Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service
(6305)
J
Review left Apr 02 2026
Review
I had a bunch of cards sitting in closet that I had accumulated from opening packs/boxes. Most of the higher value cards I had already sold. After months of them just sitting in the closet, I decided to send them off to be auto-sifted. I sent nearly 3k cards. All I had to do was put them facing the
...
Read more
I had a bunch of cards sitting in closet that I had accumulated from opening packs/boxes. Most of the higher value cards I had already sold. After months of them just sitting in the closet, I decided to send them off to be auto-sifted. I sent nearly 3k cards. All I had to do was put them facing the same way and separate foils from regular cards. I received a report of the cards and was surprised how many I had of value even though the cards were of no use/value to me. I would definitely recommend the auto-sifted service if you have a bunch of leftover cards sitting in booster boxes that you are not using. I felt the grading and prices were very fair and the fee was minimal compared to the time I’d have taken looking them all up on my own.
David
Review left Apr 02 2026
Review
Process was easy, I think the comp was fair. Some of the grades seemed harsh relative to some of the more expensive cards. Before shipping I would have thought 90% at near mint as that is how I've been selling myself on tcgplayer per their guidelines, which card conduit follows. But some cards came
...
Read more
Process was easy, I think the comp was fair. Some of the grades seemed harsh relative to some of the more expensive cards. Before shipping I would have thought 90% at near mint as that is how I've been selling myself on tcgplayer per their guidelines, which card conduit follows. But some cards came back as MP or LP but not specific evidence to support. I understand too that logistically that could be a challenge but it would be great to have that detail (like how TAG does their card grading) to invoke a greater sense of transparency and drive up confidence
cory padia
Review left Apr 01 2026
Review
I've been using Card Conduit for a while. every experience is perfect from start to finish. This time I got to use a promo code from one of my favorite content creators Joel Are Magic which was awesome!
I've been using Card Conduit for a while. every experience is perfect from start to finish. This time I got to use a promo code from one of my favorite content creators Joel Are Magic which was awesome!
Andrew
Review left Apr 01 2026
Review
Overall the process was easy to navigate from start to finish. I just highly disagree with some of the grading. I bought a majority of the cards at LP and they were doubled sleeved immediately so not sure how they became damaged all the sudden. I wont be using this service again
Overall the process was easy to navigate from start to finish. I just highly disagree with some of the grading. I bought a majority of the cards at LP and they were doubled sleeved immediately so not sure how they became damaged all the sudden. I wont be using this service again
Connor C.
Review left Apr 01 2026
Review
Fair pricing, easy shipment process and no hassles. Thank you!
Fair pricing, easy shipment process and no hassles. Thank you!
Aaron Friend
Review left Mar 31 2026
Review
I have sold many Magic cards throughout my life. From different shops/LGS, online retailers (Star City Games, Channel Fireball, etc), and even individuals, Card Conduit is currently the best experience I have had selling cards. From the beginning they project a time window of when you will receive
...
Read more
I have sold many Magic cards throughout my life. From different shops/LGS, online retailers (Star City Games, Channel Fireball, etc), and even individuals, Card Conduit is currently the best experience I have had selling cards. From the beginning they project a time window of when you will receive your payout, and it is very accurate. I have had nightmares with other companies where they sent payment to an incorrect PayPal account, or told me the condition of a card was way worse than it was when I mailed it.
Card Conduit was fair throughout the entire process. The online buy-list and shipping instructions were easy to navigate and tracking the process was easy. When they sent the final report and payment, I had a few questions to review on condition, and they kindly sent photos of some of the wear on corners of a card and surface scratches that kept the card from being NM. They were professional and the process is the most fair I have dealt with recently. Sure you can find individual buyers that may pay a little more but the security isn't there. You may be able to get more store credit from Star City Games, but they don't always have the card you need in stock. If you are looking to buy into another format, or are looking to pick up a few higher end cards, this has got to be the best way to go.
Card Conduit was fair throughout the entire process. The online buy-list and shipping instructions were easy to navigate and tracking the process was easy. When they sent the final report and payment, I had a few questions to review on condition, and they kindly sent photos of some of the wear on corners of a card and surface scratches that kept the card from being NM. They were professional and the process is the most fair I have dealt with recently. Sure you can find individual buyers that may pay a little more but the security isn't there. You may be able to get more store credit from Star City Games, but they don't always have the card you need in stock. If you are looking to buy into another format, or are looking to pick up a few higher end cards, this has got to be the best way to go.
Brett Manifold-Wheeler
Review left Mar 31 2026
Review
I think the process was quick and easy, and overall, I got about what I expected for my cards. Interestingly, there were card grades that I think were completely bogus, and other grades that I think were likely better than I expected. It did even out in the end.
My general commentary on the gradi ... Read more
My general commentary on the gradi ... Read more
I think the process was quick and easy, and overall, I got about what I expected for my cards. Interestingly, there were card grades that I think were completely bogus, and other grades that I think were likely better than I expected. It did even out in the end.
My general commentary on the grading is that items which had low value, that there were a lot of (10+), tended to be lower graded as a lumped grade, and things that had higher value ($50+ tended to be more harshly graded, which is partially expected, but in some cases felt questionable. By no stretch do I think my shipment was all NM or even LP; however, some items were pack to sleeve that got graded as damaged (most notably a Secret Lair Phyrexian Tower) when it was IMO, clearly NM or at worst LP. Again, none of this is a big deal, and I believe it is the cost of doing business.
