Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service
(5628)
Nicol Bolas
Review left Nov 17 2025
Review
It was an easy and efficient service that I would recommend to a friend
It was an easy and efficient service that I would recommend to a friend
Basil
Review left Nov 16 2025
Review
very easy to sell cards, would send cards to your team again.
very easy to sell cards, would send cards to your team again.
Zack
Review left Nov 16 2025
Review
This is a great service. I played MtG in high school and have kept my cards (in card boxes and many sleeved) over the last 10 years. It took a few hours to unsleeve and box them up for shipping, but it was way easier than trying to determine market value for all of them and selling myself. I didn’
...
Read more
This is a great service. I played MtG in high school and have kept my cards (in card boxes and many sleeved) over the last 10 years. It took a few hours to unsleeve and box them up for shipping, but it was way easier than trying to determine market value for all of them and selling myself. I didn’t have anything crazy valuable but it added up pretty well. I’d definitely use this service again.
Carey
Review left Nov 16 2025
Review
This is the simplest way to get the most out of your collection. Highly recommend
This is the simplest way to get the most out of your collection. Highly recommend
Jrob
Review left Nov 16 2025
Review
My second time using the service. I am satisfied and will continue to use card conduit.
My second time using the service. I am satisfied and will continue to use card conduit.
Alex R
Review left Nov 16 2025
Review
Service was easy and payment came through quickly. Grading is a bit harsher than I was used to from using TCGplayer buylist (Several pack fresh cards were graded LP or even MP) but the price impact of the lower grades is a lot less than at other services which makes up for it.
Service was easy and payment came through quickly. Grading is a bit harsher than I was used to from using TCGplayer buylist (Several pack fresh cards were graded LP or even MP) but the price impact of the lower grades is a lot less than at other services which makes up for it.
Mason
Review left Nov 16 2025
Review
Very easy to register a shipment and get it prepped. Once it is shipped off, they are very communicative about the entire process. If you are looking for a low effort way to sell of a bunch of cards at once, Card Conduit will have you taken care of.
Very easy to register a shipment and get it prepped. Once it is shipped off, they are very communicative about the entire process. If you are looking for a low effort way to sell of a bunch of cards at once, Card Conduit will have you taken care of.
Sonata
Review left Nov 15 2025
Review
Everything proceeded quickly, payment hit my bank account within a business day of approving. I like the itemization, and for the time taken to get value out of the cards everything went very well. Better option for me than trying to sell everything individually then doing a bulk sale.
Everything proceeded quickly, payment hit my bank account within a business day of approving. I like the itemization, and for the time taken to get value out of the cards everything went very well. Better option for me than trying to sell everything individually then doing a bulk sale.
Jaime Hernandez
Review left Nov 15 2025
Review
I'm very happy with how things worked out. I look forward to working with you in the future.
I'm very happy with how things worked out. I look forward to working with you in the future.
Joseph T.
Review left Nov 15 2025
Shipment processed Oct 23 2025
Review
The process was easy. Once the package arrived at the facility, there was a slight delay in processing it but afterwards my results were processed in less than a week. I would highly recommend the service and will be using it agian!
The process was easy. Once the package arrived at the facility, there was a slight delay in processing it but afterwards my results were processed in less than a week. I would highly recommend the service and will be using it agian!
Ervin Gonzales
Review left Nov 15 2025
Shipment processed Nov 06 2025
Review
The process was really easy. I got solid value for the cards I sent over and I would highly recommend!
The process was really easy. I got solid value for the cards I sent over and I would highly recommend!
Justin AkaSyx
Review left Nov 14 2025
Review
I've said it before and I'll say it again; the process is easy and the stats at the end are fun to look at!
I've said it before and I'll say it again; the process is easy and the stats at the end are fun to look at!
Jack Williams
Review left Nov 14 2025
Review
Team was great to work with. Will definitely use again.
Team was great to work with. Will definitely use again.
Dan B
Review left Nov 14 2025
Review
Ive used CC 3 times now. I'm very happy with the service. It's easily the easiest was to liquidate cards that I don't have a use for. When you add in your time and effort to sell 50 or 500 cards it's an easy proposition.
Ive used CC 3 times now. I'm very happy with the service. It's easily the easiest was to liquidate cards that I don't have a use for. When you add in your time and effort to sell 50 or 500 cards it's an easy proposition.
Scott Floyd
Review left Nov 14 2025
Review
The process was easy. Fast and fair. Would recommend to anyone looking for a fair fast payout without all the haste
The process was easy. Fast and fair. Would recommend to anyone looking for a fair fast payout without all the haste
Drew H
Review left Nov 14 2025
Review
The process to sort and itemize the cards was a little tedious but it was more than worth it to get the great sale prices. I got better prices than any buy list and it was easy to ship my cards in once I got them sorted. I'll definitely be selling cards through Card Conduit again and recommending it to my play group!
The process to sort and itemize the cards was a little tedious but it was more than worth it to get the great sale prices. I got better prices than any buy list and it was easy to ship my cards in once I got them sorted. I'll definitely be selling cards through Card Conduit again and recommending it to my play group!
Anthony nunez
Review left Nov 14 2025
Shipment processed Nov 12 2025
Review
They really are here to help in any way run by folks with good business ethics..
They really are here to help in any way run by folks with good business ethics..
Carissa Fowler
Review left Nov 14 2025
Review
Great experience when selling my me magic cards!!!
Great experience when selling my me magic cards!!!
Marco P.
Review left Nov 13 2025
Review
I had a fantastic experience using Card Conduit. Their process was straightforward and easy from start to finish. The website is well designed, intuitive, and made submitting my cards simple.
One of the highlights for me was receiving a detailed report of my cards along with their graded conditio ... Read more
One of the highlights for me was receiving a detailed report of my cards along with their graded conditio ... Read more
I had a fantastic experience using Card Conduit. Their process was straightforward and easy from start to finish. The website is well designed, intuitive, and made submitting my cards simple.
One of the highlights for me was receiving a detailed report of my cards along with their graded condition. It gave me confidence in the evaluation process and transparency I haven’t seen elsewhere. Even better, if you disagree with their assessment, they offer the option to request your card back... something I haven’t encountered with any other site that buys Magic cards. That level of flexibility and respect for the customer really stood out.
Overall, Card Conduit combines ease of use, transparency, and customer-friendly policies in a way that makes selling Magic cards stress-free. I’ll definitely be using them again.
One of the highlights for me was receiving a detailed report of my cards along with their graded condition. It gave me confidence in the evaluation process and transparency I haven’t seen elsewhere. Even better, if you disagree with their assessment, they offer the option to request your card back... something I haven’t encountered with any other site that buys Magic cards. That level of flexibility and respect for the customer really stood out.
Overall, Card Conduit combines ease of use, transparency, and customer-friendly policies in a way that makes selling Magic cards stress-free. I’ll definitely be using them again.
Mainer
Review left Nov 13 2025
Review
I went through my cards, and if it was gonna be worth more than $3 or so, I threw it in a box. When the box was full, I taped it up, and mailed it out. Maybe 10 days later, boom almost $6400 in my bank account. To my knowledge, there is no other company that even comes close to both the convenience
...
Read more
I went through my cards, and if it was gonna be worth more than $3 or so, I threw it in a box. When the box was full, I taped it up, and mailed it out. Maybe 10 days later, boom almost $6400 in my bank account. To my knowledge, there is no other company that even comes close to both the convenience of the service, and the degree of payout. Honestly hard for me to understand why they even decide to be this good when they have no competition, maybe decisionmakers at the company are just good people?
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every
previous customer to leave a review.
Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page.
We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a
review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).