Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service
(6305)
Shawn R.
Review left May 25 2026
Review
Thank you for the expedited processing, even during the holidays. I appreciate the service.
Thank you for the expedited processing, even during the holidays. I appreciate the service.
Harvey Whiting
Review left May 23 2026
Review
The process was very easy, and prompt. I was however a little disappointed with the value I got back. I use manna box and frequently check tcg player. I was told that some of my higher value foils were “clouded” and I was dinged for card quality a bit more than I thought was fair. I only rec
...
Read more
The process was very easy, and prompt. I was however a little disappointed with the value I got back. I use manna box and frequently check tcg player. I was told that some of my higher value foils were “clouded” and I was dinged for card quality a bit more than I thought was fair. I only recieved a little more than $8.00 for a foil super shredder. I feel like having to take the cards out of sleeves caused this issue. I tried to pack them as tightly as I could, but shipping carriers don’t treat things with the best of care at times. The market value I assessed on my cards was about $800. I was hoping to get about 60% of that, $450-$480. I recieved $367 dollars. I feel that was a bit low.
Leo Howell
Review left May 23 2026
Review
Have used Card Conduit multiple times now and every time it's been fair, easy and quick. The team does a great job, the process is very easy and transparent, and I get money quickly for cards I don't need.
Have used Card Conduit multiple times now and every time it's been fair, easy and quick. The team does a great job, the process is very easy and transparent, and I get money quickly for cards I don't need.
Sean Larsen
Review left May 23 2026
Review
Was super easy to do. Appreciate the process transparency - the full report is nice to have
Was super easy to do. Appreciate the process transparency - the full report is nice to have
Great service
Review left May 23 2026
Review
Good stuff. I've used twice and plan to continue to use indefinitely.
Good stuff. I've used twice and plan to continue to use indefinitely.
Joel Reschke
Review left May 23 2026
Review
This was the smoothest sale with some of the best communication I've ever had selling cards. It'll be tough for another company to earn my business in the future over Card Conduit.
This was the smoothest sale with some of the best communication I've ever had selling cards. It'll be tough for another company to earn my business in the future over Card Conduit.
Adam
Review left May 23 2026
Review
I have used your service only a couple of times and you all made it so easy. I will gladly use it again, thanks!
I have used your service only a couple of times and you all made it so easy. I will gladly use it again, thanks!
Zach
Review left May 23 2026
Review
Process was extremely easy and I got way more for my cards than I was expecting, definitely using this service again.
Process was extremely easy and I got way more for my cards than I was expecting, definitely using this service again.
Brandon
Review left May 22 2026
Shipment processed May 13 2026
Review
Quoted me a price before sent in, sorted at better values than I gave them in the estimate, the paid way less, I accepted as I just wanted the cards out of the house.. they paid $0 on 10lbs of cards on 1 of my 3 boxes.. I will never ever.. ever use them again or recommend anyone ever even spitting in the direction of this company.
Quoted me a price before sent in, sorted at better values than I gave them in the estimate, the paid way less, I accepted as I just wanted the cards out of the house.. they paid $0 on 10lbs of cards on 1 of my 3 boxes.. I will never ever.. ever use them again or recommend anyone ever even spitting in the direction of this company.
Miles
Review left May 22 2026
Review
Very easy process, good communication and quick turnaround. The spreadsheet was very informative and very nice to see what you were getting and what everything was marked as.
Very easy process, good communication and quick turnaround. The spreadsheet was very informative and very nice to see what you were getting and what everything was marked as.
Jared
Review left May 22 2026
Review
Too many companies nowadays are not transparent and forthcoming to the consumer, however, Conduit is an exception.
They provide a detailed report of each of your cards' condition and value, so you know exactly where your money is coming from. Additionally, I had a good experience with their custo ... Read more
They provide a detailed report of each of your cards' condition and value, so you know exactly where your money is coming from. Additionally, I had a good experience with their custo ... Read more
Too many companies nowadays are not transparent and forthcoming to the consumer, however, Conduit is an exception.
They provide a detailed report of each of your cards' condition and value, so you know exactly where your money is coming from. Additionally, I had a good experience with their customer service.
Their prices were fair. Not much more you can ask for. Card Conduit is worth supporting.
They provide a detailed report of each of your cards' condition and value, so you know exactly where your money is coming from. Additionally, I had a good experience with their customer service.
Their prices were fair. Not much more you can ask for. Card Conduit is worth supporting.
