Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service
(5633)
Henry Pile
Review left Jun 05 2025
Shipment processed May 22 2025
Review
Card Conduit’s transparent, highly communicative process for card evaluation and payment make this the best process for downsizing my collection. Shipping was easy and payment was fast. I’m excited that another play can build a better collection now that my cards are available for them to purchase.
Card Conduit’s transparent, highly communicative process for card evaluation and payment make this the best process for downsizing my collection. Shipping was easy and payment was fast. I’m excited that another play can build a better collection now that my cards are available for them to purchase.
Derek Brooks
Review left Jun 04 2025
Review
I've only used card conduit one time so far but definitely plan on using again. I used their sorted service for my first time as I wanted to get the most out of my cards as I could. The process wasn't to bad honestly. I had more issues with putting insurance on my package through my local shipping c
...
Read more
I've only used card conduit one time so far but definitely plan on using again. I used their sorted service for my first time as I wanted to get the most out of my cards as I could. The process wasn't to bad honestly. I had more issues with putting insurance on my package through my local shipping center (story for another time, not a problem with card conduit) than I did going through the process with card conduit. I really liked how they have a ongoing status about where you are at in the process. I shipped about $1100k worth of cards (if they were all near mint) which was a mix of near mint and lightly played and maybe a few heavy played. After their review process I ended up getting back just under $1000 (which is about what I guessed it would be). Their fees for this process was really considerable ( about $20) which i liked. During the process they give you detailed list of how they graded your cards and what the value was, as well as some other neat stats on the cards you had submitted, which i really liked as well. I had some questions regarding a few cards that scored lower than I would have hoped. They reached out to me in regards to my concerns and even sent me details and pictures of why they were graded the way they were. I will be using them again in the future except i plan on using their other service to send in some bulk. Sorry for the long review. I would recommend anyone thinking about it to give it a shot.
Sheldon
Review left Jun 04 2025
Review
I feel like I got more than if I had sold myself on eBay, certainly less hassle. For cards that I had sitting around it was an easy decision and if I end up with more would use the service again!
I feel like I got more than if I had sold myself on eBay, certainly less hassle. For cards that I had sitting around it was an easy decision and if I end up with more would use the service again!
Thomas Morrison
Review left Jun 04 2025
Review
Process was easy, transparent and the Card Conduit team was extremely communicative. Would recommend to anyone looking to sell their Magic cards.
Process was easy, transparent and the Card Conduit team was extremely communicative. Would recommend to anyone looking to sell their Magic cards.
Don H
Review left Jun 04 2025
Review
Solid communication. Good turn around time. Online system is very straight forward and easy to use. Happy with this service.
Solid communication. Good turn around time. Online system is very straight forward and easy to use. Happy with this service.
Arin D
Review left Jun 04 2025
Review
Card Conduit makes selling cards incredibly simple. The process was smooth and easy to understand, and I really appreciated the explanations they provide of their process and why they ask for certain things (e.g. why they charge for sleeved cards & how to properly ship your cards). I was recommended
...
Read more
Card Conduit makes selling cards incredibly simple. The process was smooth and easy to understand, and I really appreciated the explanations they provide of their process and why they ask for certain things (e.g. why they charge for sleeved cards & how to properly ship your cards). I was recommended Card Conduit by a friend and I would definitely pass that recommendation on to anyone else interested in selling cards.
Chris Z
Review left Jun 03 2025
Review
Service was exactly as described. Timing was great. Communication was great. Helped me clear 15 years of mtg. Beats checking the cost of each card and listing it myself by farrrrrr
Service was exactly as described. Timing was great. Communication was great. Helped me clear 15 years of mtg. Beats checking the cost of each card and listing it myself by farrrrrr
Max B
Review left Jun 03 2025
Review
Card Conduit made it so easy - being able to list my collection from Moxfield directly made everything easier. Quick turnaround and great communication. I’ll definitely be using Card Conduit again!