I want to emphasize at the end here that my experience was overall very positive, but I want to give an honest assessment of the areas I found were good as well as bad. The speed at which everything was completed and that money was sent was phenomenal, and even with my issues with grading on certain items, my expected payout was right about where I expected it to be, so everything came out as a wash for any issues I had with grading.
My general commentary on the grading is that items which had low value, that there were a lot of (10+), tended to be lower graded as a lumped grade, and things that had higher value ($50+ tended to be more harshly graded, which is partially expected, but in some cases felt questionable. By no stretch do I think my shipment was all NM or even LP; however, some items were pack to sleeve that got graded as damaged (most notably a Secret Lair Phyrexian Tower) when it was IMO, clearly NM or at worst LP. Again, none of this is a big deal, and I believe it is the cost of doing business.
I want to emphasize at the end here that my experience was overall very positive, but I want to give an honest assessment of the areas I found were good as well as bad. The speed at which everything was completed and that money was sent was phenomenal, and even with my issues with grading on certain items, my expected payout was right about where I expected it to be, so everything came out as a wash for any issues I had with grading.
Eli Guthrie
Review left Mar 31 2026
Review
I would recommend them for sure. Got 400 out of stuff I had laying around. 75 less than I thought. But I just had to ship off the cards and get paid. Little effort on my part. I missed a 125 dollar card on their state sheet they gave me. I would have kept that one.
I would recommend them for sure. Got 400 out of stuff I had laying around. 75 less than I thought. But I just had to ship off the cards and get paid. Little effort on my part. I missed a 125 dollar card on their state sheet they gave me. I would have kept that one.
Jasper Forrester
Review left Mar 31 2026
Shipment processed Feb 27 2026
Review
An outstanding company dedicated to the service of Magic The Gathering fans everywhere. They are the absolute cornerstone of everything MACIC!
An outstanding company dedicated to the service of Magic The Gathering fans everywhere. They are the absolute cornerstone of everything MACIC!
Terry
Review left Mar 30 2026
Review
Easy to use, fair grading and prices. Will continue to use.
Easy to use, fair grading and prices. Will continue to use.
ALPHA
Review left Mar 30 2026
Review
great company for selling cards!!! have used them multiple times
great company for selling cards!!! have used them multiple times
Alex
Review left Mar 30 2026
Review
I've done a few shipments through card conduit and it's always everything I want in a service like this. They pay good value for the cards, charge a reasonable fee, and it's very quick and easy.
I've done a few shipments through card conduit and it's always everything I want in a service like this. They pay good value for the cards, charge a reasonable fee, and it's very quick and easy.
Joshua
Review left Mar 30 2026
Review
Sent a curated group of cards. The communication was great I knew what was happening every step they provide great detail of values and condition. Fair prices and easy to submit. I would recommend.
Sent a curated group of cards. The communication was great I knew what was happening every step they provide great detail of values and condition. Fair prices and easy to submit. I would recommend.
Alex
Review left Mar 29 2026
Shipment processed Mar 20 2026
$127.15
payout, $2.33
fees
Review
Everything was clearly explained, with detailed reports and fast responses.
Everything was clearly explained, with detailed reports and fast responses.
Kevin Swanson
Review left Mar 29 2026
Review
Live you guys.... will keep coming back to cardconduit every time. I was even shown a better way to submit my cards to maximize my money!
Live you guys.... will keep coming back to cardconduit every time. I was even shown a better way to submit my cards to maximize my money!
Justin Brady
Review left Mar 28 2026
Review
I sent them a package of rares I was not playing and was chided for how small the shipment was, but I got about $140.
Then I sent a 7 lb package of cards of all rarities to get about $20. That covers shipping and a pack of gum.
Basically dont bother sending your bulk, they just want the good stuff, which you probably want to keep anyhow.
Then I sent a 7 lb package of cards of all rarities to get about $20. That covers shipping and a pack of gum.
Basically dont bother sending your bulk, they just want the good stuff, which you probably want to keep anyhow.
I sent them a package of rares I was not playing and was chided for how small the shipment was, but I got about $140.
Then I sent a 7 lb package of cards of all rarities to get about $20. That covers shipping and a pack of gum.
Basically dont bother sending your bulk, they just want the good stuff, which you probably want to keep anyhow.
Then I sent a 7 lb package of cards of all rarities to get about $20. That covers shipping and a pack of gum.
Basically dont bother sending your bulk, they just want the good stuff, which you probably want to keep anyhow.
Trey Lasseigne
Review left Mar 28 2026
Review
Quick, easy, love the self service aspect. Card Conduit even followed up with answers to questions I had after.
Quick, easy, love the self service aspect. Card Conduit even followed up with answers to questions I had after.
Benjamin Kuntz
Review left Mar 28 2026
Review
I sent a sorted shipment and promptly received payment. Prices are good and fees are quite minimal.
I sent a sorted shipment and promptly received payment. Prices are good and fees are quite minimal.
Clayton
Review left Mar 27 2026
Review
It was really easy to send my cards in for cash in return. It works as promised.
It was really easy to send my cards in for cash in return. It works as promised.
Farhaan Khan
Review left Mar 27 2026
Review
Fast, Efficient, Communicative, Easy. Everything from setting up my shipment to updates to payment were all a breeze. Will be using again!
Fast, Efficient, Communicative, Easy. Everything from setting up my shipment to updates to payment were all a breeze. Will be using again!
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every
previous customer to leave a review.
Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page.
We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a
review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).