Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service
(6073)
Anonymous
Review left Jan 29 2026
Shipment processed Jan 23 2026
Review
Highly recommended them until I sent them 3 orders and 1 order had 3 cards which were valuable and they of course didn’t receive this order when I received confirmation that they received all 3 packages with the same tracking information they are now saying1 box was empty which I find extremely st
...
Read more
Highly recommended them until I sent them 3 orders and 1 order had 3 cards which were valuable and they of course didn’t receive this order when I received confirmation that they received all 3 packages with the same tracking information they are now saying1 box was empty which I find extremely strange. 3 packages with same tracking number they were all received but now they r saying 1 box was empty so don’t send your valuable cards because u may not get paid on it
Jeremy M
Review left Jan 28 2026
Review
The process was simple, I received emails at each step. The report provided was detailed and being able to approve the card grading prior to completing the transactions is a nice touch. In my case the prices were a little better than others as well.
The process was simple, I received emails at each step. The report provided was detailed and being able to approve the card grading prior to completing the transactions is a nice touch. In my case the prices were a little better than others as well.
Edward Palfini
Review left Jan 28 2026
Shipment processed Jan 20 2026
Review
Process was made very easy and any questions I had about the process with answered quickly and clearly. 10/10 would recommend
Process was made very easy and any questions I had about the process with answered quickly and clearly. 10/10 would recommend
Codey C.
Review left Jan 28 2026
Review
I chose the curated service. I entered in my full card list and their software showed me the cards that fall within the service that I picked. It took some time for me to round up all of the cards but once that was done and the package was shipped within about 48 hours they notified me that they rec
...
Read more
I chose the curated service. I entered in my full card list and their software showed me the cards that fall within the service that I picked. It took some time for me to round up all of the cards but once that was done and the package was shipped within about 48 hours they notified me that they received the package and had started the sorting process. Once that was completed I received the offer for the cards that I sent in and was genuinely impressed by how close to their quoted total I was. Once I approved the everything within 24 hours my bank showed the funds had been direct deposited and I was good to go. To summarize the experience I would say it was very timely, honest and very friendly. Amazing company to work with. I look forward to working with them again in the future.
Jared M
Review left Jan 28 2026
Review
My friend told me about Card Conduit and I thought it was too good to be true. I love how transparent they are with the steps of the process. Everything was easy and quick. I would HIGHLY recommend this service to anyone looking to offload cards for whatever reason. The prices they pay are very fai
...
Read more
My friend told me about Card Conduit and I thought it was too good to be true. I love how transparent they are with the steps of the process. Everything was easy and quick. I would HIGHLY recommend this service to anyone looking to offload cards for whatever reason. The prices they pay are very fair and I was paid the day after I confirmed their card condition assessment. Awesome people doing an awesome job.
Michael
Review left Jan 28 2026
Review
I could not have asked for a better experiencing offloading some of my bulk. CC took the labor out of it on my end, and got me some solid returns on the cards! Could not recommend CC more to anyone looking to expedite the process of selling their cards!
I could not have asked for a better experiencing offloading some of my bulk. CC took the labor out of it on my end, and got me some solid returns on the cards! Could not recommend CC more to anyone looking to expedite the process of selling their cards!
Jonathan C Wilbur
Review left Jan 28 2026
Review
Selling with Card Conduit is always easy, fast, and provides the best value. Easily the best way to get rid of old cards out there!
Selling with Card Conduit is always easy, fast, and provides the best value. Easily the best way to get rid of old cards out there!
Bill C
Review left Jan 28 2026
Review
Card Consuit makes selling your playable bulk super easy! Plus, you get a very good return on card value compared to other websites.
Card Consuit makes selling your playable bulk super easy! Plus, you get a very good return on card value compared to other websites.
Blair
Review left Jan 28 2026
Shipment processed Jan 20 2026
Review
Easy process and fair prices. I had tons of cards that would have taken me weeks to sort through to likely get the same amount I got through Card Conduit. This made my life much easier and I am very pleased with the outcome. Great service!
