Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service
(6603)
Robert Levin
Review left Jul 11 2026
Review
Would use again, easy process, good communication.
Would use again, easy process, good communication.
Sean Wayt
Review left Jul 11 2026
Review
The most hassle free, stress free, effort free process I've ever gone through. Card conduit took care of everything all I had to do was ship them my cards. I'd choose them 10/10 times
The most hassle free, stress free, effort free process I've ever gone through. Card conduit took care of everything all I had to do was ship them my cards. I'd choose them 10/10 times
Stephen S
Review left Jul 11 2026
Review
Crystal clear about every step, and fair valuation on cards. They sent back a couple that I wanted to hold onto, and swiftly helped with any issues I had. Probably the best way to sell your cards if you aren’t gonna do a bunch of work for it!
Crystal clear about every step, and fair valuation on cards. They sent back a couple that I wanted to hold onto, and swiftly helped with any issues I had. Probably the best way to sell your cards if you aren’t gonna do a bunch of work for it!
Margie Nichols
Review left Jul 11 2026
Review
I was a little apprehensive about trying this service but it was extremely user friendly. I chose to sort my own cards and I was able to look up all my cards. When I had all my cards selected, I was given a list of what order to place them in. Very detailed instructions for shipping were given and b
...
Read more
I was a little apprehensive about trying this service but it was extremely user friendly. I chose to sort my own cards and I was able to look up all my cards. When I had all my cards selected, I was given a list of what order to place them in. Very detailed instructions for shipping were given and bam it was on the way. Every step of the way I got email confirmation and it only took a few days and I received my bank transfer. Thanks!
Matthew Berggren
Review left Jul 11 2026
Review
Fast and fair grading. Quick payment and great communication.
Fast and fair grading. Quick payment and great communication.
Luke Hoffman
Review left Jul 10 2026
Review
I was looking to cash out my collection as I don't play much anymore, and was pleasantly surprised with the deal I was getting for sorting my own cards and shipping them out. I'm now also considering sending in my bulk as well, not entirely sure on that front, but sending my major cards over was a q
...
Read more
I was looking to cash out my collection as I don't play much anymore, and was pleasantly surprised with the deal I was getting for sorting my own cards and shipping them out. I'm now also considering sending in my bulk as well, not entirely sure on that front, but sending my major cards over was a quick process (you know, after actually sorting/pricing them was done). It can be tedious, especially with how many alt arts there are and double checking they're the right versions, but that's more on MTG than Card Conduit anyways.
Anonymous
Review left Jul 10 2026
Shipment processed Jul 01 2026
Review
I would recommend card conduit, the process was fast, easy and fair.
I would recommend card conduit, the process was fast, easy and fair.
Logan Parrish
Review left Jul 10 2026
Review
It was super easy to go through and select the version of the card and the condition.
It was super easy to go through and select the version of the card and the condition.
Kyle
Review left Jul 10 2026
Review
I made a mistake on payment forms. They were quick to notice and help correct it. And payment came quickly after! I will be using them for my rares and mythics in the future.
I made a mistake on payment forms. They were quick to notice and help correct it. And payment came quickly after! I will be using them for my rares and mythics in the future.
C West
Review left Jul 10 2026
Shipment processed Jul 08 2026
$238.11
payout, $4.36
fees
Review
I consistently use card conduit to process mid to large quantities of card sales and every time the process has been incredibly easy and smooth. I have no doubts on the service level or validity of this service and I will continue to use them as my preferred method for selling cards.
I consistently use card conduit to process mid to large quantities of card sales and every time the process has been incredibly easy and smooth. I have no doubts on the service level or validity of this service and I will continue to use them as my preferred method for selling cards.
Alex Michelfelder
Review left Jul 10 2026
Review
I enjoyed using Card Conduit to ship my cards back. I did choose to self sort the cards before shipping them out, so that took some extra time for a bit of saving on fees. But that also gave me a chance to look through my collection again and choose some cards I want to keep, and I appreciate that.
... Read more
... Read more
I enjoyed using Card Conduit to ship my cards back. I did choose to self sort the cards before shipping them out, so that took some extra time for a bit of saving on fees. But that also gave me a chance to look through my collection again and choose some cards I want to keep, and I appreciate that.
Absolutely would recommend Card Conduit to anyone who wants to sell off some Magic cards, and if I ever amass a large enough collection again I'll come back to Card Conduit if I want to sell some.
Absolutely would recommend Card Conduit to anyone who wants to sell off some Magic cards, and if I ever amass a large enough collection again I'll come back to Card Conduit if I want to sell some.
