Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service
(5644)
Jason StMary
Review left Oct 04 2024
Review
Everything was simple and smooth! Will definitely use this service again
Everything was simple and smooth! Will definitely use this service again
Damion Brown
Review left Oct 04 2024
Review
Easier than I thought it would be to clear out all the MTG cards I just had sitting around.
Easier than I thought it would be to clear out all the MTG cards I just had sitting around.
Daniel Langsdale
Review left Oct 03 2024
Shipment processed Aug 27 2024
Review
I was very pleased with the good level of communication that came from the staff. Both in simple form responses that let me know when cards were received and processed, as well as with prompt and informative answers to more specific questions that I had along the way. When staff illness created a
...
Read more
I was very pleased with the good level of communication that came from the staff. Both in simple form responses that let me know when cards were received and processed, as well as with prompt and informative answers to more specific questions that I had along the way. When staff illness created a delay in processing, I was promptly informed and not left hanging.
The price tools were very helpful in helping me make a decision about how to submit my cards for sale. Taking the time to use them and sort them into three lots really helped to get the most value out of my collection. (One lot for Sorted Service, one for Standard Service, and one for bulk value that ended up being traded to a LGS for store credit) I recommend taking the time to use the tools, they are worth it.
I found the grading of the cards' condition to be strict but fair. Payment was speedy and easy. Overall, a positive experience that I wish was available for other collectible hobbies.
The price tools were very helpful in helping me make a decision about how to submit my cards for sale. Taking the time to use them and sort them into three lots really helped to get the most value out of my collection. (One lot for Sorted Service, one for Standard Service, and one for bulk value that ended up being traded to a LGS for store credit) I recommend taking the time to use the tools, they are worth it.
I found the grading of the cards' condition to be strict but fair. Payment was speedy and easy. Overall, a positive experience that I wish was available for other collectible hobbies.
Eric H
Review left Oct 03 2024
Review
Results were quick, customer service was excellent. Extremely happy with the experience!
Results were quick, customer service was excellent. Extremely happy with the experience!
Eric Holland
Review left Oct 03 2024
Review
good service a little on the slower end of the things but was still great and would use them again
good service a little on the slower end of the things but was still great and would use them again
Sage
Review left Oct 02 2024
Review
Had a bunch of cards sitting around and a few that were difficult to sell due to value. Managed to get a fair price with minimal work. Would do again.
Had a bunch of cards sitting around and a few that were difficult to sell due to value. Managed to get a fair price with minimal work. Would do again.
Nicholas Reyes
Review left Oct 02 2024
Review
I liked the whole process, very easy. But I would like to know the value of my cards before finalizing everything. I see an estimated total but I got something a lot lower due to conditions of my cards. Or maybe returning cards once I find out the total
I liked the whole process, very easy. But I would like to know the value of my cards before finalizing everything. I see an estimated total but I got something a lot lower due to conditions of my cards. Or maybe returning cards once I find out the total
Patrick Meijer
Review left Oct 02 2024
Shipment processed Sep 14 2024
Review
Highly recommend to avoid all the headache, I did sorted so I knew what kind of payout per card I was getting.
Highly recommend to avoid all the headache, I did sorted so I knew what kind of payout per card I was getting.
David Anderson
Review left Oct 02 2024
Review
The turn around time was exactly as quoted, and they were even able to rush a payment so that I could have it before the weekend! They were super quick to respond to any inquiries.
The turn around time was exactly as quoted, and they were even able to rush a payment so that I could have it before the weekend! They were super quick to respond to any inquiries.
Evan
Review left Oct 02 2024
Review
I wasn't sure how exactly to deal with my old collection, so I had put off selling forever. Card Conduit's guidance on how to package up the cards was exceptional. In the end, it turned out I had been too conservative on deciding the service type, so of their own accord, they reclassified me upwards
...
Read more
I wasn't sure how exactly to deal with my old collection, so I had put off selling forever. Card Conduit's guidance on how to package up the cards was exceptional. In the end, it turned out I had been too conservative on deciding the service type, so of their own accord, they reclassified me upwards to the Curated tier. Just a terrific team; would recommend to anyone without hesitation.
Clay
Review left Oct 01 2024
Shipment processed Aug 29 2024
Review
This is a great replacement for the TCGPlayer buy list! And I’m able to sell cards I otherwise would not have been able to sell.
This is a great replacement for the TCGPlayer buy list! And I’m able to sell cards I otherwise would not have been able to sell.
Diego
Review left Oct 01 2024
Shipment processed Sep 12 2024
Review
I've sold my cards multiple times with them and never encountered an issue. It's straight forward they give you good value for your cards , and it's seamless. Thank you very much
I've sold my cards multiple times with them and never encountered an issue. It's straight forward they give you good value for your cards , and it's seamless. Thank you very much
Clint
Review left Oct 01 2024
Shipment processed Aug 29 2024
Review
Quick, fair price, overall a awesome experience. Best way to sell your cards and get fair value
Quick, fair price, overall a awesome experience. Best way to sell your cards and get fair value
John Young
Review left Oct 01 2024
Review
The process was extremely well outlined so I knew what I was getting into from the beginning. Communication was consistent throughout the process, and I received the value from my cards that I expected in a reasonable time. Will use again.
The process was extremely well outlined so I knew what I was getting into from the beginning. Communication was consistent throughout the process, and I received the value from my cards that I expected in a reasonable time. Will use again.
Graham Bateman
Review left Oct 01 2024
Review
The process was easy and I was very satisfied with the payout!
The process was easy and I was very satisfied with the payout!
John
Review left Oct 01 2024
Review
I had cards with mixed value from $1 to $40, and I even threw in a small stack of bulk just to fill out the rest of the box so things wouldn't move during shipment. Even with that extra bulk they still upgraded my package to the curated service! Excellent processing and value, will definitely be using them again soon.
I had cards with mixed value from $1 to $40, and I even threw in a small stack of bulk just to fill out the rest of the box so things wouldn't move during shipment. Even with that extra bulk they still upgraded my package to the curated service! Excellent processing and value, will definitely be using them again soon.
Marshall
Review left Sep 30 2024
Review
Super easy!! All I had to do was package/ship out my cards and Card Conduit took care of the rest. Will definitely use in the future and would highly recommend!!
Super easy!! All I had to do was package/ship out my cards and Card Conduit took care of the rest. Will definitely use in the future and would highly recommend!!
Andrew Craley
Review left Sep 30 2024
Shipment processed Sep 19 2024
Review
easy and straight forward. processing isnt the quickest process in the world but that will vary depending on the number of cards submitted.
easy and straight forward. processing isnt the quickest process in the world but that will vary depending on the number of cards submitted.
Dr Burger
Review left Sep 30 2024
Review
Everything about the process was easy, and I always felt like I knew where I was along the way. Updates on processing are clear and prompt, this was exactly the service I have been looking for on cards I was never going to cast, but also never going to sell individually.
Everything about the process was easy, and I always felt like I knew where I was along the way. Updates on processing are clear and prompt, this was exactly the service I have been looking for on cards I was never going to cast, but also never going to sell individually.
Alex
Review left Sep 30 2024
Shipment processed Sep 19 2024
$72.66
payout, $1.48
fees
Review
The entire process is transparent and simple. I would never sell through any other service
The entire process is transparent and simple. I would never sell through any other service
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every
previous customer to leave a review.
Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page.
We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a
review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).