Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service
(6072)
AJ
Review left Feb 01 2026
Review
Best way to get cash for your collection if you don't have the time or energy necessary to sell individual cards. Would and will continue to recommend.
Best way to get cash for your collection if you don't have the time or energy necessary to sell individual cards. Would and will continue to recommend.
Erik Blaser
Review left Jan 31 2026
Review
Clear, transparent, rational, communicative. Great service all around!
Clear, transparent, rational, communicative. Great service all around!
Jeremy
Review left Jan 31 2026
Review
Easy process throughout and I received a very fair price. I will be using the service much more in the future.
Easy process throughout and I received a very fair price. I will be using the service much more in the future.
A Bonin
Review left Jan 31 2026
Shipment processed Jan 22 2026
Review
The process was very easy. I did the curated choice and sent about 175 cards. I sent via UPS and put extra insurance on the package since I estimated the value at over $2000. With the insurance, shipping was about $55 from Florida to Utah. Once received it only took about 4 days for the card gradin
...
Read more
The process was very easy. I did the curated choice and sent about 175 cards. I sent via UPS and put extra insurance on the package since I estimated the value at over $2000. With the insurance, shipping was about $55 from Florida to Utah. Once received it only took about 4 days for the card grading and value results to come. I was very pleased with the offer. I would say the payout was about 70% of value. Payment followed directly to my bank within two days of the result. So much easier than trying to sell thru other methods, and better payout. Will definitely use them again. Also, using the promo code saved me a few dollars as well! Highly recommended.
Dan
Review left Jan 31 2026
Review
I have used this service multiple times and I have never been disappointed.
I have used this service multiple times and I have never been disappointed.
Emerson C.
Review left Jan 30 2026
Shipment processed Jan 22 2026
Review
Thank you Card Conduit - i am glad to have found a hidden gem. The process is easy, fair and speedy enough (considering there's shipping time involved). Don't hesitate to utilize their services - highly recommend!
Thank you Card Conduit - i am glad to have found a hidden gem. The process is easy, fair and speedy enough (considering there's shipping time involved). Don't hesitate to utilize their services - highly recommend!
Taylor
Review left Jan 30 2026
Shipment processed Jan 30 2026
Review
This whole thing is super easy! I've submitted a few sales now since it's so easy to use. I would highly recommend Card Conduit to anyone looking to liquidate their collections!
This whole thing is super easy! I've submitted a few sales now since it's so easy to use. I would highly recommend Card Conduit to anyone looking to liquidate their collections!
Taylor
Review left Jan 30 2026
Shipment processed Jan 22 2026
Review
Super easy process, values came in where I expected (mostly NM, these were all binder cards sleeved almost immediately after opening). Great service, would recommend!
Super easy process, values came in where I expected (mostly NM, these were all binder cards sleeved almost immediately after opening). Great service, would recommend!
Mike
Review left Jan 30 2026
Shipment processed Jan 22 2026
Review
Process was simple and straightforward. Card conduit kept me informed of every step. Payment was fair, transparent, and efficient. Will definitely do business again! Cannot recommend enough of looking to sell cards at a fair price. Love Card Conduit!
Process was simple and straightforward. Card conduit kept me informed of every step. Payment was fair, transparent, and efficient. Will definitely do business again! Cannot recommend enough of looking to sell cards at a fair price. Love Card Conduit!
Jeremy Rochlitz
Review left Jan 30 2026
Review
Gave fair price for cards. Service was easy to use.
Gave fair price for cards. Service was easy to use.
Brandon
Review left Jan 30 2026
Review
Could not have been more please with this process. It was incredibly easy to pull the list of cards they wanted via moxfield. Updates were consistent and timely and the whole process was really very fast. I felt the prices offered were very fair and the fees charged were more than worth it to me rat
...
Read more
Could not have been more please with this process. It was incredibly easy to pull the list of cards they wanted via moxfield. Updates were consistent and timely and the whole process was really very fast. I felt the prices offered were very fair and the fees charged were more than worth it to me rather than having to do so the leg work myself. Will definitely use this service again and can't recommend then enough!
JP
Review left Jan 30 2026
Shipment processed Dec 30 2025
Review
Process is easy with these guys, fast turn around and easy payment options.
Process is easy with these guys, fast turn around and easy payment options.
Nathaniel Asbury
Review left Jan 30 2026
Shipment processed Dec 27 2025
Review
I grabbed a couple dozen of my high ticket cards and submitted them very easily and the full process went off without any issues and everything was completed with prompt professionalism.
I grabbed a couple dozen of my high ticket cards and submitted them very easily and the full process went off without any issues and everything was completed with prompt professionalism.
James A
Review left Jan 30 2026
Review
Highly recommended. Quick and easy and a reasonable payout.
Highly recommended. Quick and easy and a reasonable payout.
Brandon Harris
Review left Jan 29 2026
Review
If you need to sell cards in bulk fast, I would def recommend Card Conduit.
If you need to sell cards in bulk fast, I would def recommend Card Conduit.
John F
Review left Jan 29 2026
Review
Great value proposition if you value your time. Highly recommend.
Great value proposition if you value your time. Highly recommend.
Anto
Review left Jan 29 2026
Shipment processed Jan 21 2026
Review
super simple website and process. Will definitely return when I need to sell cards again.
super simple website and process. Will definitely return when I need to sell cards again.
Justin
Review left Jan 29 2026
Shipment processed Jan 21 2026
Review
Super easy to ship and see the value of the cards. I was sent an email with an explanation of the cards I sent in and then they also sent an email with a detailed list of each card and the value based on best market price. Super happy with my experience.
Super easy to ship and see the value of the cards. I was sent an email with an explanation of the cards I sent in and then they also sent an email with a detailed list of each card and the value based on best market price. Super happy with my experience.
Sean
Review left Jan 29 2026
Review
The people at Card Conduit are great. I was able to sell over 600 cards with them without the hassle of waiting for sellers on other marketplace sites while still getting a fair return. They were communicative and answered all of the questions I had. If ever I need to sell cards again, I'll be using Card Conduit.
The people at Card Conduit are great. I was able to sell over 600 cards with them without the hassle of waiting for sellers on other marketplace sites while still getting a fair return. They were communicative and answered all of the questions I had. If ever I need to sell cards again, I'll be using Card Conduit.
Anonymous
Review left Jan 29 2026
Shipment processed Jan 23 2026
Review
Highly recommended them until I sent them 3 orders and 1 order had 3 cards which were valuable and they of course didn’t receive this order when I received confirmation that they received all 3 packages with the same tracking information they are now saying1 box was empty which I find extremely st
...
Read more
Highly recommended them until I sent them 3 orders and 1 order had 3 cards which were valuable and they of course didn’t receive this order when I received confirmation that they received all 3 packages with the same tracking information they are now saying1 box was empty which I find extremely strange. 3 packages with same tracking number they were all received but now they r saying 1 box was empty so don’t send your valuable cards because u may not get paid on it
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every
previous customer to leave a review.
Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page.
We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a
review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).