Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service
(5856)
Vincent Valentine
Review left Dec 23 2025
Review
Process is easy but I always send in very good quality cards yet they always seem to get price knocked. Idk if you guys are banging them around when reviewing or what but my expected pay out is always significantly less. I think I will start using card kingdom instead.
Process is easy but I always send in very good quality cards yet they always seem to get price knocked. Idk if you guys are banging them around when reviewing or what but my expected pay out is always significantly less. I think I will start using card kingdom instead.
Sid Allen
Review left Dec 22 2025
Review
Uploading my collection to card conduit was super easy. Some of the printings came through wrong, but the interface to add/correct them is very intuitive and easy. After uploading my collection, I took it to my LGS for evaluation. They offered about 20% less than card conduit did… and that’s aft
...
Read more
Uploading my collection to card conduit was super easy. Some of the printings came through wrong, but the interface to add/correct them is very intuitive and easy. After uploading my collection, I took it to my LGS for evaluation. They offered about 20% less than card conduit did… and that’s after I factored in the flat rate shipping too.
Thanks to their shipping guidelines, I was able to package and ship my cards super easily. Once my cards were received and evaluated, I got a pretty good report of the payout. It came out lower than I expected so I dug into the spreadsheet which included their valuation of each card - allowing me to find the discrepancies between what I expected and the actual values really easily. I emailed them about these discrepancies, and they were able to give me explanations for the notable ones and even included some pictures. It actually helped me understand grading card conditions a lot more than I did.
Once I approved the payout, I received it pretty quick.
10/10 service, and I definitely recommend the sorted service.
Thanks to their shipping guidelines, I was able to package and ship my cards super easily. Once my cards were received and evaluated, I got a pretty good report of the payout. It came out lower than I expected so I dug into the spreadsheet which included their valuation of each card - allowing me to find the discrepancies between what I expected and the actual values really easily. I emailed them about these discrepancies, and they were able to give me explanations for the notable ones and even included some pictures. It actually helped me understand grading card conditions a lot more than I did.
Once I approved the payout, I received it pretty quick.
10/10 service, and I definitely recommend the sorted service.
David B.
Review left Dec 22 2025
Shipment processed Dec 06 2025
Review
Easy instructions, great communication, and no hassle.
I couldn't recommend a more convenient method to cash in on cleaning out unused cards, than card conduit.
They were thorough, fast, and transparent. Good work from a great team. Good Job.
I couldn't recommend a more convenient method to cash in on cleaning out unused cards, than card conduit.
They were thorough, fast, and transparent. Good work from a great team. Good Job.
Easy instructions, great communication, and no hassle.
I couldn't recommend a more convenient method to cash in on cleaning out unused cards, than card conduit.
They were thorough, fast, and transparent. Good work from a great team. Good Job.
I couldn't recommend a more convenient method to cash in on cleaning out unused cards, than card conduit.
They were thorough, fast, and transparent. Good work from a great team. Good Job.
Ned
Review left Dec 22 2025
Shipment processed Nov 27 2025
Review
Overall very easy, clear instructions and fair grading!
Overall very easy, clear instructions and fair grading!
JP
Review left Dec 21 2025
Shipment processed Dec 19 2025
Review
Process was amazing and definitely will use again for cards I do not need. 100% would recommend to my friends.
Process was amazing and definitely will use again for cards I do not need. 100% would recommend to my friends.
Andrew
Review left Dec 21 2025
Review
I would recommend. They were very transparent about the process, it was easy to track, and once they received the cards, they catalogued each one by condition and sent me a final tally. Payment was quick!
I would recommend. They were very transparent about the process, it was easy to track, and once they received the cards, they catalogued each one by condition and sent me a final tally. Payment was quick!
Nomad
Review left Dec 21 2025
Review
While it took me a short bit to get things done on my end, Card Conduit made the process rather straight forward. Simple, easy, and paid out in a timely manner.
While it took me a short bit to get things done on my end, Card Conduit made the process rather straight forward. Simple, easy, and paid out in a timely manner.
Jon
Review left Dec 21 2025
Shipment processed Dec 11 2025
Review
Had a decent amount of rares (bulk and list) just sitting around, shipped them to cc and got a fair return without the headache of listing individually. Be realistic with what the service is and you will be happy, great customer service.
Had a decent amount of rares (bulk and list) just sitting around, shipped them to cc and got a fair return without the headache of listing individually. Be realistic with what the service is and you will be happy, great customer service.
JT
Review left Dec 20 2025
Review
I found some older magic cards I had as a kid. Instructions were clear. I was able to get some money without the hassle of trying to sell myself. Id recommend
I found some older magic cards I had as a kid. Instructions were clear. I was able to get some money without the hassle of trying to sell myself. Id recommend
Evan DeCaprio
Review left Dec 20 2025
Review
Easily the best and most secure way to sell cards for a quick and reasonable turnaround
Easily the best and most secure way to sell cards for a quick and reasonable turnaround
Chris Atkinson
Review left Dec 20 2025
Review
The process was easy. Communication was 10/10. Very happy with the outcome of the shipment.
Will likely be using the service in the near future.
Will likely be using the service in the near future.
The process was easy. Communication was 10/10. Very happy with the outcome of the shipment.
