Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service
(5628)
Joseph
Review left Nov 25 2025
Review
The process was simple and easy to understand. The value was better than the cards sitting around. I would tell other about card conduit.
The process was simple and easy to understand. The value was better than the cards sitting around. I would tell other about card conduit.
Zikri Hasanbasri
Review left Nov 25 2025
Review
Long story short, I have an old collection of cards that were just sitting there, unlikely to be played. I didn't expect much out of it, but I figured someone could use it better. I was happy with any amount they were willing to give me, but they reduced some fees because of my low average value for
...
Read more
Long story short, I have an old collection of cards that were just sitting there, unlikely to be played. I didn't expect much out of it, but I figured someone could use it better. I was happy with any amount they were willing to give me, but they reduced some fees because of my low average value for these cards. They didn't need to do that, and I wouldn't expect them to do that every time. But, they cared for a first time customer, and I'm glad I sent my cards to them.
brandon
Review left Nov 25 2025
Review
Based on my overall experience i am extremely satisfied. Everything was done in a timely manner. The amount i received was a good value for what i sent in. I plan on using Card Conduit again soon. Would recommend to anyone.
Based on my overall experience i am extremely satisfied. Everything was done in a timely manner. The amount i received was a good value for what i sent in. I plan on using Card Conduit again soon. Would recommend to anyone.
Tanner Bethany
Review left Nov 25 2025
Review
First time using you guys and it was way easier than expected! Definitely going to be using you guys more!
First time using you guys and it was way easier than expected! Definitely going to be using you guys more!
Aaron Friend
Review left Nov 25 2025
Review
I have used a lot of companies over the years I've been playing Magic. I started playing during Ice Age and stopped shortly after Apocalypse came out. I collected the card Show and Tell from Urza's Saga for fun. In 2013 I had some friends in the office playing in the meeting room after work and I
...
Read more
I have used a lot of companies over the years I've been playing Magic. I started playing during Ice Age and stopped shortly after Apocalypse came out. I collected the card Show and Tell from Urza's Saga for fun. In 2013 I had some friends in the office playing in the meeting room after work and I had no idea how relevant my cards still were. So I started drafting again and played the Grand Prix that year in Nashville. I got into tournament playing again, but then found myself spending too much time on it and quit again in 2020. I found myself back into Commander casually with friends this past year, and wanted to sell some cards to get some staples for my deck. I'm very thankful for an organized and honest company to review and offer a fair price.
The entire process from signing up to the payout date was 12 days (that includes shipping time, review time, and payment processing). That is better than MTG Seattle and Star City Games. Also their payouts tend to be about 15-20% more.
If I need to offload any cards again, I will definitely be using Card Conduit!
The entire process from signing up to the payout date was 12 days (that includes shipping time, review time, and payment processing). That is better than MTG Seattle and Star City Games. Also their payouts tend to be about 15-20% more.
If I need to offload any cards again, I will definitely be using Card Conduit!
David Drake
Review left Nov 25 2025
Review
Card Conduit did an excellent job for me. After reviewing their website and information I submitted some MTG to see how it worked and it was as they advertised. In fact I submitted much more a second time with the intent continue as needed. Fast and Fair valuations and payments. Best to you Card Conduit and staff.
Card Conduit did an excellent job for me. After reviewing their website and information I submitted some MTG to see how it worked and it was as they advertised. In fact I submitted much more a second time with the intent continue as needed. Fast and Fair valuations and payments. Best to you Card Conduit and staff.
Dillon
Review left Nov 25 2025
Review
I've used CardConduit multiple times and their process is well laid out, easy to follow, and they have excellent communication. I've always been pleased with the payback and haven't had any issues with my shipments
I've used CardConduit multiple times and their process is well laid out, easy to follow, and they have excellent communication. I've always been pleased with the payback and haven't had any issues with my shipments
Chris
Review left Nov 25 2025
Shipment processed Nov 13 2025
Review
Easy process from start to finish. As it was my first time I was impressed with the report and customer service!
Easy process from start to finish. As it was my first time I was impressed with the report and customer service!
Josh
Review left Nov 24 2025
Review
Process was quick and easy. Payment was very fair.
