked quickly to assess my large shipment of cards. Fair pricing. A+
Easy process. They worked quickly to assess my large shipment of cards. Fair pricing. A+
Mike N
Review left Oct 28 2026
Shipment processed Oct 19 2026
$660.89
payout, $34.78
fees
Review
Just finished my 3rd order and it was just as flawless as my first two. They processed the order quickly and I love the reports they send before confirming payment. Have has absolutely no issues and this will continue to be my preferred method of selling MTG cards.
Just finished my 3rd order and it was just as flawless as my first two. They processed the order quickly and I love the reports they send before confirming payment. Have has absolutely no issues and this will continue to be my preferred method of selling MTG cards.
Sam
Review left Oct 28 2026
Shipment processed Oct 26 2026
Review
Solid value, super easy and hands off, love the clear status of the workflow.
Solid value, super easy and hands off, love the clear status of the workflow.
Sean
Review left Oct 28 2026
Review
Sold cards, prices and previews came back at a reasonable time. Fast cash return. Would do again
Sold cards, prices and previews came back at a reasonable time. Fast cash return. Would do again
Jon
Review left Oct 28 2026
Review
Easy,fast and paid the most out of all the sites I saw.
Easy,fast and paid the most out of all the sites I saw.
Amy
Review left Oct 27 2026
Review
The thing I most liked about selling here was that I could see where my cards were in the process along the way. I also liked the final report and that I could download a CSV with how they graded everything etc.
The thing I most liked about selling here was that I could see where my cards were in the process along the way. I also liked the final report and that I could download a CSV with how they graded everything etc.
Ahmed Alahmady
Review left Oct 27 2026
Review
Great experience, fast turn around. Different service types let me group up my cards by value without worrying too much about sorting and all that other time consuming stuff.
Great experience, fast turn around. Different service types let me group up my cards by value without worrying too much about sorting and all that other time consuming stuff.
Dixie Taylor
Review left Oct 26 2026
Review
Using Card Conduit was super easy and totally worth it! Im working on a second batch to send them now. I recommend them 100%!
Using Card Conduit was super easy and totally worth it! Im working on a second batch to send them now. I recommend them 100%!
Great service
Review left Oct 26 2026
Review
My only complaint is the speed. However they are faster than I would be doing it solo
1100 payout and about a 50$ fee on thousands of cards
1100 payout and about a 50$ fee on thousands of cards
My only complaint is the speed. However they are faster than I would be doing it solo
1100 payout and about a 50$ fee on thousands of cards
1100 payout and about a 50$ fee on thousands of cards
Cody K
Review left Oct 25 2026
Review
Card Conduit makes it easy. I’ve used them a few times and each time have been pleased. The grading is a little harsher than I’m used too, but it’s fast and convenient. Will use again!
Card Conduit makes it easy. I’ve used them a few times and each time have been pleased. The grading is a little harsher than I’m used too, but it’s fast and convenient. Will use again!
Alex Bennett
Review left Oct 25 2026
Review
The process was easy even after dealing with some hiccups that was out of my control from my shipping provider. The extra fees were not terrible and if I ended up with a large bulk again later down the line I will definitely use this service again.
The process was easy even after dealing with some hiccups that was out of my control from my shipping provider. The extra fees were not terrible and if I ended up with a large bulk again later down the line I will definitely use this service again.
Zachary Kettell
Review left Oct 25 2026
Shipment processed Oct 20 2026
Review
The process was very straightforward and was handled quickly and professionally with great communication throughout
The process was very straightforward and was handled quickly and professionally with great communication throughout
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every
previous customer to leave a review.
Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page.
We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a
review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).