Card Conduit made it so easy - being able to list my collection from Moxfield directly made everything easier. Quick turnaround and great communication. I’ll definitely be using Card Conduit again!
Devin A Gilbert
Review left Jun 02 2025
Review
They reviewed my cards fast, gave me a decent price and all I had to do was take every card out of the sleeves, put them in a box and ship it.
They reviewed my cards fast, gave me a decent price and all I had to do was take every card out of the sleeves, put them in a box and ship it.
Nick Burger
Review left Jun 01 2025
Review
Payout was low as expected, but response was fast, detailed, and accurate for my bulk collection.
Payout was low as expected, but response was fast, detailed, and accurate for my bulk collection.
Nick Burger
Review left Jun 01 2025
Review
great experience as always! fast, convenient, and accurate.
great experience as always! fast, convenient, and accurate.
JJ
Review left Jun 01 2025
Review
Some of the cards labeled as LP went straight from a booster to the binder and then were shipped and never played with. So i wonder if its a wizards problem. the secret lair stuff i never even touched.
Some of the cards labeled as LP went straight from a booster to the binder and then were shipped and never played with. So i wonder if its a wizards problem. the secret lair stuff i never even touched.
Kaloyan Zamfirov
Review left May 31 2025
Review
The process was simple and not too difficult if you know how to mess with your card counting app (mtg for me).
The process was simple and not too difficult if you know how to mess with your card counting app (mtg for me).
Ben
Review left May 31 2025
Review
Easy process, fair prices, overall great experience. Would recommend.
Easy process, fair prices, overall great experience. Would recommend.
Neil Q.
Review left May 31 2025
Review
I'm very happy with the overall experience. I did the Curated option and the process was easy from start to finish. It saved me a lot of time selling my collection in one go and receiving good pricing.
I'm very happy with the overall experience. I did the Curated option and the process was easy from start to finish. It saved me a lot of time selling my collection in one go and receiving good pricing.
Jon Derek Wright
Review left May 30 2025
Shipment processed May 21 2025
Review
I am selling a competitive Magic the Gathering collection, so most of the cards are in played condition from years of tourneys. Card Conduit allows me to sell the collection without worrying or arguing about condition and realize the maximum possible value.
Card Conduit is a great professional service.
Card Conduit is a great professional service.
I am selling a competitive Magic the Gathering collection, so most of the cards are in played condition from years of tourneys. Card Conduit allows me to sell the collection without worrying or arguing about condition and realize the maximum possible value.
Card Conduit is a great professional service.
Card Conduit is a great professional service.
Nate
Review left May 30 2025
Shipment processed May 22 2025
Review
Good return on time investment. Received payment promptly.
Good return on time investment. Received payment promptly.
Cassandra
Review left May 30 2025
Shipment processed May 22 2025
$488.22
payout, $25.70
fees
Review
The whole process was easy and fairly quick. I actually got more for the cards I sent in than I was expecting to. Nick’s communication was great and I’ll definitely be selling to Card Conduit again.
The whole process was easy and fairly quick. I actually got more for the cards I sent in than I was expecting to. Nick’s communication was great and I’ll definitely be selling to Card Conduit again.
Daniel Bretado
Review left May 30 2025
Review
Thank you for helping me with processing my cards. I'll miss them but they will be in good hands. Sorry I categorized some of my cards incorrectly. I'll be more careful next time.
Thank you for helping me with processing my cards. I'll miss them but they will be in good hands. Sorry I categorized some of my cards incorrectly. I'll be more careful next time.
Michael A
Review left May 29 2025
Review
I love this service so much and have done several submissions. I like the status updates as it’s processed. Not having to sort cards alphabetically is a life saver. Thanks Card Conduit! <3
I love this service so much and have done several submissions. I like the status updates as it’s processed. Not having to sort cards alphabetically is a life saver. Thanks Card Conduit! <3
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every
previous customer to leave a review.
Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page.
We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a
review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).