Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service
(5629)
Dr Stafford Lumsden
Review left Sep 13 2025
Review
From start to finish, my 3rd experience with Card Conduit was exceptional. The ease of use is unmatched, the streamlined platform made submitting my cards simple and stress-free. I especially appreciated how quickly they tendered funds, turning my cards into cash without any hassle.
Card Conduit ... Read more
Card Conduit ... Read more
From start to finish, my 3rd experience with Card Conduit was exceptional. The ease of use is unmatched, the streamlined platform made submitting my cards simple and stress-free. I especially appreciated how quickly they tendered funds, turning my cards into cash without any hassle.
Card Conduit continues to provide a fair and transparent evaluation of every card, with clear breakdowns and no surprises. What really stands out, though, is their care and excellent communication: I received timely updates at every step, and the responsiveness when I had a question gave me total confidence in the process.
BTW - I live in Australia and taking into account shipping versus the exchange rate and the ease of the whole process, you cannot get a better deal than with Card Conduit!
If you’re looking for a trustworthy, efficient, and customer-focused way to sell your cards, Card Conduit is an outstanding choice. Highly recommended!
Card Conduit continues to provide a fair and transparent evaluation of every card, with clear breakdowns and no surprises. What really stands out, though, is their care and excellent communication: I received timely updates at every step, and the responsiveness when I had a question gave me total confidence in the process.
BTW - I live in Australia and taking into account shipping versus the exchange rate and the ease of the whole process, you cannot get a better deal than with Card Conduit!
If you’re looking for a trustworthy, efficient, and customer-focused way to sell your cards, Card Conduit is an outstanding choice. Highly recommended!
Steven Z
Review left Sep 12 2025
Shipment processed Sep 09 2025
Review
Very easy selection and sorting process. Fast response between receiving shipment and issuing payment. Card pricing was very fair and, in some cases, better than other outlets that I've used in the past (which was a double win with their convenience). Around 90% of the cards sent in came back NM whi
...
Read more
Very easy selection and sorting process. Fast response between receiving shipment and issuing payment. Card pricing was very fair and, in some cases, better than other outlets that I've used in the past (which was a double win with their convenience). Around 90% of the cards sent in came back NM which I was very pleased with. Payout was greater what I initially expected and was received promptly. Overall, very happy with the service, would recommend to my friends or anyone looking to sell off non bulk cards. Will use Card Conduit again in the future!
Mason B.
Review left Sep 11 2025
Review
The whole process was seamless—my shipment was processed quickly, and the team even followed up with a personal summary of my order. I won’t be using any other buylist service from now on.
The whole process was seamless—my shipment was processed quickly, and the team even followed up with a personal summary of my order. I won’t be using any other buylist service from now on.
Phillip Dyer
Review left Sep 11 2025
Review
I keep going back to these guys. Best combination of convenience and fair payout out there.
I keep going back to these guys. Best combination of convenience and fair payout out there.
Marc Prosch
Review left Sep 11 2025
Review
They gave 3 options, pretty clear what needed to be done. I tried to maximize the return by organizing and providing the filtered list, but in the end I went the route of just hmshipping the collection. It was what I wanted to do anyways and it just makes life easiest.
They are the only game I ... Read more
They are the only game I ... Read more
They gave 3 options, pretty clear what needed to be done. I tried to maximize the return by organizing and providing the filtered list, but in the end I went the route of just hmshipping the collection. It was what I wanted to do anyways and it just makes life easiest.
They are the only game I town that just allows me to box everything up and get some money for it. The prices seemed reasonable, but in all honesty I wasn't trying to get as much for my cards as I could. I was just trying to clean house a bit and get rid of some good fun card that wouldn't make it back into a deck I'll use. I mean how many hidden strings can 1 man really run :).
They are the only game I town that just allows me to box everything up and get some money for it. The prices seemed reasonable, but in all honesty I wasn't trying to get as much for my cards as I could. I was just trying to clean house a bit and get rid of some good fun card that wouldn't make it back into a deck I'll use. I mean how many hidden strings can 1 man really run :).
