Customer Reviews

of our Magic collection selling service

Condition grading felt very conservative. I feel like it’s help to post a video or images to align with customers on how you grade. I felt you could buy LP from TCGplayer and should expect MP from CardConduit. Regardless of whether they do or it is intentional, the incentives are setup for CC to w ... Read more

Condition grading felt very conservative. I feel like it’s help to post a video or images to align with customers on how you grade. I felt you could buy LP from TCGplayer and should expect MP from CardConduit. Regardless of whether they do or it is intentional, the incentives are setup for CC to want not grade fairly (e.g. covers them in case buy list grades differently).

That said, I wasn’t going to sell all my singles myself, so I appreciated that the service exists even if I’m not sold on the grading. The team was fairly transparent and communicated well. Payment was prompt.

From start to finish the process was quick, easy and painless. The overall interface made adding the cards with their estimated value a breeze. The list given to sort the cards is concise and easy to read. I had no issues with any estimations or quality choices that the team made. 10/10 will be using again.

From start to finish the process was quick, easy and painless. The overall interface made adding the cards with their estimated value a breeze. The list given to sort the cards is concise and easy to read. I had no issues with any estimations or quality choices that the team made. 10/10 will be using again.

The grading has become more inconsistent. Even pack fresh cards that I have double checked before submitting are receiving MP grades, significantly lowering the payout. This is particularly true for foils. Still, this is a smooth and easy process if you have more difficult to move cards.

The grading has become more inconsistent. Even pack fresh cards that I have double checked before submitting are receiving MP grades, significantly lowering the payout. This is particularly true for foils. Still, this is a smooth and easy process if you have more difficult to move cards.

Helping me fund a man cave one shipment at a time. Wife can’t complain about found money, that’s what this place offers.

Helping me fund a man cave one shipment at a time. Wife can’t complain about found money, that’s what this place offers.

The process was very quick, taking just about a week from ship out to pay out during the week of Christmas, which I was very impressed with. I used the sorted tier sending in my trades that my locals at the LGS haven't been interested in. The payout was as expected and I was quite pleased with it.

The process was very quick, taking just about a week from ship out to pay out during the week of Christmas, which I was very impressed with. I used the sorted tier sending in my trades that my locals at the LGS haven't been interested in. The payout was as expected and I was quite pleased with it.

Typically I buy list my cards to cardkingdom for store credit. However, they've been slower and slower recently and I had a batch of cards worth $0.50+ and sent to CC.

They were quick, paid cash (a bit less than CK credit, but actual dollars), and good communication.

Typically I buy list my cards to cardkingdom for store credit. However, they've been slower and slower recently and I had a batch of cards worth $0.50+ and sent to CC.

They were quick, paid cash (a bit less than CK credit, but actual dollars), and good communication.

The entire process from start to finish is easy to navigate. The level of communication and the speed at which my order was processed far outpaced the companies providing similar services. If you're thinking about giving card conduit a chance, do it.

The entire process from start to finish is easy to navigate. The level of communication and the speed at which my order was processed far outpaced the companies providing similar services. If you're thinking about giving card conduit a chance, do it.

I have used this service multiple times and will continue to in the future. Best way to sell cards for a fair price and no hassle!

I have used this service multiple times and will continue to in the future. Best way to sell cards for a fair price and no hassle!

The process was easy, efficient and at every point felt safe and secure. I highly recommend Card Conduit.

The process was easy, efficient and at every point felt safe and secure. I highly recommend Card Conduit.

Very easy. Only suggestion: would be nice if able to export list of cards in shipment with both CC price and TCG market/low price (like in the price check tool). That would be nice to quickly see which cards I may want to take out due to low buylist values

Very easy. Only suggestion: would be nice if able to export list of cards in shipment with both CC price and TCG market/low price (like in the price check tool). That would be nice to quickly see which cards I may want to take out due to low buylist values

Easy process, decent value. Would use the service again.

Easy process, decent value. Would use the service again.

I cannot properly express the amazingness of Card Conduit's service. It's like a magic button that converts your hard-to-sell, low-end singles into near market value money. They save you countless dollars worth of time and do it all for you. I have used them multiple times and will continue to do so indefinitely. Thanks for everything!

I cannot properly express the amazingness of Card Conduit's service. It's like a magic button that converts your hard-to-sell, low-end singles into near market value money. They save you countless dollars worth of time and do it all for you. I have used them multiple times and will continue to do so indefinitely. Thanks for everything!

