Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service
(5636)
John Knetemann
Review left Dec 22 2024
Shipment processed Dec 10 2024
Review
I used Card Conduit for my first ever experience selling MTG cards and they couldn't have made it easier. The payout was exactly what they claimed it would be, the instructions were clear and easy to follow, and I could track every step of my experience easily. I couldn't ask for more from their service!
I used Card Conduit for my first ever experience selling MTG cards and they couldn't have made it easier. The payout was exactly what they claimed it would be, the instructions were clear and easy to follow, and I could track every step of my experience easily. I couldn't ask for more from their service!
Wesley Sutton
Review left Dec 21 2024
Review
Great experience and very kind people when I made an error when first setting up all 3 “orders” with this being my first time utilising your services! Will definitely use again if I ever have surplus again but will definitely recommend to others!
Great experience and very kind people when I made an error when first setting up all 3 “orders” with this being my first time utilising your services! Will definitely use again if I ever have surplus again but will definitely recommend to others!
Ian
Review left Dec 21 2024
Shipment processed Dec 19 2024
$2,586.57
payout, $136.14
fees
Review
I didn’t have the time to unsleeve most, I almost wrote a note saying I saw sorry to whomever was going to be processing my first 1500 cards. O got an email that my sorter was so happy with the overall collection they changed fees and it made my day to see them go and have someone else appreciate
...
Read more
I didn’t have the time to unsleeve most, I almost wrote a note saying I saw sorry to whomever was going to be processing my first 1500 cards. O got an email that my sorter was so happy with the overall collection they changed fees and it made my day to see them go and have someone else appreciate keeping them hoarded. I will very much be sending more cases in.
Darren
Review left Dec 21 2024
Review
Worked with support to send a shipment slightly over their requested limit, they were very accommodating and still processed it in a very reasonable time frame. I've sent several batches of cards in over the years, some high value, some low, and every time I'm pleased with the results.
Worked with support to send a shipment slightly over their requested limit, they were very accommodating and still processed it in a very reasonable time frame. I've sent several batches of cards in over the years, some high value, some low, and every time I'm pleased with the results.
Jed Mayer
Review left Dec 21 2024
Review
aways a pleasure selling to this company. they make it so easy.
aways a pleasure selling to this company. they make it so easy.
Deangelo
Review left Dec 21 2024
Review
This process was easy, I don’t feel cheated with how much I made from my collection, and great overall service. They will always be the first service I go to when I want to sell cards.
This process was easy, I don’t feel cheated with how much I made from my collection, and great overall service. They will always be the first service I go to when I want to sell cards.
Blake
Review left Dec 21 2024
Shipment processed Dec 13 2024
Review
The process was very easy. The most disappointing aspect is not being able to really contest any of the grading. For offloading cards very quickly and with minimal effort and decent returns, I can recommend the service.
The process was very easy. The most disappointing aspect is not being able to really contest any of the grading. For offloading cards very quickly and with minimal effort and decent returns, I can recommend the service.
Mike
Review left Dec 20 2024
Review
Easiest process ever. Paid fair prices and literally required no work on my end. This is the only place I’ll be selling my magic cards to.
Easiest process ever. Paid fair prices and literally required no work on my end. This is the only place I’ll be selling my magic cards to.
Christopher W Savage
Review left Dec 20 2024
Review
It was, yet time consuming for a curated shipment.
It was, yet time consuming for a curated shipment.
Yupheng Vang
Review left Dec 18 2024
Review
I used to love MTG and liked to play Commander. Over the years, I built up quite a large collection but slowly stopped playing. Soon, I just had a bunch of cards collecting dust. I tried selling my collection to my LGS, but they only offered to buy it at a major discount or for store credit. I decid
...
Read more
I used to love MTG and liked to play Commander. Over the years, I built up quite a large collection but slowly stopped playing. Soon, I just had a bunch of cards collecting dust. I tried selling my collection to my LGS, but they only offered to buy it at a major discount or for store credit. I decided to sell it online with Card Conduits' help. The process was quite easy. All I had to do was ship it, and they handled the rest. The total I got back was slightly disappointing but understandable because most of it was commons. Card Conduit is worth it due to its convenience and becuase they only take 10%.
chhouen prach
Review left Dec 18 2024
Review
Easy process. Got paid within a week of delivery. Great customer service!
