Chat with us

Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service

(2691)
John W.
Review left Jul 05 2023
Shipment processed Jun 17 2023
$941.41 payout, $44.36 fees

Review

I sent in 119 cards that qualified for the 5% curated service. I kept seeing them on mtg goldfish and felt it was time to give it a shot.

The prices given on Card Conduits card pricing tool lined up to at or better TCG Player buy list prices. Their price was higher than any LGS offers also. I ... Read more
I sent in 119 cards that qualified for the 5% curated service. I kept seeing them on mtg goldfish and felt it was time to give it a shot.

The prices given on Card Conduits card pricing tool lined up to at or better TCG Player buy list prices. Their price was higher than any LGS offers also. I expected 800-1000 for my cards and card conduit came in at the higher end of that valuation AFTER their 5% fee!

This plus their constant updates on my cards built tons of trust. I will definitely be using them again. It really is an easy and profitable way to sell cards you are not playing with anymore.
Danny
Review left Jul 04 2023
Shipment processed Jul 01 2023
$1,039.56 payout, $150.63 fees

Review

I have been in the process of minimalizing my living for the past few years, and the enormous and heavy boxes of MTG cards was more of a burden than a thing that brought me joy. I've shipped about 5 times to Card Conduit, and it helped me clean up my life and get some money in my bank account! Super ... Read more
I have been in the process of minimalizing my living for the past few years, and the enormous and heavy boxes of MTG cards was more of a burden than a thing that brought me joy. I've shipped about 5 times to Card Conduit, and it helped me clean up my life and get some money in my bank account! Super easy and convenient, I can't recommend these guys highly enough.
Christopher C.
Review left Jul 04 2023
Shipment processed Jun 01 2023

Review

The process was easy and payment was shipped out soon after arrival. Communication was top-notch. Would for sure use their services again.
The process was easy and payment was shipped out soon after arrival. Communication was top-notch. Would for sure use their services again.
Timothy Bouquet
Review left Jul 03 2023
Shipment processed Jun 22 2023
$157.22 payout, $3.21 fees

Review

It seemed like they underrated condition of the valuable card in my submission.
It seemed like they underrated condition of the valuable card in my submission.
Card Conduit Team

Replied Jul 03 2023

We can certainly understand disappointment when a card receives an unexpected grade, and we regret that the service wasn't able to meet your expectations. Unfortunately in this case, the card is warped, has bends, and also has minor liquid damage. While it is possible that the liquid damage may have contributed to the warping, the card would be defined as damaged by all major vendors, as well as per the TCGPlayer grading criteria.

For those concerned about unexpected downgrades, we do offer the ability to put a shipment on hold for 48 hours after receipt, which will allow for us to address any potential concerns regarding specific cards prior to the finalization of shipments. Even without a hold, we are always happy to provide additional information where possible, and encourage customers to contact us with concerns as soon as possible so they can be addressed while the card is still in our possession.
We can certainly understand disappointment when a card receives an unexpected grade, and we regret that the service wasn't able to meet your expectations. Unfortunately in this case, the card is warped, has bends, and also has minor liquid damage. While it is possible that the liquid damage may have contributed to the warping, the card would be defined as damaged by all major vendors, as well as per the TCGPlayer grading criteria.

For those concerned about unexpected downgrades, we do offer the ability to put a shipment on hold for 48 hours after receipt, which will allow for us to address any potential concerns regarding specific cards prior to the finalization of shipments. Even without a hold, we are always happy to provide additional information where possible, and encourage customers to contact us with concerns as soon as possible so they can be addressed while the card is still in our possession.
Garrett
Review left Jul 03 2023
Shipment processed Jun 22 2023
$64.33 payout, $1.18 fees

Review

Great payout, very prompt with answers to questions and explaining if I have a question. By far the best card selling service for the best payout too.
Great payout, very prompt with answers to questions and explaining if I have a question. By far the best card selling service for the best payout too.
Neal Connolly
Review left Jul 03 2023
Shipment processed Jun 22 2023
$968.15 payout, $19.76 fees

Review

I recommend sending your cards to these guys. The curated shipment worked great
I recommend sending your cards to these guys. The curated shipment worked great
Kris Schnell
Review left Jul 03 2023
Shipment processed Jun 22 2023
$159.79 payout, $2.92 fees

Review

Never disappointed with card conduit. Their service never misses
Never disappointed with card conduit. Their service never misses
Austin
Review left Jul 03 2023
Shipment processed Jun 10 2023
$900.23 payout, $38.34 fees

Review

May not be as payout as selling direct, but takes out all the hassle and is a simple and quick process! Easily one of the best sites to sell, and I also sell on TCG Player. Between the two, I often wonder why I even bother with the other site!
May not be as payout as selling direct, but takes out all the hassle and is a simple and quick process! Easily one of the best sites to sell, and I also sell on TCG Player. Between the two, I often wonder why I even bother with the other site!
Austin
Review left Jul 03 2023
Shipment processed Jun 14 2023
$4,328.97 payout, $183.70 fees

