Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service
(5856)
Anonymous
Review left Feb 15 2026
Shipment processed Jan 28 2026
Review
3 packages were sent out at once therefore they all had the same tracking information well they claimed to receive to and not the 3rd after confirming it was received and they r saying the cards weren’t in the box now why in heck would I pay to send an empty box when they received the other orders
...
Read more
3 packages were sent out at once therefore they all had the same tracking information well they claimed to receive to and not the 3rd after confirming it was received and they r saying the cards weren’t in the box now why in heck would I pay to send an empty box when they received the other orders horrible experience after all started out well until they lost or are they are claiming the box was empty after sending a confirmation it was received
Card Conduit Team
Replied Feb 15 2026
We require customers to label each shipment with the unique Shipment ID provided during registration. In this case, the customer mislabeled their box -- which became apparent when our processing team found that the enclosed cards belonged to another sorted shipment the customer had registered with us.
Our support team promptly reached out to notify the customer of the discrepancy. We did not receive a response. We placed the affected shipment on hold and, after waiting without hearing back, proceeded to process the shipment that matched the cards we had in hand.
Several weeks later, the customer contacted us claiming we received cards that our records -- including intake notes, outreach history, and video evidence -- show we did not receive. We shared our original communication about the issue, which the customer states they did not see. The customer also indicated they had emailed us multiple times, though we have no record of those messages.
We take shipment accuracy seriously and make every effort to flag issues early and work with customers to resolve them. We're confident in our process and documentation in this case.
Our support team promptly reached out to notify the customer of the discrepancy. We did not receive a response. We placed the affected shipment on hold and, after waiting without hearing back, proceeded to process the shipment that matched the cards we had in hand.
Several weeks later, the customer contacted us claiming we received cards that our records -- including intake notes, outreach history, and video evidence -- show we did not receive. We shared our original communication about the issue, which the customer states they did not see. The customer also indicated they had emailed us multiple times, though we have no record of those messages.
We take shipment accuracy seriously and make every effort to flag issues early and work with customers to resolve them. We're confident in our process and documentation in this case.
We require customers to label each shipment with the unique Shipment ID provided during registration. In this case, the customer mislabeled their box -- which became apparent when our processing team found that the enclosed cards belonged to another sorted shipment the customer had registered with us.
Our support team promptly reached out to notify the customer of the discrepancy. We did not receive a response. We placed the affected shipment on hold and, after waiting without hearing back, proceeded to process the shipment that matched the cards we had in hand.
Several weeks later, the customer contacted us claiming we received cards that our records -- including intake notes, outreach history, and video evidence -- show we did not receive. We shared our original communication about the issue, which the customer states they did not see. The customer also indicated they had emailed us multiple times, though we have no record of those messages.
We take shipment accuracy seriously and make every effort to flag issues early and work with customers to resolve them. We're confident in our process and documentation in this case.
Our support team promptly reached out to notify the customer of the discrepancy. We did not receive a response. We placed the affected shipment on hold and, after waiting without hearing back, proceeded to process the shipment that matched the cards we had in hand.
Several weeks later, the customer contacted us claiming we received cards that our records -- including intake notes, outreach history, and video evidence -- show we did not receive. We shared our original communication about the issue, which the customer states they did not see. The customer also indicated they had emailed us multiple times, though we have no record of those messages.
We take shipment accuracy seriously and make every effort to flag issues early and work with customers to resolve them. We're confident in our process and documentation in this case.
Dan
Review left Feb 14 2026
Review
I had a set of cards from my childhood. I'd managed to sell a few of the stand out ones independently, but Card Conduit gave me a chance to sell in mass the cards that wouldn't move independently. The process was simple, the valuation seemed fair, and the transaction was quick and painless. That you very much!
I had a set of cards from my childhood. I'd managed to sell a few of the stand out ones independently, but Card Conduit gave me a chance to sell in mass the cards that wouldn't move independently. The process was simple, the valuation seemed fair, and the transaction was quick and painless. That you very much!
Jared Jagotka
Review left Feb 14 2026
Review
I used to use tcgplayers buylist service to sell off cards I no longer wanted. After they discontinued that service I found card conduit and decided to give it a try. Their website is well constructed being user friendly and quite intuitive. All of their fees are laid out transparently for a quick a
...
Read more
I used to use tcgplayers buylist service to sell off cards I no longer wanted. After they discontinued that service I found card conduit and decided to give it a try. Their website is well constructed being user friendly and quite intuitive. All of their fees are laid out transparently for a quick and honest process. The card selection tool is fast and makes selecting the correct printing of your cards easy. I will continue to use this service for my buylist needs as I continue to buy and sell trading cards.
justin
Review left Feb 14 2026
Review
easiest way to sell cards in bulk and get what there worth without any effort except for shipping- awesome service
easiest way to sell cards in bulk and get what there worth without any effort except for shipping- awesome service
Ilya Zarembsky
Review left Feb 13 2026
Review
This was my second or third shipment in recent weeks and the experience was once again excellent. Processing was timely, payment was prompt, and grading seemed quite fair and in line with my own perception. Also, the web application that walks you through the card adding/sorting processes and later
...
Read more
This was my second or third shipment in recent weeks and the experience was once again excellent. Processing was timely, payment was prompt, and grading seemed quite fair and in line with my own perception. Also, the web application that walks you through the card adding/sorting processes and later helps you keep track of the shipment transit/processing status is well designed. Finally, and this is huge, the staff are very responsive over email in case of any questions, clarifications, etc. Honestly, selling to CC has consistently been a much better experience than I expected, and I've gotten more $ than I expected I would by using a service like this.