Lucas
Review left Jul 10 2026
Review
I played Magic a lot when I was young but it had been more than 10 years since my last game so I decided to sell my collection. I had no idea how much it was worth but I was extremely pleased by the results of selling it here. I would definitely recommend Card Conduit to anyone else who was looking to sell a large number of cards.
I played Magic a lot when I was young but it had been more than 10 years since my last game so I decided to sell my collection. I had no idea how much it was worth but I was extremely pleased by the results of selling it here. I would definitely recommend Card Conduit to anyone else who was looking to sell a large number of cards.
John Murphy-Weiss
Review left Jul 09 2026
Review
After several different transactions with Card Conduit, I am thoroughly satisfied with every step of the process. They make it simple and very cost effective to offload my collection in small shipments or in bulk. Would recommend.
After several different transactions with Card Conduit, I am thoroughly satisfied with every step of the process. They make it simple and very cost effective to offload my collection in small shipments or in bulk. Would recommend.
Rudolphi
Review left Jul 09 2026
Review
Quick and easy service, they got back to me quickly, and informed me every step of the process.
Quick and easy service, they got back to me quickly, and informed me every step of the process.
Joshua Claytor
Review left Jul 09 2026
Review
every step of the journey to sell cards is explained clearly. Every step that Card Conduit well is also communicated professionally. The recap of the sell process is enlightening and every thing about this was super easy.
every step of the journey to sell cards is explained clearly. Every step that Card Conduit well is also communicated professionally. The recap of the sell process is enlightening and every thing about this was super easy.
Kiara McKernan
Review left Jul 09 2026
Review
I was moving and I haven't played in years. So it made sense to sell.
I started running out of time so I just shipped my cards. It was pretty simple and painless. Payout was fast and straightforward. Didn't make as much as I had hoped but you never will with a buylist
I started running out of time so I just shipped my cards. It was pretty simple and painless. Payout was fast and straightforward. Didn't make as much as I had hoped but you never will with a buylist
I was moving and I haven't played in years. So it made sense to sell.
I started running out of time so I just shipped my cards. It was pretty simple and painless. Payout was fast and straightforward. Didn't make as much as I had hoped but you never will with a buylist
I started running out of time so I just shipped my cards. It was pretty simple and painless. Payout was fast and straightforward. Didn't make as much as I had hoped but you never will with a buylist
Sean Mayer
Review left Jul 09 2026
Review
To be honest I had to attempt this shipment like 5 times, half of it was my fault. But here are somethings I learned. Better have the portion of your collection you are wanting to sell ready in some online archive like moxfield that can easily be exported. Now that doesn't mean the import is perfect
...
Read more
To be honest I had to attempt this shipment like 5 times, half of it was my fault. But here are somethings I learned. Better have the portion of your collection you are wanting to sell ready in some online archive like moxfield that can easily be exported. Now that doesn't mean the import is perfect, if a card is unique it might confuse it with another set. They need to be more transparent with how they are getting market prices and what cards are acceptable, 50 cents is definitely not their set point. Prices for cards were already low but then grading will put it even lower, some were fair others not so much. Like for instance I sold a Witches Clinic that has never been played, still rated it MP. A little disappointed but it is kind of expected with selling a collection The more work you put in the more you save but really you need to know what you are willing to do. All in all my experience was just okay, it works especially if you need to sell stuff relatively quickly.
Bryan
Review left Jul 09 2026
Review
Always an easy process and fast payment! I will keep coming back
Always an easy process and fast payment! I will keep coming back
Jay Gray
Review left Jul 08 2026
Shipment processed Jun 29 2026
Review
This is my 3rd or 4th order with Card Conduit. I use the sorted fee option, I don’t mind taking the time to sort cards. I haven’t processed bulk, just singles. Their buy prices seem to be higher than other sites, and they accept more cards than other sites. If you’re trying to get rid of 200 o
...
Read more
This is my 3rd or 4th order with Card Conduit. I use the sorted fee option, I don’t mind taking the time to sort cards. I haven’t processed bulk, just singles. Their buy prices seem to be higher than other sites, and they accept more cards than other sites. If you’re trying to get rid of 200 or so cards, even with most of them being less than $5, I would recommend Card Conduit
Johnny D
Review left Jul 08 2026
Review
I’ve done a few shipments with Card Conduit and they’ve been fantastic each time. I’ve done bulk shipments as well as the curated one where you ship the cards in order and the processing time & payout amounts exceeded my expectations each time!
I’ve done a few shipments with Card Conduit and they’ve been fantastic each time. I’ve done bulk shipments as well as the curated one where you ship the cards in order and the processing time & payout amounts exceeded my expectations each time!
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every
previous customer to leave a review.
Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page.
We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a
review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).