Customer Reviews

of our Magic collection selling service

The process was easy, and for the cards that weren't as valuable pricing and grading was fair, however for the most valuable card I sent in, a Silver Scroll Vampiric Tutor being graded at Moderately Played was disappointing. Every card shop near me has said the card was lightly played at the worst, and it's disappointing that Card Conduit would grade it lower based on damage that TCGplayer says is LP.

If you have a lot of cards you're looking to sell, the service is decent and convenient, just make sure you save anything extremely valuable to sell yourself and don't hesitate to have those cards sent back after getting the news that they believe your card is in much worse condition than it actually is.

And as an update to the review several weeks later, I sold the Vampiric Tutor to an LGS, and they fairly and correctly graded the exact same card as Lightly played, giving me a SIGNIFICANT amount more than card conduit offered. Absolutely be cautious sending cards in, know what they're worth, know the condition they're in, and do NOT hesitate getting them sent back if this happens to you too.