Customer Reviews

of our Magic collection selling service

In terms of the advertised service everything went very well. I did the sorted service and used their website to build the list and put everything in order, it was fast and easy. I was very disappointed in the grading particularly of the most valuable cards. My #1 most valuable card which was never played and went straight into a sleeve graded as LP and my 3rd most valuable card did the same thing. This would be less annoying if there was some even distribution of card grades but the LP grade was really biased towards the most valuable cards in my shipment, which I find questionable. I ultimately decided to proceed with the payment since shipping with tracking was ~$30 anyways. If you plan to use this service I would set an expectation level around 80% of the advertised price, even if you consider all cards NM. Otherwise the other features of this service were as advertised. It is a good way to unload bulk but if I were to do it again I would prefer to do the legwork myself for any card over $20.