Easy process and fair prices. I had tons of cards that would have taken me weeks to sort through to likely get the same amount I got through Card Conduit. This made my life much easier and I am very pleased with the outcome. Great service!
Marshall Smith
Review left Jan 28 2026
Review
Little effort, quick results, satisfied customer. Will work with CardConduit again.
Little effort, quick results, satisfied customer. Will work with CardConduit again.
James Hillman
Review left Jan 28 2026
Review
I paid 50 bucks to ship 1800 dollars of TCGplayer mid cards. Wait 2 weeks and get ~55% value. I could have saved the shipping and 2 weeks by going to my crappiest LGS for that amount. Do not recommend.
I paid 50 bucks to ship 1800 dollars of TCGplayer mid cards. Wait 2 weeks and get ~55% value. I could have saved the shipping and 2 weeks by going to my crappiest LGS for that amount. Do not recommend.
craig
Review left Jan 28 2026
Review
Highly recommend for selling your unused cards!!!!
Highly recommend for selling your unused cards!!!!
craig
Review left Jan 28 2026
Review
Highly recommend for selling your unused cards!!!!
Highly recommend for selling your unused cards!!!!
craig
Review left Jan 28 2026
Review
Highly recommend for selling your unused cards!!!!
Highly recommend for selling your unused cards!!!!
Miguel M.
Review left Jan 28 2026
Review
Card Conduit is a great way to sell a lot of cards, I would definitely recommend them to my friends and will most likely use them again in the future. I chose the self-sort option and was very happy with the payout I received for my cards.
Card Conduit is a great way to sell a lot of cards, I would definitely recommend them to my friends and will most likely use them again in the future. I chose the self-sort option and was very happy with the payout I received for my cards.
Corey
Review left Jan 27 2026
Review
Easy to use and valued as expected. Would use again
Easy to use and valued as expected. Would use again
James Musser
Review left Jan 27 2026
Review
The process is intuitive and easy, the payout prices are often higher than TCGPlayer low, and the payments are delivered timely and exactly as expected. I would recommend this service to anyone looking to sell any medium-value MTG cards!
The process is intuitive and easy, the payout prices are often higher than TCGPlayer low, and the payments are delivered timely and exactly as expected. I would recommend this service to anyone looking to sell any medium-value MTG cards!
Jesse Friedlander
Review left Jan 27 2026
Review
Great process, easy to use (after reading the CSV submission instructions), fair payout, easy to receive the money. The hardest part of the transaction was packaging my cards securely and mailing them out. Would definitely do business with Card Conduit again!
Great process, easy to use (after reading the CSV submission instructions), fair payout, easy to receive the money. The hardest part of the transaction was packaging my cards securely and mailing them out. Would definitely do business with Card Conduit again!
Eric P.
Review left Jan 27 2026
Review
Was looking to recoup a few bucks after holidays so I took a chunk of lower end cards from my binder and threw them in a shipment. Was able to put a few bucks into savings again thanks guys!
Was looking to recoup a few bucks after holidays so I took a chunk of lower end cards from my binder and threw them in a shipment. Was able to put a few bucks into savings again thanks guys!
Andrea Barnum
Review left Jan 26 2026
Review
I'm not a MTG player but my ex-husband was. After he passed, I wasn't sure what to do with his card collection. Card Conduit was an easy platform to sort through the cards and prepare them for sale. The proceeds are helping pay for our children's college tuition. Thanks for making the process easy for someone unfamiliar with this world.
I'm not a MTG player but my ex-husband was. After he passed, I wasn't sure what to do with his card collection. Card Conduit was an easy platform to sort through the cards and prepare them for sale. The proceeds are helping pay for our children's college tuition. Thanks for making the process easy for someone unfamiliar with this world.
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every
previous customer to leave a review.
Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page.
We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a
review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).