Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service
(5629)
Trever Phillips
Review left Sep 26 2025
Review
I always like how easy it is to just send cards and you guys sort through price them and pay good reasonable amounts. Than you for always being fair and definitely will be sending more cards in the future!
I always like how easy it is to just send cards and you guys sort through price them and pay good reasonable amounts. Than you for always being fair and definitely will be sending more cards in the future!
Kyle K
Review left Sep 26 2025
Shipment processed Aug 20 2025
Review
I found the process and customer service incredibly easy/helpful. Not only was the support team responsive to my questions, but the process to send my collection was easy. The payment was also very fair!
I found the process and customer service incredibly easy/helpful. Not only was the support team responsive to my questions, but the process to send my collection was easy. The payment was also very fair!
Ryan Gano Jr.
Review left Sep 26 2025
Review
Everything from choosing which cards to send, to shipping them off, to Card Conduit finishing everything on their end and payment was super smooth!
Everything from choosing which cards to send, to shipping them off, to Card Conduit finishing everything on their end and payment was super smooth!
Dolan king
Review left Sep 26 2025
Review
I had no issues sending my sorted order in and got paid out in about 2 weeks. All steps of the process were easily communicated
I had no issues sending my sorted order in and got paid out in about 2 weeks. All steps of the process were easily communicated
Ryan
Review left Sep 26 2025
Review
It was easy and painless………………………?.?.?.?.?.?.?.?.?.?.?.?.?.?.??.
It was easy and painless………………………?.?.?.?.?.?.?.?.?.?.?.?.?.?.??.
Cody McCarty
Review left Sep 26 2025
Review
Everything about the process was fluid and it was easy to get a guesstimate of how much I would receive. Would recommend this service to anyone who has an excessive amount of cards collecting dust.
Everything about the process was fluid and it was easy to get a guesstimate of how much I would receive. Would recommend this service to anyone who has an excessive amount of cards collecting dust.
Vincent Pascoe
Review left Sep 26 2025
Review
I've used Card Conduit twice now and they where amazing, The custumer suport was great comunications and really went above and beyond to help me out. They also take some cards that no one else will buylist, overall great experience.
I've used Card Conduit twice now and they where amazing, The custumer suport was great comunications and really went above and beyond to help me out. They also take some cards that no one else will buylist, overall great experience.
Eric Augherton
Review left Sep 26 2025
Review
I am very satisfied with the simplicity and effectiveness that Card Conduit provides! I loved their hard work the first time and I appreciate them for doing this so well again a second time! Expect me to come back again in the near future :)
I am very satisfied with the simplicity and effectiveness that Card Conduit provides! I loved their hard work the first time and I appreciate them for doing this so well again a second time! Expect me to come back again in the near future :)
Dan
Review left Sep 25 2025
Review
Process was easy, and I think the pricing was very fair. Will be creating another shipment soon!
Process was easy, and I think the pricing was very fair. Will be creating another shipment soon!
Jared Geuther
Review left Sep 25 2025
Review
Was an easy process to get my cards sold. 4 day turnaround on their site wasn't correct though, it took almost 7 days. Will definitely sell to them again.
Was an easy process to get my cards sold. 4 day turnaround on their site wasn't correct though, it took almost 7 days. Will definitely sell to them again.
Campbell
Review left Sep 25 2025
Review
The team responds quickly, is thorough and communicates well. I was surprised by how much i got back. I would recommend Card Conduit to any one looking to sell cards!
The team responds quickly, is thorough and communicates well. I was surprised by how much i got back. I would recommend Card Conduit to any one looking to sell cards!
Cory
Review left Sep 25 2025
Shipment processed Sep 13 2025
Review
Card Conduit has revolutionized the way card collectors can evaluate, liquidate, and evolve our collections. The process was simple, user friendly, and had options for each step of the process that allowed customization for my personal goals. After prepping and sending the shipment, CC was communicative and helpful from evaluation to payment.
Card Conduit has revolutionized the way card collectors can evaluate, liquidate, and evolve our collections. The process was simple, user friendly, and had options for each step of the process that allowed customization for my personal goals. After prepping and sending the shipment, CC was communicative and helpful from evaluation to payment.
Doug
Review left Sep 25 2025
Review
The process to record and trade in my cards was really easy I thought. I also thought I got a pretty decent price for what I traded in. I really appreciated the detailed breakdown of the quality and amount that I would be getting for my cards before the final step.
The only negative part of this ... Read more
The only negative part of this ... Read more
The process to record and trade in my cards was really easy I thought. I also thought I got a pretty decent price for what I traded in. I really appreciated the detailed breakdown of the quality and amount that I would be getting for my cards before the final step.
