Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service
(5629)
John
Review left Oct 16 2025
Review
Detailed and easy to follow directions.
Won't sell my cards anywhere else.
Won't sell my cards anywhere else.
Detailed and easy to follow directions.
Won't sell my cards anywhere else.
Won't sell my cards anywhere else.
Christopher S.
Review left Oct 16 2025
Review
I have been sending small packages of my Magic the Gathering collection to Card Conduit on several occasions. Their card services are fast and efficient.
I have been sending small packages of my Magic the Gathering collection to Card Conduit on several occasions. Their card services are fast and efficient.
Jeremy Jensen
Review left Oct 15 2025
Review
Very professionally done, I am always happy with the outcome of rach shipment I send their way.
Very professionally done, I am always happy with the outcome of rach shipment I send their way.
Yen
Review left Oct 15 2025
Review
Everything was handled well and when I reached out they answered all of my questions quickly. Their service was very easy to use and would highly recommend!
Everything was handled well and when I reached out they answered all of my questions quickly. Their service was very easy to use and would highly recommend!
Charlie
Review left Oct 15 2025
Review
The process couldn’t have been easier, and the valuation of the cards I sent aligned well with my expectations.
The process couldn’t have been easier, and the valuation of the cards I sent aligned well with my expectations.
Dan
Review left Oct 15 2025
Shipment processed Sep 13 2025
$653.60
payout, $13.34
fees
Review
The process was very clear. I used the sorted service (which was kind of fun). Nick wrote me a personal note about the valuation of my cards, and the payment was prompt.
And the **website** is just 🤌. So snappy. No loading spinners, search feels instantaneous. I build websites professionally a ... Read more
And the **website** is just 🤌. So snappy. No loading spinners, search feels instantaneous. I build websites professionally a ... Read more
The process was very clear. I used the sorted service (which was kind of fun). Nick wrote me a personal note about the valuation of my cards, and the payment was prompt.
And the **website** is just 🤌. So snappy. No loading spinners, search feels instantaneous. I build websites professionally and I'm jealous of what CardConduit's performance metrics must be.
And the **website** is just 🤌. So snappy. No loading spinners, search feels instantaneous. I build websites professionally and I'm jealous of what CardConduit's performance metrics must be.
Michelle
Review left Oct 15 2025
Review
Fast, easy and exceeded expectations! I recommend this service
Fast, easy and exceeded expectations! I recommend this service
Chase
Review left Oct 15 2025
Shipment processed Oct 07 2025
Review
Sent my cards out and about a week later I received a full report and was paid. Overall fantastic experience.
Sent my cards out and about a week later I received a full report and was paid. Overall fantastic experience.
Tyler Works
Review left Oct 15 2025
Review
I can honestly say ive been looking for a place for a while to offload some cards and this place is it. they give fair prices and transparency for every grade. lots of photos showing that you are being taken for. A good company with fair business. I will be back with another load soon!
I can honestly say ive been looking for a place for a while to offload some cards and this place is it. they give fair prices and transparency for every grade. lots of photos showing that you are being taken for. A good company with fair business. I will be back with another load soon!
Nicolas Difurio
Review left Oct 15 2025
Review
It was super easy to fill everything out, the forms answered all my questions and made the process super easy. I got paid easily double what a local store was offering (and in Dallas I had 5+ locations to choose from). They were very fair with the grading and payout was very fast, definitely recomme
...
Read more
It was super easy to fill everything out, the forms answered all my questions and made the process super easy. I got paid easily double what a local store was offering (and in Dallas I had 5+ locations to choose from). They were very fair with the grading and payout was very fast, definitely recommend using this service over anything else. I did declare value on my FedEx shipment to protect myself in case the worst happened, which forced a signature for the drop off, was worried that might cause issues but their office received the package just fine!
Juan PB
Review left Oct 15 2025
Review
Easy, fast, and accurate. What else can I ask for?
