Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service
(4486)
Brenden Griffith
Review left Mar 31 2025
Review
An overall great experience, really helped with quickly clearing out my old collection!
An overall great experience, really helped with quickly clearing out my old collection!
Devin
Review left Mar 31 2025
Review
The process of selling magic cards with card conduit was seamless from sorting and shipping the cards to receiving payment. If selling and haggling over cards seems daunting, card conduit is the route to take. Curb your expectations on the payout though!
The process of selling magic cards with card conduit was seamless from sorting and shipping the cards to receiving payment. If selling and haggling over cards seems daunting, card conduit is the route to take. Curb your expectations on the payout though!
Alex H
Review left Mar 30 2025
Review
Always great service and turnaround times! Honestly the submission site is so cool, and hi-tech, and I always feel confident in submitting cards to Card Conduit.
Always great service and turnaround times! Honestly the submission site is so cool, and hi-tech, and I always feel confident in submitting cards to Card Conduit.
Kevin Preston
Review left Mar 29 2025
Review
The process was super simple! The prices are more than fair usually around 80% of market value! They make it everything super easy.
The process was super simple! The prices are more than fair usually around 80% of market value! They make it everything super easy.
Eric K.
Review left Mar 29 2025
Review
easy way for me to offload both bulk and value cards that I no longer need, always great sending cards here
easy way for me to offload both bulk and value cards that I no longer need, always great sending cards here
Kevin Litner
Review left Mar 29 2025
Review
Smooth transaction, I think they grade foils a little roughly, but no real complaints
Smooth transaction, I think they grade foils a little roughly, but no real complaints
Eric Williams
Review left Mar 29 2025
Review
A few tips, filter even bulk uncommon they are not worth nearly as much as you may think and it could save time and the cost it takes to break down your shipment. Some cards were not worth anything but you still have .3 cents a card so that eats into the commission and sales. Do your homework but th
...
Read more
A few tips, filter even bulk uncommon they are not worth nearly as much as you may think and it could save time and the cost it takes to break down your shipment. Some cards were not worth anything but you still have .3 cents a card so that eats into the commission and sales. Do your homework but this was so easy and nice. I just spent a week gathering every decent magic card that I could find laying around in boxes and sent in a large box.
Caleb Tresky
Review left Mar 28 2025
Review
The process was super easy, fast and the directions were easy to understand. I would 100% recommend this company.
The process was super easy, fast and the directions were easy to understand. I would 100% recommend this company.
Joseph Torres
Review left Mar 28 2025
Review
Answered all my questions quickly. Showed me every issue I had a question about as to why the conditions were classified as they were. Great service. Would definitely use again.
Answered all my questions quickly. Showed me every issue I had a question about as to why the conditions were classified as they were. Great service. Would definitely use again.
John
Review left Mar 28 2025
Review
Overall it was a great experience working with CC. While the process of checking each card against their list is definitely a time investment, they're very clear up front about how it works. The communication during the shipment and processing flow was very good and they're very upfront about the ca
...
Read more
Overall it was a great experience working with CC. While the process of checking each card against their list is definitely a time investment, they're very clear up front about how it works. The communication during the shipment and processing flow was very good and they're very upfront about the card conditions. I would definitely use them again. One thing that I think would improve things is when they provide a collection estimate, if they could provide a condition range as well... their estimates assume NM condition, which for older sets is probably not too realistic, so having a range for other conditions would be informative as well.
Cole
Review left Mar 28 2025
Review
Fast, easy, and more than fair grading. Will use their service again.
Fast, easy, and more than fair grading. Will use their service again.
Gabe
Review left Mar 28 2025
Review
Really great service offered here. I went with the sorted option since I actually enjoy sorting and packaging my cards up, but selling them one by one is too much effort for not enough profit. But with Card Conduit, I was able to submit my cards and got paid an extremely fair amount very quickly after it was processed! 10/10 will use them again!
Really great service offered here. I went with the sorted option since I actually enjoy sorting and packaging my cards up, but selling them one by one is too much effort for not enough profit. But with Card Conduit, I was able to submit my cards and got paid an extremely fair amount very quickly after it was processed! 10/10 will use them again!
Kizzianne Zaborowski
Review left Mar 27 2025
Review
Selling cards that aren't mine, not a player and don't have time to investigate the value of each card. Card Conduit was recommended by a relative who previously worked at another grading/reselling company. I feel I got great value for my first curated shipment, far more than I was expecting. I have
...
Read more
Selling cards that aren't mine, not a player and don't have time to investigate the value of each card. Card Conduit was recommended by a relative who previously worked at another grading/reselling company. I feel I got great value for my first curated shipment, far more than I was expecting. I have since used the price check tool to spot check some of the additional bulk cards I have and was pleasantly surprised at the values. The comprehensive report made me feel very confident that I wasn't being lowballed.
Chris Coakley
Review left Mar 27 2025
Review
Process was simple, well explained, and prompt. The grading was fair for all submitted cards, and pricing was competitive. Will absolutely use again.
Process was simple, well explained, and prompt. The grading was fair for all submitted cards, and pricing was competitive. Will absolutely use again.
Samantha Lowe
Review left Mar 27 2025
Review
I would absolutely recommend Card Conduit to anyone looking to downsize their collection, or even just to unload bulk! The process is so simple and you get paid well!
I would absolutely recommend Card Conduit to anyone looking to downsize their collection, or even just to unload bulk! The process is so simple and you get paid well!
John Brett Linton
Review left Mar 27 2025
Review
I liked the outcome of this shipment. I really appreciate the discount also. Have a great day 😀
I liked the outcome of this shipment. I really appreciate the discount also. Have a great day 😀
John Brett Linton
Review left Mar 27 2025
Review
Overall I was pleased. Just couldn't understand that every card that was actually worth something, the grading was either LP OR MP. CARDS that just came out of the pack. I know in shipment they could be damaged. I generally look at front , back and sides of cards. Actually took some pictur
...
Read more
Overall I was pleased. Just couldn't understand that every card that was actually worth something, the grading was either LP OR MP. CARDS that just came out of the pack. I know in shipment they could be damaged. I generally look at front , back and sides of cards. Actually took some pictures. It's all water under the bridge now. Thank you for your time. Have a great day.
John Brett Linton
Review left Mar 27 2025
Review
Thank you for what you do. I will definitely use yall again. Have a great day 😀
Thank you for what you do. I will definitely use yall again. Have a great day 😀
Tyler
Review left Mar 26 2025
Review
3rd time using this service and I loved how easy and efficient it is
3rd time using this service and I loved how easy and efficient it is
Neil T Merrick
Review left Mar 26 2025
Review
I find the experience overall good, I think the grading is extremely harsh but whatever. The communication was excellent and payment was quick.
I find the experience overall good, I think the grading is extremely harsh but whatever. The communication was excellent and payment was quick.
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every
previous customer to leave a review.
Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page.
We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a
review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).