Review

I saw this advertised online and was initially skeptical. No longer! I am a true fan of this site, the liquidity they add to the market, and their fair dealings. Will be using often!
I saw this advertised online and was initially skeptical. No longer! I am a true fan of this site, the liquidity they add to the market, and their fair dealings. Will be using often!
Mitchell R Walter
Review left Jul 03 2023
Shipment processed Jun 07 2023

Review

super awesome company, love what they do! They will give you the best prices you can find without any of the hassle!
super awesome company, love what they do! They will give you the best prices you can find without any of the hassle!
Eric Grewal
Review left Jul 02 2023
Shipment processed Jun 22 2023
$395.74 payout, $56.14 fees

Review

Can not recommend this service enough. I just threw all my cards in a box and shipped it off. Zero hassle and very fair prices for having to do such little work
Can not recommend this service enough. I just threw all my cards in a box and shipped it off. Zero hassle and very fair prices for having to do such little work
J H
Review left Jul 02 2023
Shipment processed Jun 21 2023
$2,131.04 payout, $112.16 fees

Review

A+ really easy to work with. Great service. Would recommend.
A+ really easy to work with. Great service. Would recommend.
Kaleb
Review left Jul 02 2023
Shipment processed Jun 22 2023

Review

I got the most value for my cards that I could've unless I listed the singles myself. Great value and great service!
I got the most value for my cards that I could've unless I listed the singles myself. Great value and great service!
Michael H
Review left Jul 02 2023
Shipment processed May 27 2023
$98.70 payout, $82.75 fees

Review

Pricing was clear, putting all my cards into a TCGPlayer list and then importing the list via Card Conduit's estimator tool was highly useful in determining whether Card Conduit was a good option or not. Payment and card grading was fair.

Communication was good throughout, with updates provided ... Read more
Pricing was clear, putting all my cards into a TCGPlayer list and then importing the list via Card Conduit's estimator tool was highly useful in determining whether Card Conduit was a good option or not. Payment and card grading was fair.

Communication was good throughout, with updates provided for a single delay that occurred during processing and when payment was sent.

Would use again.
Trevor
Review left Jul 01 2023
Shipment processed Jun 28 2023
$226.12 payout, $11.90 fees

Review

I’m never selling bulk cards any other way. Incredibly easy and efficient process, I’ve already reccomended it my other friends who play magic.
I’m never selling bulk cards any other way. Incredibly easy and efficient process, I’ve already reccomended it my other friends who play magic.
Kevin Smith
Review left Jul 01 2023
Shipment processed May 27 2023

Review

Quick easy process. Very thorough. Would highly recommend for selling bulk, pricey cards etc. 10 out of 10
Quick easy process. Very thorough. Would highly recommend for selling bulk, pricey cards etc. 10 out of 10
Theo
Review left Jul 01 2023
Shipment processed May 24 2023
$270.06 payout, $34.64 fees

Review

I had a good experience with Card Conduit. I decided a while ago to get out of Magic and it was taking a lot of time to sort my cards for buylists. I had a decent amount of cards left and I knew there was some good value there but that most of it was bulk. Card Conduit seemed like an attractive opti ... Read more
I had a good experience with Card Conduit. I decided a while ago to get out of Magic and it was taking a lot of time to sort my cards for buylists. I had a decent amount of cards left and I knew there was some good value there but that most of it was bulk. Card Conduit seemed like an attractive option, but I was a little nervous about shipping that many cards. I looked around on Reddit and saw that they were reliable and doing this for several years. I think it's a really good deal for the services provided. Yes I could have made more money if I sold cards individually, picked the bulk, etc. but by the time I'm done what's the point? Doing it this way I saw what everything was worth, they handled sorting the bulk, and I didn't have to do anything except mail the box. A little less money but 1% of the effort. No regrets on doing it this way!
Jeff Westhead
Review left Jun 30 2023
Shipment processed May 18 2023
$343.95 payout, $14.37 fees

Review

Nick was extremely helpful as usual. Dealt with a few minor hiccups, very satisfactorily, during the process. Quick turnaround and fair results.
Nick was extremely helpful as usual. Dealt with a few minor hiccups, very satisfactorily, during the process. Quick turnaround and fair results.
Damien
Review left Jun 30 2023
Shipment processed Jun 19 2023
$3,946.62 payout, $72.34 fees

Review

The process is really quite easy, and even with some mid to high end stuff the quote I got was what I received. If you are gonna move your cards this is the way to do it.
The process is really quite easy, and even with some mid to high end stuff the quote I got was what I received. If you are gonna move your cards this is the way to do it.
Chris
Review left Jun 30 2023
Shipment processed Jun 19 2023
$105.07 payout, $1.93 fees

Review

I clean out my binders every couple months and ALWAYS send my cardboard to Card Conduit. Service is fast and pleasant every time.
I clean out my binders every couple months and ALWAYS send my cardboard to Card Conduit. Service is fast and pleasant every time.
1 2 ... 52 53 54 55 56 57 58 ... 134 135
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every previous customer to leave a review. Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page. We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).