Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service
Eulalio Pena Reyna
Review left Oct 17 2022
Review
The process was very easy. You guys give great value for the cards, usually ranging from 50-90% of the price of what tcg sells cards for, sometimes even higher which is surprising. I would have given 5 stars and deservedly so, but I had sent a foreign Aetherflux reservoir which I assumed and was tol
...
Read more
The process was very easy. You guys give great value for the cards, usually ranging from 50-90% of the price of what tcg sells cards for, sometimes even higher which is surprising. I would have given 5 stars and deservedly so, but I had sent a foreign Aetherflux reservoir which I assumed and was told would have been worth something, I was not expecting 3 cents for it. Apart from that I haven't had any negative experiences. This is my first time selling so if there's one thing I've learned and adjusted, it's the expectations of my card conditions and how much value I'm actually getting. I looked up each card and sent them with the hopes that they were all worth over a dollar but there were several cards I didn't receive a dollar for surprisingly. But like I said this is my first time selling. I will continue to use you guys in the future and will be sending you guys more cards soon! Thanks
Kevin W
Review left Oct 17 2022
Review
Easy and efficient process to selling cards. Fair value when compared to LGS. Would recommend to anyone.
Easy and efficient process to selling cards. Fair value when compared to LGS. Would recommend to anyone.
Rob Holtz
Review left Oct 17 2022
Shipment processed Oct 06 2022
Review
Much easier and worthwhile than other buy lists. Highly recommended. I don't like keeping a large collection. Card Conduit made it easy and worth my while to turn the cards that I wasn't playing with into the best buy list price around. If I ever accrue more valuable cards that I don't end up using,
...
Read more
Much easier and worthwhile than other buy lists. Highly recommended. I don't like keeping a large collection. Card Conduit made it easy and worth my while to turn the cards that I wasn't playing with into the best buy list price around. If I ever accrue more valuable cards that I don't end up using, I will absolutely come back to Card Conduit for their services. They truly are the easiest way to sell your Magic cards!
Aaron
Review left Oct 17 2022
Review
They took care of everything for me and it was a seamless transaction. I sent a lot of cards in so it took awhile but they gave me updates and kept in contact so I wasn't out of the loop waiting for an answer.
They took care of everything for me and it was a seamless transaction. I sent a lot of cards in so it took awhile but they gave me updates and kept in contact so I wasn't out of the loop waiting for an answer.
Joe U
Review left Oct 17 2022
Review
The process was simple, just sent in a box of my unused cards and CardConduit did the rest. Everything was well explained and quick, and they kept me informed every step of the way. I will definitely be using them in the future, and highly recommend using their services!
The process was simple, just sent in a box of my unused cards and CardConduit did the rest. Everything was well explained and quick, and they kept me informed every step of the way. I will definitely be using them in the future, and highly recommend using their services!
Zachary Lincoln
Review left Oct 17 2022
Review
The overall process was great! I think one thing that happens with Magic players is that they value their cards more than they should be, so even with a promotional code, I received less for my cards than I thought was appropriate for condition. The process for payment, despite sending a small shipm
...
Read more
The overall process was great! I think one thing that happens with Magic players is that they value their cards more than they should be, so even with a promotional code, I received less for my cards than I thought was appropriate for condition. The process for payment, despite sending a small shipment of 9 cards, in an organized fashion, was a bit longer than I anticipated. All that to say their fees were incredibly fair and I had an overall positive experience. I think with the cost of shipping, sending them large collections may lose quite a bit of value, but for small collections I think it's really smooth.
Tyler Higgins
Review left Oct 16 2022
Review
Paid me even more than I expected to get for a bunch of stuff just taking up space in my collection boxes. Sent them stuff no one around me would trade for, and most convention buyers won't waster their time on bulk rare's. Turned my trash into a enough cash to buy a collector's booster box!
Paid me even more than I expected to get for a bunch of stuff just taking up space in my collection boxes. Sent them stuff no one around me would trade for, and most convention buyers won't waster their time on bulk rare's. Turned my trash into a enough cash to buy a collector's booster box!
