Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service
(6603)
Michael Weil
Review left Sep 02 2026
Review
Very easy smooth process with a fair price for my cards. I have sold a few orders with them now and am always satisfied. I would def recommend to anyone who wants a hassle-free way to offload some cards for some extra cash.
Very easy smooth process with a fair price for my cards. I have sold a few orders with them now and am always satisfied. I would def recommend to anyone who wants a hassle-free way to offload some cards for some extra cash.
Tim
Review left Sep 02 2026
Review
Thanks for processing my order. It is easy to send in the cards this way.
Thanks for processing my order. It is easy to send in the cards this way.
Tim
Review left Sep 01 2026
Review
The process was easy, not the first time I've sent in. Will do it again
The process was easy, not the first time I've sent in. Will do it again
Fast and Fair
Review left Sep 01 2026
Review
easy process to follow. Will be sending more cards for another order soon
easy process to follow. Will be sending more cards for another order soon
Chris H
Review left Sep 01 2026
Shipment processed Aug 21 2026
$442.08
payout, $9.02
fees
Review
My third experience with Card Conduit! The team made the whole submission process smooth, transparent, and completely stress-free. It’s rare to find a service that works this efficiently. They’ve set the standard for me, and I’ll exclusively be selling through them from now on.
My third experience with Card Conduit! The team made the whole submission process smooth, transparent, and completely stress-free. It’s rare to find a service that works this efficiently. They’ve set the standard for me, and I’ll exclusively be selling through them from now on.
5 stars all the way
Review left Sep 01 2026
Review
I never knew how to sell bulk and I wanted to get the most money I could. I found this site and gave it a try, and it was a great experience and I loved the results I got!
I never knew how to sell bulk and I wanted to get the most money I could. I found this site and gave it a try, and it was a great experience and I loved the results I got!
Matt Velardi
Review left Aug 31 2026
Review
Getting the cards ready to ship was a bit of a hassle, but well worth it to have all the worry about sorting and valuing and actually selling them completely out of my hands. Plus they were very polite and communicative at the end when it came to the evaluation and payment process.
Also, it's a b ... Read more
Also, it's a b ... Read more
Getting the cards ready to ship was a bit of a hassle, but well worth it to have all the worry about sorting and valuing and actually selling them completely out of my hands. Plus they were very polite and communicative at the end when it came to the evaluation and payment process.
Also, it's a bit expensive but if you're sending a lot of cards I definitely thought UPS pack and ship was worth it to cut down on the aforementioned hassle (~$200 for ~8000 cards).
Also, it's a bit expensive but if you're sending a lot of cards I definitely thought UPS pack and ship was worth it to cut down on the aforementioned hassle (~$200 for ~8000 cards).
Hunter Lambright
Review left Aug 31 2026
Review
Pricing was fair considering age and condition, simple, easy, just shipped off the cards and got an email about pricing after.
Pricing was fair considering age and condition, simple, easy, just shipped off the cards and got an email about pricing after.
James
Review left Aug 31 2026
Shipment processed Aug 19 2026
Review
It was very easy to send a large amount of cards at buylist costs and be updated throughout the process.
However I strongly disagreed on some of the conditions of cards that were determined. I had many high value $50-100 cards and they were all assessed to be HP-MP condition, lowering their value ... Read more
However I strongly disagreed on some of the conditions of cards that were determined. I had many high value $50-100 cards and they were all assessed to be HP-MP condition, lowering their value ... Read more
It was very easy to send a large amount of cards at buylist costs and be updated throughout the process.
However I strongly disagreed on some of the conditions of cards that were determined. I had many high value $50-100 cards and they were all assessed to be HP-MP condition, lowering their value massively. They say they use TCGPlayer for condition criteria but the ironic part is that I bought all these cards as NM from TCGPlayer themselves and didn't use them since.
How can the cards be Near Mint when I buy them from TCGPlayer and then Heavily Played when I sell them to Card Conduit after not using them?
However I strongly disagreed on some of the conditions of cards that were determined. I had many high value $50-100 cards and they were all assessed to be HP-MP condition, lowering their value massively. They say they use TCGPlayer for condition criteria but the ironic part is that I bought all these cards as NM from TCGPlayer themselves and didn't use them since.
How can the cards be Near Mint when I buy them from TCGPlayer and then Heavily Played when I sell them to Card Conduit after not using them?
Joseph Snyder
Review left Aug 30 2026
Review
I've never had a bad experience with Card Conduit.
Easy to use, Quick turnaround, and Communication with every step of the process.
The communication and clear guidelines on the site truly sets Card Conduit leaps and bounds ahead of any similar service.
