Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service
(6603)
Curtis Petty
Review left May 19 2026
Review
Easy, helpful and very reliable. I trusted the efforts of Card Conduit. Cards were shipped, received and verified in a timely manner. And payment was issued as expected and promised. I strongly recommend Card Conduit as an easy and efficient way to sell your Magic collections. 10/10
Easy, helpful and very reliable. I trusted the efforts of Card Conduit. Cards were shipped, received and verified in a timely manner. And payment was issued as expected and promised. I strongly recommend Card Conduit as an easy and efficient way to sell your Magic collections. 10/10
Mitch
Review left May 19 2026
Review
Super easy to run through the process and the payment was fast. I appreciate the level of transparency in the final report.
Super easy to run through the process and the payment was fast. I appreciate the level of transparency in the final report.
Brandon
Review left May 19 2026
Shipment processed May 13 2026
*Fees were waived during a special promotion.
Review
Severly lower value than the buy list quoted even though I graded my cards lower than what they graded in the finals.. a $30 card went to $10 and such.. on top of that a entire shipment they said was $0.. will never use again and will highly recommend people stay away from this predatory company.
Severly lower value than the buy list quoted even though I graded my cards lower than what they graded in the finals.. a $30 card went to $10 and such.. on top of that a entire shipment they said was $0.. will never use again and will highly recommend people stay away from this predatory company.
Alan
Review left May 19 2026
Review
The process took a little bit to figure out but once the shipment was sent everything worked out great. Decent to very good value. My cards were appraised appropriately. Definitely would recommend for someone with unwanted cards that are on the card conduit buylist
The process took a little bit to figure out but once the shipment was sent everything worked out great. Decent to very good value. My cards were appraised appropriately. Definitely would recommend for someone with unwanted cards that are on the card conduit buylist
Jeremy B
Review left May 18 2026
Shipment processed Apr 15 2026
Review
I came into ownership of old 3rd and 4th edition Magic cards. I researched a bit but don't have much knowledge on Magic cards. I was able to sell the cards very easily with Card Conduit.
I reached out to several other companies and learn how they charge. I looked at Buy sheets and I thought ... Read more
I reached out to several other companies and learn how they charge. I looked at Buy sheets and I thought ... Read more
I came into ownership of old 3rd and 4th edition Magic cards. I researched a bit but don't have much knowledge on Magic cards. I was able to sell the cards very easily with Card Conduit.
I reached out to several other companies and learn how they charge. I looked at Buy sheets and I thought Card Conduit would get me the most money in the easy process. And that was correct. 5 stars!
I reached out to several other companies and learn how they charge. I looked at Buy sheets and I thought Card Conduit would get me the most money in the easy process. And that was correct. 5 stars!
JF
Review left May 18 2026
Shipment processed Apr 15 2026
Review
Had a great experience with Card Conduit. They notify every step of the way and I was happy with the overall outcome. I definitely recommend.
Had a great experience with Card Conduit. They notify every step of the way and I was happy with the overall outcome. I definitely recommend.
Eric
Review left May 18 2026
Shipment processed Jan 31 2026
Review
Never had a purchasing company send stats on cards!
Never had a purchasing company send stats on cards!
John W Scarbeck
Review left May 18 2026
Review
A painless and excellent way to get top value for your cards. Service and communication are top notch. All my questions were answered quickly and efficiently. I recommend secured shipment for max value. it is a little work but well worth it. could not be happier with my experience
A painless and excellent way to get top value for your cards. Service and communication are top notch. All my questions were answered quickly and efficiently. I recommend secured shipment for max value. it is a little work but well worth it. could not be happier with my experience
Chance Gunter
Review left May 18 2026
Review
I have used the service several times and with the curated card selection I know what I’m getting paid and the review process have been able to chat with the company to resolve issues that may arise
I have used the service several times and with the curated card selection I know what I’m getting paid and the review process have been able to chat with the company to resolve issues that may arise
Peter Marvin
Review left May 18 2026
Review
I sent in a bunch of cards and the process was quick. I got good value considering a new set released as I sent the cards in
I sent in a bunch of cards and the process was quick. I got good value considering a new set released as I sent the cards in
Justin Kelly
Review left May 18 2026
Shipment processed May 14 2026
Review
Turnaround time was exactly as stated and payout was fast and easy. Great feedback on card quality and it was fun to see the stats.
Turnaround time was exactly as stated and payout was fast and easy. Great feedback on card quality and it was fun to see the stats.
Chad
Review left May 18 2026
Shipment processed May 12 2026
Review
Using the sorted service was quick and easy! The communication was great as well!
Using the sorted service was quick and easy! The communication was great as well!
mARCUS
Review left May 18 2026
Review
these folks are great. always sell to them. thank you
these folks are great. always sell to them. thank you
mARCUS
Review left May 18 2026
Review
these folks are great. always sell to them. thank you
these folks are great. always sell to them. thank you
Joseph Celentano
Review left May 17 2026
Review
Convenient but the grading is way too harsh. All of my cards were extremely undervalued and I recieved less than 50% of the estimated value of my collection.
Convenient but the grading is way too harsh. All of my cards were extremely undervalued and I recieved less than 50% of the estimated value of my collection.
James Mina
Review left May 16 2026
Review
My overall experience was great. Hailey responded quickly to my email asking for help with shipping instructions, and Zander and Nathaniel both kept me updated after they received and processed my shipment. My payout was exactly what I expected and I was very pleased with the result.
My overall experience was great. Hailey responded quickly to my email asking for help with shipping instructions, and Zander and Nathaniel both kept me updated after they received and processed my shipment. My payout was exactly what I expected and I was very pleased with the result.
Andromeda
Review left May 16 2026
Review
The process was super easy and the communication was excellent. Will definitely be using their services again.
The process was super easy and the communication was excellent. Will definitely be using their services again.
RJ
Review left May 16 2026
Review
Fast, reliable and great prices. The reports are really helpful. Direct deposit is super easy.
Fast, reliable and great prices. The reports are really helpful. Direct deposit is super easy.
Joseph Laurenti
Review left May 15 2026
Review
The process was a little daunting for me as a first time Card Conduit customer. But I gotta say I found the end result well worth it. I had about 218 total cards out of over 5,000 that held any real value. Their total TCG Player estimated value through ManaBox was around 1k. Card Conduit was only i
...
Read more
The process was a little daunting for me as a first time Card Conduit customer. But I gotta say I found the end result well worth it. I had about 218 total cards out of over 5,000 that held any real value. Their total TCG Player estimated value through ManaBox was around 1k. Card Conduit was only interested in about 140 cards and once sent in (using their pre sorted 2% fee option) they got back to me with a very acceptable offer of 400 for the cards. Taking everything into consideration on what I would need to do to maximize the value of each and every card that I had I found if I didn’t send the cards to Card Conduit … I would much rather do Card Conduit. Very satisfied.
Josh
Review left May 15 2026
Review
This is the second time I've used Card Conduit to send off cards and I'm already getting a third batch ready to ship because of how pleased I was with the service. I refer them to my play group constantly and many of us have used the service.
This is the second time I've used Card Conduit to send off cards and I'm already getting a third batch ready to ship because of how pleased I was with the service. I refer them to my play group constantly and many of us have used the service.
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every
previous customer to leave a review.
Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page.
We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a
review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).