Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service
(5633)
Drake Beckner
Review left Jun 26 2025
Review
Did a collection estimate, followed packing instructions, and shipped off for a curated service. A week later a great offer was deposited into my bank account. Definitely recommend Card Conduit!
Did a collection estimate, followed packing instructions, and shipped off for a curated service. A week later a great offer was deposited into my bank account. Definitely recommend Card Conduit!
Austin Smith
Review left Jun 25 2025
Review
I recently used card conduit for the first time and sold them over 1000+ of my cards I've been collecting over the past 10 or so years of playing the game. All I had to do for my selected shipment was sort my cards and send them in and they did the rest! Received my payment shortly thereafter and le
...
Read more
I recently used card conduit for the first time and sold them over 1000+ of my cards I've been collecting over the past 10 or so years of playing the game. All I had to do for my selected shipment was sort my cards and send them in and they did the rest! Received my payment shortly thereafter and left very satisfied! Would definitely recommend to anyone looking to offload their cards!
Alex
Review left Jun 24 2025
Review
Sent in a multiple thousand dollar shipment. It was promptly processed and I was paid quickly and fairly. Overall took about 10 days from dropping off the package at USPS to money clearing in ACH and hitting my account. Would use again
Sent in a multiple thousand dollar shipment. It was promptly processed and I was paid quickly and fairly. Overall took about 10 days from dropping off the package at USPS to money clearing in ACH and hitting my account. Would use again
Patrick laRue
Review left Jun 24 2025
Review
Fast and easy and price is ok not may others that do it.
Fast and easy and price is ok not may others that do it.
diego
Review left Jun 23 2025
Review
process was easy and reached out to me once they received my shipment and promptly communicated any concerns by a nice receiving team. i recommend this service. i felt i got the appropriate valuation on my shipment and felt their fees were justifiable
process was easy and reached out to me once they received my shipment and promptly communicated any concerns by a nice receiving team. i recommend this service. i felt i got the appropriate valuation on my shipment and felt their fees were justifiable
Edgar
Review left Jun 23 2025
Review
It was a relatively simple process and easy to get things done, will hope to use more of this service
It was a relatively simple process and easy to get things done, will hope to use more of this service
Turk Moore
Review left Jun 23 2025
Review
I sent over bulk cards with a few rare things. (over 2000 cards) They gave me a fair price. I was updated all along the way.
I sent over bulk cards with a few rare things. (over 2000 cards) They gave me a fair price. I was updated all along the way.
James
Review left Jun 23 2025
Review
The process was incredibly fast and as simple as advertised. Nathaniel was super responsive and answered all questions I had. Shipping was easy as I followed the instructions provided on the website with no issues at all. I was very happy with the appraisal as well. I think there is always a hesitat
...
Read more
The process was incredibly fast and as simple as advertised. Nathaniel was super responsive and answered all questions I had. Shipping was easy as I followed the instructions provided on the website with no issues at all. I was very happy with the appraisal as well. I think there is always a hesitation or power imbalance when getting cards graded, but I felt like the card conduit team was very fair.
If you are considering a quick and convenient method of selling your cards, I definitely recommend card conduit.
If you are considering a quick and convenient method of selling your cards, I definitely recommend card conduit.
Chris
Review left Jun 23 2025
Shipment processed Jun 13 2025
Review
great service, easy to use! Helped me clear out some older, unused cards without hassle from my collection
great service, easy to use! Helped me clear out some older, unused cards without hassle from my collection
Jess
Review left Jun 22 2025
Review
I decided to trade in the majority of my higher-value cards. I knew I didn't want to individually sell them because it would be more hassle than I'd like. Local card shops (at least where I'm at) tend to low-ball. Card Conduit is a great in-between option. I chose to do the sorted service and looked
...
Read more
I decided to trade in the majority of my higher-value cards. I knew I didn't want to individually sell them because it would be more hassle than I'd like. Local card shops (at least where I'm at) tend to low-ball. Card Conduit is a great in-between option. I chose to do the sorted service and looked up a YouTube tutorial to be extra cautious. The process was very simple. It took less than a week to get a payment after Card Conduit received my package. I would definitely recommend it to a friend if I knew they were looking to sell cards.
