Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service
JC
Review left Mar 07 2026
Business at its Finest
Review
I sent in cards that looked to be paying out at around $900 if all were NM. However, by the time the cards arrived, the max payout was a good deal lower - around $850. They were upfront about card prices not locking in until they receive the cards, and though it did not work in my favor this time, I am sure it actually benefits sellers at times.
My cards were mostly pack fresh or very nearly pack fresh. However, I received a spread of about 55% NM, 25% LP, and 20% HP. I was understandably concerned and put my sale on hold and asked for clarification. Though the automated outreach did not work, I eventually connected with support and received a full image breakdown of all cards I flagged.
After reviewing their photos I actually agree with most of their grade assessments. Honestly, they often erred on the side of caution and gave me a better grade than the card warranted. We discussed two cards and I negotiated a slightly better payout. One card I wanted returned because their offer price was too low for me. They returned that free of charge, and I am certain they would have done the same with the entire shipment if I had requested it.
Card Conduit is a business and they likely sell the cards they receive to other buyers and vendors. They will have built up trust with these clients that a NM card is always 100% NM. That is almost certainly why they are so strict on conditions. Would I have liked to receive $900 for my cards. Heck yea. Am I happy with $700? Eh, not really. But at the end of the day, it was my choice alone to take the deal.
They paid me out at around 70% of market value in cash (even when factoring in their processing fee and my shipping costs). You will not find anywhere else willing to do this while simultaneously providing such good customer service. If you find someone doing it better, then use them. But when you don't, no worries. You can always come back and use Card Conduit with full confidence.
My cards were mostly pack fresh or very nearly pack fresh. However, I received a spread of about 55% NM, 25% LP, and 20% HP. I was understandably concerned and put my sale on hold and asked for clarification. Though the automated outreach did not work, I eventually connected with support and received a full image breakdown of all cards I flagged.
After reviewing their photos I actually agree with most of their grade assessments. Honestly, they often erred on the side of caution and gave me a better grade than the card warranted. We discussed two cards and I negotiated a slightly better payout. One card I wanted returned because their offer price was too low for me. They returned that free of charge, and I am certain they would have done the same with the entire shipment if I had requested it.
Card Conduit is a business and they likely sell the cards they receive to other buyers and vendors. They will have built up trust with these clients that a NM card is always 100% NM. That is almost certainly why they are so strict on conditions. Would I have liked to receive $900 for my cards. Heck yea. Am I happy with $700? Eh, not really. But at the end of the day, it was my choice alone to take the deal.
They paid me out at around 70% of market value in cash (even when factoring in their processing fee and my shipping costs). You will not find anywhere else willing to do this while simultaneously providing such good customer service. If you find someone doing it better, then use them. But when you don't, no worries. You can always come back and use Card Conduit with full confidence.
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every
previous customer to leave a review.
Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page.
We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a
review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).