Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service
(5856)
Adam Berendt
Review left Dec 03 2025
Review
This is a great way to sell alot of mid to low value cards vs trying to sell them all yourself one at a time. Shipped and very quickly they gave me a very fair offer on my cards. Paid me within 2 days. I will use the service again.
This is a great way to sell alot of mid to low value cards vs trying to sell them all yourself one at a time. Shipped and very quickly they gave me a very fair offer on my cards. Paid me within 2 days. I will use the service again.
Caleb Grimes
Review left Dec 03 2025
Review
I like the process, the wait time isn’t bad, and card conduit gives the right value of what’s its worth. As long as you’re willing to do the sorting work, it’s the best buck for a card. Thank you. I’ll continue to use this platform as I process my collection
I like the process, the wait time isn’t bad, and card conduit gives the right value of what’s its worth. As long as you’re willing to do the sorting work, it’s the best buck for a card. Thank you. I’ll continue to use this platform as I process my collection
Luis Juarez
Review left Dec 03 2025
Review
Highly recommend using Card Conduit to sell your cards, as long as your collection is in good quality you'll get the best value for your cards. Does take around 1-2 weeks but well worth the wait.
Highly recommend using Card Conduit to sell your cards, as long as your collection is in good quality you'll get the best value for your cards. Does take around 1-2 weeks but well worth the wait.
Justin McAdams
Review left Dec 02 2025
Review
The process is simple and streamline no matter which route you take, the communication throughout the process and explanation at each step is wonderful. I've had a great experience selling cards and will definitely come back to do so again.
The process is simple and streamline no matter which route you take, the communication throughout the process and explanation at each step is wonderful. I've had a great experience selling cards and will definitely come back to do so again.
Leo VanderWhitte Ma
Review left Dec 02 2025
Review
Good communication and faq page/ shipping guide, sorted is the way to go
Good communication and faq page/ shipping guide, sorted is the way to go
Mike P
Review left Dec 02 2025
Shipment processed Nov 12 2025
Review
Have been clearing out my older bulk for MTG before i move and card conduit has been a great help in making it easy to ship off a lot of my cards for some extra value. Service is quick and the communication is top notch. Thank you all!
Have been clearing out my older bulk for MTG before i move and card conduit has been a great help in making it easy to ship off a lot of my cards for some extra value. Service is quick and the communication is top notch. Thank you all!
JC
Review left Dec 02 2025
Review
There just isn't an easier way available to turn some of your unused cardboard into cash. I am appreciative of this service.
There just isn't an easier way available to turn some of your unused cardboard into cash. I am appreciative of this service.
J.
Review left Dec 02 2025
Review
Hassle free way to cash in old cards from storage. Fair grading. Would recommend.
Hassle free way to cash in old cards from storage. Fair grading. Would recommend.
Anonymous
Review left Dec 01 2025
Shipment processed Nov 19 2025
$516.80
payout, $53.57
fees
Review
I have used Card Conduit many times to sell cards and the process is always low stress and satisfying with a high level of customer service. I recommend them!
I have used Card Conduit many times to sell cards and the process is always low stress and satisfying with a high level of customer service. I recommend them!
Nicholas
Review left Dec 01 2025
Review
I have been selling my Magic cards exclusively through Card Conduit for over a year now, and I simply cannot recommend them enough. Every single time, they consistently deliver the highest possible value for my collections.
Beyond the great value, the speed of their service is incredible. The en ... Read more
Beyond the great value, the speed of their service is incredible. The en ... Read more
I have been selling my Magic cards exclusively through Card Conduit for over a year now, and I simply cannot recommend them enough. Every single time, they consistently deliver the highest possible value for my collections.
Beyond the great value, the speed of their service is incredible. The entire process, from shipping to final payment, is remarkably fast. What truly sets them apart is their phenomenal customer experience and communication. They are transparent, responsive, and make you feel confident and informed throughout the whole submission process.
If you are looking to sell your MTG cards efficiently and profitably, Card Conduit is the only choice. They always deliver.
Beyond the great value, the speed of their service is incredible. The entire process, from shipping to final payment, is remarkably fast. What truly sets them apart is their phenomenal customer experience and communication. They are transparent, responsive, and make you feel confident and informed throughout the whole submission process.
