Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service
(5873)
Roy
Review left Nov 03 2024
Review
Super simple process, once the box was shipped my part was over. I was upgraded to a cheaper sorting option for free because my cards were higher quality and emails notified me of every single step. Cheers!
Super simple process, once the box was shipped my part was over. I was upgraded to a cheaper sorting option for free because my cards were higher quality and emails notified me of every single step. Cheers!
Samuel Galandi
Review left Nov 03 2024
Review
Overall great experience, got way more money for my cards than I expected, great value! Highly recommend!!
Overall great experience, got way more money for my cards than I expected, great value! Highly recommend!!
ABV
Review left Nov 02 2024
Review
Process was easy. However, some cards were not evaluated properly. New ones were rated played and used were rated new and so on. They have to make money somehow. If your not patient enough to list yourself and need to sell fast this is an option. You will get 70% mabe 80% what you want out of them.
...
Read more
Process was easy. However, some cards were not evaluated properly. New ones were rated played and used were rated new and so on. They have to make money somehow. If your not patient enough to list yourself and need to sell fast this is an option. You will get 70% mabe 80% what you want out of them. I got 600 less than what i wanted for mine. If I had got 200 more I would be pleased and rated 8 or 9 out of 10. Use the service but just know they have to make money somehow and it's in the evaluation process. I would recommend if one needs fast money and doesn't care to take a small bath.
Gareth Hogan
Review left Nov 02 2024
Review
Really didn't want to sell on the cards and really appreciated how easy the team made the process. No hassles, great communication and was super quick.
Really didn't want to sell on the cards and really appreciated how easy the team made the process. No hassles, great communication and was super quick.
Edward F
Review left Nov 02 2024
Review
The process was quick , fast and easy , top notch work.
The process was quick , fast and easy , top notch work.
Nuhi
Review left Nov 01 2024
Review
The process was very simple, not as tedious as listing yourself and definitely worth the wait. I was worried about sending my higher end cards packed in the order requested so I used a perfect fit sleeve hoping to not get a desleeving fee but it seemed to get graded reasonably and assured that packing was sufficient. 10/10 would recommend.
The process was very simple, not as tedious as listing yourself and definitely worth the wait. I was worried about sending my higher end cards packed in the order requested so I used a perfect fit sleeve hoping to not get a desleeving fee but it seemed to get graded reasonably and assured that packing was sufficient. 10/10 would recommend.
William Matteson
Review left Oct 31 2024
Review
Got about what I expected when they also need to run a business
Got about what I expected when they also need to run a business
Terry G.
Review left Oct 31 2024
Review
+: The communication and service is great. Staff are responsive and willing to work through issues and queries.
-: As many others have noted, the grading is very strict. I have had about half of pack-fresh cards from recent sets graded as MP. I cannot comment whether the same cards would be grade ... Read more
-: As many others have noted, the grading is very strict. I have had about half of pack-fresh cards from recent sets graded as MP. I cannot comment whether the same cards would be grade ... Read more
+: The communication and service is great. Staff are responsive and willing to work through issues and queries.
-: As many others have noted, the grading is very strict. I have had about half of pack-fresh cards from recent sets graded as MP. I cannot comment whether the same cards would be graded better if sent directly to a vendor, but this is quite surprising and also somewhat disappointing. I would recommend the hold for review option for any shipment containing high value cards.
-: As many others have noted, the grading is very strict. I have had about half of pack-fresh cards from recent sets graded as MP. I cannot comment whether the same cards would be graded better if sent directly to a vendor, but this is quite surprising and also somewhat disappointing. I would recommend the hold for review option for any shipment containing high value cards.
Wes
Review left Oct 31 2024
Shipment processed Oct 19 2024
Review
Pretty smooth and painless process. Grading is fair as well.
Pretty smooth and painless process. Grading is fair as well.
Anthony Ariola
Review left Oct 31 2024
Review
I had a collection of MTG cards and haven't played in about 15 years. They were useless to me and collecting dust. No desire to play these days. It was nice to a get a few bucks for them and Card Conduit took great care of me in a very efficient and transparent manner. Highly recommend and may use them again!
I had a collection of MTG cards and haven't played in about 15 years. They were useless to me and collecting dust. No desire to play these days. It was nice to a get a few bucks for them and Card Conduit took great care of me in a very efficient and transparent manner. Highly recommend and may use them again!
Aaron Earl
Review left Oct 31 2024
Review
Clean and easy to understand report. Fair offers on cards. Will use again.
Clean and easy to understand report. Fair offers on cards. Will use again.
Zach
Review left Oct 30 2024
Review
I trusted you guys because of the MTGGoldfish pod!
I trusted you guys because of the MTGGoldfish pod!
matthew sloniger
Review left Oct 30 2024
Review
was happy with service and payout. card conduit is straightforward and fair
was happy with service and payout. card conduit is straightforward and fair
Michael Jokinen
Review left Oct 30 2024
Review
This was my first time using the service and they make it so easy. The grading is very accurate as well it came back actually better than I thought it would and was pleasantly surprised. Great place to get rid of some clutter and get some extra money!
This was my first time using the service and they make it so easy. The grading is very accurate as well it came back actually better than I thought it would and was pleasantly surprised. Great place to get rid of some clutter and get some extra money!
Tim A
Review left Oct 30 2024
Review
I would say if you're looking to reinvest into another format. or get rid of binder trades. This is the place.
I would say if you're looking to reinvest into another format. or get rid of binder trades. This is the place.
Joseph Canfield
Review left Oct 30 2024
Shipment processed Oct 20 2024
Review
First time using card conduit, I sent in a lot of the cards I had set aside and wasn't using but had some value, but they were still sleeved and unsorted so I expected certain fees and charges but due to the value of the cards included they bumped the delivery to a higher tier and I got a much bette
...
Read more
First time using card conduit, I sent in a lot of the cards I had set aside and wasn't using but had some value, but they were still sleeved and unsorted so I expected certain fees and charges but due to the value of the cards included they bumped the delivery to a higher tier and I got a much better payout than expected! I sincerely appreciate that extra mile they took and will be using their services again! Thanks so much!
Morgan
Review left Oct 30 2024
Review
Sold out of a lot of my extras just laying around. Would’ve taken me forever to process it all. They did so and got me paid incredibly quick.
Will say, they do not check the address you mail to daily, so it may take a few days after arrival before processing. However, once they did get it in t ... Read more
Will say, they do not check the address you mail to daily, so it may take a few days after arrival before processing. However, once they did get it in t ... Read more
Sold out of a lot of my extras just laying around. Would’ve taken me forever to process it all. They did so and got me paid incredibly quick.
Will say, they do not check the address you mail to daily, so it may take a few days after arrival before processing. However, once they did get it in their office, it was a quick process and they communicated every step of the way via email. 10/10, would recommend
Will say, they do not check the address you mail to daily, so it may take a few days after arrival before processing. However, once they did get it in their office, it was a quick process and they communicated every step of the way via email. 10/10, would recommend
David A
Review left Oct 30 2024
Review
Fourth shipment sent in and fourth five star review
Fourth shipment sent in and fourth five star review
Collin
Review left Oct 30 2024
Shipment processed Sep 26 2024
Review
Easy process, ty for the help. Always communicating and in a timely manner
Easy process, ty for the help. Always communicating and in a timely manner
Jonathan Bernal
Review left Oct 30 2024
Review
Process too long and harsh grading lost 16% value.
Process too long and harsh grading lost 16% value.
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every
previous customer to leave a review.
Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page.
We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a
review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).