Process was quick and easy. Payment was very fair.
Thanh Nguyen
Review left Nov 24 2025
Shipment processed Nov 22 2025
Review
Easy, fast, and happy with the results! Will definitely get more magic cards and use this service time over time so i can collect happily !
Easy, fast, and happy with the results! Will definitely get more magic cards and use this service time over time so i can collect happily !
Dan
Review left Nov 24 2025
Shipment processed Oct 27 2025
Review
I've had a number of positive experiences so far with Card Conduit, and it continues to be the easiest and fastest way to sell cards. The prices are fair, payment is quick, and communication is friendly. Highly recommended!
I've had a number of positive experiences so far with Card Conduit, and it continues to be the easiest and fastest way to sell cards. The prices are fair, payment is quick, and communication is friendly. Highly recommended!
Justin Schmidt
Review left Nov 23 2025
Review
They were fast, communicated with me in every step of the process, and their pricing was great. It was a painless way to get rid of my cards and get some money in return without having to run to the local game stores.
They were fast, communicated with me in every step of the process, and their pricing was great. It was a painless way to get rid of my cards and get some money in return without having to run to the local game stores.
Jack
Review left Nov 23 2025
Shipment processed Nov 15 2025
Review
I continue to use Card Conduit for all my selling needs. They are quick, efficient, transparent and very fair. I look forward to doing business with them again.
I continue to use Card Conduit for all my selling needs. They are quick, efficient, transparent and very fair. I look forward to doing business with them again.
ANDREW CHANEY
Review left Nov 22 2025
Review
I shipped several different orders in one box and got a fast, detailed recount of each card and condition. Payment was just as quick. I definitely recommend this service
I shipped several different orders in one box and got a fast, detailed recount of each card and condition. Payment was just as quick. I definitely recommend this service
Lantz Wagner
Review left Nov 22 2025
Review
The process was explained well and was straightforward on the website. Nick and team were great communicators regarding shipment and order details. It’s an excellent, convenient service and value, especially if you have a large amount of cards to sell. Highly recommended!
The process was explained well and was straightforward on the website. Nick and team were great communicators regarding shipment and order details. It’s an excellent, convenient service and value, especially if you have a large amount of cards to sell. Highly recommended!
Tomie Lockamy
Review left Nov 22 2025
Review
Everything went perfectly fine. No issues. Fast enough and fair enough price.
Everything went perfectly fine. No issues. Fast enough and fair enough price.
Kessie
Review left Nov 22 2025
Review
I have been collecting magic cards for over 30 years, and letting go of my collection is hard. Since I decided to sell much of it, sending my cards to Card Conduit made the process very easy for me. I used their sorted service, and sent in multiple shipments. Creating and collating shipments was eas
...
Read more
I have been collecting magic cards for over 30 years, and letting go of my collection is hard. Since I decided to sell much of it, sending my cards to Card Conduit made the process very easy for me. I used their sorted service, and sent in multiple shipments. Creating and collating shipments was easy and the turn around time was faster than estimated. I feel that the grading is fair. Nick contacted me about my shipment. Nick was courteous and professional. Would recommend this service as it makes selling my cards very easy.
Austin
Review left Nov 22 2025
Review
Overall it was a great experience. I felt like I got fair enough value for my cards and value being able to send over 2000. I think it's the only sane way to sell tons of cards.
Overall it was a great experience. I felt like I got fair enough value for my cards and value being able to send over 2000. I think it's the only sane way to sell tons of cards.
James
Review left Nov 21 2025
Review
The folks at Card Conduit handled my shipment quickly and easily, with solid communication after having received it and processed it, with no delays. I ended up getting much more than I would have expected from any other buylist service by a very sizeable margin
The folks at Card Conduit handled my shipment quickly and easily, with solid communication after having received it and processed it, with no delays. I ended up getting much more than I would have expected from any other buylist service by a very sizeable margin
Stephen Karambis
Review left Nov 21 2025
Review
High recommend, had a great time. Smooth as it could be
High recommend, had a great time. Smooth as it could be
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every
previous customer to leave a review.
Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page.
We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a
review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).