Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service
(5630)
Edward Sheats
Review left Aug 20 2025
Review
First time using this service and it was great! Super helpful staff as well guiding you through the process if you have any questions. 10/10
First time using this service and it was great! Super helpful staff as well guiding you through the process if you have any questions. 10/10
Brad
Review left Aug 20 2025
Review
Easy submission, easy payout, detailed reports. Can’t ask for more.
Easy submission, easy payout, detailed reports. Can’t ask for more.
Daniel
Review left Aug 19 2025
Shipment processed Aug 05 2025
Review
Order was processed quickly and I received payment promptly
Order was processed quickly and I received payment promptly
Nick
Review left Aug 19 2025
Review
All around a very easy and quick process. I felt it was fair pricing and they communicated well throughout the process.
All around a very easy and quick process. I felt it was fair pricing and they communicated well throughout the process.
Jaya Prime
Review left Aug 19 2025
Review
I've sent in three or four sell orders to Card Conduit and I've been pleased each time. Overall. They give a good price, have even better graders, and my only complaint really is the requirement to ship foils to them without sleeves or any protection. I'm not taking off a star for it, as I really li
...
Read more
I've sent in three or four sell orders to Card Conduit and I've been pleased each time. Overall. They give a good price, have even better graders, and my only complaint really is the requirement to ship foils to them without sleeves or any protection. I'm not taking off a star for it, as I really like the service and the incredible communication throughout each step of the process, but it has made me consider and go through other services in the past when a foil was concerned.
Zachary Wright
Review left Aug 19 2025
Review
Will definitely use again in the future, thanks!!!
Will definitely use again in the future, thanks!!!
Shawn R.
Review left Aug 19 2025
Review
The process was simple, felt like appropriate value, and I would recommend it to multiple friends.
The process was simple, felt like appropriate value, and I would recommend it to multiple friends.
Eric Chaco
Review left Aug 19 2025
Shipment processed Aug 16 2025
Review
Great customer service and awesome turn sround time
Great customer service and awesome turn sround time
Kirk Lewis
Review left Aug 18 2025
Review
Felt like my shipment was accurately rated and I was compensated well for the transaction
Felt like my shipment was accurately rated and I was compensated well for the transaction
Maxsimiliano Luna
Review left Aug 18 2025
Review
The process was easy to follow and the reports have all the details I want.
The process was easy to follow and the reports have all the details I want.
Rick
Review left Aug 18 2025
Shipment processed Aug 06 2025
$108.00
payout, $5.56
fees
Review
I would still recommend because of how easy it is to sell compared to the other ways. I would say thought keep any expensive card , anything over $20, and sell to local card shop. I hope I'm wrong because of the good transactions, this is my 4th time so 3 good and 1 bad so far. I just fill that the
...
Read more
I would still recommend because of how easy it is to sell compared to the other ways. I would say thought keep any expensive card , anything over $20, and sell to local card shop. I hope I'm wrong because of the good transactions, this is my 4th time so 3 good and 1 bad so far. I just fill that the expensive cards always gets damaged when they are lp or hp at worst. And it was only $4.25 to ship but $10 to get 1/4 shipped back and i still haven't got them. I will send another lot in a few weeks and I hope and do believe next time will be better, I hope.
Daniel
Review left Aug 18 2025
Shipment processed Jul 12 2025
Review
Would highly recommend CC for selling cards in the future, I know I will be. Thanks!
Would highly recommend CC for selling cards in the future, I know I will be. Thanks!
Easy process, disappointing result, but better than nothing
Review left Aug 18 2025
Review
The process was easy, and I felt that I put in sufficient work beforehand to maximize my card values. Though I'm no formal rater, based off that work, and what I eventually got, I felt that the value I eventually received was much lower than expected. That clearly points to the card conditions, but
...
Read more
The process was easy, and I felt that I put in sufficient work beforehand to maximize my card values. Though I'm no formal rater, based off that work, and what I eventually got, I felt that the value I eventually received was much lower than expected. That clearly points to the card conditions, but I wish there was an easy way at home to estimate this accurately.
Ben
Review left Aug 18 2025
Shipment processed Aug 06 2025
$3.75
payout, No
fees
*Fees were waived during a special promotion.
Review
Although I gained almost no value, everything worked well and flawlessly.
Although I gained almost no value, everything worked well and flawlessly.
Dominic Baker
Review left Aug 18 2025
Review
can't complain ssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssss
can't complain ssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssss
Will
Review left Aug 17 2025
Review
My cards were quickly assessed once they arrived and I was given a fair evaluation. I played most of these cards a lot over the years and was given fair appraisals.
My cards were quickly assessed once they arrived and I was given a fair evaluation. I played most of these cards a lot over the years and was given fair appraisals.
Padraig
Review left Aug 17 2025
Shipment processed Aug 16 2025
$704.09
payout, $12.91
fees
Review
Had some shipping issues with USPS that slowed the process down but everything on Card Conduit’s end was very quick and easy, polite service etc
Had some shipping issues with USPS that slowed the process down but everything on Card Conduit’s end was very quick and easy, polite service etc
Justin A Saltzman
Review left Aug 17 2025
Review
I had to part with my collection of magic the gathering cards and cardconduit really helped me out as a first time user. Cards were processed fast and in line with their tracking application on their site. Thank you for helping out!
I had to part with my collection of magic the gathering cards and cardconduit really helped me out as a first time user. Cards were processed fast and in line with their tracking application on their site. Thank you for helping out!
Robert Braunstein
Review left Aug 16 2025
Review
Process continues to be easy. Impressed by speed and efficiency. Very fair valuation.
Process continues to be easy. Impressed by speed and efficiency. Very fair valuation.
Robert Braunstein
Review left Aug 16 2025
Review
Very used to process now. Very easy. Very impressed with quick turnaround and fair valuation.
Very used to process now. Very easy. Very impressed with quick turnaround and fair valuation.
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every
previous customer to leave a review.
Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page.
We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a
review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).