Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service
(5856)
Anonymous
Review left Feb 11 2026
Shipment processed Feb 10 2026
Review
Great n easy
Overall great experience and easy process
Overall great experience and easy process
Great n easy
Overall great experience and easy process
Overall great experience and easy process
Peter Trihas
Review left Feb 10 2026
Review
Overall extremely happy with their services and response time in emails should they be needed! The best services out there by far!
Overall extremely happy with their services and response time in emails should they be needed! The best services out there by far!
james roderick
Review left Feb 10 2026
Review
Traded in some cards I wasn't using got my payout about a week later
Traded in some cards I wasn't using got my payout about a week later
GP
Review left Feb 10 2026
Shipment processed Jan 07 2026
Review
So much easier than other solutions and very reasonably priced. They have different pricing models depending on the amount of work you can put in up front.
So much easier than other solutions and very reasonably priced. They have different pricing models depending on the amount of work you can put in up front.
Erick T.
Review left Feb 10 2026
Review
This was my 3rd time sending in cards to them, and this time was no exception: my order was processed quickly, and they communicated every step of the way! Would definitely sell with them again in the future!
This was my 3rd time sending in cards to them, and this time was no exception: my order was processed quickly, and they communicated every step of the way! Would definitely sell with them again in the future!
Edward
Review left Feb 10 2026
Review
I was a little worried they were going to low ball on the condition of the cards. To me they were NM and im very critical. They did the right thing and i will be using them again in the future.
I was a little worried they were going to low ball on the condition of the cards. To me they were NM and im very critical. They did the right thing and i will be using them again in the future.
Brandon
Review left Feb 10 2026
Review
I am selling my collection to pay for an engagement ring. I was using eBay, but it was too much of a hassle and i wasn’t getting much yield with their fees. Card Conduit has been great to me. Nick and Nathaniel have been great to work with. Everything has been so fast and smooth I can’t recommend card conduit enough.
I am selling my collection to pay for an engagement ring. I was using eBay, but it was too much of a hassle and i wasn’t getting much yield with their fees. Card Conduit has been great to me. Nick and Nathaniel have been great to work with. Everything has been so fast and smooth I can’t recommend card conduit enough.
JoJo
Review left Feb 10 2026
Review
Great experience. Fast processing and super straightforward experience. Fair grading and fast payout.
Great experience. Fast processing and super straightforward experience. Fair grading and fast payout.
Scott Swanstrom
Review left Feb 10 2026
Review
Outstanding service, as always! I'm a repeat customer for a reason.
Outstanding service, as always! I'm a repeat customer for a reason.
Avery
Review left Feb 10 2026
Review
Easy process and payout ax always. Great service for mtg playerz
Easy process and payout ax always. Great service for mtg playerz
Fimafeng
Review left Feb 10 2026
Review
I was expecting to have to request cards be shipped back, but was happy to see that even the worst among them (Ulamog--what happened to you!?) was able to get a fair price.
I was expecting to have to request cards be shipped back, but was happy to see that even the worst among them (Ulamog--what happened to you!?) was able to get a fair price.
Joseph Wang
Review left Feb 09 2026
Review
Professional service with fair prices and fast turnaround. Communication was clear, payment was prompt, and the whole process was hassle-free. Exactly what I was looking for. Highly recommend for anyone looking to sell their collection efficiently.
Professional service with fair prices and fast turnaround. Communication was clear, payment was prompt, and the whole process was hassle-free. Exactly what I was looking for. Highly recommend for anyone looking to sell their collection efficiently.
Sean
Review left Feb 09 2026
Review
Rather than deal with the secondary market directly for many of my most valuable MTG cards, I chose to sell through Card Conduit again. Yes, there is the singular obvious drawback of likely not getting 'full' market value for your card. However, not needing to compete with other sellers, wait for an
...
Read more
Rather than deal with the secondary market directly for many of my most valuable MTG cards, I chose to sell through Card Conduit again. Yes, there is the singular obvious drawback of likely not getting 'full' market value for your card. However, not needing to compete with other sellers, wait for an expensive card to maybe get sold, and knowing that Card Conduit is doing everything they can to ensure I get as much as I can while they can still operate their business is worth the lost cost. I had 100 cards that were market valued NM at around 2000, and I got 1750 from Card Conduit. I didn't need to wait for buyers to be interested, I didn't need to ship cards individually, I didn't need to deal with 'lost in mail' or other buyer complaints or issues. I got a good deal without any of the hassle. What's not to like.
T. Schmidt
Review left Feb 09 2026
Review
My brother and I use Card Conduit for our cards. Even though im was leary of sending cards to a company without a guarantee of the amount I would get for them. Ive only sent in fresh pulls that were sleeved and hard cased . Nick and his team have judged each accurately. And I was able to get a solid
...
Read more
My brother and I use Card Conduit for our cards. Even though im was leary of sending cards to a company without a guarantee of the amount I would get for them. Ive only sent in fresh pulls that were sleeved and hard cased . Nick and his team have judged each accurately. And I was able to get a solid price for my cards that offer a higher % rate for my cards than any competitors company such as fb ebay etc I have agreed to share my info so everyone knows that im a real person and not a company marketing director or a AI computer system. Also my grammar cant be faked haha. Thanks again Nick . ☆☆☆☆☆
Sebastian
Review left Feb 09 2026
Review
The process is extremely easy. They are always fair.
The process is extremely easy. They are always fair.
Ryan C
Review left Feb 08 2026
Shipment processed Jan 06 2026
Review
with the customer service, and the price point as well as the quote on how much i am gettting back, i would have to say that i will be selling only to card conduit moving forward.
with the customer service, and the price point as well as the quote on how much i am gettting back, i would have to say that i will be selling only to card conduit moving forward.
Jon
Review left Feb 08 2026
Shipment processed Jan 06 2026
Review
Super easy and good value, fair pricing and the entire process was made super smooth with the ability to follow your cards theough each step of the process. Would definitely use again
Super easy and good value, fair pricing and the entire process was made super smooth with the ability to follow your cards theough each step of the process. Would definitely use again
Phoenix Wachob
Review left Feb 08 2026
Review
It is a nice and easy process that makes selling cards easy. Feels good!
It is a nice and easy process that makes selling cards easy. Feels good!
Brandon Budenz
Review left Feb 08 2026
Review
I sent a shipment in and at least two-thirds of the cards were near mint. I was given the 'lightly played' rate for the whole batch of cards that had never been played.
I sent a shipment in and at least two-thirds of the cards were near mint. I was given the 'lightly played' rate for the whole batch of cards that had never been played.
Jordan
Review left Feb 08 2026
Review
Was also pleasantly surprised to receive communication from the Card Conduit team themselves when they appraised my cards. Their appraisals were accurate and very detailed. Will definitely be using their services again!
Was also pleasantly surprised to receive communication from the Card Conduit team themselves when they appraised my cards. Their appraisals were accurate and very detailed. Will definitely be using their services again!
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every
previous customer to leave a review.
Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page.
We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a
review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).