Easy to use, Quick turnaround, and Communication with every step of the process.
The communication and clear guidelines on the site truly sets Card Conduit leaps and bounds ahead of any similar service.
I've never had a bad experience with Card Conduit.
Easy to use, Quick turnaround, and Communication with every step of the process.
The communication and clear guidelines on the site truly sets Card Conduit leaps and bounds ahead of any similar service.
Easy to use, Quick turnaround, and Communication with every step of the process.
The communication and clear guidelines on the site truly sets Card Conduit leaps and bounds ahead of any similar service.
Steve Morales
Review left Aug 30 2026
Review
It was accurate and the payment was quick. Will do business with this company again in the future.
It was accurate and the payment was quick. Will do business with this company again in the future.
Steve Moralesq
Review left Aug 30 2026
Shipment processed Aug 26 2026
Review
It was accurate and the payment was quick. Will do business with this company again in the future.
It was accurate and the payment was quick. Will do business with this company again in the future.
Steve Morales
Review left Aug 30 2026
Shipment processed Aug 20 2026
Review
It was accurate and the payment was quick. Will do business with this company again in the future.
It was accurate and the payment was quick. Will do business with this company again in the future.
Geoff
Review left Aug 30 2026
Shipment processed Jul 28 2026
$2,660.99
payout, $125.39
fees
Review
This is my second shipment to Card Conduit, and as before it was an easy, streamlined process. The trade is saving time, and for me it's well worth it. I would like to highlight their automated professionalism - all the stages of their intake, review and payment steps are clear and the timing of each is transparent. Thanks!
This is my second shipment to Card Conduit, and as before it was an easy, streamlined process. The trade is saving time, and for me it's well worth it. I would like to highlight their automated professionalism - all the stages of their intake, review and payment steps are clear and the timing of each is transparent. Thanks!
Jon
Review left Aug 30 2026
Review
Pretty seamless way to get fair value for a LOT of cards.
Pretty seamless way to get fair value for a LOT of cards.
marco
Review left Aug 30 2026
Review
always love to use card conduit. great service and prices
always love to use card conduit. great service and prices
marco
Review left Aug 30 2026
Review
always love to use card conduit. great service and prices
always love to use card conduit. great service and prices
S.M.
Review left Aug 29 2026
Review
I used the sorted service and it took some time, but in the end it was worth it to take the time to prepare my order.
I found the grading to be fair, and the quick payment was convenient. Online coupons from streamers and Card Conduit even gave me a little more off my fees.
Would use this service again.
I found the grading to be fair, and the quick payment was convenient. Online coupons from streamers and Card Conduit even gave me a little more off my fees.
Would use this service again.
I used the sorted service and it took some time, but in the end it was worth it to take the time to prepare my order.
I found the grading to be fair, and the quick payment was convenient. Online coupons from streamers and Card Conduit even gave me a little more off my fees.
Would use this service again.
I found the grading to be fair, and the quick payment was convenient. Online coupons from streamers and Card Conduit even gave me a little more off my fees.
Would use this service again.
S.M.
Review left Aug 29 2026
Review
I had a lot of good cards and tried selling online. But in the end, it was worth it to me to sell in bulk for a lump-sum payment and avoid all the ancillary shipping / meeting up with people to sell one card at a time.
I actually got more value than I thought I would. I found the grading to be fair. And payment was fast.
I actually got more value than I thought I would. I found the grading to be fair. And payment was fast.
I had a lot of good cards and tried selling online. But in the end, it was worth it to me to sell in bulk for a lump-sum payment and avoid all the ancillary shipping / meeting up with people to sell one card at a time.
I actually got more value than I thought I would. I found the grading to be fair. And payment was fast.
I actually got more value than I thought I would. I found the grading to be fair. And payment was fast.
S.M.
Review left Aug 29 2026
Review
I actually got more than I expected I was going to get. The grading was fair. The service was fast. So much easier for myself when I'm looking for a lump-sum payment on a collection. I tried selling online individual cards, but for a collection like mine, I valued getting paid today, rather than
...
Read more
I actually got more than I expected I was going to get. The grading was fair. The service was fast. So much easier for myself when I'm looking for a lump-sum payment on a collection. I tried selling online individual cards, but for a collection like mine, I valued getting paid today, rather than over the course of how-ever-long it would take to sell each one individually. And because I took the time to do the sorted service, the 2% fee was a fair price to have my cards graded. And I got a little more off the fees using some coupon codes from MartyMagic and Card Conduit. I would use this service again.
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every
previous customer to leave a review.
Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page.
We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a
review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).