Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service
(5629)
Matthew Cohen
Review left Sep 07 2025
Review
The entire process was very easy, and I was well communicated with and treated kindly by Card Conduit staff member Nick Anderson. I look forward to utilizing their services again in the future
The entire process was very easy, and I was well communicated with and treated kindly by Card Conduit staff member Nick Anderson. I look forward to utilizing their services again in the future
Joe
Review left Sep 07 2025
Review
The process is straightforward and there are no surprises. CC follows through with what they advertise.
The process is straightforward and there are no surprises. CC follows through with what they advertise.
Neal
Review left Sep 07 2025
Review
Easy to follow instructions, smooth shipment/review process, and no hidden fees. Highly recommended!
Easy to follow instructions, smooth shipment/review process, and no hidden fees. Highly recommended!
Andrew Hofmann
Review left Sep 06 2025
Review
Overall directions were easy and the system gives a comprehensive overview of the process and tracks the results. The report out data after everything is processed is interesting to look at as well. Will likely use again I have a large collection I am in the midst of selling.
Overall directions were easy and the system gives a comprehensive overview of the process and tracks the results. The report out data after everything is processed is interesting to look at as well. Will likely use again I have a large collection I am in the midst of selling.
Donovan
Review left Sep 05 2025
Review
I was a little hesitant to send a card collection to a third party, but the level of professionalism this company showed took all worries away. Since selling individuals is tedious work, I’m sending card lots to Card Condiut from now on. All steps layed out, easy to follow and was contacted every step of the way. This is the way!
I was a little hesitant to send a card collection to a third party, but the level of professionalism this company showed took all worries away. Since selling individuals is tedious work, I’m sending card lots to Card Condiut from now on. All steps layed out, easy to follow and was contacted every step of the way. This is the way!
Benjamin
Review left Sep 05 2025
Shipment processed Aug 28 2025
$1,797.00
payout, $84.67
fees
Review
The whole process start to finish was excellent. I feel like the grading was fair and aligned with my expectations. Would I want more things rated NM? Sure, but realistically my expectation was that the average was LP and that's what happened. Would 100% use again.
The whole process start to finish was excellent. I feel like the grading was fair and aligned with my expectations. Would I want more things rated NM? Sure, but realistically my expectation was that the average was LP and that's what happened. Would 100% use again.
KATHERINE F BENNETT
Review left Sep 05 2025
Review
My son had piles of Magic cards and only uses a fraction of them in the deck he plays with. I know nothing about them and my son didn't have the time to sort through them all. Card Conduit made it easy to look them up and get an estimate of their value. I sent them in and they paid a fair price for
...
Read more
My son had piles of Magic cards and only uses a fraction of them in the deck he plays with. I know nothing about them and my son didn't have the time to sort through them all. Card Conduit made it easy to look them up and get an estimate of their value. I sent them in and they paid a fair price for them, with a clear explanation for their value. I will definitely use them again and recommend it to others.
Jory Tudder
Review left Sep 05 2025
Review
Paid very quickly after package was received, thanks to the people who helped with my order. Would recommend to anyone looking for an easy transaction.
Paid very quickly after package was received, thanks to the people who helped with my order. Would recommend to anyone looking for an easy transaction.
Nick
Review left Sep 04 2025
Review
Card conduit is a great way to sell cards of modest value. I received reasonable value for my cards with minimal hassle. I would be happy to do business again. Thanks Nick!
Card conduit is a great way to sell cards of modest value. I received reasonable value for my cards with minimal hassle. I would be happy to do business again. Thanks Nick!
Ryan Wilkinson
Review left Sep 04 2025
Review
easiest way to get what you need and in the shortest amount of time!
easiest way to get what you need and in the shortest amount of time!
Dale G.
Review left Sep 04 2025
Review
CardConduit made selling a part of my collection fast and easy. I really appreciated working with them, and hope to do so again in the future!
CardConduit made selling a part of my collection fast and easy. I really appreciated working with them, and hope to do so again in the future!
