Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service
(5629)
Wiley S
Review left Sep 23 2025
Shipment processed Aug 20 2025
Review
The entire process was easy and conducted as advertised in a quick timely manner.
The entire process was easy and conducted as advertised in a quick timely manner.
Josh
Review left Sep 23 2025
Review
If you're on the fence (which I get--mailing off valuable cards is scary), you can rest assured that CC is legit. Easily the best card selling experience I've ever had. It was easy, straightforward, and well-explained. Value was great!
If you're on the fence (which I get--mailing off valuable cards is scary), you can rest assured that CC is legit. Easily the best card selling experience I've ever had. It was easy, straightforward, and well-explained. Value was great!
James
Review left Sep 23 2025
Review
I sell cards on ebay and to my LGS pretty regularly. Some cards are just not worth it for me to sell as an individual, and they pile up. Card Conduit takes a fair cut to turn my fully dead to rights inventory into cash i didnt have and wouldnt get otherwise in about two weeks time or so. Thats insan
...
Read more
I sell cards on ebay and to my LGS pretty regularly. Some cards are just not worth it for me to sell as an individual, and they pile up. Card Conduit takes a fair cut to turn my fully dead to rights inventory into cash i didnt have and wouldnt get otherwise in about two weeks time or so. Thats insane. If youre scared over the fees and the grading you gotta remember that everyone has to eat, yourself included, and i cant eat the cards i cant sell. Put in a little work to scratch their back and they'll scratch yours. Everyone wins.
Kyle
Review left Sep 23 2025
Review
They processed my order fast, and gave me a very fair offer. Also, they're really good about keeping in contact. Highly recommended!
They processed my order fast, and gave me a very fair offer. Also, they're really good about keeping in contact. Highly recommended!
Joseph McNeely
Review left Sep 23 2025
Review
Card Conduit exceeded my expectations. I was looking for a way to sell off some of my collection and wasn't completely sure who was the best fit for me, but after doing some research and looking into them, I decided Card Conduit was the one. They may pay a bit less than nickel and dime-ing each card
...
Read more
Card Conduit exceeded my expectations. I was looking for a way to sell off some of my collection and wasn't completely sure who was the best fit for me, but after doing some research and looking into them, I decided Card Conduit was the one. They may pay a bit less than nickel and dime-ing each card, but I was still able to get a respectable and even generous amount of money for the cards I sent in.
I do want to clarify that I used the sorted service, which is a bit time consuming, but the return and confidence in the value you are sending is worth it.
I wish they could take foreign language cards, but I understand that there isn't a large market so it makes sense. Otherwise, I would highly recommend Card Conduit to anyone who wishes to quickly get rid of cards and get a return on them.
I do want to clarify that I used the sorted service, which is a bit time consuming, but the return and confidence in the value you are sending is worth it.
I wish they could take foreign language cards, but I understand that there isn't a large market so it makes sense. Otherwise, I would highly recommend Card Conduit to anyone who wishes to quickly get rid of cards and get a return on them.
Derek Minich
Review left Sep 23 2025
Review
I feel like the prices i get at card conduit are super reasonable and 5he only work i have to do is ship them the cards. Ive used multiple card conduit services and they all have been great.
I feel like the prices i get at card conduit are super reasonable and 5he only work i have to do is ship them the cards. Ive used multiple card conduit services and they all have been great.
Alex Votava
Review left Sep 23 2025
Review
Process was easy-to-use amd fair. Constant contact with every step
Process was easy-to-use amd fair. Constant contact with every step
Coleman
Review left Sep 22 2025
Review
I have needed so sell a chunk of cards for a while because I am moving, but the process always felt either too difficult or like I was getting ripped off. I felt like this was a very good middle ground where it was easy to do but like I got as much as possible for my cards without selling them all individually
I have needed so sell a chunk of cards for a while because I am moving, but the process always felt either too difficult or like I was getting ripped off. I felt like this was a very good middle ground where it was easy to do but like I got as much as possible for my cards without selling them all individually
Kirill Kovalenko
Review left Sep 22 2025
Review
I needed to sell my cards quick but didn't want to get low returns from game stores. Selling through Card Conduit gave me a hassle free solution.
I needed to sell my cards quick but didn't want to get low returns from game stores. Selling through Card Conduit gave me a hassle free solution.
David Stone
Review left Sep 22 2025
Review
Process was quick and easy. I did the one where I sorted the cards. Payout was what I was looking for and was direct deposit making it even easier.
