Chat with us

Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service

(2583)
Drew Shaffer
Review left Sep 21 2023
Shipment processed Sep 14 2023
$383.96 payout, $18.09 fees

Review

I was a little skeptical at first and reached out to the company first do do a little research. After reading all of the positive reviews I decided to give them a try. Nick Anderson reached out to me and helped me every step throughout the process and was amazing to work with. The cards were sorted ... Read more
I was a little skeptical at first and reached out to the company first do do a little research. After reading all of the positive reviews I decided to give them a try. Nick Anderson reached out to me and helped me every step throughout the process and was amazing to work with. The cards were sorted and valued way faster than I thought, and I also received more money than I initially expected.

Everything went extremely seamlessly, and I will definitely be using Card Conduit in the future. Thanks again Nick and team!!!
logen
Review left Sep 20 2023
Shipment processed Sep 09 2023
$824.65 payout, $38.85 fees

Review

I thought this whole process would be harder than it ended up being. I got paid more than if I had sold my cards individually and if that wasn't enough I barely did anything! 10/10 service
I thought this whole process would be harder than it ended up being. I got paid more than if I had sold my cards individually and if that wasn't enough I barely did anything! 10/10 service
David Satterwhite
Review left Sep 20 2023
Shipment processed Sep 09 2023
$19,454.60 payout, $1,023.93 fees

Review

Process was very easy. Shipped in a slew of cards and they sorted and had the price back to me within a week. Prices were better than I would have gotten selling to local store.
Process was very easy. Shipped in a slew of cards and they sorted and had the price back to me within a week. Prices were better than I would have gotten selling to local store.
Evan
Review left Sep 20 2023
Shipment processed Sep 09 2023
$698.31 payout, $32.90 fees

Review

Process was easy and straightforward. No complaints really. I will say that the estimate assumes all of your cards are mint condition and they are very critical when it comes to card quality. So don't believe their rosy estimate as you likely won't be getting that, and you don't really have any bargaining power once they have your cards.
Process was easy and straightforward. No complaints really. I will say that the estimate assumes all of your cards are mint condition and they are very critical when it comes to card quality. So don't believe their rosy estimate as you likely won't be getting that, and you don't really have any bargaining power once they have your cards.
Card Conduit Team

Replied Sep 20 2023

Our estimate tool will default to Near Mint if no condition is provided, but you are able to input different conditions into that tool to get a more accurate idea of the prices you can expect. Unfortunately we need to grade the cards as they are received, and anyone with concerns about grading should consider requesting a hold be put on their shipment prior to processing.
Our estimate tool will default to Near Mint if no condition is provided, but you are able to input different conditions into that tool to get a more accurate idea of the prices you can expect. Unfortunately we need to grade the cards as they are received, and anyone with concerns about grading should consider requesting a hold be put on their shipment prior to processing.
Anthony
Review left Sep 20 2023
Shipment processed Sep 10 2023
$434.97 payout, $83.34 fees

Review

I followed on the sidelines for years. I was skeptical, especially after reading a few of the bad reviews (even though the vast majority are positive).

I found the whole experience perfectly smooth. The grading wasn’t just fair, it was near perfect. Customer service was top notch too.

Defini ... Read more
I followed on the sidelines for years. I was skeptical, especially after reading a few of the bad reviews (even though the vast majority are positive).

I found the whole experience perfectly smooth. The grading wasn’t just fair, it was near perfect. Customer service was top notch too.

Definitely will use again in the future, highly recommend. If you’re unsure, just do it, you won’t regret it.
Shawn Brewer
Review left Sep 20 2023
Shipment processed Sep 09 2023
$1,044.40 payout, $49.21 fees

Review

I've used TCGplayer for my card selling needs for awhile but recently I had a horrible experience with them that left $80 worth of cards ruined. After reading a few reviews of Card Conduit I decided to give them a try and it's probably the best decision I've made in a long while.

The 3 levels of ... Read more
I've used TCGplayer for my card selling needs for awhile but recently I had a horrible experience with them that left $80 worth of cards ruined. After reading a few reviews of Card Conduit I decided to give them a try and it's probably the best decision I've made in a long while.

