Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service
(5636)
Field Griffith
Review left Feb 16 2025
Review
Great value for simply ordering cards by a list, very clear instructions. Would use again.
Great value for simply ordering cards by a list, very clear instructions. Would use again.
Andrew
Review left Feb 16 2025
Review
They're a little harsh on grading, but it is what it is. My biggest "wish" is that prices were locked in at shipping, or there was a maximum "price drop" in place. Otherwise, I have used them 10+ times and never had a problem. Once cards arrive, they are processed quickly and payment is made quickly. Thanks as always!
They're a little harsh on grading, but it is what it is. My biggest "wish" is that prices were locked in at shipping, or there was a maximum "price drop" in place. Otherwise, I have used them 10+ times and never had a problem. Once cards arrive, they are processed quickly and payment is made quickly. Thanks as always!
Brad K
Review left Feb 16 2025
Shipment processed Dec 31 2024
Review
This was a very good experience for me. I really enjoyed sifting through my cards and putting a collection together to sell to CC. On their end, the whole process was very smooth, quick, and easy, communication was great, and from start to finish everything was excellent.
This was a very good experience for me. I really enjoyed sifting through my cards and putting a collection together to sell to CC. On their end, the whole process was very smooth, quick, and easy, communication was great, and from start to finish everything was excellent.
Jared Gilpin
Review left Feb 16 2025
Shipment processed Jan 04 2025
Review
The whole process was easy. All I had to do was decide which cards to send in, then after waiting a little while for the cards to be delivered, graded, and valued, I got a sizeable check in the mail.
The whole process was easy. All I had to do was decide which cards to send in, then after waiting a little while for the cards to be delivered, graded, and valued, I got a sizeable check in the mail.
Nathaniel Perhay
Review left Feb 15 2025
Review
I had a great experience with Card Conduit! The process was smooth and hassle-free, from shipping my cards to receiving my payment. Their communication was clear, and they provided updates along the way, which I really appreciated. The turnaround time was reasonable, and the final payout was fair. I
...
Read more
I had a great experience with Card Conduit! The process was smooth and hassle-free, from shipping my cards to receiving my payment. Their communication was clear, and they provided updates along the way, which I really appreciated. The turnaround time was reasonable, and the final payout was fair. I’d definitely recommend their service to anyone looking for a simple and efficient way to sell their cards!
Connor
Review left Feb 15 2025
Review
The process from start to finish was smooth and easy to follow. I appreciate having the option to sort the high value cards myself for a higher payout.
The process from start to finish was smooth and easy to follow. I appreciate having the option to sort the high value cards myself for a higher payout.
Mcloyd
Review left Feb 14 2025
Review
So easy, so simple, so fair. Blew away my expectations. Received a full detailed report along with a breakdown and summary of the big hits.
The way I see it, everyone wins!
The way I see it, everyone wins!
So easy, so simple, so fair. Blew away my expectations. Received a full detailed report along with a breakdown and summary of the big hits.
The way I see it, everyone wins!
The way I see it, everyone wins!
Jack
Review left Feb 14 2025
Review
Easy process, good value, would recommend to anyone wanting to sell bulk cards
Easy process, good value, would recommend to anyone wanting to sell bulk cards
Jeremy Rochlitz
Review left Feb 13 2025
Review
Very easy to use. Fair prices for the cards I sold. Would recommend
Very easy to use. Fair prices for the cards I sold. Would recommend
Eric K.
Review left Feb 13 2025
Review
As always, they are great for sending all the extra value cards I don't need
As always, they are great for sending all the extra value cards I don't need
Garrett
Review left Feb 13 2025
Review
I sold a 100 card angel commander deck to card conduit! I took the cards out of their sleeves and just sent it in the deck box. They processed it and paid me for it--and I got about 50 bucks more than I expected!
This is the second time I have used the service and will continue to use it.
This is the second time I have used the service and will continue to use it.
I sold a 100 card angel commander deck to card conduit! I took the cards out of their sleeves and just sent it in the deck box. They processed it and paid me for it--and I got about 50 bucks more than I expected!
This is the second time I have used the service and will continue to use it.
This is the second time I have used the service and will continue to use it.
Logan Runyan
Review left Feb 13 2025
Review
The service was absolutely incredible and done in a timely manner. I only sent in short of under a thousand cards and got way more than I expected. when doing research to see who would be better to send cards to via card conduit or card Kingdom a lot of people were saying they are very similar and h
...
Read more
The service was absolutely incredible and done in a timely manner. I only sent in short of under a thousand cards and got way more than I expected. when doing research to see who would be better to send cards to via card conduit or card Kingdom a lot of people were saying they are very similar and how much you will get back. however, card Kingdom requires you to actually send in a specific list and ship the cards on a specific order and it's a ginormous hassle whereas card conduit lets you send them in on sorted and they charge a very small fee for it which wasn't even that bad. I 100% will recommend card conduit to any of my friends that have larger collections they just want to sell without the hassle of sorting it at all.
