Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service
(5863)
Rob Lucchetti
Review left Oct 30 2025
Review
Took a risk sending out what I felt was a huge amount of money's worth of cards. Got the report back and was very happy with the results.
Took a risk sending out what I felt was a huge amount of money's worth of cards. Got the report back and was very happy with the results.
Steve
Review left Oct 30 2025
Review
Most of the other store buylists are a hassle, tcgplayer is gone and a thing of the past. Card conduit is fantastic for anyone, if you don't feel like sorting they've got you, if you want to take all the time to get as much as you can, you can. They are -very- competitive with their prices and make the job very easy.
Most of the other store buylists are a hassle, tcgplayer is gone and a thing of the past. Card conduit is fantastic for anyone, if you don't feel like sorting they've got you, if you want to take all the time to get as much as you can, you can. They are -very- competitive with their prices and make the job very easy.
Adam Bretsch
Review left Oct 30 2025
Review
Responded quickly to questions. Quick good service, payment arrived quickly.
Briefly questioned my own sanity that the cards were graded so low, much worse than when I had them evaluated at a local game store, but with more cards able to be bought here I had no choice but accept the grading. Har ... Read more
Briefly questioned my own sanity that the cards were graded so low, much worse than when I had them evaluated at a local game store, but with more cards able to be bought here I had no choice but accept the grading. Har ... Read more
Responded quickly to questions. Quick good service, payment arrived quickly.
Briefly questioned my own sanity that the cards were graded so low, much worse than when I had them evaluated at a local game store, but with more cards able to be bought here I had no choice but accept the grading. Harsher standards are acceptable for an online service that takes away the friction from the process, and I can understand how near mint really means mint condition if you look at it from a perspective of a bulk card purchaser.
With the sentiments of a long time gamer, GG WP
Briefly questioned my own sanity that the cards were graded so low, much worse than when I had them evaluated at a local game store, but with more cards able to be bought here I had no choice but accept the grading. Harsher standards are acceptable for an online service that takes away the friction from the process, and I can understand how near mint really means mint condition if you look at it from a perspective of a bulk card purchaser.
With the sentiments of a long time gamer, GG WP
Chuck S
Review left Oct 30 2025
Review
Every step was clearly explained and easy to follow. Communication was consistent throughout the process. For a relatively niche service, the whole thing exudes professionalism and care for the customer. If I ever build up another collection of cards worth selling, this would be the first place I check!
Every step was clearly explained and easy to follow. Communication was consistent throughout the process. For a relatively niche service, the whole thing exudes professionalism and care for the customer. If I ever build up another collection of cards worth selling, this would be the first place I check!
Tim
Review left Oct 29 2025
Shipment processed Oct 17 2025
Review
Very easy to work with. Card grading felt a little critical but they were able to provide an explanation and photos when I asked. Corrected some issues quickly with great communication. Was helping a friend with their collection and will return for my collection down the line.
Very easy to work with. Card grading felt a little critical but they were able to provide an explanation and photos when I asked. Corrected some issues quickly with great communication. Was helping a friend with their collection and will return for my collection down the line.
Ben W
Review left Oct 29 2025
Review
Did a large sorted shipment and processing and shipment went very smoothly and faster than the estimate, will be using again!
Did a large sorted shipment and processing and shipment went very smoothly and faster than the estimate, will be using again!
Dylan Gehrtz
Review left Oct 29 2025
Review
Smooth transaction, would definitely use again when selling a collection.
Smooth transaction, would definitely use again when selling a collection.
Vincent Marianelli
Review left Oct 28 2025
Review
Yes the process was easy. Nick was very helpful with a lengthy email response to my questions. I was disappointed with the high shipping costs in my area, which was not covered by CardConduit. Would recommend to anyone looking to sell magic cards!
Yes the process was easy. Nick was very helpful with a lengthy email response to my questions. I was disappointed with the high shipping costs in my area, which was not covered by CardConduit. Would recommend to anyone looking to sell magic cards!
