Customer Reviews

of our Magic collection selling service

I’ve noticed a change like some others have who’ve been using CC for several years now. I’ve submitted roughly 10 orders to CC. I began noticing a change in their standard for grading in a previous submission. However, now it’s more than clear the changes. Now, I’m submitting cards pulled directly from packs that are not foil and receiving immediate LP conditioning and not NM as often.

Clearly, we should all be aware that card conditions are not Mint out of a pack. However, to say that they are not Near Mint out of a package the majority of the time is very laughable. This submission had many cards that came direct from packs only a few days before shipping to CC.

I just opened two more boxes of MaKM and as usual pulled a ton of Surveil Lands and other good cards. Why should I send them to CC only to be instantly be hit with LP conditioning on cards and losing out Selling individual cards myself while also only sending cards to CC that are clearly in the HP to LP condition already, because you’ll be automatically downgraded to a lower rating if NM and the price difference between LP and NM is a wide enough gap to try and sneak one past your customers?

After submitting my complaint, the person (maybe a human) replied back with what you’d expect to hear. However, I do love that they mentioned it wouldn’t he in CC’s interest to down grade cards, because they don’t sell them to vendors at a different grade. But, you’ll notice something, there’s no proof to say they don’t just mark the card’s condition higher when selling to vendors.

Ultimately, rating I give is purely based on how they grade the cards. Everything else is smooth as usual and easy to do. However, at this point, CC isn’t a new company and now they can get away with not being as generous and fair with their grading since it’s obvious their name is now out there. I’ll maybe come back in a year to two and see if things have changed, but we shall see.