If you are looking to sell your MTG cards efficiently and profitably, Card Conduit is the only choice. They always deliver.
Tony Clavelli
Review left Dec 01 2025
Review
A really great way to trade in cards I wasn't using--much easier than when I've done the buylist thing, and really thorough with details. I definitely plan to do this again.
A really great way to trade in cards I wasn't using--much easier than when I've done the buylist thing, and really thorough with details. I definitely plan to do this again.
Aaron
Review left Nov 30 2025
Review
The whole process is super easy and I got back a lot more money than I was expecting from my collection! I would recommend everyone use this when they need to sell cards!
The whole process is super easy and I got back a lot more money than I was expecting from my collection! I would recommend everyone use this when they need to sell cards!
andrew thomas
Review left Nov 30 2025
Review
The convenience and ease was fantastic. My main complaint is that the grading seemed harsher than usual tcg player standards, and thusly my payout was less than expected, even when I curated my own cards
The convenience and ease was fantastic. My main complaint is that the grading seemed harsher than usual tcg player standards, and thusly my payout was less than expected, even when I curated my own cards
Nicole
Review left Nov 30 2025
Review
Easy to ship, website was simple to navigate and use plus I got more than what I was getting on tcg.
Easy to ship, website was simple to navigate and use plus I got more than what I was getting on tcg.
Mike
Review left Nov 30 2025
Review
I sent in about 66 cards and had money in my account in a little over 2 weeks time. Everything went smoothly and I even had a question about the condition of one of my cards that Nate was able to answer promptly and confidently. I will definitely be using Card Conduit again to offload other cards I don't need.
I sent in about 66 cards and had money in my account in a little over 2 weeks time. Everything went smoothly and I even had a question about the condition of one of my cards that Nate was able to answer promptly and confidently. I will definitely be using Card Conduit again to offload other cards I don't need.
Jacob C
Review left Nov 29 2025
Review
I've been sitting on my collection for a while but haven't played the game in forever due to getting into another card game and disagreements with the direction MTG was taking (not to say it's bad, just not what I was there for). Finally decided to pull the trigger and map out my collection with Gol
...
Read more
I've been sitting on my collection for a while but haven't played the game in forever due to getting into another card game and disagreements with the direction MTG was taking (not to say it's bad, just not what I was there for). Finally decided to pull the trigger and map out my collection with Goldfish and I saw the ad for card conduit and figured I'd look into it. I had been prepping to talk to my LGS about it first, but after seeing the fee percentages and expected payout it was an easy choice to go with card conduit. Process was pretty quick, about 2 weeks in total from prepping my shipment and mailing it out, to getting payment. Every step was clearly communicated and the detailed report of cards, their conditions, and pricing was superb. I'd highly recommend their service if you have extra cards laying around, I don't think anyone else on the market provides the same caliber of service.
deangelo
Review left Nov 29 2025
Review
the process is easy. it doesnt take a longtime to process the cards. always had a great experience with Card Conduit.
the process is easy. it doesnt take a longtime to process the cards. always had a great experience with Card Conduit.
Christopher J
Review left Nov 29 2025
Review
Reasonable timing. Thorough and excellent value, none better.
Reasonable timing. Thorough and excellent value, none better.
Lolo
Review left Nov 29 2025
Shipment processed Nov 27 2025
$3,135.90
payout, $64.00
fees
Review
As always process is super simple and transparent with the CC crew.
I submitted two boxes around the holiday, fully expecting a delay.. they finished and sent my report on a holiday! I'm not saying anyone should expect it.. but that's some incredible service!
I submitted two boxes around the holiday, fully expecting a delay.. they finished and sent my report on a holiday! I'm not saying anyone should expect it.. but that's some incredible service!
As always process is super simple and transparent with the CC crew.
I submitted two boxes around the holiday, fully expecting a delay.. they finished and sent my report on a holiday! I'm not saying anyone should expect it.. but that's some incredible service!
I submitted two boxes around the holiday, fully expecting a delay.. they finished and sent my report on a holiday! I'm not saying anyone should expect it.. but that's some incredible service!
Parker Madsen
Review left Nov 28 2025
Review
Far easier than most services and way fairer price
Far easier than most services and way fairer price
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every
previous customer to leave a review.
Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page.
We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a
review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).