Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service
(5628)
Ronald Wade
Review left Nov 21 2025
Review
Easy process would definitely use them again to sell cards
Easy process would definitely use them again to sell cards
Spencer D
Review left Nov 20 2025
Review
The process started off easily enough from scanning in my collection on Moxfield and simply importing that list to CardConduit’s shipment/appraisal tool! The entire process took about a week to ship the cards, have them appraised, and receive an offer which was way faster than I expected AND there
...
Read more
The process started off easily enough from scanning in my collection on Moxfield and simply importing that list to CardConduit’s shipment/appraisal tool! The entire process took about a week to ship the cards, have them appraised, and receive an offer which was way faster than I expected AND there was a full write up of each card with the reason for the condition appraisal. They communicated very clearly and honestly about where they were at in each step of the process and I could see estimates periodically about where my shipment was in their system, which was nice as well. Overall, I’d highly recommend this service to anyone looking to sell their collection as the pricing was fair, communication was sincere and human, and the process was fairly quick!
Chase
Review left Nov 20 2025
Review
My return was way more than I expected. Fast processing.
My return was way more than I expected. Fast processing.
Brian
Review left Nov 20 2025
Shipment processed Nov 11 2025
Review
I've used CardConduit twice now and had a great experience - this is the easiest way I've found to sell cards.
I've used CardConduit twice now and had a great experience - this is the easiest way I've found to sell cards.
Somebody
Review left Nov 19 2025
Review
Excellent service, easy execution! !
Excellent service, easy execution! !
Somebody
Review left Nov 19 2025
Review
Excellent service, easy execution! !
Excellent service, easy execution! !
Somebody
Review left Nov 19 2025
Review
Excellent service, easy execution! .
Excellent service, easy execution! .
Seth Wolf
Review left Nov 18 2025
Review
My cards arrived at their facilities on a weekend but as soon as Monday hit they worked on checking my order right away.
My cards arrived at their facilities on a weekend but as soon as Monday hit they worked on checking my order right away.
Chase S.
Review left Nov 18 2025
Review
Extremely easy, I choose the option with the least amount of work and sent in around 1k cards. Processing took about a week and the layout was right on par with what I was hoping for. All in all very fair and I will use these guys again for sure!
Extremely easy, I choose the option with the least amount of work and sent in around 1k cards. Processing took about a week and the layout was right on par with what I was hoping for. All in all very fair and I will use these guys again for sure!
Dani D
Review left Nov 18 2025
Review
You aren’t going to be able to sell all of your cards anywhere else like this. It’s soo much quicker than trying to sell on your own.
You aren’t going to be able to sell all of your cards anywhere else like this. It’s soo much quicker than trying to sell on your own.
Jeffrey L
Review left Nov 18 2025
Review
This is the easiest way to sell a large amount of cards. The process is exactly as they describe it and it's very easy.
They are very strick on grading the cards though and you shouldn't expect full price that they list. If you come in with the mindset that you will get 70% of what they say for near mint, you will be very happy.
They are very strick on grading the cards though and you shouldn't expect full price that they list. If you come in with the mindset that you will get 70% of what they say for near mint, you will be very happy.
This is the easiest way to sell a large amount of cards. The process is exactly as they describe it and it's very easy.
They are very strick on grading the cards though and you shouldn't expect full price that they list. If you come in with the mindset that you will get 70% of what they say for near mint, you will be very happy.
They are very strick on grading the cards though and you shouldn't expect full price that they list. If you come in with the mindset that you will get 70% of what they say for near mint, you will be very happy.
Oliver Updyke
Review left Nov 18 2025
Review
Fast process, a good deal, and way quicker than other selling places!
Fast process, a good deal, and way quicker than other selling places!
Matthew Chappell
Review left Nov 18 2025
Review
Fair prices, fast payment. My foils were all LP and have never been played, just immediately sleeved, but I didn't lose too much value.
Fair prices, fast payment. My foils were all LP and have never been played, just immediately sleeved, but I didn't lose too much value.
JP
Review left Nov 18 2025
Shipment processed Nov 06 2025
Review
I tried out Card Conduit for the first time using the standard service, they have an easy to use price checking tool which came in handy. The process was very easy. I like the fact that you can see the process of you shipment and when your payout is ready. Regardless of some of the conditioning I wa
...
Read more
I tried out Card Conduit for the first time using the standard service, they have an easy to use price checking tool which came in handy. The process was very easy. I like the fact that you can see the process of you shipment and when your payout is ready. Regardless of some of the conditioning I was still very happy with the service and my payout. I will be using these guys more often.
David Ding
Review left Nov 17 2025
Review
The processing is very smooth and the return on value is as expected.
The processing is very smooth and the return on value is as expected.
Ethan Blake
Review left Nov 17 2025
Shipment processed Nov 01 2025
Review
Easy Process, Fast turnaround, would recommend to a friend.
Easy Process, Fast turnaround, would recommend to a friend.
Kendall Cormier
Review left Nov 17 2025
Review
Fast and easy can complete trade in in just a couple weeks
Fast and easy can complete trade in in just a couple weeks
Spencer
Review left Nov 17 2025
Shipment processed Nov 08 2025
Review
Easy glad they take all cards and not pick and choose like local stores
Easy glad they take all cards and not pick and choose like local stores
Chandler Lee
Review left Nov 17 2025
Review
I've been buying and selling magic cards for 15 years now. This is by far the best way to sell if your goals are getting money fast and not putting in a ton of effort.
I've been buying and selling magic cards for 15 years now. This is by far the best way to sell if your goals are getting money fast and not putting in a ton of effort.
Jaime Hernandez
Review left Nov 17 2025
Review
Thank you for taking my cards. I have way to many magic cards and plan on sending several more shipments to you guys soon
Thank you for taking my cards. I have way to many magic cards and plan on sending several more shipments to you guys soon
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every
previous customer to leave a review.
Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page.
We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a
review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).