RT
Review left Oct 16 2022
Shipment processed Sep 20 2022
Review
Easiest card sale of my life. Got a pretty good amount for the cards. Estimated value was 410 before quality. Took home $350.
Easiest card sale of my life. Got a pretty good amount for the cards. Estimated value was 410 before quality. Took home $350.
James zeisler
Review left Oct 16 2022
Review
For me, who had amassed a lot of MTG cards that were collecting dust, I was happy to find a service that I could ship the entire collection to. Their process is as transparent as can be and their customer service is outstanding. They answered all of my questions before, during, and after the process
For me, who had amassed a lot of MTG cards that were collecting dust, I was happy to find a service that I could ship the entire collection to. Their process is as transparent as can be and their customer service is outstanding. They answered all of my questions before, during, and after the process
Benjamin Farnsworth
Review left Oct 16 2022
Review
The process was pretty simple and easy. I only have a couple of gripes. One was that it took a while for everything to be processed and I didn't send in more than 100 cards. Another was that the grading system felt rather harsh and since I couldn't get returns I couldn't turn down an offer on a coup
...
Read more
The process was pretty simple and easy. I only have a couple of gripes. One was that it took a while for everything to be processed and I didn't send in more than 100 cards. Another was that the grading system felt rather harsh and since I couldn't get returns I couldn't turn down an offer on a couple of cards. It may have been my fault, but given what I got for some of my higher value cards, I would rather have the card. That being said, I am still planning on sifting through my bulk commons and uncommons to see if it's worth sending. Now the good part was that I did receive a full breakdown of each card and I did receive the exact amount that they said I would. Even if it took longer than expected. And it was more than I would have received from my LGS. Though with my LGS I was able to deny an offer and keep my card. Highly recommended for cards valued between $1 and $5, but higher than that sell on ebay or TCG Player.
Card Conduit Team
Replied Oct 17 2022
We appreciate you taking the time to review your experience. We just wanted to provide some additional information regarding a few of the items you mentioned.
(1) On timing, we do our best be as up front about this as possible. Unfortunately, due to how our internal systems are set up, the size of the shipments typically won’t result in them being completed before expected (though very large shipments will at times be pushed back). If there is a particular urgency for a shipment/situation, we do our best to try to prioritize a shipment to accommodate the customer.
(2) Regarding returns, we do allow customers to request that their shipment be held for review so they can review/approve results before things are finalized. It sounds like this option would have worked well for you, and allowed you to get more information on particular cards (often customers request pictures/additional explanations of grading) and/or potentially have those particular cards returned.
(1) On timing, we do our best be as up front about this as possible. Unfortunately, due to how our internal systems are set up, the size of the shipments typically won’t result in them being completed before expected (though very large shipments will at times be pushed back). If there is a particular urgency for a shipment/situation, we do our best to try to prioritize a shipment to accommodate the customer.
(2) Regarding returns, we do allow customers to request that their shipment be held for review so they can review/approve results before things are finalized. It sounds like this option would have worked well for you, and allowed you to get more information on particular cards (often customers request pictures/additional explanations of grading) and/or potentially have those particular cards returned.
We appreciate you taking the time to review your experience. We just wanted to provide some additional information regarding a few of the items you mentioned.
(1) On timing, we do our best be as up front about this as possible. Unfortunately, due to how our internal systems are set up, the size of the shipments typically won’t result in them being completed before expected (though very large shipments will at times be pushed back). If there is a particular urgency for a shipment/situation, we do our best to try to prioritize a shipment to accommodate the customer.
(2) Regarding returns, we do allow customers to request that their shipment be held for review so they can review/approve results before things are finalized. It sounds like this option would have worked well for you, and allowed you to get more information on particular cards (often customers request pictures/additional explanations of grading) and/or potentially have those particular cards returned.
