Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service
(6305)
David Ding
Review left Feb 24 2026
Review
For the expedited (2%) service, the processing was very fast and I felt that I got the value of my cards back.
For the expedited (2%) service, the processing was very fast and I felt that I got the value of my cards back.
James
Review left Feb 24 2026
Review
The process was very easy and they have a lot of help in the FAQ. I had no issues and the payout for my collection was the best I could find anywhere. Overall I was very happy with this service and will be doing this again.
The process was very easy and they have a lot of help in the FAQ. I had no issues and the payout for my collection was the best I could find anywhere. Overall I was very happy with this service and will be doing this again.
Alfian Poon Yong Sheng
Review left Feb 24 2026
Review
Thanks again! Will definitely send more. This one was faster than usual so I was pretty happy
Thanks again! Will definitely send more. This one was faster than usual so I was pretty happy
Matt Smith
Review left Feb 24 2026
Review
Card Conduit it my go-to way to sell unused/unneeded cards. They are fast, communicative, and incredibly easy.
Card Conduit it my go-to way to sell unused/unneeded cards. They are fast, communicative, and incredibly easy.
Jillian
Review left Feb 23 2026
Review
I had inherited a bunch of cards from my dad and was unsure if they would be worth anything. I was pleasantly surprised at how much I was able to get! The process was easy and they responded to my question super quickly. I would definitely recommend this service.
I had inherited a bunch of cards from my dad and was unsure if they would be worth anything. I was pleasantly surprised at how much I was able to get! The process was easy and they responded to my question super quickly. I would definitely recommend this service.
michael
Review left Feb 23 2026
Review
I always have a good experience when selling my cards to cardconduit.
I always have a good experience when selling my cards to cardconduit.
David L Knudsen
Review left Feb 23 2026
Review
I felt this shipment was undergraded. Almost all of the 120 cards I sent were unplayed, the only wear on them was from sitting in boxes for years. Over half these cards were graded as LP or MP and I feel more of them should have been graded NM. Oddly, the only cards that were used in a deck were
...
Read more
I felt this shipment was undergraded. Almost all of the 120 cards I sent were unplayed, the only wear on them was from sitting in boxes for years. Over half these cards were graded as LP or MP and I feel more of them should have been graded NM. Oddly, the only cards that were used in a deck were the 2 Trumpeting Carnosaurs and they were graded NM! Downgrading this shipment cost me about $80 from NM condition. I don't think I will sell any more cards to this vendor, as the grading seemed to get stricter with each shipment I sent. This review reflects my latest shipment to Card Conduit.
Chad
Review left Feb 23 2026
Shipment processed Feb 20 2026
Review
Everything went very smoothly. The sorting was quick and the grading was fair. Highly recommened.
Everything went very smoothly. The sorting was quick and the grading was fair. Highly recommened.
SpellVault
Review left Feb 23 2026
Review
I've been using CC for years now. The new addition of the auto sifting is an amazing process. I'm impressed and excited to use it more in the future!
I've been using CC for years now. The new addition of the auto sifting is an amazing process. I'm impressed and excited to use it more in the future!
Tim
Review left Feb 22 2026
Review
Thank you for processing my order, auto sift service is awesome.
Thank you for processing my order, auto sift service is awesome.
Zach Guerrette
Review left Feb 22 2026
Review
The Card Conduit process was quite simple and efficient, compatible with common card scanning apps, detailed shipping recommendations, quick card evaluation time, and rapid payment via direct deposit. The service is very much appreciated!
The Card Conduit process was quite simple and efficient, compatible with common card scanning apps, detailed shipping recommendations, quick card evaluation time, and rapid payment via direct deposit. The service is very much appreciated!
Tyler M.
Review left Feb 22 2026
Shipment processed Feb 12 2026
Review
Transparent assessment. Fair grading. Fast turnaround. Overall great experience.
Transparent assessment. Fair grading. Fast turnaround. Overall great experience.
Sam Suarez
Review left Feb 21 2026
Review
After a fun weekend of sorting cards and reminiscing on old sets and memories. I chose the auto-sift option for most of my bulk and can’t believe how easy and what great value I received. Already started recommending this option to friends. Thank you again!
After a fun weekend of sorting cards and reminiscing on old sets and memories. I chose the auto-sift option for most of my bulk and can’t believe how easy and what great value I received. Already started recommending this option to friends. Thank you again!
Nate
Review left Feb 21 2026
Review
I have used Card Conduit in the past to remove bulk from my collection, but also to sell of my more impressive assets. The process is simple, and worth the while no matter their condition. I must say that selling magic cards cannot be made easier or more accessible. I recommend using the curated list for valuable cards especially 👌
I have used Card Conduit in the past to remove bulk from my collection, but also to sell of my more impressive assets. The process is simple, and worth the while no matter their condition. I must say that selling magic cards cannot be made easier or more accessible. I recommend using the curated list for valuable cards especially 👌
Charlie
Review left Feb 21 2026
Review
The process is really simple, and I feel like I got good value out of my cards. If I end up with a small collection of things worth selling again, I will be back.
The process is really simple, and I feel like I got good value out of my cards. If I end up with a small collection of things worth selling again, I will be back.
Ron bender
Review left Feb 21 2026
Review
Depending on which service you choose you can make about the same you would get selling on other sites like tcg player. If you do the curated service and are selling a card above $50 it makes sense to send it to CC.
Depending on which service you choose you can make about the same you would get selling on other sites like tcg player. If you do the curated service and are selling a card above $50 it makes sense to send it to CC.
Alex
Review left Feb 21 2026
Review
So fast and easy. I send my cards in and have used card conduit for the third time now and each time gets easier.
So fast and easy. I send my cards in and have used card conduit for the third time now and each time gets easier.
Steven Dempsey
Review left Feb 21 2026
Review
The process was super easy and really fast. The longest part was inputting my cards for the list. But from start to finish it took less than a week from making the list, shipping it off, to getting paid. Would definitely recommend this to others and will be using Card Conduit again
The process was super easy and really fast. The longest part was inputting my cards for the list. But from start to finish it took less than a week from making the list, shipping it off, to getting paid. Would definitely recommend this to others and will be using Card Conduit again
Joe
Review left Feb 21 2026
Shipment processed Feb 13 2026
$4,402.44
payout, $231.71
fees
Review
Used multiple times - most recently for 2 shipments. Fast, thorough, and willing to make any issues right.
Used multiple times - most recently for 2 shipments. Fast, thorough, and willing to make any issues right.
Shadow
Review left Feb 21 2026
Review
Really helped me clear my closet and make some cash!
Really helped me clear my closet and make some cash!
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every
previous customer to leave a review.
Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page.
We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a
review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).