Jeremy
Review left Oct 28 2025
Review
Very professional and transparent process. Fair evaluation, and fast payment. I'll definitely use again.
Very professional and transparent process. Fair evaluation, and fast payment. I'll definitely use again.
Matt L.
Review left Oct 27 2025
Review
I decided to get rid of my bulk and found this service. I put in the work to find all the cards worth anything packaged them up and sent them over. I read a ton of positive reviews and some about the grading being harsh, but I went in assuming the worst and got a far better result than expected. Definitely would use again.
I decided to get rid of my bulk and found this service. I put in the work to find all the cards worth anything packaged them up and sent them over. I read a ton of positive reviews and some about the grading being harsh, but I went in assuming the worst and got a far better result than expected. Definitely would use again.
Memnon
Review left Oct 27 2025
Review
Would have liked a little more payout but always a good time.
Would have liked a little more payout but always a good time.
James
Review left Oct 27 2025
Review
Getting rid of collection seemed like it would be a long hassle but Card Conduit made the process simple and quick. The transaction didn’t leave me feeling cheated afterwards it was a fair and reasonable exchange for both parties which is rare these days. I would suggest Card Conduit for anyone lo
...
Read more
Getting rid of collection seemed like it would be a long hassle but Card Conduit made the process simple and quick. The transaction didn’t leave me feeling cheated afterwards it was a fair and reasonable exchange for both parties which is rare these days. I would suggest Card Conduit for anyone looking to avoid headaches that come with selling cards through multiple buyers and just deal directly with Card Conduit.
David Ding
Review left Oct 27 2025
Review
The process felt smooth with quick turnaround and fair processing.
The process felt smooth with quick turnaround and fair processing.
Casey Graham
Review left Oct 27 2025
Review
Selling to CardConduit was incredibly easy and convenient. The entire process—from submitting my cards to getting paid—was straightforward and hassle-free. Their website made it simple to organize and ship my collection, and I appreciated the clear communication throughout. I’ll definitely use
...
Read more
Selling to CardConduit was incredibly easy and convenient. The entire process—from submitting my cards to getting paid—was straightforward and hassle-free. Their website made it simple to organize and ship my collection, and I appreciated the clear communication throughout. I’ll definitely use CardConduit again the next time I want to sell cards without all the extra work!
Tucker OBrien
Review left Oct 26 2025
Review
I would sell my cards with no one else. Easiest process and always fair pricing.
I would sell my cards with no one else. Easiest process and always fair pricing.
L1fewater
Review left Oct 24 2025
Review
Card Conduit is always a slam dunk for selling unneeded dupes and bulk. Every process has been smooth and easy, and the payment always comes quickly after processing.
Card Conduit is always a slam dunk for selling unneeded dupes and bulk. Every process has been smooth and easy, and the payment always comes quickly after processing.
Dylan
Review left Oct 24 2025
Review
Card Conduit saved me many hours of uploading cards and assessing quality levels. Yes, you can potentially get more by individually selling your cards, but is it worth the time? Card Conduit provides a unique and efficient solution.
Card Conduit saved me many hours of uploading cards and assessing quality levels. Yes, you can potentially get more by individually selling your cards, but is it worth the time? Card Conduit provides a unique and efficient solution.
Jake
Review left Oct 24 2025
Review
Best price received with no hassle. Super quick turnaround time.
Best price received with no hassle. Super quick turnaround time.
Jake
Review left Oct 24 2025
Review
Super easy process, quick turnaround and the best price received. Will do business with again.
Super easy process, quick turnaround and the best price received. Will do business with again.
Alex Zammataro
Review left Oct 24 2025
Review
Quick and easy process. Very clear on all steps when receiving and sending payment.
Quick and easy process. Very clear on all steps when receiving and sending payment.
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every
previous customer to leave a review.
Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page.
We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a
review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).