The 3 levels of service they provide cover just about the entire spectrum of sellers out there. Even though I wasn't sending them bulk cards (I was selling off a few unused commander decks with some high value staples) I was fully prepared to pay the full service prices as I didn't want to do the work......except the team at Card Conduit moved my order to the mid service level as a courtesy which put about an extra $50 in my pocket. Amazing to see customer service like that these days!

From start to finish it took about a little over week to complete processing and payment but I was in no rush and that's a fair amount of time given it was over a holiday weekend and the work they have to do especially considering some of these cards were sitting in TCGplayer's office, lost, for a month.

Finally the payout. Wow. I was under no illusion about the state of my cards and what I could get for them given the buylist market but I was simply blown away with what I got. Again, I kept a portion of my cards that were rejected from TCGplayer due to grading over the last year and surprise surprise not only did Card Conduit grade them fairly, but also found buyers for them!

Honestly my only regret is I don't have any more cards to send to these guys. Maybe in a few months if I build up a decent amount of cards I will not hesitate to use Card Conduit again, these guys are simply the best.
Brian
Review left Sep 19 2023
Shipment processed Sep 08 2023

Review

The process was easy to accomplish. I was able to sell a lot of my MTG cards for decent prices when I quit playing. Card Conduit makes doing so simple.
The process was easy to accomplish. I was able to sell a lot of my MTG cards for decent prices when I quit playing. Card Conduit makes doing so simple.
Nathan W
Review left Sep 18 2023
Shipment processed Sep 05 2023
$731.70 payout, $14.93 fees

Review

I opted to sort and organize the cards myself to cut down on fees and I really appreciated having that option. Overall the experience was relatively fast and very convenient, which were my priorities as I'm exiting the hobby. I would say it took about a week from postage to payout, and I really appr ... Read more
I opted to sort and organize the cards myself to cut down on fees and I really appreciated having that option. Overall the experience was relatively fast and very convenient, which were my priorities as I'm exiting the hobby. I would say it took about a week from postage to payout, and I really appreciated the peace of mind from the constant communication at each stage of the process. I feel good about the service and have told friends about it, but I'd be remiss if I didn't advise people to temper their expectations. In my experience, players and collectors alike tend to overvalue the condition of their card, but Card Conduit grades cards way more stringently than any physical or online retailer I've ever interacted with. I'm not making a value judgement there, but I think it's important to note for anyone using the service.
Dani
Review left Sep 18 2023
Shipment processed Sep 07 2023
$220.22 payout, $288.61 fees

Review

Easy and quick way to get money for cards taking up space on a shelf
Easy and quick way to get money for cards taking up space on a shelf
francisco Branco
Review left Sep 18 2023
Shipment processed Aug 15 2023
$128.67 payout, $2.63 fees

Review

Fast and fair prices. The check arrived quick after a few days processing

Thanks
Fast and fair prices. The check arrived quick after a few days processing

Thanks
Jeremi
Review left Sep 18 2023
Shipment processed Sep 02 2023
$1,627.00 payout, $76.66 fees

Review

I’m happy with the outcome of my shipment. I had my collection priced by an LGS and ended up going with card conduit, and made about 20% more after shipping and all that. One recommendation, keep in mind your cards may not grade near mint with them, the majority of my shipment was in what I consid ... Read more
I’m happy with the outcome of my shipment. I had my collection priced by an LGS and ended up going with card conduit, and made about 20% more after shipping and all that. One recommendation, keep in mind your cards may not grade near mint with them, the majority of my shipment was in what I considered near mint but was priced for the next grade down. Still a great value, but something to keep in mind.
RJ
Review left Sep 17 2023
Shipment processed Aug 12 2023
$68.86 payout, $3.24 fees

Review

This was my first foray into selling collector cards online. I was admittedly squeamish about mailing cards to a stranger, letting them value them / keep them, and then just send a check. Lots of "how can I trust that _____." Card Conduit provided all the necessary resources on their site to help me ... Read more
This was my first foray into selling collector cards online. I was admittedly squeamish about mailing cards to a stranger, letting them value them / keep them, and then just send a check. Lots of "how can I trust that _____." Card Conduit provided all the necessary resources on their site to help me decide if I wanted to just hand over everything or do some of the legwork myself. I ultimately decided that I could spend a few evenings valuing my cards and deciding which ones were worth sending in. The communication was top notch and there was transparency throughout. I knew where my cards where throughout the process and received a detailed breakdown of everything.

