Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service
(5629)
jason saldana
Review left Oct 01 2025
Review
quick and easy! would use again! 11/10! Looked through various other companies and this was the best!
quick and easy! would use again! 11/10! Looked through various other companies and this was the best!
Eric
Review left Oct 01 2025
Shipment processed Sep 20 2025
Review
Great service, fast and easy. Received a good value for my cards.
Great service, fast and easy. Received a good value for my cards.
Mike
Review left Sep 30 2025
Review
They give you many options depending on how much of your own time you want to spend on sorting, which is great. I used sorted and was easy process, quick responses and payment. Of all my cards only a couple were not excepted and they explained what the issue was or I shipped something incorrectly. Will be using again.
They give you many options depending on how much of your own time you want to spend on sorting, which is great. I used sorted and was easy process, quick responses and payment. Of all my cards only a couple were not excepted and they explained what the issue was or I shipped something incorrectly. Will be using again.
Tristan Jordan
Review left Sep 30 2025
Review
Process was simple and I was payed quickly. Happy with the outcome, would recommend.
Process was simple and I was payed quickly. Happy with the outcome, would recommend.
Tristan Jordan
Review left Sep 30 2025
Review
Process was simple, and payment was quick. Happy with the outcome.
Process was simple, and payment was quick. Happy with the outcome.
Andy
Review left Sep 30 2025
Review
The process was easy and intuitive. The payment through Zelle was convenient as well. I do plan on utilizing this service again. The only con is that you are roughly paid at around 75-80% of any cards cards retail value. It seems that is the sacrifice you make for convenience.
The process was easy and intuitive. The payment through Zelle was convenient as well. I do plan on utilizing this service again. The only con is that you are roughly paid at around 75-80% of any cards cards retail value. It seems that is the sacrifice you make for convenience.
Matt
Review left Sep 30 2025
Review
I was very happy with my overall experience with Card Conduit. I put in this sorted shipment as well as an additional bulk shipment. I was able to ship both together in the same packaging and the process couldn’t have been easier. I exported my card list straight from ManaBox and the website was a
...
Read more
I was very happy with my overall experience with Card Conduit. I put in this sorted shipment as well as an additional bulk shipment. I was able to ship both together in the same packaging and the process couldn’t have been easier. I exported my card list straight from ManaBox and the website was able to give me an ordered list of price estimates for the cards and the best way to sort them (bulk vs curated vs sorted) to maximize my payout. After shipping, the cards made it to Card Conduit and they got my money deposited within just a few days of receiving the shipment. My cards were generally in good but not great condition and I feel like I got a very fair price for them, probably not much different than if I had tried to sell the cards individually but with none of the hassle. Overall very pleased with the entire experience.
Avery
Review left Sep 30 2025
Review
Great way to sell cards i wasn't using for warhammer minis!
Great way to sell cards i wasn't using for warhammer minis!
Marcus
Review left Sep 30 2025
Shipment processed Sep 18 2025
Review
Great service! It was recommended by a friend. It was easy to use, and customer service was great.
Great service! It was recommended by a friend. It was easy to use, and customer service was great.
David Taylor
Review left Sep 29 2025
Review
Very easy process and staff was very helpful thank you
Very easy process and staff was very helpful thank you
Preston
Review left Sep 29 2025
Shipment processed Aug 28 2025
Review
Process was extremely easy and they were very good at communicating on where in the process they were. Felt like I was walked through it all with zero confusion.
Process was extremely easy and they were very good at communicating on where in the process they were. Felt like I was walked through it all with zero confusion.
Tim schmidt
Review left Sep 29 2025
Review
I want my review to show that I am pleased with the outcome on my card situation. I sent in a small collection that I sorted for them and used that option. So I only got charged two percent plus they gave me another ten percent off coupon. The things people should know. I know most of my cards that
...
Read more
I want my review to show that I am pleased with the outcome on my card situation. I sent in a small collection that I sorted for them and used that option. So I only got charged two percent plus they gave me another ten percent off coupon. The things people should know. I know most of my cards that I sent in were fresh poles to sleeves, and I would have judged that mostly near mint. However, a lot of my cards were put into light play. My near mint value on TCG marketplace, was five hundred and fifty dollars. I ended up with three seventy five. Which means that this company averaged paid me sixty eight percent of my card's value... Anyone looking to trade in cards, will know that sixty eight percent value of near market. Is fair ..I get offered eighty percent of tcg, low on facebook or fifty percent cash at my local car shop , or selling an ebay and paying their fees in shipping costs.Even with the ten dollar shipping charge, I still came out ahead better than on facebook or the local card shops/ ebay. I would definitely recommend using this site. One of the management up team Nick reached out to me multiple times when I had questions about the process, the market shifting in the card prices and just a few other questions him he got back to me ASAP, which means these guys are not scammers, they're here to help me. And make money. And so was I, and we did both ...five stars
Derek
Review left Sep 29 2025
Review
I have sold cards multiple time and have had a good e patience each time.
I have sold cards multiple time and have had a good e patience each time.
John Mitchell
Review left Sep 29 2025
Review
The process was incredibly easy and I received a lot more money than I thought I would.
The process was incredibly easy and I received a lot more money than I thought I would.
Reagan
Review left Sep 28 2025
Review
Process was super easy and quick! The pay out was fair also
Process was super easy and quick! The pay out was fair also
Edward
Review left Sep 27 2025
Review
I sent them a large box of largely unsorted cards. Within a week or so I received a fair evaluation and payment. Many of my cards were graded NM which surprised me. I would use them again.
I sent them a large box of largely unsorted cards. Within a week or so I received a fair evaluation and payment. Many of my cards were graded NM which surprised me. I would use them again.
David Ding
Review left Sep 27 2025
Review
I felt like I received good value on the cards that I was selling.
I felt like I received good value on the cards that I was selling.
Cale
Review left Sep 27 2025
Review
I had been meaning to sell off some of my cards for a year or two, but I was always hesitant to start, given the perceived hassle of individual card selling, either to buy lists or online tcg marketplaces. Card conduit is a game changer for this. They were fast, graded my cards accurately, and paid
...
Read more
I had been meaning to sell off some of my cards for a year or two, but I was always hesitant to start, given the perceived hassle of individual card selling, either to buy lists or online tcg marketplaces. Card conduit is a game changer for this. They were fast, graded my cards accurately, and paid me a fair price. I will definitely use their services in the future - and I think you should too, so long as you’re ok with not getting “retail” price for your cards. To me, the convenience and hassle-free nature of the card conduit process more than makes up the difference.
John Brett Linton
Review left Sep 27 2025
Review
Nobody better than you! Thank you for fast and professional service.
Nobody better than you! Thank you for fast and professional service.
Michael Durnberger
Review left Sep 27 2025
Review
All I had to do was gather my cards that were just sitting in binders anyway, and mail them off. The payment was more than I anticipated and everything was handled super professionally and communication was clear and pleasant. The whole experience was better than I had hoped
All I had to do was gather my cards that were just sitting in binders anyway, and mail them off. The payment was more than I anticipated and everything was handled super professionally and communication was clear and pleasant. The whole experience was better than I had hoped
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every
previous customer to leave a review.
Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page.
We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a
review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).