Will likely be using the service in the near future.
Will likely be using the service in the near future.
Richard S.
Review left Dec 20 2025
Review
After sorting through my collection, I had a bunch of cards that didn't serve my decks. After comparing buy prices verses selling online myself and using Card Conduit, going with Card Conduit was the right option. I saved on fees by curating my shipment first and then after making sure my shipping l
...
Read more
After sorting through my collection, I had a bunch of cards that didn't serve my decks. After comparing buy prices verses selling online myself and using Card Conduit, going with Card Conduit was the right option. I saved on fees by curating my shipment first and then after making sure my shipping label and tracking information is correct, the rest of the process was easy.
I got paid what was estimated for the value of my cards which was awesome!
I repeated this process three more times and each time my curated cards got shipped, verified, and then I got paid!
I would recommend using Card Conduit to get rid of any unwanted high value cards in bulk. The selling process is simple; you save fees if you curate the cards first and most importantly you don't have to deal with the hassle of selling each card online to individual buyers.
I got paid what was estimated for the value of my cards which was awesome!
I repeated this process three more times and each time my curated cards got shipped, verified, and then I got paid!
I would recommend using Card Conduit to get rid of any unwanted high value cards in bulk. The selling process is simple; you save fees if you curate the cards first and most importantly you don't have to deal with the hassle of selling each card online to individual buyers.
Matt
Review left Dec 20 2025
Review
The process was fast and relatively simple. It was good to see a detailed breakdown of the grading for each card. Customer service was responsive and payment happened quickly after accepting the offer. I plan to work with Card Conduit again in the future.
The process was fast and relatively simple. It was good to see a detailed breakdown of the grading for each card. Customer service was responsive and payment happened quickly after accepting the offer. I plan to work with Card Conduit again in the future.
Sean Larsen
Review left Dec 20 2025
Review
Process was fairly quick and easy. I had already sorted the cards I was looking to sell. I do want to try the more unsorted service at some point to see how that goes. Entire process took a bit longer than some of the other large options out there but it was easy and the communication during the process was good. I would use it again
Process was fairly quick and easy. I had already sorted the cards I was looking to sell. I do want to try the more unsorted service at some point to see how that goes. Entire process took a bit longer than some of the other large options out there but it was easy and the communication during the process was good. I would use it again
JJ
Review left Dec 19 2025
Review
Condition can be harsh, but I felt like I received fair value for cards in less than NM condition.
It was hard to time things with selling lands. At the time I sorted them, all the older lands had value above .10, and I selected specifically for those. However by the time everything was submi ... Read more
It was hard to time things with selling lands. At the time I sorted them, all the older lands had value above .10, and I selected specifically for those. However by the time everything was submi ... Read more
Condition can be harsh, but I felt like I received fair value for cards in less than NM condition.
It was hard to time things with selling lands. At the time I sorted them, all the older lands had value above .10, and I selected specifically for those. However by the time everything was submitted and processed, some of those had dropped to .002 and others that I omitted from the shipment had risen to higher levels.
I've used them several times and happy with the service and communication, and I always enjoy seeing the report.
It was hard to time things with selling lands. At the time I sorted them, all the older lands had value above .10, and I selected specifically for those. However by the time everything was submitted and processed, some of those had dropped to .002 and others that I omitted from the shipment had risen to higher levels.
I've used them several times and happy with the service and communication, and I always enjoy seeing the report.
P. Boyle
Review left Dec 19 2025
Review
I was pleased with the easy process. I really enjoyed having multiple options to cut down fees. I chose to sort the order for card conduit and it dropped the fees down to 2%. Just be realistic with yourself on what they will payout. I saw great value in them buying a majority of my ~$5 cards because
...
Read more
I was pleased with the easy process. I really enjoyed having multiple options to cut down fees. I chose to sort the order for card conduit and it dropped the fees down to 2%. Just be realistic with yourself on what they will payout. I saw great value in them buying a majority of my ~$5 cards because otherwise that would be a decent hassle selling them as singles. Regardless the prices they were willing to pay were not bad at all. I would recommend it to anybody with a lot of cards to move.
Ernie
Review left Dec 19 2025
Review
I was happy with what I sent and received back. It will help me buy a few cards I need. Thank you for the quick turnaround and payout. I will use your service again.
I was happy with what I sent and received back. It will help me buy a few cards I need. Thank you for the quick turnaround and payout. I will use your service again.
Apollo
Review left Dec 19 2025
Review
The cards were handled amazingly, professionally, and quickly! As soon as the cards arrived at their facility, the process was finished in just a couple of days! The payout and ratings were done fairly and I'm overall happy with the results!
The cards were handled amazingly, professionally, and quickly! As soon as the cards arrived at their facility, the process was finished in just a couple of days! The payout and ratings were done fairly and I'm overall happy with the results!
Channing
Review left Dec 19 2025
Review
I love Card Conduit! Best decision ever to sell my cards here.
I love Card Conduit! Best decision ever to sell my cards here.
Dallan
Review left Dec 18 2025
Review
Better value than trading into an LGS for sure, would recommend
Better value than trading into an LGS for sure, would recommend
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every
previous customer to leave a review.
Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page.
We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a
review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).