Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service
(5856)
Samir H
Review left Dec 13 2025
Shipment processed Dec 02 2025
Review
Have done 3 shipments now with card conduit and they have all been great. Very simple and straight forward about everything and doesn’t ever take to long.
Have done 3 shipments now with card conduit and they have all been great. Very simple and straight forward about everything and doesn’t ever take to long.
Pax
Review left Dec 13 2025
Review
The process was easy and straightforward. I was informed and kept updated on the whole process through e-mail. The customer service seems to be solid. I feel like if I had a problem I would be able to reach out and get help. I found I can get more $ for the cards if I sell lots in my local commu
...
Read more
The process was easy and straightforward. I was informed and kept updated on the whole process through e-mail. The customer service seems to be solid. I feel like if I had a problem I would be able to reach out and get help. I found I can get more $ for the cards if I sell lots in my local community. This is all stated on the website so I was aware this may be the case. I'm glad I tried the service and will use Card Conduit again in the future. If you don't care about getting the max value, or if you don't have the time or will to sort out the cards, I would definitely recommend. Overall very satisfied with the service. Works exactly how they describe on the website.
Kyle Peters
Review left Dec 12 2025
Review
Super simple. I had to downsize my collection, and this was such a simple way to do it.
Super simple. I had to downsize my collection, and this was such a simple way to do it.
Mike Savarese
Review left Dec 12 2025
Review
I was loath to sell my collection due to the hassle, but this was a simple and straight forward process. The offer was fair and I was extremely happy with the whole thing from start to finish
I was loath to sell my collection due to the hassle, but this was a simple and straight forward process. The offer was fair and I was extremely happy with the whole thing from start to finish
Ryan
Review left Dec 12 2025
Shipment processed Dec 06 2025
Review
Easiest process ever, fast payment received, very fair prices! Love this company
Easiest process ever, fast payment received, very fair prices! Love this company
Christian
Review left Dec 12 2025
Shipment processed Dec 04 2025
$818.68
payout, $43.09
fees
Review
10/10 transparency , 10/10 friendly, 100/10 experience
10/10 transparency , 10/10 friendly, 100/10 experience
Nathan
Review left Dec 11 2025
Review
Easy to do. Great communication. I will reuse in the future.
Easy to do. Great communication. I will reuse in the future.
A.H.
Review left Dec 11 2025
Review
I was very pleased with how much I got for my cards after all subsequent costs and fees, will definitely use this company again in the future
I was very pleased with how much I got for my cards after all subsequent costs and fees, will definitely use this company again in the future
Joshua Cunningham
Review left Dec 11 2025
Review
Excellent service and communication through the whole process!
Excellent service and communication through the whole process!
Chad Q
Review left Dec 10 2025
Review
Was a very smooth process. If I had any more magic cards I would use them again. :)
Was a very smooth process. If I had any more magic cards I would use them again. :)
Eric Wiltsie
Review left Dec 10 2025
Review
This is the third shipment I've sent to CC in the last year or so, and it is perfect for someone who simply does not have the time to start a business selling off singles on TCGPlayer or Ebay. I accumulate tons of cards through opening packs and buying things for deckbuilding, and I will periodicall
...
Read more
This is the third shipment I've sent to CC in the last year or so, and it is perfect for someone who simply does not have the time to start a business selling off singles on TCGPlayer or Ebay. I accumulate tons of cards through opening packs and buying things for deckbuilding, and I will periodically sell off my extra stock through CC to recoup funds. I work full time and have a kid, so slapping everything in a box and shipping it off with minimal effort is great. The CC staff will even sometimes apply additional discounts to their fees if the shipment is large enough, as it seems like they really want customers to walk away feeling like they got the most they possibly could from the transaction.
I recommend CC to all of my friends, and you should too!
I recommend CC to all of my friends, and you should too!
Porter Benson
Review left Dec 10 2025
Review
Easy Peasy, quick. I love it every time. You all do a great job.
Easy Peasy, quick. I love it every time. You all do a great job.
Taylor Shirley
Review left Dec 10 2025
Review
I really liked how easy it was to liquidate cards into cash. The process was simple and easy to figure out. I would recommend this to anyone and everyone who wan’s to seek their cards without all the hassle.
I really liked how easy it was to liquidate cards into cash. The process was simple and easy to figure out. I would recommend this to anyone and everyone who wan’s to seek their cards without all the hassle.
Kash
Review left Dec 10 2025
Review
I wasn't sure what to expect. But the experience was super. You get a report after the card is received and processed. The report was accurate and price was fairly reflecting market value. It is a better deal than selling at a local store by far; I know since I compared pricing.
I highly recommend.
I highly recommend.
I wasn't sure what to expect. But the experience was super. You get a report after the card is received and processed. The report was accurate and price was fairly reflecting market value. It is a better deal than selling at a local store by far; I know since I compared pricing.
I highly recommend.
I highly recommend.
Ryan Sebacher
Review left Dec 09 2025
Shipment processed Nov 08 2025
Review
Simple process, fair grading, cut they take is also fair in my opinion. Fast, responsive customer service. Good company.
Simple process, fair grading, cut they take is also fair in my opinion. Fast, responsive customer service. Good company.
Josh
Review left Dec 09 2025
Review
This was my first shipment with Card conduit and I’m impressed.
For my sorted shipment, I uploaded my CSV from ManaBox, they gave me a buy list based on my cards, I organized and shipped, then boom payment received.
Got a fantastic offer on the value of my cards compared to cards shops and other services. Highly recommend
For my sorted shipment, I uploaded my CSV from ManaBox, they gave me a buy list based on my cards, I organized and shipped, then boom payment received.
Got a fantastic offer on the value of my cards compared to cards shops and other services. Highly recommend
This was my first shipment with Card conduit and I’m impressed.
For my sorted shipment, I uploaded my CSV from ManaBox, they gave me a buy list based on my cards, I organized and shipped, then boom payment received.
Got a fantastic offer on the value of my cards compared to cards shops and other services. Highly recommend
For my sorted shipment, I uploaded my CSV from ManaBox, they gave me a buy list based on my cards, I organized and shipped, then boom payment received.
Got a fantastic offer on the value of my cards compared to cards shops and other services. Highly recommend
Hayley Greenstone
Review left Dec 09 2025
Shipment processed Nov 27 2025
Review
The process was easy and simple, got good value for my cards and is overall worth doing whenever I have some spare cards to sell
The process was easy and simple, got good value for my cards and is overall worth doing whenever I have some spare cards to sell
Brad HG
Review left Dec 09 2025
Review
Great experience from beginning to end. Will use again
Great experience from beginning to end. Will use again
Mitch Jahnke
Review left Dec 09 2025
Shipment processed Dec 06 2025
Review
Was a great experience all around. Will for sure be using this service again in the future!
Was a great experience all around. Will for sure be using this service again in the future!
Larisa Ann Muller
Review left Dec 09 2025
Review
Taking the tike to sort through my cards for the curated option is so worth it. This last shipment I got more than I was expecting for my cards, and its nice to have a place to sell the lower value cards along with higher value all bundled together without having to worry about individual buyers or
...
Read more
Taking the tike to sort through my cards for the curated option is so worth it. This last shipment I got more than I was expecting for my cards, and its nice to have a place to sell the lower value cards along with higher value all bundled together without having to worry about individual buyers or shipping to a bunch of places over and over as cards are bought one by one. They communicate through the whole process, and are very accommodating for larger collections. And both times I've used this service this year the payment was promp and on time. I will always use Card Conduit if I need to sell again in the future.
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every
previous customer to leave a review.
Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page.
We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a
review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).