Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service
(5634)
Prajit Deb
Review left May 15 2025
Shipment processed May 13 2025
Review
Prompt communication, fast processing and fair pricing. Thank you Nathaniel.
Prompt communication, fast processing and fair pricing. Thank you Nathaniel.
Austin Cope
Review left May 15 2025
Review
Amazing service and great step-by-step instructions that walk you through from start to finish. Definitely Recommend
Amazing service and great step-by-step instructions that walk you through from start to finish. Definitely Recommend
Thomas Howard
Review left May 15 2025
Review
I have a very large collection of cards I am sorting through and they have made the process of selling them as easy and convenient as I could have hoped for. My thanks to them for everything!!!
I have a very large collection of cards I am sorting through and they have made the process of selling them as easy and convenient as I could have hoped for. My thanks to them for everything!!!
Max Luna
Review left May 14 2025
Review
Payout was easy and the reports showed me what I got
Payout was easy and the reports showed me what I got
Matt
Review left May 14 2025
Review
It was a very simple, efficient, and straightforward process. I was able to check the status of my order at all times, and they were very quick.
Over-all I'd say that it is worth it if you are looking to sell everything and be done with it. The one thing that frustrated me was that a majority of ... Read more
Over-all I'd say that it is worth it if you are looking to sell everything and be done with it. The one thing that frustrated me was that a majority of ... Read more
It was a very simple, efficient, and straightforward process. I was able to check the status of my order at all times, and they were very quick.
Over-all I'd say that it is worth it if you are looking to sell everything and be done with it. The one thing that frustrated me was that a majority of my cards got marked as damaged, or heavily played. Because of this the actual amount I received was about 35% less than what I was expecting. So unless your cards are "mint in box" I'd expect them to get marked down in price. Still I'd say a very positive experience.
Over-all I'd say that it is worth it if you are looking to sell everything and be done with it. The one thing that frustrated me was that a majority of my cards got marked as damaged, or heavily played. Because of this the actual amount I received was about 35% less than what I was expecting. So unless your cards are "mint in box" I'd expect them to get marked down in price. Still I'd say a very positive experience.
Zach Castrejon
Review left May 14 2025
Review
The process, as always, was really easy! Create the shipment, label your box and off it goes. Timeline was accurate to a tee to what they said and their payout was higher than it usually was with my most recent send in! The fees are well worth the convenience Card Conduit provides.
I have no more ... Read more
I have no more ... Read more
The process, as always, was really easy! Create the shipment, label your box and off it goes. Timeline was accurate to a tee to what they said and their payout was higher than it usually was with my most recent send in! The fees are well worth the convenience Card Conduit provides.
I have no more friends to recommend this service to, all of them use Card Conduit and between me and them, none of have EVER ran into any issue.
I have no more friends to recommend this service to, all of them use Card Conduit and between me and them, none of have EVER ran into any issue.
Cameron Rodriguez
Review left May 14 2025
Review
Very very quick service, answered my questions and concerns quickly and the communication was fantastic. Overall, I had a great experience and would recommend anyone to use this service.
Very very quick service, answered my questions and concerns quickly and the communication was fantastic. Overall, I had a great experience and would recommend anyone to use this service.
Shelby K
Review left May 14 2025
Review
I would highly recommend card conduit to anyone who is looking to sell their collection without the hassle and stress of buy listing. The customer service is top notch, they were transparent and helpful every step of the way. The payout was more than I anticipated for the cards I sent and I am very pleased. 10/10 would recommend!
I would highly recommend card conduit to anyone who is looking to sell their collection without the hassle and stress of buy listing. The customer service is top notch, they were transparent and helpful every step of the way. The payout was more than I anticipated for the cards I sent and I am very pleased. 10/10 would recommend!
josh
Review left May 14 2025
Review
needed money quickly and turned 400 cards into $875 bucks :)
needed money quickly and turned 400 cards into $875 bucks :)
Jason Holm
Review left May 14 2025
Review
The process was very easy to follow. I appreciate working with someone directly to ensure my order is handled correctly. I would recommend Card Conduit to anyone looking to sell unused magic cards.
The process was very easy to follow. I appreciate working with someone directly to ensure my order is handled correctly. I would recommend Card Conduit to anyone looking to sell unused magic cards.
Austin Smith
Review left May 13 2025
Review
Sent in 2 400count boxes of cards I wasn’t using. Taking up space and got some funds I needed for home projects!
Sent in 2 400count boxes of cards I wasn’t using. Taking up space and got some funds I needed for home projects!
Chris
Review left May 13 2025
Review
I have had a 100% positive experience with the folks at Card Conduit. Fast processing and a quick response to an email I sent with a question.
I have had a 100% positive experience with the folks at Card Conduit. Fast processing and a quick response to an email I sent with a question.
Random Customer
Review left May 13 2025
Shipment processed May 10 2025
Review
Best prices for the fastest turnaround - professional process.
Best prices for the fastest turnaround - professional process.
Chris
Review left May 13 2025
Review
Very easy to use and good rates. Service is always fast.
Very easy to use and good rates. Service is always fast.
John Byrnes
Review left May 12 2025
Review
I want to thank Card Conduit for an intuitive and streamlined way for me to sell my collection. Although I am a long-time magic player, I did not have a collection created carefully over time and so did not relish having to look up card values and individually ebay or other list cards. Card Conduit
...
Read more
I want to thank Card Conduit for an intuitive and streamlined way for me to sell my collection. Although I am a long-time magic player, I did not have a collection created carefully over time and so did not relish having to look up card values and individually ebay or other list cards. Card Conduit let me pack everything up, gave me a clear value offer, and wrote me a check all in less than a month including shipping time.
My thanks to the team.
My thanks to the team.
Alexander Glass
Review left May 12 2025
Review
Process was very fast and easy. Instructions on how to ship and catalog cards was very clear and easy to follow. Communication of all the steps once collection was received was very thorough and easy to keep up to date on the process. Email at the end of curation was very detailed and well written,
...
Read more
Process was very fast and easy. Instructions on how to ship and catalog cards was very clear and easy to follow. Communication of all the steps once collection was received was very thorough and easy to keep up to date on the process. Email at the end of curation was very detailed and well written, which I appreciate greatly. Overall a fantastic experience. Highly recommend
Derek Khan
Review left May 12 2025
Shipment processed May 02 2025
Review
Super easy process and they keep good communication throughout. I have used this service before and will continue to use it anytime I need to sell cards. Highly recommend!!
Super easy process and they keep good communication throughout. I have used this service before and will continue to use it anytime I need to sell cards. Highly recommend!!
Oliver
Review left May 12 2025
Shipment processed May 07 2025
Review
The entire process was smooth and transparent. They operate with integrity. Highly recommend this service to anyone looking to sell cards with confidence!
The entire process was smooth and transparent. They operate with integrity. Highly recommend this service to anyone looking to sell cards with confidence!
Matt
Review left May 11 2025
Review
First time, I roughly knew what i was going to get back, but this time I expected to get half of what I actually got! Super pleasantly surprised and a fantastic service, as always.
First time, I roughly knew what i was going to get back, but this time I expected to get half of what I actually got! Super pleasantly surprised and a fantastic service, as always.
Matthew Andrews
Review left May 11 2025
Review
Value is second to none. My friends and I back draft all the rares after we open a box. They been sitting there. I’m glad someone else will enjoy them.
Value is second to none. My friends and I back draft all the rares after we open a box. They been sitting there. I’m glad someone else will enjoy them.
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every
previous customer to leave a review.
Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page.
We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a
review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).