Alex Haluska
Review left Feb 13 2026
Review
Team worked fast, communicated quickly when they needed more time due to the unexpected size of the order, and still was able to quickly get me an extremely fair price for all of the cards I sent. Already getting my next shipment ready to send!
Team worked fast, communicated quickly when they needed more time due to the unexpected size of the order, and still was able to quickly get me an extremely fair price for all of the cards I sent. Already getting my next shipment ready to send!
Bryan
Review left Feb 13 2026
Review
Best and easiest buy list experience! Happy with the grading and payout.
Best and easiest buy list experience! Happy with the grading and payout.
quinn
Review left Feb 13 2026
Review
great process fair prices, easier then listing 100 cards on TCGplayer sends payments quickly. accommodated my altered card submission list!
great process fair prices, easier then listing 100 cards on TCGplayer sends payments quickly. accommodated my altered card submission list!
Jace Purdy
Review left Feb 13 2026
Review
The process was easy and clearly outlined. Payment was fair and quick. Would absolutely recommend to friends
The process was easy and clearly outlined. Payment was fair and quick. Would absolutely recommend to friends
Greg Smith
Review left Feb 12 2026
Review
Sent around 600 bulk rares and mythics for sorting and processing. The process for registering a shipment is really simple. Overall I would say Card Conduit is fair and I am satisfied with the order processing time and valuation of the cards. Once I accepted the final review, payment was received th
...
Read more
Sent around 600 bulk rares and mythics for sorting and processing. The process for registering a shipment is really simple. Overall I would say Card Conduit is fair and I am satisfied with the order processing time and valuation of the cards. Once I accepted the final review, payment was received though my PayPal in less than 24 hours. I would use Card Conduit again if needed.
Chris Schuit
Review left Feb 12 2026
Review
process was very easy. Great communication with Card Conduit personal. I was priced fairly.
process was very easy. Great communication with Card Conduit personal. I was priced fairly.
RG
Review left Feb 12 2026
Review
Easy to work with, fast payment Easy to work with, fast payment
Easy to work with, fast payment Easy to work with, fast payment
Chris
Review left Feb 12 2026
Review
This is my 4th or 5th time using Card Conduit and the experience has been 5/5 each time!
This is my 4th or 5th time using Card Conduit and the experience has been 5/5 each time!
O U
Review left Feb 12 2026
Shipment processed Jan 23 2026
Review
I've used this service a few times and they have always been fair and nice. Thank yall!
I've used this service a few times and they have always been fair and nice. Thank yall!
Jonathan M
Review left Feb 11 2026
Shipment processed Feb 07 2026
Review
I normally sell all of my cards individually or to my LGS, so selling to CC was a bit scary. Thankfully my doubts and worries were all misplaced. The communication between staff and customer was great, all of my questions were answered in a timely manner. My shipment was processed much faster than a
...
Read more
I normally sell all of my cards individually or to my LGS, so selling to CC was a bit scary. Thankfully my doubts and worries were all misplaced. The communication between staff and customer was great, all of my questions were answered in a timely manner. My shipment was processed much faster than anticipated as well as my payment. Overall I would rate my first experience with CC an 8/10. I wasn't the biggest fan of the UI when it came to sorting my cards and picking certain versions, as well as importing a list from Manabox. I also didn't agree on how some of the cards were graded, but that's my personal bias.
Clint M
Review left Feb 11 2026
Review
The process of selling cards was simple. Evaluation of cards at lower quality is odd. I'd expected about $40 more.
This next bit is more on the fault of snail mail. The check delivery took about 8 days.
Overall a positive experience.
This next bit is more on the fault of snail mail. The check delivery took about 8 days.
Overall a positive experience.
The process of selling cards was simple. Evaluation of cards at lower quality is odd. I'd expected about $40 more.
This next bit is more on the fault of snail mail. The check delivery took about 8 days.
Overall a positive experience.
This next bit is more on the fault of snail mail. The check delivery took about 8 days.
Overall a positive experience.
Andre Whyne
Review left Feb 11 2026
Review
I’ve always used Card Conduit when conduction larger sales of my cards. They are quick with their services and also fair on their prices. I highly recommend them.
I’ve always used Card Conduit when conduction larger sales of my cards. They are quick with their services and also fair on their prices. I highly recommend them.
Rob
Review left Feb 11 2026
Shipment processed Jan 30 2026
Review
CardConduit did an awesome job, gave good value, was professional and timely. Would recommend highly.
CardConduit did an awesome job, gave good value, was professional and timely. Would recommend highly.
Tyler Gee
Review left Feb 11 2026
Review
I had been sitting on my cards for years wanting to sell them cause they just sat there not being used.
I had seen ads for this company a few times and decided to take a shot. It took exactly the length they say on the website.
I was happy with the results and would recommend to anyone needing a service like this.
I had seen ads for this company a few times and decided to take a shot. It took exactly the length they say on the website.
I was happy with the results and would recommend to anyone needing a service like this.
I had been sitting on my cards for years wanting to sell them cause they just sat there not being used.
I had seen ads for this company a few times and decided to take a shot. It took exactly the length they say on the website.
I was happy with the results and would recommend to anyone needing a service like this.
I had seen ads for this company a few times and decided to take a shot. It took exactly the length they say on the website.
I was happy with the results and would recommend to anyone needing a service like this.
Anonymous
Review left Feb 11 2026
Shipment processed Feb 07 2026
Review
Great and easy experience and highly recommend
Great experience by far
Great experience by far
Great and easy experience and highly recommend
Great experience by far
Great experience by far
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every
previous customer to leave a review.
Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page.
We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a
review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).