Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service
(6304)
Ben Sammet
Review left Jun 23 2026
Review
The process was very easy and every step of Customer Support has been extraordinarily helpful and informative. I've had a rocky time getting my info right for ACH payment, and everyone has been quick to respond and truly helpful during the whole experience.
I even previously sent in a portion of ... Read more
I even previously sent in a portion of ... Read more
The process was very easy and every step of Customer Support has been extraordinarily helpful and informative. I've had a rocky time getting my info right for ACH payment, and everyone has been quick to respond and truly helpful during the whole experience.
I even previously sent in a portion of this bulk and when it wasn't worthwhile I was reached out to and given back the cards. I cannot believe the quality of service Card Conduit has.
I even previously sent in a portion of this bulk and when it wasn't worthwhile I was reached out to and given back the cards. I cannot believe the quality of service Card Conduit has.
Ben
Review left Jun 23 2026
Review
The auto sifting process was very easy to work with, the only real low point is that since you’re not necessarily looking each card up and then deciding to sell, there may be more bulk than you realize. And it’s not amazing seeing cards going for .003¢ although I do understand the trade off.
The auto sifting process was very easy to work with, the only real low point is that since you’re not necessarily looking each card up and then deciding to sell, there may be more bulk than you realize. And it’s not amazing seeing cards going for .003¢ although I do understand the trade off.
Zachariah Brown
Review left Jun 23 2026
Review
Fast liquidation, trusted. They responded to my request for why a card was grade lowered unexpectedly.
Fast liquidation, trusted. They responded to my request for why a card was grade lowered unexpectedly.
Matt Kahkonen
Review left Jun 23 2026
Review
This was a convenient way to sell a lot of MTG cards at prices higher than what I’d get at my LGS. Highly recommended.
This was a convenient way to sell a lot of MTG cards at prices higher than what I’d get at my LGS. Highly recommended.
brandon
Review left Jun 22 2026
Review
the grades i find unreasonable and i will be using cardkingdom for future buy lists.
the grades i find unreasonable and i will be using cardkingdom for future buy lists.
Milo
Review left Jun 22 2026
Review
The team at Card Conduit is really something. Responsive, follow up, follow through and everything was to the day as they explained. Their processes for fees are fair, the value given is respectable and the grading was accurate in my opinion. Turning a small box of unused cards into almost $900 is m
...
Read more
The team at Card Conduit is really something. Responsive, follow up, follow through and everything was to the day as they explained. Their processes for fees are fair, the value given is respectable and the grading was accurate in my opinion. Turning a small box of unused cards into almost $900 is magnificent. For the value they give, it is not worth selling the cards individually. I love my local game stores. They cannot afford to pay the rates Card Conduit pays. Joel from Joel are Magic uses Code: JOEL and I saved another few small cards worth of my money. Even the information given afterwards was easy to go through to make sure I was making sound decisions based on facts. This company and team rocks. Give them a try!!!
june
Review left Jun 22 2026
Review
awesome sauce awesome sauce awesomesauce awesome sauce
awesome sauce awesome sauce awesomesauce awesome sauce
Zak
Review left Jun 22 2026
Review
I have made a few shipments with Card Conduit and they have all gone smoothly and I've been pleased with the prices offered.
I have made a few shipments with Card Conduit and they have all gone smoothly and I've been pleased with the prices offered.
Daniel B
Review left Jun 22 2026
Review
I appreciate Card Conduit for being my broker for my extra or super collectable cards. If I am ever need to tap into my cardboard investments, Card Conduit continues to be my first choice. They are more lucrative then my local game stores who cannot offer the same attention to some of my bigger priced cards.
I appreciate Card Conduit for being my broker for my extra or super collectable cards. If I am ever need to tap into my cardboard investments, Card Conduit continues to be my first choice. They are more lucrative then my local game stores who cannot offer the same attention to some of my bigger priced cards.
Daniel H
Review left Jun 21 2026
Review
Was timely at grading and giving a report. Payment was prompt and fair pricing
Was timely at grading and giving a report. Payment was prompt and fair pricing
Jonathan Walesiewicz
Review left Jun 21 2026
Review
I appreciate the different services Card Conduit provides. I feel they give great value for the cards, as well as saves me hours from sorting through cards. Thank you!
I appreciate the different services Card Conduit provides. I feel they give great value for the cards, as well as saves me hours from sorting through cards. Thank you!
Seth Taylor
Review left Jun 20 2026
Review
I am incredibly impressed with Card Conduit. They make it so easy to sell cards, and the returns are better than any local store I have sold to.
I am incredibly impressed with Card Conduit. They make it so easy to sell cards, and the returns are better than any local store I have sold to.
Joel Reschke
Review left Jun 20 2026
Review
Very smooth as usual, this is my go to for selling from here on out.
Very smooth as usual, this is my go to for selling from here on out.
Paul
Review left Jun 20 2026
Review
Process was super easy, and the value spot on. 10/10 would recommend.
Process was super easy, and the value spot on. 10/10 would recommend.
Randy
Review left Jun 20 2026
Review
Love this process. So easy to get money for stuff I have laying around that I don't have the time or energy to sell individually myself. They're very transparent and quick to respond if I have questions
Love this process. So easy to get money for stuff I have laying around that I don't have the time or energy to sell individually myself. They're very transparent and quick to respond if I have questions
Caleb
Review left Jun 20 2026
Review
Nothing much to say really, the whole process was smooth, and the prices were decently fair
Nothing much to say really, the whole process was smooth, and the prices were decently fair
Marco
Review left Jun 20 2026
Review
used them a lot. quick communication. GOOD prices.
used them a lot. quick communication. GOOD prices.
Marco
Review left Jun 20 2026
Review
used them a lot. quick communication. GOOD prices.
used them a lot. quick communication. GOOD prices.
Marco
Review left Jun 20 2026
Review
used them a lot. quick communication. GOOD prices.
used them a lot. quick communication. GOOD prices.
Marco
Review left Jun 20 2026
Review
used them a lot. quick communication. GOOD prices.
used them a lot. quick communication. GOOD prices.
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every
previous customer to leave a review.
Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page.
We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a
review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).