Lessia Fagg
Review left May 22 2026
Review
process was easy and fair in price saved me tons of time looking up cards then listing to waiting for a sale card conduit is the way to go to sell your card collection
process was easy and fair in price saved me tons of time looking up cards then listing to waiting for a sale card conduit is the way to go to sell your card collection
Ross Laskowski
Review left May 21 2026
Shipment processed May 12 2026
$3,188.11
payout, $167.79
fees
Review
Quite literally just packed the stuff I didn’t want up, took it to the post office, shipped it to ‘em, and they took care of the rest! I will absolutely be sending them more stuff soon!
Quite literally just packed the stuff I didn’t want up, took it to the post office, shipped it to ‘em, and they took care of the rest! I will absolutely be sending them more stuff soon!
Robert K.
Review left May 21 2026
Review
So far so good, have had no complaints, and they've been true to their word every time. Appreciate you guys.
So far so good, have had no complaints, and they've been true to their word every time. Appreciate you guys.
JD
Review left May 20 2026
Review
Overall it was a good process. The communication was strong and while they grade a little harder than TCG Players standards, they are fair. The only thing I found frustrating was how much my collection value shifted while in transit, and then again after grading. After grading there was one card tha
...
Read more
Overall it was a good process. The communication was strong and while they grade a little harder than TCG Players standards, they are fair. The only thing I found frustrating was how much my collection value shifted while in transit, and then again after grading. After grading there was one card that was worth more to me in my collection than being traded in. and they shipped that back no issues. Would use the service again, but might be more selective on what I sent
Bingo
Review left May 20 2026
Review
I don’t normally leave reviews, but after my last two experiences with CardConduit, I will no longer be utilizing their service
I’m sure a member of their team will vehemently defend their grading practices, but they’re absurd. Cards I know I purchased from reputable sellers at NM, envelope ... Read more
I’m sure a member of their team will vehemently defend their grading practices, but they’re absurd. Cards I know I purchased from reputable sellers at NM, envelope ... Read more
I don’t normally leave reviews, but after my last two experiences with CardConduit, I will no longer be utilizing their service
I’m sure a member of their team will vehemently defend their grading practices, but they’re absurd. Cards I know I purchased from reputable sellers at NM, envelope to sleeve, marked as MP
You’ll have far more luck getting reasonable grading from Card Kingdom. I’m no professional, and again, I’m sure they’ll write me off as some jaded dork who expected too much, but when the high end of your trade in is $900, and you end up with less than $500, for well-cared for cards, something is amuck.
The process is easy, and if you’re looking for a quick turnaround, this may still be the simplest route.
I’m sure a member of their team will vehemently defend their grading practices, but they’re absurd. Cards I know I purchased from reputable sellers at NM, envelope to sleeve, marked as MP
You’ll have far more luck getting reasonable grading from Card Kingdom. I’m no professional, and again, I’m sure they’ll write me off as some jaded dork who expected too much, but when the high end of your trade in is $900, and you end up with less than $500, for well-cared for cards, something is amuck.
The process is easy, and if you’re looking for a quick turnaround, this may still be the simplest route.
Eli Guthrie
Review left May 20 2026
Review
The process was easy. Took awhile to get the check. I think I got a good deal on the cards. Some cards I thought to be near mint - did not get the price I wanted.
The process was easy. Took awhile to get the check. I think I got a good deal on the cards. Some cards I thought to be near mint - did not get the price I wanted.
Tyler Coit
Review left May 20 2026
Review
Spent a couple hours sorting and whatnot but it was well worth it. Will be doing this again in the future!
Spent a couple hours sorting and whatnot but it was well worth it. Will be doing this again in the future!
Avery Dorko
Review left May 20 2026
Review
I was not impressed with the quality of grading I got one particular card, but I have overall had great experiences with this service, so I cannot complain on the whole.
I was not impressed with the quality of grading I got one particular card, but I have overall had great experiences with this service, so I cannot complain on the whole.
Joe
Review left May 20 2026
Review
CC staff were very quick to answer a question I had about the condition of a ~$30 card that I thought might have been graded incorrectly. A few hours after I sent my question I received a detailed explanation of the card's condition, including high-res photos of the flaws. The attention to detail an
...
Read more
CC staff were very quick to answer a question I had about the condition of a ~$30 card that I thought might have been graded incorrectly. A few hours after I sent my question I received a detailed explanation of the card's condition, including high-res photos of the flaws. The attention to detail and a fast, thorough response made me confident that CC's grading and pricing systems are transparent and accurate, especially since I got about what I expected from the other 194 cards I shipped.
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every
previous customer to leave a review.
Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page.
We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a
review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).