Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service
(5629)
Kyle
Review left Sep 18 2025
Review
Super easy process. Very nice and professional. Would definitely recommend.
Super easy process. Very nice and professional. Would definitely recommend.
Kyle
Review left Sep 18 2025
Review
I mistakenly sent to many cards and they reached out and I was able to correct it. They were very nice and helpful.
I mistakenly sent to many cards and they reached out and I was able to correct it. They were very nice and helpful.
Joseph
Review left Sep 18 2025
Review
I have kind of a large collection and have a good variety of both $1 rares and more expensive cards. This service made it easy to sell a large amount of cards in one transaction while I trim down my collection.
I have kind of a large collection and have a good variety of both $1 rares and more expensive cards. This service made it easy to sell a large amount of cards in one transaction while I trim down my collection.
Aaron Proctor
Review left Sep 18 2025
Review
I was given clear information on how to organize and pack my cards. I was never confused about the timeline. Once the shipment was received, the processing and payment were quick. I think the values assigned to the cards were reasonable. While I've cleared out most of my paper Magic collection at th
...
Read more
I was given clear information on how to organize and pack my cards. I was never confused about the timeline. Once the shipment was received, the processing and payment were quick. I think the values assigned to the cards were reasonable. While I've cleared out most of my paper Magic collection at this point, if for some reason a few cards spike in value in the future, I'll be sending them to Card Conduit.
Cory Starks
Review left Sep 17 2025
Review
The whole process was easy. I did do a sorted shipment so it took me a while to actually sort my cards. But, every time I reached out to customer service they responded promptly, and once I sent my cards the process was completely shortly after. Additionally I believe they graded my cards very fairly.
The whole process was easy. I did do a sorted shipment so it took me a while to actually sort my cards. But, every time I reached out to customer service they responded promptly, and once I sent my cards the process was completely shortly after. Additionally I believe they graded my cards very fairly.
Noah
Review left Sep 17 2025
Review
Working with Card Conduit was super easy. Their customer support kept me well informed and treated me very well even though my order was mostly bulk. The smaller interraction could have easily been a low priority, but the folks at Card Conduit handled it with care and speed. I am overall very satisfied with my experience.
Working with Card Conduit was super easy. Their customer support kept me well informed and treated me very well even though my order was mostly bulk. The smaller interraction could have easily been a low priority, but the folks at Card Conduit handled it with care and speed. I am overall very satisfied with my experience.
Drew D
Review left Sep 17 2025
Review
The process to submit cards is easy and payouts happen quickly. I was happy with the service and plan to use it again in the future.
The process to submit cards is easy and payouts happen quickly. I was happy with the service and plan to use it again in the future.
Dan H.
Review left Sep 17 2025
Shipment processed Aug 09 2025
$72.48
payout, $1.48
fees
Review
This was the first of three sorted shipments (of increasing volume) I have sent to Card Conduit so far, all have gone perfectly. They offer a top-notch user experience that allows for quick identification of specific versions of cards along with transparent payout estimates. I’ve found their gradi
...
Read more
This was the first of three sorted shipments (of increasing volume) I have sent to Card Conduit so far, all have gone perfectly. They offer a top-notch user experience that allows for quick identification of specific versions of cards along with transparent payout estimates. I’ve found their grading process to be thorough and accurate. If you’re looking for a secure, reliable way to sell a bunch of cards with zero regrets, this is it!
Derek Applegarth
Review left Sep 16 2025
Review
This is the third time I have sold cards. The process was easy and the payout was exactly as expected.
This is the third time I have sold cards. The process was easy and the payout was exactly as expected.
Daniel Yohannasikajuquim
Review left Sep 16 2025
Review
I was surprised with how quickly they handled everything. It was a great experience I am going to use it again. Great way to offload after ripping some packs selling those 2-5 dollars cards in bulk.
I was surprised with how quickly they handled everything. It was a great experience I am going to use it again. Great way to offload after ripping some packs selling those 2-5 dollars cards in bulk.
Sean Rodden
Review left Sep 16 2025
Shipment processed Sep 06 2025
Review
From start to finish the process was very easy. I had an amazing experience with all of this and the and you for everything!!!!
From start to finish the process was very easy. I had an amazing experience with all of this and the and you for everything!!!!
Maxime
Review left Sep 16 2025
Review
Have been using CC for several sorted packages at this point, and the experience has been excellent. They are professional, quick, and fair in their gradings. Highly recommend this service.
Have been using CC for several sorted packages at this point, and the experience has been excellent. They are professional, quick, and fair in their gradings. Highly recommend this service.
Nik Nomad
Review left Sep 15 2025
Review
it was easy and a better sale value than all my local stores
it was easy and a better sale value than all my local stores
JAM
Review left Sep 15 2025
Review
I've used Card Conduit multiple times now to sell my MTG collection in bulk. The experience has always been quality, intuitive, and without issue. I really value this service as it makes cards so much easier for me, and I don't feel like I am getting taken advantage of with bulk pricing. Appreciate y'all!!
I've used Card Conduit multiple times now to sell my MTG collection in bulk. The experience has always been quality, intuitive, and without issue. I really value this service as it makes cards so much easier for me, and I don't feel like I am getting taken advantage of with bulk pricing. Appreciate y'all!!
Jerrad Schmittle
Review left Sep 15 2025
Review
Card Conduit gave a very fair price, explained what the process was and processed the order and payment very promptly. Terrific overall experience, and I will definitely do business with them again.
Card Conduit gave a very fair price, explained what the process was and processed the order and payment very promptly. Terrific overall experience, and I will definitely do business with them again.
Ben K
Review left Sep 13 2025
Review
Quick and easy process. Highly recommend it! Took about a week after I sent it in
Quick and easy process. Highly recommend it! Took about a week after I sent it in
Danny
Review left Sep 13 2025
Review
The process was easy. Of course I wanted a little more for my vintage cards, but I'm happy knowing that someone will have the opportunity to appreciate my old cards that were just sitting around.
The process was easy. Of course I wanted a little more for my vintage cards, but I'm happy knowing that someone will have the opportunity to appreciate my old cards that were just sitting around.
Luis
Review left Sep 13 2025
Shipment processed Sep 04 2025
Review
way faster than imagined and satisfied with payout
way faster than imagined and satisfied with payout
Eric
Review left Sep 13 2025
Review
great service! quick turnaround & favorable pricing. thanks!
great service! quick turnaround & favorable pricing. thanks!
Dr Stafford Lumsden
Review left Sep 13 2025
Review
Selling large quantities of bulk cards can be daunting, but Card Conduit simplifies the process significantly. Their service offers a straightforward way to offload unsorted bulk for a reasonable return, ideal for all of those sub-30cent rares and mythics.
The entire experience is remarkably e ... Read more
The entire experience is remarkably e ... Read more
Selling large quantities of bulk cards can be daunting, but Card Conduit simplifies the process significantly. Their service offers a straightforward way to offload unsorted bulk for a reasonable return, ideal for all of those sub-30cent rares and mythics.
The entire experience is remarkably easy, providing a convenient alternative to sorting and selling individually. Overall, Card Conduit presents a practical solution for those looking to declutter their collection quickly.
The entire experience is remarkably easy, providing a convenient alternative to sorting and selling individually. Overall, Card Conduit presents a practical solution for those looking to declutter their collection quickly.
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every
previous customer to leave a review.
Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page.
We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a
review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).