Connor
Review left Sep 11 2025
Shipment processed Sep 03 2025
Review
Great communication and completion speed for my order, the payout was also clearly communicated
Great communication and completion speed for my order, the payout was also clearly communicated
Gabriel Josko
Review left Sep 11 2025
Review
The process was just as easy as buylisting, and it would have been even easier if I selected the unsorted option. Payments were issued by the deadlines given.
The process was just as easy as buylisting, and it would have been even easier if I selected the unsorted option. Payments were issued by the deadlines given.
Copefresh
Review left Sep 11 2025
Shipment processed Aug 30 2025
Review
Whole team is phenomenal taking care of processing so quickly and accurately
Whole team is phenomenal taking care of processing so quickly and accurately
Chad
Review left Sep 11 2025
Shipment processed Aug 30 2025
Review
Great to sell your cards to if you want your cards devalued by 75%.
Great to sell your cards to if you want your cards devalued by 75%.
Terrence Murphy
Review left Sep 11 2025
Review
The process was straightforward with no issues duirng the process
The process was straightforward with no issues duirng the process
Hugh Jan
Review left Sep 11 2025
Review
Not bad to test it out, might use again in future. I sell on TCGplayer (which is the conditioning guide they use) and have to say they under graded a bunch of cards. NM on all the cheap cards and MP on the more expensive cards. For what it is it's fast and good way to get rid of cards quickly that might sit in inventory for 2-6+ months if I sold myself.
Not bad to test it out, might use again in future. I sell on TCGplayer (which is the conditioning guide they use) and have to say they under graded a bunch of cards. NM on all the cheap cards and MP on the more expensive cards. For what it is it's fast and good way to get rid of cards quickly that might sit in inventory for 2-6+ months if I sold myself.
Alec allen
Review left Sep 11 2025
Review
This has been the best experience that I have had selling cards. Card conduit let's you know how things are going every step of the way. They also give you great prices for your cards I would 10 out of 10 recommend this service to people
This has been the best experience that I have had selling cards. Card conduit let's you know how things are going every step of the way. They also give you great prices for your cards I would 10 out of 10 recommend this service to people
Orson U.
Review left Sep 10 2025
Shipment processed Sep 03 2025
Review
The process is simple and it took a reasonable amount of time, thank yall again!
The process is simple and it took a reasonable amount of time, thank yall again!
Phillip
Review left Sep 10 2025
Review
The process was fairly easy, looking forward to do business in the future.
The process was fairly easy, looking forward to do business in the future.
Nathanial Bennett
Review left Sep 10 2025
Review
Easy process, quick payment. I've used other card selling platforms and this was by far the easiest and highest paying.
Easy process, quick payment. I've used other card selling platforms and this was by far the easiest and highest paying.
Josiah DeFer
Review left Sep 10 2025
Review
The process was easy for a small fee. Would recommend!
The process was easy for a small fee. Would recommend!
Matt
Review left Sep 09 2025
Review
Overall, especially compared to manually buylisting each card, using CardConduit was pretty quick and easy. If you're willing to spend a little more time sifting through your collection for cards worth selling you can actually get a better rate than just sending in the whole box. I definitely recommend that option, but it was a bit time consuming.
Overall, especially compared to manually buylisting each card, using CardConduit was pretty quick and easy. If you're willing to spend a little more time sifting through your collection for cards worth selling you can actually get a better rate than just sending in the whole box. I definitely recommend that option, but it was a bit time consuming.
David Weilnau
Review left Sep 09 2025
Review
The curated service is so easy to use, I've compared the return from CC to my local stores and in most cases CC is as good or better on the payment!
The curated service is so easy to use, I've compared the return from CC to my local stores and in most cases CC is as good or better on the payment!
Rene Rebollo
Review left Sep 08 2025
Review
The process was super easy and gave better prices then other shops or sites that buy singles
The process was super easy and gave better prices then other shops or sites that buy singles
Brian Butler
Review left Sep 08 2025
Review
Exteremely easy and fair service. I will not hesitate to use them again in the future.
Exteremely easy and fair service. I will not hesitate to use them again in the future.
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every
previous customer to leave a review.
Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page.
We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a
review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).