I didn't have a large collection I was trying to unload by any means, but I didn't want to sell individual cards on eBay or some other marketplace, and I didn't want to send them to the garbage/recycling either.

If I had more cards in my collection to offload, I would do business with Card Conduit again.
Joseph Nguyen
Review left Sep 17 2023
Shipment processed Sep 07 2023

Review

Friendly. Also help lower my processing cost with all the cards I sent.
Friendly. Also help lower my processing cost with all the cards I sent.
Ethan
Review left Sep 17 2023
Shipment processed Sep 06 2023
$34.14 payout, $5.78 fees

Review

Came into this process completely blind. The Card Conduit site was easy to navigate and the team handled everything quickly and professionally. I breathed a huge sigh of relief after offloading several thousand cards. Thank you Nick & Team!
Came into this process completely blind. The Card Conduit site was easy to navigate and the team handled everything quickly and professionally. I breathed a huge sigh of relief after offloading several thousand cards. Thank you Nick & Team!
Ethan
Review left Sep 17 2023
Shipment processed Sep 06 2023
$57.19 payout, $12.60 fees

Review

Came into this process completely blind. The Card Conduit site was easy to navigate and the team handled everything quickly and professionally. I breathed a huge sigh of relief after offloading several thousand cards. Thank you Nick & Team!
Came into this process completely blind. The Card Conduit site was easy to navigate and the team handled everything quickly and professionally. I breathed a huge sigh of relief after offloading several thousand cards. Thank you Nick & Team!
Ethan
Review left Sep 17 2023
Shipment processed Sep 06 2023
$21.98 payout, $5.18 fees

Review

Came into this process completely blind. The Card Conduit site was easy to navigate and the team handled everything quickly and professionally. I breathed a huge sigh of relief after offloading several thousand cards. Thank you Nick & Team!
Came into this process completely blind. The Card Conduit site was easy to navigate and the team handled everything quickly and professionally. I breathed a huge sigh of relief after offloading several thousand cards. Thank you Nick & Team!
Ethan
Review left Sep 17 2023
Shipment processed Sep 06 2023
$32.59 payout, $9.01 fees

Review

Came into this process completely blind. The Card Conduit site was easy to navigate and the team handled everything quickly and professionally. I breathed a huge sigh of relief after offloading several thousand cards. Thank you Nick & Team!
Came into this process completely blind. The Card Conduit site was easy to navigate and the team handled everything quickly and professionally. I breathed a huge sigh of relief after offloading several thousand cards. Thank you Nick & Team!
Jason S
Review left Sep 17 2023
Shipment processed Sep 07 2023
$2,193.99 payout, $103.38 fees

Review

My wife was pretty thrilled when I brought home an extra paycheck from selling a couple hundred commander staples that I’m not using! Thanks Card Conduit, excited to work with you again soon!
My wife was pretty thrilled when I brought home an extra paycheck from selling a couple hundred commander staples that I’m not using! Thanks Card Conduit, excited to work with you again soon!
Copefresh
Review left Sep 17 2023
Shipment processed Aug 31 2023
$698.93 payout, $171.96 fees

Review

Honest with pricing and great service if anything goes arry!
Honest with pricing and great service if anything goes arry!
Jacob
Review left Sep 16 2023
Shipment processed Sep 05 2023
$2,401.36 payout, $49.01 fees

Review

Process was straightforward. I got better value than I expected. Would recommend
Process was straightforward. I got better value than I expected. Would recommend
1 2 ... 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 ... 129 130
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every previous customer to leave a review. Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page. We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).