Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service
(6073)
Drew Carlson
Review left May 06 2026
Review
I had a couple friends use this service and they were right…it’s a great value and very easy to use. I was updated throughout the process and I thought my payout was extremely fair. Will I use Card Conduit again…absolutely!
I had a couple friends use this service and they were right…it’s a great value and very easy to use. I was updated throughout the process and I thought my payout was extremely fair. Will I use Card Conduit again…absolutely!
Tyler H
Review left May 05 2026
Review
I came away super happy tbh! The return amount I got was much higher than I expected to get back & multiple people I’ve told were also impressed! I was sad to see so many cards go; but I needed the money & they kind of saved me!
I came away super happy tbh! The return amount I got was much higher than I expected to get back & multiple people I’ve told were also impressed! I was sad to see so many cards go; but I needed the money & they kind of saved me!
Luke
Review left May 05 2026
Shipment processed Apr 11 2026
Review
Convenient way of getting rid of unwanted bulk and valuable cards. Like how organized the value charts
Convenient way of getting rid of unwanted bulk and valuable cards. Like how organized the value charts
Kyle S
Review left May 05 2026
Review
Made a lot more money with a few thousand cards than I would in store credit. Great service.
Made a lot more money with a few thousand cards than I would in store credit. Great service.
mARCUS
Review left May 05 2026
Review
great prices... will always sell to them.. thank you
great prices... will always sell to them.. thank you
mARCUS
Review left May 05 2026
Review
great prices... will always sell to them.. thank you
great prices... will always sell to them.. thank you
Phil
Review left May 04 2026
Review
Stress and complication are a big issue for me. Cardconduit removed all that entirely. I recommend them to everyone who even jokes about selling some of their collection. I will be using them again for sure.
Stress and complication are a big issue for me. Cardconduit removed all that entirely. I recommend them to everyone who even jokes about selling some of their collection. I will be using them again for sure.
Mitch Jahnke
Review left May 04 2026
Review
Will continue to use when I plan on selling cards.
Will continue to use when I plan on selling cards.
Taylor Myers
Review left May 04 2026
Review
Straight forward process with concise instructions. Works really nice with moxfield and importing lists from there. Have already sent off a second shipment of cards, and will probably use again down the road!
Straight forward process with concise instructions. Works really nice with moxfield and importing lists from there. Have already sent off a second shipment of cards, and will probably use again down the road!
Blaine John Schultz
Review left May 03 2026
Review
This was just so easy. I mailed my cards with sleeves, and they took care of it. Grading was spot on and payment was fast and secure. I would recommended this company to anyone. Have been in MTG since 1993 and this is a service I would use anytime to selling. I did not have many cards the first time
...
Read more
This was just so easy. I mailed my cards with sleeves, and they took care of it. Grading was spot on and payment was fast and secure. I would recommended this company to anyone. Have been in MTG since 1993 and this is a service I would use anytime to selling. I did not have many cards the first time, but I am already on my second shipment. 100% trust. Great service. Thank you all so much, I appreciate it.
Nico Baron
Review left May 03 2026
Review
Great value and smooth transaction - transparency with the card values that resulted in a lower payment (fine with me) and easy to use the curated listing service. Even if I messed up 'The List' cards - CC team was able to remedy those mixups and correct the associated values.
This is the 3rd time I've used them, been beyond impressed each time.
This is the 3rd time I've used them, been beyond impressed each time.
Great value and smooth transaction - transparency with the card values that resulted in a lower payment (fine with me) and easy to use the curated listing service. Even if I messed up 'The List' cards - CC team was able to remedy those mixups and correct the associated values.
This is the 3rd time I've used them, been beyond impressed each time.
This is the 3rd time I've used them, been beyond impressed each time.
Robert Rose
Review left May 03 2026
Review
Great easy process and awesome way to get rid of excess bulk. Had an ACH issue where my bank refused the transaction and returned the payment. Nathaniel was awesome about the whole process and found an alternative way to make the transaction.
Great easy process and awesome way to get rid of excess bulk. Had an ACH issue where my bank refused the transaction and returned the payment. Nathaniel was awesome about the whole process and found an alternative way to make the transaction.
Avery
Review left May 03 2026
Review
Easy to deal with as they always are this service is always easy for selling cards
Easy to deal with as they always are this service is always easy for selling cards
Leif
Review left May 02 2026
Review
I like you guys, because everything is spelled out before. People see what is required before selling to you. The terms are right there no guessing games. No bullshit. Fast payment once delivery report is appoved. Contact is open quick, any concerns taken care of. These guys are trustworthy.
I like you guys, because everything is spelled out before. People see what is required before selling to you. The terms are right there no guessing games. No bullshit. Fast payment once delivery report is appoved. Contact is open quick, any concerns taken care of. These guys are trustworthy.
Aaron C
Review left May 02 2026
Review
Submitted my collection as I am getting out of the game and struggled to get decent offers locally. A friend recommended me CC so I said what the heck I’ll give it a shot. Ended up getting a great/fair offer on my collection in about a week from when it was shipped/received. I’d definitely go through with them again in the future!
Submitted my collection as I am getting out of the game and struggled to get decent offers locally. A friend recommended me CC so I said what the heck I’ll give it a shot. Ended up getting a great/fair offer on my collection in about a week from when it was shipped/received. I’d definitely go through with them again in the future!
Nick Shively
Review left May 02 2026
Review
Was able to get a decent amount for a few thousand cards that I was likely never to sort through. The price was definitely worth the convenience for me!
Was able to get a decent amount for a few thousand cards that I was likely never to sort through. The price was definitely worth the convenience for me!
Lisa H
Review left May 02 2026
Shipment processed Feb 11 2026
Review
I was extremely impressed with the clear instructions and continuous communication. I even had some questions about my quote and they were able
To answer very detailed to make sure I was comfortable with the discrepancy between my data and their quote. I would highly
Recommend this service.
To answer very detailed to make sure I was comfortable with the discrepancy between my data and their quote. I would highly
Recommend this service.
I was extremely impressed with the clear instructions and continuous communication. I even had some questions about my quote and they were able
To answer very detailed to make sure I was comfortable with the discrepancy between my data and their quote. I would highly
Recommend this service.
To answer very detailed to make sure I was comfortable with the discrepancy between my data and their quote. I would highly
Recommend this service.
Ryan Rutledge
Review left May 01 2026
Review
I was kept informed throughout the entire process.
Given a fair estimate.
Accepted the offer then the money was in my account the next day.
10/10
Given a fair estimate.
Accepted the offer then the money was in my account the next day.
10/10
I was kept informed throughout the entire process.
Given a fair estimate.
Accepted the offer then the money was in my account the next day.
10/10
Given a fair estimate.
Accepted the offer then the money was in my account the next day.
10/10
Bob
Review left May 01 2026
Review
The whole process is super simple and easy to do, especially with all the import file formats they support. My only suggestion is they should have a page outlining how cards are graded as stuff i viewed as all near mint was graded lightly played. Would still recommend to friends though!
The whole process is super simple and easy to do, especially with all the import file formats they support. My only suggestion is they should have a page outlining how cards are graded as stuff i viewed as all near mint was graded lightly played. Would still recommend to friends though!
Huy
Review left May 01 2026
Review
Third time selling. CC made it easy and simple. Will sale more soon.
Third time selling. CC made it easy and simple. Will sale more soon.
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every
previous customer to leave a review.
Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page.
We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a
review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).