Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service
(6603)
Jake Grabarek
Review left Jul 19 2026
Review
The process is very easy and convenient and I really enjoy the userface they publish afterwards that displays your cards and condition and value etc. I’ll gladly use this service again.
The process is very easy and convenient and I really enjoy the userface they publish afterwards that displays your cards and condition and value etc. I’ll gladly use this service again.
Chad
Review left Jul 19 2026
Review
Quick, easy, professional... Great way to upgrade your personal collection with bulk!
Quick, easy, professional... Great way to upgrade your personal collection with bulk!
Marco
Review left Jul 19 2026
Review
great service like always, thank you so much lets do it
great service like always, thank you so much lets do it
Marco
Review left Jul 19 2026
Review
great service like always, thank you so much lets do it
great service like always, thank you so much lets do it
Marco
Review left Jul 19 2026
Review
great service like always, thank you so much lets do it
great service like always, thank you so much lets do it
Marco
Review left Jul 19 2026
Review
great service like always, thank you so much lets do it
great service like always, thank you so much lets do it
Marco
Review left Jul 19 2026
Review
great service like always, thank you so much lets do it
great service like always, thank you so much lets do it
Marco
Review left Jul 19 2026
Review
great service like always, thank you so much lets do it
great service like always, thank you so much lets do it
Austin
Review left Jul 19 2026
Review
Always impressed with the service and speed of shipments and payouts!
Always impressed with the service and speed of shipments and payouts!
David Clark
Review left Jul 19 2026
Review
Total time from shipment to payment was good.
Pricing and rating seemed fair. The whole process was fairly easy.
Pricing and rating seemed fair. The whole process was fairly easy.
Total time from shipment to payment was good.
Pricing and rating seemed fair. The whole process was fairly easy.
Pricing and rating seemed fair. The whole process was fairly easy.
Kristen Stadler
Review left Jul 19 2026
Shipment processed Jul 01 2026
Review
Super easy process to sell my cards! The process for getting things into an order was simple enough, shipping instructions were clear, and I got a good turnaround time! Got a good payout for the cards I sent in. Will absolutely be using them again!
Super easy process to sell my cards! The process for getting things into an order was simple enough, shipping instructions were clear, and I got a good turnaround time! Got a good payout for the cards I sent in. Will absolutely be using them again!
Dom
Review left Jul 19 2026
Review
Everything was great from start to finish. Easy to understand, and process was timely. Would recommend.
Everything was great from start to finish. Easy to understand, and process was timely. Would recommend.
Shannon
Review left Jul 18 2026
Review
Great experience. Got more than I thought I would.
Great experience. Got more than I thought I would.
Will G
Review left Jul 18 2026
Review
I would highly recommend using this service if you need to sell your cards. I sold out of my EDH collection, and overall my experience was good but I should have read reviews about their grading. I had several old EDH staples in foil, bought from a variety of vendors over the years (Card Kingdom, SC
...
Read more
I would highly recommend using this service if you need to sell your cards. I sold out of my EDH collection, and overall my experience was good but I should have read reviews about their grading. I had several old EDH staples in foil, bought from a variety of vendors over the years (Card Kingdom, SCG, TCGPlayer, etc.) and many of them were graded and sold by these vendors as NM. These foils were beautiful, and were well taken care of. Double sleeved and in a binder. It was a bit of a shock to see how low some of those cards were graded by Card Conduit. Some of the cards, especially the old NM ones, were downgraded to MP. Long story short, if you have old cards to sell, particularly foils, sell those to Card Kingdom or on ebay instead. If I could do it over again, that is what I would do. Other than that, I was very happy with their service.
John Linton
Review left Jul 18 2026
Review
I have used this service several times and I have never been disappointed. Customer service is beyond reproach. If you are in the market for selling your magic cards, look no further, this is the BEST COMPANY PERIOD!
I have used this service several times and I have never been disappointed. Customer service is beyond reproach. If you are in the market for selling your magic cards, look no further, this is the BEST COMPANY PERIOD!
Fernando Fernandez
Review left Jul 18 2026
Review
Sent in two orders, one sorted, the other auto-sifted. I'm very pleased with the handling of both orders. They worked through them quickly, the grading was fair, payout was fast and the fees were very reasonable. I would highly recommend using Card Conduit if you want to sell your collection.
Sent in two orders, one sorted, the other auto-sifted. I'm very pleased with the handling of both orders. They worked through them quickly, the grading was fair, payout was fast and the fees were very reasonable. I would highly recommend using Card Conduit if you want to sell your collection.
Kevin Sanders
Review left Jul 18 2026
Review
You guys did a great job! I have no complaints. Thank you all!
You guys did a great job! I have no complaints. Thank you all!
Eric Barkman
Review left Jul 18 2026
Review
The process was easy and shipping was great. There were some cards that had no business being marked as Damaged that were apparently damaged. Since I was receiving so much more credit that going through my LGS, I decided it was just better to agree with their grading decision.
The process was easy and shipping was great. There were some cards that had no business being marked as Damaged that were apparently damaged. Since I was receiving so much more credit that going through my LGS, I decided it was just better to agree with their grading decision.
Owen
Review left Jul 17 2026
Review
Fast payment, fair and detailed grading, and customer support always keeps me in the loop
Fast payment, fair and detailed grading, and customer support always keeps me in the loop
William
Review left Jul 17 2026
Shipment processed Jul 07 2026
$249.05
payout, $5.08
fees
Review
I chose to pre-sort my cards which felt like a good deal. I received lots of communication through emails about timelines and where my cards were which was really convenient.
I chose to pre-sort my cards which felt like a good deal. I received lots of communication through emails about timelines and where my cards were which was really convenient.
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every
previous customer to leave a review.
Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page.
We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a
review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).