Process was quick and easy. I did the one where I sorted the cards. Payout was what I was looking for and was direct deposit making it even easier.
Luigi Mario
Review left Sep 21 2025
Review
You’ve likely seen your favorite mtg streamers promote card conduit. Some even provide promo codes for additional discounts. They are promoting a good experience. Use a card scanner app on your phone to segregate all the $1+ cards that you want to sell. Package them in a way that will protect the
...
Read more
You’ve likely seen your favorite mtg streamers promote card conduit. Some even provide promo codes for additional discounts. They are promoting a good experience. Use a card scanner app on your phone to segregate all the $1+ cards that you want to sell. Package them in a way that will protect the cards in all weather conditions. I had a feeling I would get a big check, but they valued the cards at the same rate as I was guessing and I got a great payout that was so much easier than trying to see which cards card kingdom is willing to buy. Highly recommended for people looking to sell cards quickly.
Bradford
Review left Sep 21 2025
Review
I was sketchy at first to send my cards around a value of about $1300. I received approximately $600 and the process was pretty smooth that I was well informed on each step and the payment actually came in on a Saturday not a business day, which was helpful very much would do it again in a heartbeat.
I was sketchy at first to send my cards around a value of about $1300. I received approximately $600 and the process was pretty smooth that I was well informed on each step and the payment actually came in on a Saturday not a business day, which was helpful very much would do it again in a heartbeat.
Owen Winbun
Review left Sep 21 2025
Review
I have a lot more lightly played than I thought but otherwise I feel like I got a really great price for the amount of work put in! Was super easy and they are very good at reaching out and making the experience feel personal!
I have a lot more lightly played than I thought but otherwise I feel like I got a really great price for the amount of work put in! Was super easy and they are very good at reaching out and making the experience feel personal!
Chris C.
Review left Sep 21 2025
Review
Card Conduit maintains a competitive buy list price and is very fair on card condition assessments.
Card Conduit maintains a competitive buy list price and is very fair on card condition assessments.
Chris C
Review left Sep 21 2025
Review
Card Conduit continues to do great work. Their staff answers questions pretty quickly and the reports are very comprehensive.
Card Conduit continues to do great work. Their staff answers questions pretty quickly and the reports are very comprehensive.
Chris C.
Review left Sep 21 2025
Review
Pretty easy process, payouts are fair and fast. I’ve sold a bunch of times on here and never had an issue!
Pretty easy process, payouts are fair and fast. I’ve sold a bunch of times on here and never had an issue!
Tim
Review left Sep 20 2025
Shipment processed Sep 12 2025
Review
The process was super easy, they were quick at both assessing the cards and then payment was not delayed at all. They saved me months of my life had I tried to sell all my cards myself. Thank you and I will definitely use this service again when my collection grows back up!
The process was super easy, they were quick at both assessing the cards and then payment was not delayed at all. They saved me months of my life had I tried to sell all my cards myself. Thank you and I will definitely use this service again when my collection grows back up!
B Boyer
Review left Sep 20 2025
Shipment processed Sep 12 2025
$1,987.94
payout, $104.63
fees
Review
Very happy with the service, speed and price for my cards. They even auto upgraded me to curated when I submitted under standard when I wasn’t sure if I’d meet the qualifications.
Very happy with the service, speed and price for my cards. They even auto upgraded me to curated when I submitted under standard when I wasn’t sure if I’d meet the qualifications.
Mike Q
Review left Sep 20 2025
Shipment processed Sep 20 2025
Review
This was my first time using Card Conduit, the website was easy to use and navigate through. I felt the process was quick and payout fair to my expectations. I will be using Card Conduit again for my card selling needs.
Thanks!
Thanks!
This was my first time using Card Conduit, the website was easy to use and navigate through. I felt the process was quick and payout fair to my expectations. I will be using Card Conduit again for my card selling needs.
Thanks!
Thanks!
Alexandre A Blouse
Review left Sep 19 2025
Review
As always they are a great way to sell cards for a good value and a quick turnaround. I've sent close to 1300 cards in and it took them a week and a half from shipping to grading and selling. I got my payment in a very expedited manner. The overall list and stats are super fun to look at and the who
...
Read more
As always they are a great way to sell cards for a good value and a quick turnaround. I've sent close to 1300 cards in and it took them a week and a half from shipping to grading and selling. I got my payment in a very expedited manner. The overall list and stats are super fun to look at and the whole process is very painless. Would highly recommend to people that don't want to sell their collections or non-needed cards.
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every
previous customer to leave a review.
Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page.
We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a
review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).