Chat with us

Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service

(3150)
Matthew Geary
Review left Nov 01 2023
Shipment processed Oct 05 2023
$42.28 payout, $19.89 fees

Review

amazing experience. loved the in depth analysis of the cards I had and felt like I got nice value for the remnants of my collection. I wish I could find a service like this for my comics and sports cards!
amazing experience. loved the in depth analysis of the cards I had and felt like I got nice value for the remnants of my collection. I wish I could find a service like this for my comics and sports cards!
Sean
Review left Nov 01 2023
Shipment processed Oct 28 2023
$355.08 payout, $16.73 fees

Review

I just want to add that getting an unprompted support ticket discussing my order was awesome. It turned into a learning experience for me about quality grading and card storage. Kudos to Nick, he really went above and beyond for me.
I just want to add that getting an unprompted support ticket discussing my order was awesome. It turned into a learning experience for me about quality grading and card storage. Kudos to Nick, he really went above and beyond for me.
Eric
Review left Oct 31 2023
Shipment processed Sep 27 2023

Review

Card Conduit kept excellent communitication processes.
Card Conduit kept excellent communitication processes.
Anne G.
Review left Oct 31 2023
Shipment processed Sep 28 2023
$447.45 payout, $95.61 fees

Review

Process was super easy. Great value and timing was impeccable. Third time working with Card Conduit and every time was fast and easy. Thank you!!
Process was super easy. Great value and timing was impeccable. Third time working with Card Conduit and every time was fast and easy. Thank you!!
Eric E
Review left Oct 31 2023
Shipment processed Oct 23 2023
$47.33 payout, $0.97 fees

Review

As long as you understand how this service works and know what to expect, you should be very satisfied with your payouts. This an excellent way to get some buylist money for your collection.
As long as you understand how this service works and know what to expect, you should be very satisfied with your payouts. This an excellent way to get some buylist money for your collection.
Leo
Review left Oct 31 2023
Shipment processed Oct 28 2023
$2,667.35 payout, $125.67 fees

Review

Shipping a ton of cards was stressful, but once my shipment was on its way, the process was great. The website kept me updated and the staff were communicative, fair and I got paid!
Shipping a ton of cards was stressful, but once my shipment was on its way, the process was great. The website kept me updated and the staff were communicative, fair and I got paid!
Joe Jemsek - 90's MTG Player
Review left Oct 31 2023
Shipment processed Oct 27 2023
$1,178.19 payout, $24.04 fees

Review

I sold 2 shipments of roughly 50 -60 cards of Revised and Dark MTG. I was surprised when the 1st shipment paid roughly 70% of the estimate, I though card were in near perfect shape, corners were crisp, minimal scuffing, and had been sorted in climate control room for nearly 30 years. CC showed me wh ... Read more
I sold 2 shipments of roughly 50 -60 cards of Revised and Dark MTG. I was surprised when the 1st shipment paid roughly 70% of the estimate, I though card were in near perfect shape, corners were crisp, minimal scuffing, and had been sorted in climate control room for nearly 30 years. CC showed me where the binders rings had marked cards and I understood where the value was lost. Before sending the second shipment I made sure the most valuable cards(dual lands) had no binder marks, but most were still marked as MP. I'm glad I kept the most valuable Dual Lands from my collection. I was disappointed with overall payments, but certainly less effort than selling individually. Would recommend, but have realistic expectations.
David Holt
Review left Oct 30 2023
Shipment processed Oct 19 2023
$1,607.17 payout, $183.92 fees

Review

Holy crap was this great!
I'm getting out of the hobby since it's not bringing joy and I have no time.
I sold some of my collection to a very nice LGS, the bulk and a lot of mid-tier I send to CC.
I should have skipped the LGS.
CC gave me a better percentage for less time and work.
In fact, one ... Read more
Holy crap was this great!
I'm getting out of the hobby since it's not bringing joy and I have no time.
I sold some of my collection to a very nice LGS, the bulk and a lot of mid-tier I send to CC.
I should have skipped the LGS.
CC gave me a better percentage for less time and work.
In fact, one of my shipments happened to have most of my disassembled decks, and they automatically upgraded my service due to the number of quality cards.

I was also fully expecting grading to be low, but over 2/3 of my shipments were graded as LP, most NM.
100% would recommend!
David Holt
Review left Oct 30 2023
Shipment processed Oct 19 2023
$1,288.57 payout, $163.07 fees

Review

Holy crap was this great!
I'm getting out of the hobby since it's not bringing joy and I have no time.
I sold some of my collection to a very nice LGS, the bulk and a lot of mid-tier I send to CC.
I should have skipped the LGS.
CC gave me a better percentage for less time and work.
In fact, one ... Read more
Holy crap was this great!
I'm getting out of the hobby since it's not bringing joy and I have no time.
I sold some of my collection to a very nice LGS, the bulk and a lot of mid-tier I send to CC.
I should have skipped the LGS.
CC gave me a better percentage for less time and work.
In fact, one of my shipments happened to have most of my disassembled decks, and they automatically upgraded my service due to the number of quality cards.

