Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service
(5631)
Phillip Dyer
Review left Jul 28 2025
Review
The service has been good other than every order I put in takes longer than the one before it and now this one and I feel the condition of the cards is a little bias as almost all my cards have NEVER been played. I had a Dark Ritual I only got like $40 for. But we will see going forward I still have A LOT of cards
The service has been good other than every order I put in takes longer than the one before it and now this one and I feel the condition of the cards is a little bias as almost all my cards have NEVER been played. I had a Dark Ritual I only got like $40 for. But we will see going forward I still have A LOT of cards
John W Duell
Review left Jul 27 2025
Review
I really like this service and the folks who work here are also very helpful.
I really like this service and the folks who work here are also very helpful.
Phil L
Review left Jul 27 2025
Review
most efficient way to move cards in mass. Used by our store and myself personally
most efficient way to move cards in mass. Used by our store and myself personally
Casey K
Review left Jul 25 2025
Shipment processed Jul 01 2025
Review
Leaving another incredible review, because its always so easy and I love being able to sort my cards for them. Thank you!
Leaving another incredible review, because its always so easy and I love being able to sort my cards for them. Thank you!
Ben
Review left Jul 25 2025
Review
Could not have been easier. With good explanations for everything
Could not have been easier. With good explanations for everything
J G
Review left Jul 25 2025
Shipment processed Jul 17 2025
Review
Card Conduit is easily the best experience I’ve had selling Magic cards online in all my (long) years. Processing was quick, payout was painless, and they have the best web app in the market to support this. The detailed breakdown of my order was great and the personal email about it was an excellent touch.
Card Conduit is easily the best experience I’ve had selling Magic cards online in all my (long) years. Processing was quick, payout was painless, and they have the best web app in the market to support this. The detailed breakdown of my order was great and the personal email about it was an excellent touch.
Dave S
Review left Jul 25 2025
Review
Fast, easy process. Fair pricing for sure. Communicates well and I love the stats breakdown.
Fast, easy process. Fair pricing for sure. Communicates well and I love the stats breakdown.
Luke
Review left Jul 24 2025
Review
The process was very easy and I commend the CC team as they answered honestly and quickly to questions I had for some of the card prices.
Overall the process was easy and convenient. I was a slight bit disappointed in the final payout amount as the collection represented a large portion of my MTG ... Read more
Overall the process was easy and convenient. I was a slight bit disappointed in the final payout amount as the collection represented a large portion of my MTG ... Read more
The process was very easy and I commend the CC team as they answered honestly and quickly to questions I had for some of the card prices.
Overall the process was easy and convenient. I was a slight bit disappointed in the final payout amount as the collection represented a large portion of my MTG collection, but still I do believe it was a fair payout and the work I did to package and prepare the collection was nearly nothing.
Overall the process was easy and convenient. I was a slight bit disappointed in the final payout amount as the collection represented a large portion of my MTG collection, but still I do believe it was a fair payout and the work I did to package and prepare the collection was nearly nothing.
Nathan
Review left Jul 24 2025
Shipment processed Jul 16 2025
Review
Great experience. Pleased with the pricing. Staff is incredibly knowledgeable and their email responses are top notch.
Great experience. Pleased with the pricing. Staff is incredibly knowledgeable and their email responses are top notch.
Cody T
Review left Jul 24 2025
Shipment processed Jul 12 2025
$441.00
payout, $9.00
fees
Review
Quick and easy to have cards graded and sold after presorting. 10/10 customer service
Quick and easy to have cards graded and sold after presorting. 10/10 customer service
Jimmy Hood
Review left Jul 23 2025
Review
Easy process, fair prices. Will use again without hesitation.
Easy process, fair prices. Will use again without hesitation.
Joseph D
Review left Jul 23 2025
Review
Entire process was incredibly easy. Everything was well documented. Felt I got a fair price for the cards I sent in. I definitely plan on using the service again in the future. Thank you.
Entire process was incredibly easy. Everything was well documented. Felt I got a fair price for the cards I sent in. I definitely plan on using the service again in the future. Thank you.
Phillip Dyer
Review left Jul 23 2025
Review
Fast and fair. What more could you ask for. Will definitely use in the future.
Fast and fair. What more could you ask for. Will definitely use in the future.
michael lyons
Review left Jul 23 2025
Review
let me just start this off and say I am not very computer savvy but card conduits website is so easy for me to use. It’s so professional and I love the direct deposit payout so I’m not waiting on a paycheck in the mail and I always get paid out more than I expect fast easy professional I will only sell my cards through card conduit
let me just start this off and say I am not very computer savvy but card conduits website is so easy for me to use. It’s so professional and I love the direct deposit payout so I’m not waiting on a paycheck in the mail and I always get paid out more than I expect fast easy professional I will only sell my cards through card conduit
Jeremy S
Review left Jul 23 2025
Review
I've used Card Conduit before and they've always provided good, reasonable value for my cards. Seeing how much I shipped to them, they processed it pretty quickly.
I've used Card Conduit before and they've always provided good, reasonable value for my cards. Seeing how much I shipped to them, they processed it pretty quickly.
Aaron
Review left Jul 23 2025
Review
The process is straightforward and easy to follow. Response times are as advertised. The grading for some card conditions was poorer than I had anticipated, but overall the pricing is fair. Best part, I don’t have to sort, individual cards myself because they do all the work and a check arrives in the mail.
The process is straightforward and easy to follow. Response times are as advertised. The grading for some card conditions was poorer than I had anticipated, but overall the pricing is fair. Best part, I don’t have to sort, individual cards myself because they do all the work and a check arrives in the mail.
Conor B
Review left Jul 23 2025
Review
Recently took apart some old commander decks, lots of valuable cards and plenty of random ones that I knew had value but didn't want to individually calculate. Sent it all to Card Conduit, got $3K that week, sent right to my bank account. Thanks for making it so easy!
Recently took apart some old commander decks, lots of valuable cards and plenty of random ones that I knew had value but didn't want to individually calculate. Sent it all to Card Conduit, got $3K that week, sent right to my bank account. Thanks for making it so easy!
Brandon Hubbard
Review left Jul 22 2025
Review
Process is easy as always! Returning customer here, would absolutely recommend to anyone. Best customer service I've had out of any buylist and card buying business!
Process is easy as always! Returning customer here, would absolutely recommend to anyone. Best customer service I've had out of any buylist and card buying business!
Huy
Review left Jul 22 2025
Review
Final Fantasy MTG card. Good pricing. I would recommend service to those who seek to sale bulk MTG. Will do another order soon .
Final Fantasy MTG card. Good pricing. I would recommend service to those who seek to sale bulk MTG. Will do another order soon .
Ryan
Review left Jul 22 2025
Shipment processed Jul 19 2025
Review
I will say that while a couple cards took a bit harsher grade than I expected. Really just the brand new ones not getting near mint sometimes. Overall pleased with the service provided and company.
I will say that while a couple cards took a bit harsher grade than I expected. Really just the brand new ones not getting near mint sometimes. Overall pleased with the service provided and company.
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every
previous customer to leave a review.
Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page.
We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a
review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).