Dustin
Review left Feb 13 2025
Shipment processed Feb 01 2025
Review
In a world without TCG player buylist, cardconduit is fantastic. They overestimated what my return would be to me (10-15%); which is unfortunate but a common experience buylisting cards anywhere. They made it really easy for me to trade in my cards, and will likely be the only service i use for such going forward
In a world without TCG player buylist, cardconduit is fantastic. They overestimated what my return would be to me (10-15%); which is unfortunate but a common experience buylisting cards anywhere. They made it really easy for me to trade in my cards, and will likely be the only service i use for such going forward
Alex
Review left Feb 13 2025
Review
I’ve never sold cards before and this is the best!
I’ve never sold cards before and this is the best!
Dustin S.
Review left Feb 13 2025
Review
The process of selling my cards was very easy. If you have any questions they do an excellent job explaining the process and providing any clarifications you need. Overall I would say their card grading is tough but fair. I will definitely use their service to sell more of my collection in the future.
The process of selling my cards was very easy. If you have any questions they do an excellent job explaining the process and providing any clarifications you need. Overall I would say their card grading is tough but fair. I will definitely use their service to sell more of my collection in the future.
Steve
Review left Feb 12 2025
Review
There are relatively few experiences that one can reasonably call peerless, especially nowadays. Card Conduit's ease of use, professionalism in all aspects (but especially communication and transparency), and prompt turnaround times even on more robustly-sized orders cement their status as one of th
...
Read more
There are relatively few experiences that one can reasonably call peerless, especially nowadays. Card Conduit's ease of use, professionalism in all aspects (but especially communication and transparency), and prompt turnaround times even on more robustly-sized orders cement their status as one of the best buylisting experiences you can find as a consumer - or even, arguably, as a vendor.
While you can absolutely elect to do a little more work (advisable in cases of higher value density collections, or easily sortable ones) to get better returns, the minimum effort required means Card Conduit affords nearly everyone an option to buylist their cards for competitive returns at the simple barrier of entry represented by postage cost, and maybe twenty minutes' time packaging.
Quietly changing the game; less quietly a service I intend to lean on many, many more times.
While you can absolutely elect to do a little more work (advisable in cases of higher value density collections, or easily sortable ones) to get better returns, the minimum effort required means Card Conduit affords nearly everyone an option to buylist their cards for competitive returns at the simple barrier of entry represented by postage cost, and maybe twenty minutes' time packaging.
Quietly changing the game; less quietly a service I intend to lean on many, many more times.
Robert Kowalski
Review left Feb 12 2025
Review
Transparent and detailed steps along the way with several options on how you wanted the team at Card Conduit to service your set. ANY level of trepidation was instantly relieved when I was welcomed to my very own Dashboard the moment I began the process of my sale. Very reasonable fees with the spee
...
Read more
Transparent and detailed steps along the way with several options on how you wanted the team at Card Conduit to service your set. ANY level of trepidation was instantly relieved when I was welcomed to my very own Dashboard the moment I began the process of my sale. Very reasonable fees with the speed and efficiency given to me. Best of all was the personal messages sent along the way until the very end detailing the estimation process and final steps.
Card Conduit isn't on the Mount Rushmore of Card Cataloging and sales, they ARE the Mount Rushmore.
Card Conduit isn't on the Mount Rushmore of Card Cataloging and sales, they ARE the Mount Rushmore.
kjatar
Review left Feb 11 2025
Review
I can't speak to the grading process, since my cards were old and well-loved, to say the least, but they definitely made the process of divesting myself from Magic as easy as could be hoped for. Thanks so much for one last nice trip through memory lane before giving away the cardboard crack.
I can't speak to the grading process, since my cards were old and well-loved, to say the least, but they definitely made the process of divesting myself from Magic as easy as could be hoped for. Thanks so much for one last nice trip through memory lane before giving away the cardboard crack.
Ryan Dugan
Review left Feb 11 2025
Review
Ship and wait, then just takes some time for you to get paid
Ship and wait, then just takes some time for you to get paid
Wes
Review left Feb 11 2025
Shipment processed Feb 08 2025
Review
This is my 3rd shipment to Card conduit. I've sold close to two thousand dollars in cards, and it beats the alternative of 50% credit with my local game store.
This is my 3rd shipment to Card conduit. I've sold close to two thousand dollars in cards, and it beats the alternative of 50% credit with my local game store.
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every
previous customer to leave a review.
Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page.
We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a
review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).