Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service
(5868)
Nate Blankenship
Review left Apr 08 2025
Review
Need I say more than the title? Send cards , get money , buy more cards , repeat. I love this company and their high quality service
Need I say more than the title? Send cards , get money , buy more cards , repeat. I love this company and their high quality service
Lucas Kontes
Review left Apr 08 2025
Review
Card Conduit made selling off my collection super easy! The entire process is smooth & transparent. I would recommend this service over any other way to sell off large amounts of your MTG collection!
Card Conduit made selling off my collection super easy! The entire process is smooth & transparent. I would recommend this service over any other way to sell off large amounts of your MTG collection!
Jeff Nicholas
Review left Apr 07 2025
Review
I've sold cards to Card Conduit several times now and they have always been fair. I've spent time selling on EBay and the fees make it hardly worthwhile. This is the place to sell cards that you want to sell fast. The turnaround time isn't too bad, and the experience is worthwhile!
I've sold cards to Card Conduit several times now and they have always been fair. I've spent time selling on EBay and the fees make it hardly worthwhile. This is the place to sell cards that you want to sell fast. The turnaround time isn't too bad, and the experience is worthwhile!
Ian Snyder
Review left Apr 07 2025
Review
I sent in a sorted shipment of about 200 valuable cards I had been holding on to. The service was easy to use, directions were clear, and the results matched my expectations and even exceeded them. I have used buy lists and even tried selling singles in the past through various online platforms. Car
...
Read more
I sent in a sorted shipment of about 200 valuable cards I had been holding on to. The service was easy to use, directions were clear, and the results matched my expectations and even exceeded them. I have used buy lists and even tried selling singles in the past through various online platforms. Card Conduit was a great compromise between those services, and allowed me to move a large quantity of my cards quickly with peace of mind. Thank you Card Conduit!
LMB
Review left Apr 07 2025
Review
Card Conduit is a spectacular service for processing unwanted cards!
Card Conduit is a spectacular service for processing unwanted cards!
Sam
Review left Apr 07 2025
Review
Everything was explained well and I knew exactly what to expect in terms of price. Everyone was friendly and helpful throughout the process.
Everything was explained well and I knew exactly what to expect in terms of price. Everyone was friendly and helpful throughout the process.
Greg Brooks
Review left Apr 07 2025
Review
I picked curated. sent in about 500 cards. I used DevLens app to get an idea of worth not the best app. took about 2 weeks for full service.
I picked curated. sent in about 500 cards. I used DevLens app to get an idea of worth not the best app. took about 2 weeks for full service.
Ryan Reed
Review left Apr 06 2025
Review
Prompt payment and easy to deal with. I appreciate you guys!
Prompt payment and easy to deal with. I appreciate you guys!
Gabe
Review left Apr 06 2025
Shipment processed Mar 04 2025
Review
I’ve done two curated orders through Card Conduit so far. In my experience they are the most convenient way out there to get value out of larger quantities of cards. Save yourself the headache of listing and selling individual cards on EBay or other places… also expect that they will grade your
...
Read more
I’ve done two curated orders through Card Conduit so far. In my experience they are the most convenient way out there to get value out of larger quantities of cards. Save yourself the headache of listing and selling individual cards on EBay or other places… also expect that they will grade your cards a little lower than you might think, but that is to be expected as they also need to make a profit. Their customer service is lightning fast, too!
Joshua Braegger
Review left Apr 06 2025
Review
I sent some cards to card conduit and it was very easy and didn't have to worry about a thing. Was able to receive payment and felt great overall!!
I sent some cards to card conduit and it was very easy and didn't have to worry about a thing. Was able to receive payment and felt great overall!!
Nathan Grace
Review left Apr 06 2025
Review
It was easy as always to sell my cards. I got more than I expected.
It was easy as always to sell my cards. I got more than I expected.
Todd Warren
Review left Apr 05 2025
Review
It felt simple enough to mail my cards in, the only issue I ran into was debating on whether it was worth it for me to sort the cards myself before shipping them out
It felt simple enough to mail my cards in, the only issue I ran into was debating on whether it was worth it for me to sort the cards myself before shipping them out
Eli
Review left Apr 05 2025
Review
This is my second time using card conduit and once again they have given me an easy, quick, simple experience of sending in my cards and receiving assessment and payment for them. Really great service.
This is my second time using card conduit and once again they have given me an easy, quick, simple experience of sending in my cards and receiving assessment and payment for them. Really great service.
TG
Review left Apr 05 2025
Shipment processed Mar 01 2025
Review
Done this a few times and the speed and quality is always appreciated.
Done this a few times and the speed and quality is always appreciated.
Georgie The Magic Man
Review left Apr 04 2025
Shipment processed Apr 04 2025
$2,749.29
payout, $144.70
fees
Review
Thank you very much, Card Conduit! This was a very fair transaction, just like the last one.
Thank you very much, Card Conduit! This was a very fair transaction, just like the last one.
Dustyn Pruitt
Review left Apr 04 2025
Shipment processed Apr 04 2025
Review
I disagree with some quality ratings but everything went well.
I disagree with some quality ratings but everything went well.
Steven Williams
Review left Apr 04 2025
Review
If you have a large collection to sell, this is the service to use. The time I saved by being able to send in over 1,300 cards and not needing to sort them was huge. The process is very transparent and has step by step instructions. I highly recommend this to anyone with a large collection they are trying to move.
If you have a large collection to sell, this is the service to use. The time I saved by being able to send in over 1,300 cards and not needing to sort them was huge. The process is very transparent and has step by step instructions. I highly recommend this to anyone with a large collection they are trying to move.
Joe R
Review left Apr 04 2025
Review
This was my second time using this awesome service. The team is always communicative and transparent about what to do and at what point of the process they are at. I was nervous to participate initially, but after an excellent first AND second experience, I can confidently say this will be my go to
...
Read more
This was my second time using this awesome service. The team is always communicative and transparent about what to do and at what point of the process they are at. I was nervous to participate initially, but after an excellent first AND second experience, I can confidently say this will be my go to avenue to shed some layers of my never ending stacks of cards. Thank you CardConduit!
Creighton
Review left Apr 04 2025
Shipment processed Mar 26 2025
Review
Exactly as advertised...easy to use and fair payments, delivered fast...everything you want in a card trade
Exactly as advertised...easy to use and fair payments, delivered fast...everything you want in a card trade
Tyler Redding
Review left Apr 04 2025
Review
The process was fairly simple and fast. Stayed in contact throughout each step of the process.
I was a bit bummed at the card value total. I scanned the collection beforehand to get an idea of what it was worth and it came out quite a bit lower than I anticipated.
Overall, I'd recommend Card Conduit to anyone looking to sell in a timely manner.
I was a bit bummed at the card value total. I scanned the collection beforehand to get an idea of what it was worth and it came out quite a bit lower than I anticipated.
Overall, I'd recommend Card Conduit to anyone looking to sell in a timely manner.
The process was fairly simple and fast. Stayed in contact throughout each step of the process.
I was a bit bummed at the card value total. I scanned the collection beforehand to get an idea of what it was worth and it came out quite a bit lower than I anticipated.
Overall, I'd recommend Card Conduit to anyone looking to sell in a timely manner.
I was a bit bummed at the card value total. I scanned the collection beforehand to get an idea of what it was worth and it came out quite a bit lower than I anticipated.
Overall, I'd recommend Card Conduit to anyone looking to sell in a timely manner.
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every
previous customer to leave a review.
Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page.
We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a
review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).