I was also fully expecting grading to be low, but over 2/3 of my shipments were graded as LP, most NM.
100% would recommend!
Michael Roth
Review left Oct 30 2023
Shipment processed Oct 20 2023
$1,160.75 payout, $21.28 fees

Review

Got the entire process done in less than 2 weeks. Team did a great job and even identified some fake cards I was sold on Mercari so I could follow up with the sellers there. Highly recommend.
Got the entire process done in less than 2 weeks. Team did a great job and even identified some fake cards I was sold on Mercari so I could follow up with the sellers there. Highly recommend.
Mattheus Bittick
Review left Oct 30 2023
Shipment processed Oct 20 2023
$601.95 payout, $9.78 fees

Review

The process was easy, especially if you have your cards cataloged. I did feel like the grading process downgraded more cards than I would have expected, considering many of the cards I submitted had never been played but such is the quality of magic cards Wizards is producing today so I did not argu ... Read more
The process was easy, especially if you have your cards cataloged. I did feel like the grading process downgraded more cards than I would have expected, considering many of the cards I submitted had never been played but such is the quality of magic cards Wizards is producing today so I did not argue the conditions. Overall satisfied with the service and will likely reuse it in the future.
Ryan
Review left Oct 30 2023
Shipment processed Oct 21 2023

Review

This is a very easy process and I would recommend it over selling things one by one any day of the week.
This is a very easy process and I would recommend it over selling things one by one any day of the week.
Ilias
Review left Oct 29 2023
Shipment processed Oct 19 2023
$117.72 payout, $41.45 fees

Review

Smooth, quick turnaround. Fully expected to be waiting weeks before I even heard a reply. Cash was in my account before I knew it. Did not want to sort through all those cards. Thanks guys!
Smooth, quick turnaround. Fully expected to be waiting weeks before I even heard a reply. Cash was in my account before I knew it. Did not want to sort through all those cards. Thanks guys!
Josh
Review left Oct 29 2023
Shipment processed Oct 19 2023
$533.16 payout, $25.12 fees

Review

Easily my new favorite way to get rid of my bulk cards, and get a fair price for them. Payment was quick after processing, and seeing every card itemized was a great touch. Can't recommend enough
Easily my new favorite way to get rid of my bulk cards, and get a fair price for them. Payment was quick after processing, and seeing every card itemized was a great touch. Can't recommend enough
Martin Dobler
Review left Oct 29 2023
Shipment processed Oct 19 2023
$2,383.22 payout, $48.64 fees

Review

The process was very straight forward and everything was laid out online. Would use to sell anything else.
The process was very straight forward and everything was laid out online. Would use to sell anything else.
Tyler
Review left Oct 29 2023
Shipment processed Oct 19 2023
$1,598.46 payout, $32.62 fees

Review

Timely, great support who answered questions very quickly, and very fair payout. 100% recommend
Timely, great support who answered questions very quickly, and very fair payout. 100% recommend
Chris Powell
Review left Oct 27 2023
Shipment processed Sep 23 2023

Review

I've used a number of Buy List services and this one is one of the best! They offer competitive prices and not having to grade the cards yourself makes everything simpler.
I've used a number of Buy List services and this one is one of the best! They offer competitive prices and not having to grade the cards yourself makes everything simpler.
David
Review left Oct 27 2023
Shipment processed Oct 19 2023
$4,316.08 payout, $229.27 fees

Review

Holy crap was this great!
I'm getting out of the hobby since it's not bringing joy and I have no time.
I sold some of my collection to a very nice LGS, the bulk and a lot of mid-tier I send to CC.
I should have skipped the LGS.
CC gave me a better percentage for less time and work.
In fact, one ... Read more
Holy crap was this great!
I'm getting out of the hobby since it's not bringing joy and I have no time.
I sold some of my collection to a very nice LGS, the bulk and a lot of mid-tier I send to CC.
I should have skipped the LGS.
CC gave me a better percentage for less time and work.
In fact, one of my shipments happened to have most of my disassembled decks, and they automatically upgraded my service due to the number of quality cards.

I was also fully expecting grading to be low, but over 2/3 of my shipments were graded as LP, most NM.
100% would recommend!
Stephen
Review left Oct 27 2023
Shipment processed Oct 12 2023
$3,353.57 payout, $176.50 fees

Review

The process was easy, convenient, and timely! CardConduit was excellent in communicating each step of the process from receiving my cards to processing/organizing my collection. Much appreciated! :-)
The process was easy, convenient, and timely! CardConduit was excellent in communicating each step of the process from receiving my cards to processing/organizing my collection. Much appreciated! :-)
Andy
Review left Oct 26 2023
Shipment processed Oct 07 2023

Review

Mailed in a bunch of cards that I didn't want to spend time sorting through and Card Conduit made it super easy. Made some money off of cards that would have otherwise sat there.
Mailed in a bunch of cards that I didn't want to spend time sorting through and Card Conduit made it super easy. Made some money off of cards that would have otherwise sat there.
1 2 ... 55 56 57 58 59 60 61 ... 157 158
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every previous customer to leave a review. Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page. We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).