Easy process. Got paid within a week of delivery. Great customer service!
Trent
Review left Dec 18 2024
Review
Couldn't be happier with the process to be honest. Quick turnaround time for a decent number of cards that I sent right before a holiday. Great communication from team throughout the process. I'll definitely be back when my collection gets unruly again.
Couldn't be happier with the process to be honest. Quick turnaround time for a decent number of cards that I sent right before a holiday. Great communication from team throughout the process. I'll definitely be back when my collection gets unruly again.
Christian
Review left Dec 18 2024
Review
Service was excellent I kept a record of my cards prior to submittal no oddities identified. The evaluation is slightly more aggressive on NM/SP/Etc than anticipated but expected. Overall due to ease of submittal they're the best service on the market.
Service was excellent I kept a record of my cards prior to submittal no oddities identified. The evaluation is slightly more aggressive on NM/SP/Etc than anticipated but expected. Overall due to ease of submittal they're the best service on the market.
Devin Jensen
Review left Dec 18 2024
Review
Process was easy and painless! 10 out of 10 recommend for anyone trying to off load some cards.
Process was easy and painless! 10 out of 10 recommend for anyone trying to off load some cards.
Andre Whyne
Review left Dec 18 2024
Review
Transaction was easy and fast. I tried to catalogue everything myself and it took forever so when I say this site I took to selling to here right away.
Transaction was easy and fast. I tried to catalogue everything myself and it took forever so when I say this site I took to selling to here right away.
Andre Whyne
Review left Dec 18 2024
Review
Fast! Fair!
I had an amazing experience. Nothing more to say.
I had an amazing experience. Nothing more to say.
Fast! Fair!
I had an amazing experience. Nothing more to say.
I had an amazing experience. Nothing more to say.
Christian Enright
Review left Dec 17 2024
Review
Their website was great at explaining the process and how I should go about getting all my cards sorted for the sorted shipment. It took a couple weeks (including the time it took for my cards to arrive) and then I was paid an amount I expected for the condition of the cards I had sent in. I didn't
...
Read more
Their website was great at explaining the process and how I should go about getting all my cards sorted for the sorted shipment. It took a couple weeks (including the time it took for my cards to arrive) and then I was paid an amount I expected for the condition of the cards I had sent in. I didn't have to get any help from support, so I can't say anything there, but I was glad I chose this service.
Andy Walker
Review left Dec 17 2024
Shipment processed Dec 10 2024
Review
very simple process, i really liked that you could track it every step of the way
very simple process, i really liked that you could track it every step of the way
Danny Gomez
Review left Dec 17 2024
Review
This was my first shipment to CC, so I went for the unsorted service since I had opened and hoarded a lot of recent MTG and have not gone through checking value on every card. A little nervous to be honest but the notifications of where and how the process was going was clear and the reports of how
...
Read more
This was my first shipment to CC, so I went for the unsorted service since I had opened and hoarded a lot of recent MTG and have not gone through checking value on every card. A little nervous to be honest but the notifications of where and how the process was going was clear and the reports of how grading is set as well as what was considered bulk and what are consider ¨winners¨ is helpful if you consider to keep send them cards either semi-sorted or buy list.
Overall the experience was good enough for me to keep sending them cards.
Overall the experience was good enough for me to keep sending them cards.
Malvin Prifti
Review left Dec 16 2024
Shipment processed Dec 10 2024
$309.41
payout, $5.67
fees
Review
Thanks for a quick and easy buylist process to let go of my old Commander deck. I was able to use the proceeds for holiday shopping within ~2 weeks of shipping my cards. I will definitely recommend this to my friends!
Thanks for a quick and easy buylist process to let go of my old Commander deck. I was able to use the proceeds for holiday shopping within ~2 weeks of shipping my cards. I will definitely recommend this to my friends!
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every
previous customer to leave a review.
Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page.
We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a
review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).