Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service
(6840)
Robert Kaplan
Review left Oct 15 2026
Review
The process from beginning to end was painless, and I trust them with the cards, I feel they have offered very reasonable grading, and I have never felt offered less then what they were worth. Thank you so much!
The process from beginning to end was painless, and I trust them with the cards, I feel they have offered very reasonable grading, and I have never felt offered less then what they were worth. Thank you so much!
Andrew Teske
Review left Oct 15 2026
Review
Process was quite easy. The only issue was on my end, I didn't realize I'd marked a single card as from M15 as some other option with a 15 in it. But the second I saw the review sheet I realized it was my own error. Everything on their end went smooth!
Process was quite easy. The only issue was on my end, I didn't realize I'd marked a single card as from M15 as some other option with a 15 in it. But the second I saw the review sheet I realized it was my own error. Everything on their end went smooth!
James B
Review left Oct 15 2026
Review
Honestly everything was pretty amazing. I used the auto sorting process and overall am very happy with Card Conduit.
Honestly everything was pretty amazing. I used the auto sorting process and overall am very happy with Card Conduit.
Meghan
Review left Oct 14 2026
Shipment processed Sep 04 2026
Review
The website has an easy/helpful guide for people who have not shipped cards before. The ability to presort or send in bulk works well as time allows. I felt great about the updates on my shipment, the response to me reaching out and was very happy with my payment amount. The cost for sorting service
...
Read more
The website has an easy/helpful guide for people who have not shipped cards before. The ability to presort or send in bulk works well as time allows. I felt great about the updates on my shipment, the response to me reaching out and was very happy with my payment amount. The cost for sorting services was very reasonable and I was happy with the payout I received for the minimal amount of work I had to do on my end. Would highly recommend.
Amy Morgan
Review left Oct 14 2026
Review
Card conduit was super easy to deal with, and this is coming from someone with zero knowledge or experience with magic the gathering cards. I sent them in 150 cards and received 350 dollars total after fees. They emailed me and thoroughly explained the amount they were giving me. The whole process w
...
Read more
Card conduit was super easy to deal with, and this is coming from someone with zero knowledge or experience with magic the gathering cards. I sent them in 150 cards and received 350 dollars total after fees. They emailed me and thoroughly explained the amount they were giving me. The whole process was easy, super fast from start to finish and I'll be sending them another batch of cards in just a few days actually. I highly recommend them.
Owen
Review left Oct 14 2026
Shipment processed Oct 05 2026
Review
I used the sorted service and it is very easy to search for and enter the cards you wish to sell. Shipping is simple. Card grading was fair and payment was quick.
I used the sorted service and it is very easy to search for and enter the cards you wish to sell. Shipping is simple. Card grading was fair and payment was quick.
Jamal
Review left Oct 14 2026
Review
Was pretty easy and fast! Overall a really good experience!!
Was pretty easy and fast! Overall a really good experience!!
Joe Kiefer-Lucas
Review left Oct 14 2026
Review
Definitely recommend. Quick responses, prompt payment. No issues
Definitely recommend. Quick responses, prompt payment. No issues
John Lloyd
Review left Oct 13 2026
Review
These guys are awesome reply very quickly and the customer service is great easy way to get some cash for your collection without having to sell them yourself and I would 100% use them again
These guys are awesome reply very quickly and the customer service is great easy way to get some cash for your collection without having to sell them yourself and I would 100% use them again
David
Review left Oct 13 2026
Shipment processed Sep 21 2026
Review
The entire process with Card Conduit was quick, efficient, and transparent from start to finish. Their communication was excellent; the pricing and fees were clearly outlined, and the turnaround time was impressive. Everything was straightforward and hassle-free. I highly recommend Card Conduit to a
...
Read more
The entire process with Card Conduit was quick, efficient, and transparent from start to finish. Their communication was excellent; the pricing and fees were clearly outlined, and the turnaround time was impressive. Everything was straightforward and hassle-free. I highly recommend Card Conduit to anyone looking for a reliable and convenient way to sell their Magic cards!
Josh Cunningham
Review left Oct 13 2026
Review
Speedy processing and fair card grading! I will continue using Card Conduit when selling my extras!
Speedy processing and fair card grading! I will continue using Card Conduit when selling my extras!
michael
Review left Oct 13 2026
Review
Every time I need to sell cards card conduit is the first place I go . I have never had a bad experience. Fast and easy, they are top tier quality when it comes to getting money for mtg cards
Every time I need to sell cards card conduit is the first place I go . I have never had a bad experience. Fast and easy, they are top tier quality when it comes to getting money for mtg cards
stephen Smith
Review left Oct 13 2026
Review
process was easy, pricing was fair, order was done in a timely fashion
process was easy, pricing was fair, order was done in a timely fashion
Kathy K
Review left Oct 12 2026
Review
The process was very easy and transparent. The website is very clear about options, valuations, and gives you plenty of choices of how you want your cards processed, depending on how involved you want to be. I didn't have a lot of cards to send, and I was curious, so I spent some time checking my ca
...
Read more
The process was very easy and transparent. The website is very clear about options, valuations, and gives you plenty of choices of how you want your cards processed, depending on how involved you want to be. I didn't have a lot of cards to send, and I was curious, so I spent some time checking my cards on their card valuation tool so I could get a general idea of what was worthwhile to send. Once I shipped out the cards, it was easy to track where they were in the process. I was happy with the report and the payout. Overall it was a very positive experience.
Derek
Review left Oct 12 2026
Shipment processed Oct 01 2026
Review
I have a large amount of bulk sub $10 rares that I wanted to offload and this was a painless process. I appreciate the service and the user interface. Thank you for existing.
I have a large amount of bulk sub $10 rares that I wanted to offload and this was a painless process. I appreciate the service and the user interface. Thank you for existing.
Jacob Bissonnette
Review left Oct 11 2026
Review
The process was pretty easy. I sent my shipment in a somewhat irregular box and was worried my cards weren’t going to be processed correctly. Communication with the team was consistent and timely throughout the process and they handled my inquiries well. Overall 10/10 would use again if the need arose.
The process was pretty easy. I sent my shipment in a somewhat irregular box and was worried my cards weren’t going to be processed correctly. Communication with the team was consistent and timely throughout the process and they handled my inquiries well. Overall 10/10 would use again if the need arose.
Matthew
Review left Oct 11 2026
Review
I love using cardconduit to sell my mtg cards. I have been using the site for two years and will continue using it in the future.
I love using cardconduit to sell my mtg cards. I have been using the site for two years and will continue using it in the future.
Justin Soria
Review left Oct 10 2026
Shipment processed Oct 01 2026
Review
Process was easy, decent value for cards. Ofcourse the more expensive cards submitted are allegedly lower quality condition. I highly disagree with a lot of the cards placed in the lower condition brackets. Because they'll probably be sold in the NM category.
Process was easy, decent value for cards. Ofcourse the more expensive cards submitted are allegedly lower quality condition. I highly disagree with a lot of the cards placed in the lower condition brackets. Because they'll probably be sold in the NM category.
Matthew Daly
Review left Oct 10 2026
Review
The process was easy and it was a great relief to not have to sort a massive amount of cards
The process was easy and it was a great relief to not have to sort a massive amount of cards
Reggie T
Review left Oct 10 2026
Review
Great payout, fair grading and assessment, and had money deposited into my Zelle promptly. So much easier than listing myself.
Great payout, fair grading and assessment, and had money deposited into my Zelle promptly. So much easier than listing myself.
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every
previous customer to leave a review.
Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page.
We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a
review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).