Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service
(6305)
Joseph Hollis
Review left Mar 27 2026
Shipment processed Mar 19 2026
Review
Easy process and fairly decent speed to finish beginning to end
Easy process and fairly decent speed to finish beginning to end
Evan Walsh
Review left Mar 27 2026
Review
Everytime I have done business here it's efficient and efficient and you are always in communication
Good stuff
Good stuff
Everytime I have done business here it's efficient and efficient and you are always in communication
Good stuff
Good stuff
Noah
Review left Mar 27 2026
Review
Process was easy and fast with a fair payout. The best online sell list service I have used thus far.
Process was easy and fast with a fair payout. The best online sell list service I have used thus far.
Dutch
Review left Mar 27 2026
Shipment processed Feb 25 2026
Review
Everything happened as described. I got a fair price for my cards and it was easy to do. I would highly recommended and will be using in the future.
Everything happened as described. I got a fair price for my cards and it was easy to do. I would highly recommended and will be using in the future.
Sierra
Review left Mar 26 2026
Review
I sent a small collection in and was very pleased with the results I got back. I received payout exactly a week after they got my delivery. What an awesome service and much better than selling on marketplace or Facebook in my opinion for more than a few cards! The grading of my collection was extremely fair, will definitely be using them again!
I sent a small collection in and was very pleased with the results I got back. I received payout exactly a week after they got my delivery. What an awesome service and much better than selling on marketplace or Facebook in my opinion for more than a few cards! The grading of my collection was extremely fair, will definitely be using them again!
Thomas Fischl
Review left Mar 26 2026
Review
Amount was towards the lower end of value scale and I found that a bit disappointing. I wasn't expecting the full amount based on the condition of the cards but it felt a bit low. Overall, good experience though.
Amount was towards the lower end of value scale and I found that a bit disappointing. I wasn't expecting the full amount based on the condition of the cards but it felt a bit low. Overall, good experience though.
Terry H
Review left Mar 26 2026
Review
Always easy and good prices. Will use and recommend.
Always easy and good prices. Will use and recommend.
Nick
Review left Mar 26 2026
Review
Very easy and I wish I had sent more cards. I sold some of my collection on ebay via singles and I likely would have recieved more from those cards if I used Card Conduit from the start. The fees were very reasonable considering I didn't need to put much work in and I was very happy with the payout!
...
Read more
Very easy and I wish I had sent more cards. I sold some of my collection on ebay via singles and I likely would have recieved more from those cards if I used Card Conduit from the start. The fees were very reasonable considering I didn't need to put much work in and I was very happy with the payout! Support even sent me an indepth report explaining the overall condition of the cards in the shipment, their pricing breakdowns, and I was impressed with the service. Honestly, I would have recieved pennies-on-the-dollar at my local LGS, but in doing it this way I can technically spend 'more' at my LGS, so win-win if you want to support local. Will definitely be using Card Condiut again!
Austin Jenkins
Review left Mar 26 2026
Review
Great service, pretty quick process for 400+ cards, can’t complain
Great service, pretty quick process for 400+ cards, can’t complain
Susan Ponds
Review left Mar 26 2026
Review
I put off doing anything with my son’s old magic cards for years because of the amount of time and effort I felt it would require. I saw card conduit online and decided to give them a shot. I initially sent about 2000 cards. I was BLOWN AWAY by how easy it was, how informative card conduit was
...
Read more
I put off doing anything with my son’s old magic cards for years because of the amount of time and effort I felt it would require. I saw card conduit online and decided to give them a shot. I initially sent about 2000 cards. I was BLOWN AWAY by how easy it was, how informative card conduit was in every step of the process, how fair they were in determining the value of my cards and how quickly they paid for the cards!
I chose the auto-sort method and could not be happier. I promptly boxed up the rest of the cards which are en-route to card conduit as we speak.
Obviously I have no hesitation about using them again!
Great experience! Great communication every step of the way! Just all around great company!
Thanks!!
I chose the auto-sort method and could not be happier. I promptly boxed up the rest of the cards which are en-route to card conduit as we speak.
Obviously I have no hesitation about using them again!
Great experience! Great communication every step of the way! Just all around great company!
Thanks!!
Jonathan Jenkins
Review left Mar 26 2026
Review
Everything went great working with Card Conduit. I followed their instructions and was able to sell my cards without a hitch. Will definitely recommend to friends and use again.
Everything went great working with Card Conduit. I followed their instructions and was able to sell my cards without a hitch. Will definitely recommend to friends and use again.
Knewt C .
Review left Mar 26 2026
Shipment processed Feb 24 2026
Review
Highly recommend because of the ease of use, the value given.
Highly recommend because of the ease of use, the value given.
Paul Chapin
Review left Mar 25 2026
Review
I have dealt with Card Conduit several times so far...I love their service. Reasonable pricing, fast turnaround, great communication....tried a few other places but had horribly mixed results...came back to Card Conduit because it is so much easier. I MAY have gotten a few bucks more somewhere els
...
Read more
I have dealt with Card Conduit several times so far...I love their service. Reasonable pricing, fast turnaround, great communication....tried a few other places but had horribly mixed results...came back to Card Conduit because it is so much easier. I MAY have gotten a few bucks more somewhere else but it would have created MANY HOURS more work to put together...not at all worth it. I won't deal with anyone but Card Conduit now.
Trist
Review left Mar 25 2026
Review
Shipped a “large” list in and cards were processed and paid in about a week.
Shipped a “large” list in and cards were processed and paid in about a week.
Sean
Review left Mar 25 2026
Review
Process was super easy, wouldn’t say there was much value as I lost money shipping the cards safely. Have to assume that’s on me for not having very many high value cards but having sent just over 1800 cards I was expecting to get more than the cost of a handful booster packs. I do think if you
...
Read more
Process was super easy, wouldn’t say there was much value as I lost money shipping the cards safely. Have to assume that’s on me for not having very many high value cards but having sent just over 1800 cards I was expecting to get more than the cost of a handful booster packs. I do think if you have the volume and high value cards this would be a great service but if you’re just looking to clear bulk of negligible value I’d recommend maybe looking for someone who offers trade credit instead.
Tim
Review left Mar 24 2026
Review
Thanks for processing my order - good service and value
Thanks for processing my order - good service and value
Tim
Review left Mar 24 2026
Review
Thank you for processing my order. Would recommend
Thank you for processing my order. Would recommend
Tim
Review left Mar 24 2026
Review
Thanks for another transaction, I like the auto sift service
Thanks for another transaction, I like the auto sift service
Corey G
Review left Mar 23 2026
Shipment processed Mar 17 2026
Review
Amazing! Effortless. This service will be recommended to everyone I know who plays.
Amazing! Effortless. This service will be recommended to everyone I know who plays.
Matt
Review left Mar 23 2026
Shipment processed Feb 28 2026
Review
Fast, easy, and great communication. Nice job! I'll definitely use the service again.
Fast, easy, and great communication. Nice job! I'll definitely use the service again.
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every
previous customer to leave a review.
Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page.
We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a
review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).