TC
Review left Sep 04 2025
Review
The process is so simple I wish I could do it for other things I want to sell in my life. Wanna buy my car??
Ship the cards, enjoy your life and get an email about a week later. Its that simple.
Ship the cards, enjoy your life and get an email about a week later. Its that simple.
The process is so simple I wish I could do it for other things I want to sell in my life. Wanna buy my car??
Ship the cards, enjoy your life and get an email about a week later. Its that simple.
Ship the cards, enjoy your life and get an email about a week later. Its that simple.
Erik
Review left Sep 04 2025
Review
This is a great service for card sellers, the report at the end let's you see the exact breakdown of your shipment and the prices are always fair
This is a great service for card sellers, the report at the end let's you see the exact breakdown of your shipment and the prices are always fair
Shaun
Review left Sep 04 2025
Review
Quick and easy way to sell my cards, will definitely use them again
Quick and easy way to sell my cards, will definitely use them again
Jonathan
Review left Sep 04 2025
Review
Efficient and honest! Highly recommend this service
Efficient and honest! Highly recommend this service
Robert Braunstein
Review left Sep 03 2025
Review
Process was easy and familiar. This is sixth batch of cards I've sent in and had no problems. Service is quick and valuation is fair.
Process was easy and familiar. This is sixth batch of cards I've sent in and had no problems. Service is quick and valuation is fair.
Nathan Bundy
Review left Sep 03 2025
Review
Shrinking my collection from taking up a tote to sitting on a single shelf, Card Conduit made it simple to process through thousands of cards, and still earned me a bit of cash at the end of the day. Admittedly, after taking apart many commander decks and trying to sort through several drafts and pr
...
Read more
Shrinking my collection from taking up a tote to sitting on a single shelf, Card Conduit made it simple to process through thousands of cards, and still earned me a bit of cash at the end of the day. Admittedly, after taking apart many commander decks and trying to sort through several drafts and preleases for the best of it, sending it all it at once made me think twice about losing value on a handful of singles, but ultimately, made the process so much simpler for me, as all I had to worry about was boxing it up and shipping it out! I could taken a bit of time more with the curated service, as I've done in the past, but taking it all in one go really simplified the whole thing, and ultimately saved me several hours of the headache that usually comes with parting with a paper collection. Thanks, CC!
Richard C.
Review left Sep 03 2025
Review
Dealing with Card Conduit is super easy and the report they send out is incredibly comprehensive. Looking forward to doing more biz in the future.
Dealing with Card Conduit is super easy and the report they send out is incredibly comprehensive. Looking forward to doing more biz in the future.
William
Review left Sep 03 2025
Shipment processed Sep 02 2025
Review
I would recommend to any of my friends. The website was great, the way they go about the whole process was great. I don't think I have amy suggestions on how to improve. Overall, Thank You!!
I would recommend to any of my friends. The website was great, the way they go about the whole process was great. I don't think I have amy suggestions on how to improve. Overall, Thank You!!
Marcus
Review left Sep 02 2025
Review
I had like 3000 cards I needed to sell. With my job as the CEO of a fortune-5 oil conglomerate, my smoking hot bikini-model wife’s slumber parties, and managing a charity that just cured cancer, I just couldn’t fit selling my cards into my schedule. I am a failure. God will judge me for my weakn
...
Read more
I had like 3000 cards I needed to sell. With my job as the CEO of a fortune-5 oil conglomerate, my smoking hot bikini-model wife’s slumber parties, and managing a charity that just cured cancer, I just couldn’t fit selling my cards into my schedule. I am a failure. God will judge me for my weakness. Card Conduit helped me get the cards out of my house fast. I usually make my own version of things when I like them. I made my own Verizon called Vermarcus, and my own Ferrari, Ferrarcus. I am going to commit seppuku for not making my own Card Conduit.
I give it 420.69 out of 420.69 Ferrarci
I give it 420.69 out of 420.69 Ferrarci
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every
previous customer to leave a review.
Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page.
We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a
review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).