The only negative part of this whole experience is the time it took for the payment to actually arrive. For whatever reason USPS took the letter on the longest path possible to get to me. Then when it finally did get here was delivered to a neighbors home who was out of town. So I had to do some extra work to get my local USPS worker to track down the letter.
The team at Card Conduit was able to help track the letter at least and we could see the long path it took and that it was supposedly delivered.
Overall a great experience and would definitly recommend the service to anyone who is interested.
The only negative part of this whole experience is the time it took for the payment to actually arrive. For whatever reason USPS took the letter on the longest path possible to get to me. Then when it finally did get here was delivered to a neighbors home who was out of town. So I had to do some extra work to get my local USPS worker to track down the letter.
The team at Card Conduit was able to help track the letter at least and we could see the long path it took and that it was supposedly delivered.
Overall a great experience and would definitly recommend the service to anyone who is interested.
Dylan James
Review left Sep 25 2025
Review
The process was super quick and easy to follow! Love the way where i can search up a card to see its value as an individual sale and see it compare to Card Conduit. Extremely fair prices. Loved it and will be using it to finish selling my other cards
The process was super quick and easy to follow! Love the way where i can search up a card to see its value as an individual sale and see it compare to Card Conduit. Extremely fair prices. Loved it and will be using it to finish selling my other cards
Avery Dorko
Review left Sep 25 2025
Review
Would sell again! The process was easier than I expected it to be
Would sell again! The process was easier than I expected it to be
Jacob
Review left Sep 25 2025
Review
Only because I’ve sent them just about everything I have :) sad to see it all go but happy to have done it with these guys. Super easy. Responsive. Reasonable payouts. Now off to the next obsession which is the One Piece TCG!
Only because I’ve sent them just about everything I have :) sad to see it all go but happy to have done it with these guys. Super easy. Responsive. Reasonable payouts. Now off to the next obsession which is the One Piece TCG!
John Moore
Review left Sep 25 2025
Review
The process was simple and easy!! Will definetly work with this company again for high value cards and even the massive amounts of bulk.
The process was simple and easy!! Will definetly work with this company again for high value cards and even the massive amounts of bulk.
Riley Armstead
Review left Sep 24 2025
Review
Selling my cards was easy and extremely convenient, and I was given consistent updates on the progress of my shipment.
Selling my cards was easy and extremely convenient, and I was given consistent updates on the progress of my shipment.
RT
Review left Sep 24 2025
Shipment processed Sep 13 2025
Review
I could not recommend Card Conduit enough. I had a very large and complicated list of sealed product, and Nick and the team at Card Conduit were extraordinarily responsive and transparent. I sent them a very long list of product, and they responded with a price list. The shipping instructions were c
...
Read more
I could not recommend Card Conduit enough. I had a very large and complicated list of sealed product, and Nick and the team at Card Conduit were extraordinarily responsive and transparent. I sent them a very long list of product, and they responded with a price list. The shipping instructions were clear.
There was even a problem with one of the sealed products - the holographic tape that sealed it was damaged during shipping. They were really transparent about the condition, sending photos and asking if I wanted to have it counted as individual cards or send it back, as they could no longer call it a sealed product. So A+ on communication.
And price-wise, what they say the site is 100% accurate: they’re very competitive. Could I have made more selling everything myself through the various channels that exist? Possibly. But it would have been a huge hassle, and Card Conduit was certainly competitive, even taking into account fees. A+ on price.
And A+ on payment. They were immediate.
I’ve already recommended Card Conduit to friends, and couldn’t recommend them more.
There was even a problem with one of the sealed products - the holographic tape that sealed it was damaged during shipping. They were really transparent about the condition, sending photos and asking if I wanted to have it counted as individual cards or send it back, as they could no longer call it a sealed product. So A+ on communication.
And price-wise, what they say the site is 100% accurate: they’re very competitive. Could I have made more selling everything myself through the various channels that exist? Possibly. But it would have been a huge hassle, and Card Conduit was certainly competitive, even taking into account fees. A+ on price.
And A+ on payment. They were immediate.
I’ve already recommended Card Conduit to friends, and couldn’t recommend them more.
Jake Regalado
Review left Sep 24 2025
Review
I have used many different services and methods to sell TCGs, mostly MTG, cards. Card Conduit has become my favorite for the ease of use alone. The process is well explained and communicated the whole way through. It’s low effort, low stress, great results.
I have used many different services and methods to sell TCGs, mostly MTG, cards. Card Conduit has become my favorite for the ease of use alone. The process is well explained and communicated the whole way through. It’s low effort, low stress, great results.
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every
previous customer to leave a review.
Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page.
We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a
review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).