The process of selling through Card Conduit always made me hesitant. I feel like any collector or long-time player is rightfully nervous about offloading the things they're done with, as the market for selling can be very time-consuming, labor-intensive, and down-right draining in many ways. When it ... Read more

The process of selling through Card Conduit always made me hesitant. I feel like any collector or long-time player is rightfully nervous about offloading the things they're done with, as the market for selling can be very time-consuming, labor-intensive, and down-right draining in many ways. When it comes to getting rid of large amounts of cards for reasonable value, it can become an even more daunting task. Card Conduit genuinely makes the process as simple as it's ever been. With built-in collection pricing tools and partnerships with tracking tools such as Moxfield, it really has become as simple as:
1) Scan
2) Appraise
3) Ship

With their standard shipment the process is even more simple & their fees are incredibly reasonable accross the board. I've never felt better about putting the sale of my cards in someone else's hands, and will definitely be doing further work with Card Conduit in the future.

This is my second time selling with Card Conduit, but first time using the more curated features. It was a breeze to sell and sort these cards, and I couldn't be happier.

This is my second time selling with Card Conduit, but first time using the more curated features. It was a breeze to sell and sort these cards, and I couldn't be happier.

Not to bury the lede, here is the TL;DR of this review: for the best Card Conduit experience, set your grading and payout expectations as low as possible and lean into the convenience.

I used the Sorted service and sent in 485 cards.

PROS:
Customer service experience was great; Nick is great; ... Read more

Not to bury the lede, here is the TL;DR of this review: for the best Card Conduit experience, set your grading and payout expectations as low as possible and lean into the convenience.

I used the Sorted service and sent in 485 cards.

PROS:
Customer service experience was great; Nick is great; responses were prompt and personal. I ran out of time preparing my order, and when I did finally ship, several cards had fallen below the $0.50 threshhold. Nick said that's fine, leave 'em in. Huge help there. My order arrived smack in the holiday season, but the CC team was still prompt in replying to my questions on Christmas Day. Payout came right on time with no hitches. Awesome.

CONS:
Even understanding that my own assessment of card quality would be high, I was still pretty disappointed by the grading. Most everything was MP or below, and the payout reflected it - I had told myself that $2,500 was the least I would accept, but... well.

The thing is, CC has to pay their clients based on a whole host of resell factors that most people wouldn't necessarily consider. And their grading is necessarily based on the demanding expectations of their own buyers. I am willing to take on faith that their grading was accurate given those parameters, but it sure feels bad to scrutinize a card, think to yourself "Yeah, this is in pretty stellar condition" and then find out that it was rated at Moderately Played and bought at 60% of the value you expected. Repeat that for 485 cards, and I would be lying if I said it didn't leave me feeling pretty bummed.

If I were to use CC again, I think it would be to maximize the convenience factor: bulk rares and so on.
If you have cards that will sell as singles, strongly consider selling them as singles. And if you do use Card Conduit, know exactly what the time saved will be worth to you.

Second round and just as good as the first! Keep up the fabulous work!

Second round and just as good as the first! Keep up the fabulous work!

This is the second time I've used Card Conduit. I had a predictable experience which is exactly what I wanted. If I need to sell cards again I'll continue to use Card Conduit.

This is the second time I've used Card Conduit. I had a predictable experience which is exactly what I wanted. If I need to sell cards again I'll continue to use Card Conduit.

Did 2 shipments together, one bulk rares and mythics and the other sorted cards over $1. Got back around what I thought I could get after seeing their initial pricing. Going to keep using them.

Did 2 shipments together, one bulk rares and mythics and the other sorted cards over $1. Got back around what I thought I could get after seeing their initial pricing. Going to keep using them.

After a stellar first experience with Card Conduit, I entrusted them with a second shipment of approximately 400 Magic cards. Once again, the process was smooth and hassle-free. The team's professionalism and efficiency in handling my collection were impressive. Opting for the PayPal payout option a ... Read more

After a stellar first experience with Card Conduit, I entrusted them with a second shipment of approximately 400 Magic cards. Once again, the process was smooth and hassle-free. The team's professionalism and efficiency in handling my collection were impressive. Opting for the PayPal payout option added to the convenience, with funds promptly appearing in my account. For anyone looking to sell their Magic cards without the usual headaches, Card Conduit remains my top recommendation.

I recently used Card Conduit to offload a couple of hundred Magic: The Gathering cards that were surplus to requirements. I couldn't be more satisfied with the service. Despite my shipment originating in Australia, the process was seamless and efficient. Card Conduit handled my really random shipmen ... Read more

I recently used Card Conduit to offload a couple of hundred Magic: The Gathering cards that were surplus to requirements. I couldn't be more satisfied with the service. Despite my shipment originating in Australia, the process was seamless and efficient. Card Conduit handled my really random shipment of cards, ranging from near mint to heavily played, with professionalism and care. I received a detailed report on each card's condition and a (more than) fair return. Their excellent communication and prompt responses made the experience stress-free, even when shipping valuable items internationally. I've already sent a second batch and highly recommend Card Conduit to anyone looking to sell their Magic cards.