Michael L
Review left Jun 22 2025
Review
I sent the shipment, and it took a while to get processed but they also changed my order to the correct type and saved me a few percentage per card. Great service!
I sent the shipment, and it took a while to get processed but they also changed my order to the correct type and saved me a few percentage per card. Great service!
Scott
Review left Jun 22 2025
Review
Process was easy, wasn't sure what to expect due to first time using. The report i got was pretty impressive but I felt like the values I got for my cards were lower than expected. I sent around 125 cards that had roughly $100 in value (per delivers lens app) I understand the commons are basicall
...
Read more
Process was easy, wasn't sure what to expect due to first time using. The report i got was pretty impressive but I felt like the values I got for my cards were lower than expected. I sent around 125 cards that had roughly $100 in value (per delivers lens app) I understand the commons are basically worthless to you guys i sent some anyhow to just see how they showed up on your final report, but I had some $2, $3, and $5 cards again to just see how everything panned out. Basically I got around $30 bucks for what I sent and it cost me like $10 to ship with tracking so in the end I got $20 for my $100 worth of cards. I know you all have to make money on the process so im not dogging you on any of it..... im just saying I probably won't be sending anything else your way. Good luck
phil
Review left Jun 20 2025
Review
smooth and efficient as always. solid outlet for moving non bulk
smooth and efficient as always. solid outlet for moving non bulk
R.J.
Review left Jun 20 2025
Shipment processed Jun 07 2025
Review
The process was well explained and the step by step manner of actions was easy to understand and commplete. Overalll i would highly recommend this company to others looking to sell their Magic The Gathering cards.
The process was well explained and the step by step manner of actions was easy to understand and commplete. Overalll i would highly recommend this company to others looking to sell their Magic The Gathering cards.
Nate Rumrill
Review left Jun 20 2025
Review
We were able to move a large portion of cards that weren't moving quickly online.
We were able to move a large portion of cards that weren't moving quickly online.
Nick
Review left Jun 19 2025
Review
Process was very easy and smooth -- I had already organized my cards so used that option. The guys/girls were highly responsive, even so much as to respond after hours and on weekends. They were transparent and I would absolutely recommend using them and will likely do so again in the future. They are the best and fastest way to sell cards.
Process was very easy and smooth -- I had already organized my cards so used that option. The guys/girls were highly responsive, even so much as to respond after hours and on weekends. They were transparent and I would absolutely recommend using them and will likely do so again in the future. They are the best and fastest way to sell cards.
Heather
Review left Jun 19 2025
Review
We recently sent in my son’s Magic: The Gathering cards to Card Conduit, and the entire process was smooth and professional from start to finish. They sorted, priced, and paid out faster than we expected—and the final payout was very fair, even generous. It saved us the hassle of trying to sell
...
Read more
We recently sent in my son’s Magic: The Gathering cards to Card Conduit, and the entire process was smooth and professional from start to finish. They sorted, priced, and paid out faster than we expected—and the final payout was very fair, even generous. It saved us the hassle of trying to sell everything individually, and the transparency throughout the process gave us peace of mind. Excellent service all around. We’ll definitely use them again and recommend them to anyone looking to sell their MTG cards!
Julie
Review left Jun 19 2025
Review
Easy process, I did two different shipments and was happy with the payout I received. Much easier to buylisting through my LGS.
Easy process, I did two different shipments and was happy with the payout I received. Much easier to buylisting through my LGS.
Max Luna
Review left Jun 19 2025
Review
This was the biggest payout and I have to agree with the prices I see on the reports. Best service for Magic cards.
This was the biggest payout and I have to agree with the prices I see on the reports. Best service for Magic cards.
Jen
Review left Jun 18 2025
Shipment processed Jun 07 2025
Review
They were timely helpful and direct, I look forward to working with them again.
They were timely helpful and direct, I look forward to working with them again.
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every
previous customer to leave a review.
Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page.
We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a
review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).