(1) On timing, we do our best be as up front about this as possible. Unfortunately, due to how our internal systems are set up, the size of the shipments typically won’t result in them being completed before expected (though very large shipments will at times be pushed back). If there is a particular urgency for a shipment/situation, we do our best to try to prioritize a shipment to accommodate the customer.
(2) Regarding returns, we do allow customers to request that their shipment be held for review so they can review/approve results before things are finalized. It sounds like this option would have worked well for you, and allowed you to get more information on particular cards (often customers request pictures/additional explanations of grading) and/or potentially have those particular cards returned.
Chase Johnson
Review left Oct 16 2022
Shipment processed Oct 05 2022
Review
I will definitely be using this service in the future. Very fast and professional. You can tell these folks care about the service they provide!
I will definitely be using this service in the future. Very fast and professional. You can tell these folks care about the service they provide!
Josh Harding
Review left Oct 16 2022
Shipment processed Oct 04 2022
Review
This company has their act together! They make the hassle of getting value from old card collections minimal. I highly recommend their services to anyone looking to quickly liquidate their collection.
This company has their act together! They make the hassle of getting value from old card collections minimal. I highly recommend their services to anyone looking to quickly liquidate their collection.
Tim James Schultz
Review left Oct 15 2022
Review
I sent my cards in and the whole process took only about two weeks from when the package was delivered to receiving payment.
I sent my cards in and the whole process took only about two weeks from when the package was delivered to receiving payment.
Michael Jardine
Review left Oct 14 2022
Review
Overall pretty good, the UI for sorting could be a bit better I think. Disappointed that my more valuable cards were downgraded to lp but that's really more the fault of wizards foiling process. This is basically the same process as selling to any individual buyer like cardkingdom- at the cost of
...
Read more
Overall pretty good, the UI for sorting could be a bit better I think. Disappointed that my more valuable cards were downgraded to lp but that's really more the fault of wizards foiling process. This is basically the same process as selling to any individual buyer like cardkingdom- at the cost of slightly more time between shipment and payment you get more money
Sabrina Marshall
Review left Oct 14 2022
Shipment processed Sep 10 2022
Review
I appreciate the detailed breakdown of my cards' value and that there is clear commumication every step of the process.
I appreciate the detailed breakdown of my cards' value and that there is clear commumication every step of the process.
Kristian
Review left Oct 14 2022
Review
Doing my reviews across multiple shipments I've done. Always will recommend card conduit
Doing my reviews across multiple shipments I've done. Always will recommend card conduit
Kristian
Review left Oct 14 2022
Review
Always am a fan of using card conduit. Brilliant service as always
Always am a fan of using card conduit. Brilliant service as always
Luis C.
Review left Oct 14 2022
Review
Based on previous reviews I was worried these guys would be extremely strict when it comes to card grading, not the case. Some cards I've played with for years graded much higher than i thought they would so i was surprised with the total payout.
Also, HANDS DOWN the best customer service of any o ... Read more
Also, HANDS DOWN the best customer service of any o ... Read more
Based on previous reviews I was worried these guys would be extremely strict when it comes to card grading, not the case. Some cards I've played with for years graded much higher than i thought they would so i was surprised with the total payout.
Also, HANDS DOWN the best customer service of any online company ive used, extremely polite informative and will update u with each step of your order. Looking forward to sending these guys my cards again , was a no hassle experience !
Also, HANDS DOWN the best customer service of any online company ive used, extremely polite informative and will update u with each step of your order. Looking forward to sending these guys my cards again , was a no hassle experience !
Adam Adrian
Review left Oct 14 2022
Review
Easiest process, amazing value, always will use card conduit for future orders. TY!!!
Easiest process, amazing value, always will use card conduit for future orders. TY!!!
Sebastian
Review left Oct 13 2022
Shipment processed Sep 20 2022
$63.05
payout, $1.29
fees
Review
Quite happy with the valuation of my shipment and the communicative customer support. Looking forward to more transactions in the future!
Quite happy with the valuation of my shipment and the communicative customer support. Looking forward to more transactions in the future!
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every
previous customer to leave a review.
Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page.
We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a
review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).