Easy, fast, and accurate. What else can I ask for?
Greg J.
Review left Oct 15 2025
Shipment processed Sep 13 2025
$833.49
payout, $76.39
fees
Review
As an introvert that is looking to downsize in order to start a family, Card Conduit has made offloading my collection easy and worry free. Super fair deal given that all we have to do is box and ship.
As an introvert that is looking to downsize in order to start a family, Card Conduit has made offloading my collection easy and worry free. Super fair deal given that all we have to do is box and ship.
Kevin
Review left Oct 14 2025
Shipment processed Oct 09 2025
Review
Would very much recommend. I was able to sell my collection painlessly and smoothly. The online process was smooth and they were communicative about every step of the process. No complaints at all. If I did have cards to sell again, I’d use Card Conduit without hesitation for the most streamlined and easy experience.
Would very much recommend. I was able to sell my collection painlessly and smoothly. The online process was smooth and they were communicative about every step of the process. No complaints at all. If I did have cards to sell again, I’d use Card Conduit without hesitation for the most streamlined and easy experience.
Richard
Review left Oct 14 2025
Shipment processed Oct 04 2025
Review
Fair and responsive. I plan to use them again in the future
Fair and responsive. I plan to use them again in the future
David Taylor
Review left Oct 14 2025
Review
It was super easy and convenient to be able to get a shipment together! And the price received for the shipment was honestly very reasonable for the convenience of offloading a good chunk of cards I don't really play with anymore. Will definitely return in the future.
It was super easy and convenient to be able to get a shipment together! And the price received for the shipment was honestly very reasonable for the convenience of offloading a good chunk of cards I don't really play with anymore. Will definitely return in the future.
Adam
Review left Oct 14 2025
Review
The process was smooth. The payment time was fast. The communication level was top notch. I would definitely do business with Card Conduit again
The process was smooth. The payment time was fast. The communication level was top notch. I would definitely do business with Card Conduit again
Spencer S
Review left Oct 14 2025
Review
Not much to say, very satisfied with service. Was concerned they would grade a lot of my cards down, but they did not.
Not much to say, very satisfied with service. Was concerned they would grade a lot of my cards down, but they did not.
H
Review left Oct 13 2025
Review
Although it took a bit of time, gave a fair payout
Although it took a bit of time, gave a fair payout
Roy
Review left Oct 13 2025
Review
I've buylisted to a lot of places and this was definitely the most seamless.
inputting was relatively painless (actually, it's painful - but not their fault. I just don't have the patience to input cards one-by-one), but once that is done, it's smooth sailing.
The grading was pretty spot ... Read more
inputting was relatively painless (actually, it's painful - but not their fault. I just don't have the patience to input cards one-by-one), but once that is done, it's smooth sailing.
The grading was pretty spot ... Read more
I've buylisted to a lot of places and this was definitely the most seamless.
inputting was relatively painless (actually, it's painful - but not their fault. I just don't have the patience to input cards one-by-one), but once that is done, it's smooth sailing.
The grading was pretty spot on and payment was beyond easy, even after a hiccup that was again not their fault.
If you're on the fence, go for it.
inputting was relatively painless (actually, it's painful - but not their fault. I just don't have the patience to input cards one-by-one), but once that is done, it's smooth sailing.
The grading was pretty spot on and payment was beyond easy, even after a hiccup that was again not their fault.
If you're on the fence, go for it.
chandler
Review left Oct 12 2025
Review
Process was simple and straightforward. I sent in my bulk cards and card Conduit handled the rest. They sent me a detailed sheet of the cards they received and contacted me to confirm I was OK with the results. I will be using the. Again in the future!
Process was simple and straightforward. I sent in my bulk cards and card Conduit handled the rest. They sent me a detailed sheet of the cards they received and contacted me to confirm I was OK with the results. I will be using the. Again in the future!
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every
previous customer to leave a review.
Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page.
We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a
review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).