Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service
(5629)
Cody
Review left Sep 02 2025
Review
It was just as the title says, the easiest way to sell the cards you either don’t need or don’t want for fast cash! I ended up submitting 213 cards I had laying around after selling all the big ones I didn’t collect. Scanned them in to TCG and got a pdf, uploaded it and got an estimate of th
...
Read more
It was just as the title says, the easiest way to sell the cards you either don’t need or don’t want for fast cash! I ended up submitting 213 cards I had laying around after selling all the big ones I didn’t collect. Scanned them in to TCG and got a pdf, uploaded it and got an estimate of the payout. I thought it was a great offer so I packed the cards up and shipped them out. It was about a week later I got paid! I received updates all along the way and it was super transparent! Even had a report at the end that explained everything. I’m putting away more already for another shipment when I get enough.
I’ll definitely be spreading the word!
I’ll definitely be spreading the word!
Matt
Review left Sep 02 2025
Review
This was my first shipment and the Card Conduit staff were so nice and helpful.
I plan on selling all my cards this way in the future.
Thanks!
I plan on selling all my cards this way in the future.
Thanks!
This was my first shipment and the Card Conduit staff were so nice and helpful.
I plan on selling all my cards this way in the future.
Thanks!
I plan on selling all my cards this way in the future.
Thanks!
Matt
Review left Sep 02 2025
Review
Thank you so much! This was so painless and such great care was taken with my cards.
Amazing!
Amazing!
Thank you so much! This was so painless and such great care was taken with my cards.
Amazing!
Amazing!
Matt
Review left Sep 02 2025
Review
I love this service!
I've been sitting on tons of cards because there wasn't a fast easy way to sell them... but now there is and I'm loving it!
I've been sitting on tons of cards because there wasn't a fast easy way to sell them... but now there is and I'm loving it!
I love this service!
I've been sitting on tons of cards because there wasn't a fast easy way to sell them... but now there is and I'm loving it!
I've been sitting on tons of cards because there wasn't a fast easy way to sell them... but now there is and I'm loving it!
J
Review left Sep 02 2025
Review
I sent in a bulk lot that was unsearched, I’ve heard a lot about problems doing this based on condition. CC reviewed my cards and charged me less than the standard fee because my cards were mostly mint. The second lot I sent, I looked up and sent based on sell list and again they were within $5 of
...
Read more
I sent in a bulk lot that was unsearched, I’ve heard a lot about problems doing this based on condition. CC reviewed my cards and charged me less than the standard fee because my cards were mostly mint. The second lot I sent, I looked up and sent based on sell list and again they were within $5 of what I thought I would get. I looked at a lot of reviews before sending any cards and in one lot they found a card worth way more than I knew and in another lot they graded a card LP that I thought should be NM. I would recommend card conduit over my lgs or scg, tgs etc.
JAVIER GARCIA
Review left Sep 02 2025
Shipment processed Aug 23 2025
Review
easy and straight forward process would definitely recommend
easy and straight forward process would definitely recommend
Mateo Silva
Review left Aug 31 2025
Review
It always goes very smooth (keeping in mind this wasn’t my first time)! But I would recommend! Decent value, was relatively quick, and was a simple and easy process
It always goes very smooth (keeping in mind this wasn’t my first time)! But I would recommend! Decent value, was relatively quick, and was a simple and easy process
Jon
Review left Aug 31 2025
Review
Very smooth experiance and was very happy with everything overall!!
Very smooth experiance and was very happy with everything overall!!
Wrandy Little
Review left Aug 31 2025
Review
For it’s taking longer to process the order and your company has been taking more out of the pay outs,and besides that it’s alright to help with selling your cards
For it’s taking longer to process the order and your company has been taking more out of the pay outs,and besides that it’s alright to help with selling your cards
Nathan Popp
Review left Aug 30 2025
Review
I was very pleased with my experience. Process is very simple and straightforward. Security Amis too notch and they do an excellent job of notifying you through each step of the process. Prices are fair and payment was fast. Reliable service to use if looking to sell quantities of cards.
I was very pleased with my experience. Process is very simple and straightforward. Security Amis too notch and they do an excellent job of notifying you through each step of the process. Prices are fair and payment was fast. Reliable service to use if looking to sell quantities of cards.
Taylor
Review left Aug 30 2025
Shipment processed Aug 09 2025
Review
It was so easy to send in, and the pre-sorted shipment was the way to go. I will definitely be doing this again!
It was so easy to send in, and the pre-sorted shipment was the way to go. I will definitely be doing this again!
Johnie
Review left Aug 30 2025
Review
Really informative process and explains a lot on what they are doing and fast payout 10/10 amazing!!!
Really informative process and explains a lot on what they are doing and fast payout 10/10 amazing!!!
John F
Review left Aug 30 2025
Review
Easy and great value. I can’t remember if I already left a review, but I’m already 6 shipments in and the process has been remarkably easy. Plenty of details and instructions along the way. I will absolutely keep using cardconduit to sell any and all cards on their buylist!
Easy and great value. I can’t remember if I already left a review, but I’m already 6 shipments in and the process has been remarkably easy. Plenty of details and instructions along the way. I will absolutely keep using cardconduit to sell any and all cards on their buylist!
Adriane
Review left Aug 29 2025
Review
Card Conduit was SO easy to use! The grading was fair, although they do use a very high standard. I was very pleased with the itemized report that I was able to review prior to the payout. I would highly recommend this service to anyone who is looking for an easy way to get fair market value of their MTG cards!
Card Conduit was SO easy to use! The grading was fair, although they do use a very high standard. I was very pleased with the itemized report that I was able to review prior to the payout. I would highly recommend this service to anyone who is looking for an easy way to get fair market value of their MTG cards!
Paul Boulanger
Review left Aug 29 2025
Shipment processed Aug 08 2025
Review
As always Card Conduit is super easy to use. I’ve used them a multitude of times and it’s way simpler with less headaches than using TCG Player or eBay. They are pretty strict with RL and foil cards but not unfair, which is okay as those cards are the ones buyers complain about condition of the most. I will absolutely use Card Conduit many more times.
As always Card Conduit is super easy to use. I’ve used them a multitude of times and it’s way simpler with less headaches than using TCG Player or eBay. They are pretty strict with RL and foil cards but not unfair, which is okay as those cards are the ones buyers complain about condition of the most. I will absolutely use Card Conduit many more times.
Ryan Sebacher
Review left Aug 29 2025
Review
Very easy to work with, and nothing but professional interactions. Great source to help you out.
Very easy to work with, and nothing but professional interactions. Great source to help you out.
Rob Christoffel
Review left Aug 28 2025
Review
Would recommend and already have. Only criticism is the condition seemed a bit harsh. Some near mint cards were listed at MP. Would have only been an issue if it was all of the more valuable cards. Otherwise not a big deal.
Would recommend and already have. Only criticism is the condition seemed a bit harsh. Some near mint cards were listed at MP. Would have only been an issue if it was all of the more valuable cards. Otherwise not a big deal.
W Henson
Review left Aug 28 2025
Review
I did the sorted service. While sorting was tedious, i believe that the added payout (lower fees) was worth the effort. Shipping and packing instructions were very clear, and the instructions guided me through the entire process easily. Definitely plan to use this service again when selling chunks of my collection.
I did the sorted service. While sorting was tedious, i believe that the added payout (lower fees) was worth the effort. Shipping and packing instructions were very clear, and the instructions guided me through the entire process easily. Definitely plan to use this service again when selling chunks of my collection.
Fu Lin Liu
Review left Aug 28 2025
Review
I picked the curated option, but was able to check the card prices before sending. The results were fairly close to the price I looked up. Overall easy to use and was given a summary list of my cards.
I picked the curated option, but was able to check the card prices before sending. The results were fairly close to the price I looked up. Overall easy to use and was given a summary list of my cards.
Richard Hannah
Review left Aug 27 2025
Review
Very prompt and responsive. Everything went smooth and will work with this company in the future
Very prompt and responsive. Everything went smooth and will work with this company in the future
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every
previous customer to leave a review.
Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page.
We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a
review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).